NCERT Exemplar Solutions Class 12 Physics Chapter 9 Ray Optics and Optical Instruments

These NCERT Exemplar solutions for Class 12 Physics Chapter 9, Ray Optics and Optical Instruments, give step-by-step answers to all 32 questions: 11 MCQs, 5 multiple-correct MCQs, 5 very short, 5 short and 6 long answer questions. They cover refraction and total internal reflection, prisms and dispersion, mirrors and lenses, the displacement method, the human eye, telescopes and Fermat's principle with graded-index media. Each answer is followed by a short Teacher's Note to build understanding and an Examination Note on how to present the answer for better marks.

Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)

Question 1: A ray of light incident at an angle θ on a refracting face of a prism emerges from the other face normally. If the angle of the prism is 5° and the prism is made of a material of refractive index 1.5, the angle of incidence is
(a) 7.5°
(b) 5°
(c) 15°
(d) 2.5°
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (a) 7.5°

Explanation:
1. The ray leaves the second face normally, so the angle of refraction at the second face is 0. Since \( r_1 + r_2 = A \), the angle of refraction at the first face is \( r_1 = A = 5^\circ \).
2. Snell's law at the first face: \( \sin\theta = \mu\sin r_1 = 1.5\sin 5^\circ \approx 0.131 \), so \( \theta \approx 7.5^\circ \).

Teacher's Note:
1. For a thin prism sinθ ≈ θ, so θ = μ r1 = 1.5 × 5° = 7.5° directly.
2. Normal emergence at the second face means the ray inside is perpendicular to that face.

Examination Note: Start from r2 = 0, get r1 = A, and then apply Snell's law once.

 

Question 2: A short pulse of white light is incident from air to a glass slab at normal incidence. After travelling through the slab, the first colour to emerge is
(a) blue
(b) green
(c) violet
(d) red
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (d) red

Explanation:
1. Inside glass the speed of a colour is \( v = c/\mu \). Red light has the longest wavelength and the smallest refractive index, so it has the greatest speed in glass.
2. The pulse enters normally, so there is no bending; all colours cover the same thickness. The fastest colour, red, emerges first.

Teacher's Note:
1. The frequency of light does not change on entering glass; only the speed and the wavelength change.
2. In the same way violet is the slowest colour in glass and arrives last.

Examination Note: Link the order of arrival to the speed v = c/μ; red has the lowest μ.

 

Question 3: An object approaches a convergent lens from the left of the lens with a uniform speed 5 m/s and stops at the focus. The image
(a) moves away from the lens with an uniform speed 5 m/s
(b) moves away from the lens with an uniform acceleration
(c) moves away from the lens with a non-uniform acceleration
(d) moves towards the lens with a non-uniform acceleration
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (c) moves away from the lens with a non-uniform acceleration

Explanation:
1. For a lens of focal length f, with the object distance u taken as a magnitude, the image distance is \( v = \dfrac{uf}{u-f} \). As the object moves from beyond f up to the focus, u decreases towards f and v increases without limit, so the image moves away from the lens.
2. Differentiating, \( \dfrac{dv}{dt} = -\dfrac{f^2}{(u-f)^2}\dfrac{du}{dt} \). The speed of the image is \( \dfrac{f^2}{(u-f)^2} \) times the speed of the object, and this factor changes as u changes.
3. The speed of the image therefore keeps changing, and it changes unevenly. The image moves away with a non-uniform acceleration.

Teacher's Note:
1. The image speed is not equal to the object speed: the longitudinal magnification depends on the position.
2. The image goes to infinity as the object reaches the focus.

Examination Note: Use the lens formula, differentiate once, and say that the factor is not constant.

 

Question 4: A passenger in an aeroplane shall
(a) never see a rainbow
(b) may see a primary and a secondary rainbow as concentric circles
(c) may see a primary and a secondary rainbow as concentric arcs
(d) shall never see a secondary rainbow
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (b) may see a primary and a secondary rainbow as concentric circles

Explanation:
1. A rainbow is a part of a cone of light around the line from the Sun through the observer's eye. On the ground the horizon cuts the cone, so we see only an arc.
2. From an aeroplane there is no ground in the way, so the full circle can be seen. The primary and the secondary bow are both circles with the same centre.

Teacher's Note:
1. The centre of the bow lies on the line joining the Sun and the observer, opposite to the Sun.
2. The primary bow is seen at about 42° and the secondary at about 51° from this line.

Examination Note: State that the ground cuts off the lower part of the circle for an observer on the earth and that the aeroplane passenger does not have this limit.

 

Question 5: You are given four sources of light each one providing a light of a single colour - red, blue, green and yellow. Suppose the angle of refraction for a beam of yellow light corresponding to a particular angle of incidence at the interface of two media is 90°. Which of the following statements is correct if the source of yellow light is replaced with that of other lights without changing the angle of incidence?
(a) The beam of red light would undergo total internal reflection
(b) The beam of red light would bend towards normal while it gets refracted through the second medium
(c) The beam of blue light would undergo total internal reflection
(d) The beam of green light would bend away from the normal as it gets refracted through the second medium
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (c) The beam of blue light would undergo total internal reflection

Explanation:
1. An angle of refraction of 90° means that the given angle of incidence is the critical angle for yellow light. The light goes from the denser to the rarer medium.
2. Blue light has a shorter wavelength than yellow, so a higher refractive index and a smaller critical angle. The same angle of incidence is now larger than its critical angle, so blue light undergoes total internal reflection: (c) is correct.
3. Red light has a lower refractive index and a larger critical angle, so it is refracted, but it still bends away from the normal in going to a rarer medium: (a) and (b) are wrong. Green light has a higher index than yellow, so it also undergoes total internal reflection, and (d) is wrong.

Teacher's Note:
1. Shorter wavelength means a higher refractive index, hence a smaller critical angle.
2. Light going from a denser to a rarer medium always bends away from the normal.

Examination Note: Identify the angle as the critical angle for yellow and compare the critical angles of the other colours.

 

Question 6: The radius of curvature of the curved surface of a plano-convex lens is 20 cm. If the refractive index of the material of the lens be 1.5, it will
(a) act as a convex lens only for the objects that lie on its curved side
(b) act as a concave lens for the objects that lie on its curved side
(c) act as a convex lens irrespective of the side on which the object lies
(d) act as a concave lens irrespective of side on which the object lies
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (c) act as a convex lens irrespective of the side on which the object lies

Explanation:
1. For a plano-convex lens one surface is plane (\( R = \infty \)), so the lens maker's formula gives \( \dfrac1f = (\mu-1)\dfrac1R \), that is \( f = \dfrac{R}{\mu-1} = \dfrac{20}{0.5} = 40 \) cm.
2. The focal length is positive and the value does not depend on which face is turned towards the object. The lens is a converging (convex) lens whichever side the object lies on.

Teacher's Note:
1. A lens is convex or concave by its shape and by the refractive index relative to the surroundings, not by the side from which light falls.
2. Reversing a thin lens does not change its focal length.

Examination Note: Substitute in \( f = R/(\mu-1) \) and state that the sign of f is positive for both sides.

 

Question 7: The phenomena involved in the reflection of radiowaves by ionosphere is similar to
(a) reflection of light by a plane mirror
(b) total internal reflection of light in air during a mirage
(c) dispersion of light by water molecules during the formation of a rainbow
(d) scattering of light by the particles of air
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (b) total internal reflection of light in air during a mirage

Explanation:
1. The refractive index of the ionosphere falls as the height increases, so a radio wave sent upwards bends away from the normal at each layer until the angle of incidence exceeds the critical angle and the wave returns to the earth.
2. In a mirage, light from the sky travels through hot air layers of different refractive index near the ground and is totally internally reflected. The two situations are similar.

Teacher's Note:
1. Both effects are based on a gradual change of refractive index and on total internal reflection.
2. This is how short radio waves reach places far beyond the horizon.

Examination Note: Name total internal reflection in layers of changing refractive index for both phenomena.

 

Question 8: The direction of ray of light incident on a concave mirror is shown by PQ while directions in which the ray would travel after reflection is shown by four rays marked 1, 2, 3 and 4 (figure). Which of the four rays correctly shows the direction of reflected ray?
2CP3FQ1 (a) 1
(b) 2
(c) 3
(d) 4
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (b) 2

Explanation:
1. The incident ray PQ, if extended, passes through the focus F of the concave mirror.
2. A ray that passes through the focus is reflected parallel to the principal axis (this is the reverse of a parallel ray being reflected through F). Ray 2 is the one parallel to the axis, directed away from the mirror.

Teacher's Note:
1. Ray 4 runs into the mirror, and rays 1 and 3 are not parallel to the axis.
2. Rays are reversible: a ray along PQ goes back along the same path as a ray from Q through F.

Examination Note: Recall the rule: a ray through the focus is reflected parallel to the axis.

 

Question 9: The optical density of turpentine is higher than that of water while its mass density is lower. Figure shows a layer of turpentine floating over water in a container. For which one of the four rays incident on turpentine in figure, the path shown is correct?
1234G (a) 1
(b) 2
(c) 3
(d) 4
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (b) 2

Explanation:
1. The refractive indices are in the order air < water < turpentine.
2. At the air-turpentine surface the ray goes into a denser medium and bends towards the normal (angle of refraction less than angle of incidence). At the turpentine-water surface it goes into a rarer medium and bends away from the normal.
3. Only ray 2 shows both bends correctly. Ray 1 bends towards the normal at both surfaces, and rays 3 and 4 do not bend in the right sense.

Teacher's Note:
1. Optical density is about the refractive index, not about the mass density; here the two orders are opposite.
2. Check each interface separately for 'towards' or 'away from' the normal.

Examination Note: Judge the bending at each of the two surfaces separately.

 

Question 10: A car is moving with at a constant speed of 60 km h−1 on a straight road. Looking at the rear view mirror, the driver finds that the car following him is at a distance of 100 m and is approaching with a speed of 5 km h−1. In order to keep track of the car in the rear, the driver begins to glance alternatively at the rear and side mirror of his car after every 2 s till the other car overtakes. If the two cars were maintaining their speeds, which of the following statement (s) is/are correct?
(a) The speed of the car in the rear is 65 km h−1
(b) In the side mirror, the car in the rear would appear to approach with a speed of 5 km h−1 to the driver of the leading car
(c) In the rear view mirror, the speed of the approaching car would appear to decrease as the distance between the cars decreases
(d) In the side mirror, the speed of the approaching car would appear to increase as the distance between the cars decreases
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (a) The speed of the car in the rear is 65 km h−1, (d) In the side mirror, the speed of the approaching car would appear to increase as the distance between the cars decreases

Explanation:
1. (a) The following car gains 5 km h−1 on a car moving at 60 km h−1, so its own speed is 60 + 5 = 65 km h−1. This is correct.
2. (b) The rear view mirror is a plane mirror and shows the true relative speed of 5 km h−1. The side mirror is convex, and its image moves with a speed different from the actual one (smaller when the car is far away), so (b) is wrong.
3. (c) In a plane mirror the image speed equals the object speed at every distance, so the speed seen in the rear view mirror stays 5 km h−1: (c) is wrong.
4. (d) For a convex mirror \( v = \dfrac{uf}{u+f} \) gives an image speed \( \left(\dfrac{f}{u+f}\right)^2 \) times the object speed. As the car comes nearer (u smaller) this factor increases, so the image appears to move faster: (d) is correct.

Teacher's Note:
1. A convex mirror always forms a small virtual image between the pole and the focus, and the image moves very slowly when the object is far away.
2. This is why the other car seems to 'speed up' suddenly as it comes close in a side mirror.

Examination Note: Give the speed in (a) with the addition, then treat the plane mirror and the convex mirror separately.

 

Question 11: There are certain material developed in laboratories which have a negative refractive index figure. A ray incident from air (Medium 1) into such a medium (Medium 2) shall follow a path given by
ir12irir2112(a)(c)(d)(b)21 (a) Path shown in figure (a)
(b) Path shown in figure (b)
(c) Path shown in figure (c)
(d) Path shown in figure (d)
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (a) Path shown in figure (a)

Explanation:
1. In a medium of negative refractive index the refracted ray lies on the same side of the normal as the incident ray, instead of on the opposite side as in the usual case.
2. Only in figure (a) does the ray go into medium 2 and stay on the same side of the normal as the incident ray. Figure (b) shows ordinary refraction, figure (c) shows reflection, and in figure (d) the ray goes along the normal side with no relation to the incident angle.

Teacher's Note:
1. Snell's law, sin i = n sin r, with n negative gives a negative angle r, which means the other side of the normal.
2. Such materials are called metamaterials.

Examination Note: State clearly that the refracted ray is on the same side of the normal as the incident ray.

 

Multiple Choice Questions (More Than One Option)

Question 12: Consider an extended object immersed in water contained in a plane trough. When seen from close to the edge of the trough the object looks distorted because
(a) the apparent depth of the points close to the edge are nearer the surface of the water compared to the points away from the edge
(b) the angle subtended by the image of the object at the eye is smaller than the actual angle subtended by the object in air
(c) some of the points of the object far away from the edge may not be visible because of total internal reflection
(d) water in a trough acts as a lens and magnifies the object
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (a) the apparent depth of the points close to the edge are nearer the surface of the water compared to the points away from the edge, (b) the angle subtended by the image of the object at the eye is smaller than the actual angle subtended by the object in air, (c) some of the points of the object far away from the edge may not be visible because of total internal reflection

Explanation:
1. Points of the object are seen along different slanted rays. The refraction at the water surface raises the apparent position of each point by a different amount, so the points near the edge are seen nearer the surface than points far from the edge: (a).
2. Refraction at the surface also changes the angle that the image subtends at the eye compared with that of the object in air, so the shape appears altered: (b).
3. For points far from the edge the rays reach the surface at a large angle of incidence, which can exceed the critical angle, and these points cannot be seen because of total internal reflection: (c).
4. A plane water surface does not act as a lens and does not magnify: (d) is wrong.

Teacher's Note:
1. Apparent depth = real depth / refractive index is exact only for near-normal viewing.
2. Total internal reflection needs a ray going from water to air at an angle beyond about 49°.

Examination Note: Cover the three causes: different apparent shifts, changed angle at the eye, and total internal reflection.

 

Question 13: A rectangular block of glass ABCD has a refractive index 1.6. A pin is placed midway on the face AB figure. When observed from the face AD, the pin shall
ABDC (a) appear to be near A
(b) appear to be near D
(c) appear to be at the centre of AD
(d) not be seen at all
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (d) not be seen at all

Explanation:
1. The critical angle of the glass is given by \( \sin C = \dfrac{1}{1.6} \), so \( C = 38.7^\circ \).
2. Light from the pin enters the glass through face AB with an angle of refraction r. The largest possible r is when the angle of incidence is 90°: \( \sin r = \dfrac{1}{1.6} \), so \( r \le 38.7^\circ \).
3. Face AD is perpendicular to AB, so the angle of incidence on AD is \( 90^\circ - r \ge 51.3^\circ \), which is greater than the critical angle. Every ray is totally internally reflected at AD, so the pin cannot be seen through AD.

Teacher's Note:
1. The two angles in the glass, r and the angle on the next face, add up to 90° for perpendicular faces.
2. This is the idea behind 'light guides' made from a rectangular block.

Examination Note: Show that r is always below C, so that the angle on the adjacent face is always above C.

 

Question 14: Between the primary and secondary rainbows, there is a dark band known as Alexander's dark band. This is because
(a) light scattered into this region interfere destructively
(b) there is no light scattered into this region
(c) light is absorbed in this region
(d) angle made at the eye by the scattered rays with respect to the incident light of the sun lies between approximately 42° and 50°
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (b) there is no light scattered into this region, (d) angle made at the eye by the scattered rays with respect to the incident light of the sun lies between approximately 42° and 50°

Explanation:
1. Rays that reach the eye after one internal reflection in a raindrop (primary bow) are all deviated by an angle for which the angle at the eye is at most about 42°. Rays that reach it after two internal reflections (secondary bow) make an angle at the eye of at least about 51°.
2. So the region between about 42° and 51° (approximately 42° and 50° in the option) receives no light scattered in either of these ways: (b) and (d) are correct.
3. The darkness is due to the absence of rays by the geometry of the drops, not because of interference or absorption: (a) and (c) are wrong.

Teacher's Note:
1. The bright primary bow is the edge of the region that receives light of single reflection; the secondary bow is the edge for two reflections.
2. The sky inside the primary bow and outside the secondary bow is brighter than the band between them.

Examination Note: Say that the angles of the two bows leave a gap of about 42° to 51° into which no ray is deviated.

 

Question 15: A magnifying glass is used, as the object to be viewed can be brought closer to the eye than the normal near point. This results in
(a) a larger angle to be subtended by the object at the eye and hence, viewed in greater detail
(b) the formation of a virtual erect image
(c) increase in the field of view
(d) infinite magnification at the near point
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (a) a larger angle to be subtended by the object at the eye and hence, viewed in greater detail, (b) the formation of a virtual erect image

Explanation:
1. The object is placed between the lens and its focus. The lens forms a virtual, erect and enlarged image: (b).
2. The object can be held closer to the eye than 25 cm, so it subtends a larger angle at the eye and is seen in greater detail: (a).
3. A magnifying glass does not increase the field of view, and its magnification at the near point is finite, \( m = 1 + \dfrac{D}{f} \): (c) and (d) are wrong.

Teacher's Note:
1. Angular magnification is the ratio of the angle with the lens to the angle without the lens, with the object at the near point.
2. A smaller focal length gives a larger magnification.

Examination Note: Mention both the larger visual angle and the virtual erect image.

 

Question 16: An astronomical refractive telescope has an objective of focal length 20 m and an eyepiece of focal length 2 cm.
(a) The length of the telescope tube is 20.02 m
(b) The magnification is 1000
(c) The image formed is inverted
(d) An objective of a larger aperture will increase the brightness and reduce chromatic aberration of the image
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (a) The length of the telescope tube is 20.02 m, (b) The magnification is 1000, (c) The image formed is inverted

Explanation:
1. In normal adjustment the tube length is \( L = f_o + f_e = 20 + 0.02 = 20.02 \) m: (a).
2. The magnifying power is \( m = \dfrac{f_o}{f_e} = \dfrac{20}{0.02} = 1000 \): (b).
3. The image formed by an astronomical telescope is inverted: (c).
4. A larger aperture collects more light and increases the brightness, but it does not reduce the chromatic aberration (this depends on the lens material, not its size): (d) is wrong.

Teacher's Note:
1. Convert both focal lengths to the same unit before dividing.
2. A reflecting telescope uses a mirror to avoid chromatic aberration.

Examination Note: Convert units, then check each option separately; (d) is half right and so wrong.

 

Very Short Answer Type Questions

Question 17. Will the focal length of a lens for red light be more, same or less than that for blue light?
Answer:
The refractive index of glass is smaller for red light than for blue light: \( \mu_r \lt \mu_b \).
By the lens maker's formula \( \dfrac1f = (\mu-1)\left(\dfrac1{R_1}-\dfrac1{R_2}\right) \), a larger \( \mu \) gives a larger power. So \( f_b \lt f_r \).
The focal length for red light is more than that for blue light (equivalently, the focal length for blue is less).
In simple words: Blue light is bent more by the lens, so it comes to a focus closer to the lens than red light.

Teacher's Note:
1. This difference of focal length with colour is the cause of chromatic aberration.
2. The radii R1 and R2 are the same for both colours; only μ changes.

Examination Note: Give the order of the refractive indices and use it in the lens maker's formula.

 

Question 18. The near vision of an average person is 25 cm. To view an object with an angular magnification of 10, what should be the power of the microscope?
Answer:
For a simple microscope (a convex lens) with the final image at infinity, the angular magnification is \( m = \dfrac{D}{f} \), where D = 25 cm is the least distance of distinct vision.
\( f = \dfrac{D}{m} = \dfrac{25}{10} = 2.5\ \text{cm} = 0.025\ \text{m} \).
Power \( P = \dfrac1f = \dfrac{1}{0.025} = \) 40 D.
In simple words: A convex lens of focal length 2.5 cm, that is of power 40 D, gives a magnification of 10.

Teacher's Note:
1. Power is in dioptre when the focal length is in metre, so convert 2.5 cm to 0.025 m before taking the reciprocal.
2. If the final image were formed at the near point, the formula would be m = 1 + D/f instead. The standard form m = D/f is used here.

Examination Note: State the formula m = D/f, convert to metres, and give the unit D for the power.

 

Question 19. An unsymmetrical double convex thin lens forms the image of a point object on its axis. Will the position of the image change if the lens is reversed?
Answer:
The focal length from the lens maker's formula is \( \dfrac1f = (\mu-1)\left(\dfrac1{R_1}-\dfrac1{R_2}\right) \). On reversing the lens, \( R_1 \) and \( R_2 \) exchange places and change sign: \( R_1 \to -R_2 \) and \( R_2 \to -R_1 \).
The bracket becomes \( \left(-\dfrac1{R_2}+\dfrac1{R_1}\right) \), which is the same as before. So f is unchanged.
For a thin lens the object distance, the image distance and f are related by the same lens formula, so the position of the image does not change.
In simple words: A thin lens has only one focal length, so turning it round makes no difference to where the image forms.

Teacher's Note:
1. The two focal points are at the same distance on the two sides of a thin lens in air.
2. For a thick lens the principal planes are not symmetric and this simple result does not hold exactly.

Examination Note: Quote the lens maker's formula and show that the bracket is unchanged.

 

Question 20. Three immiscible liquids of densities d1 > d2 > d3 and refractive indices μ1 > μ2 > μ3 are put in a beaker. The height of each liquid column is h/3. A dot is made at the bottom of the beaker. For near normal vision, find the apparent depth of the dot.
Answer:
The densest liquid (1) lies at the bottom, then liquid 2, then liquid 3 on top. For near normal viewing, a point at depth t in a medium of index \( \mu_1 \), seen from a medium of index \( \mu_2 \), has apparent depth \( t\,\dfrac{\mu_2}{\mu_1} \).
Seen from liquid 2: \( O_1 = \dfrac{h}{3}\dfrac{\mu_2}{\mu_1} \).
This image is the object for liquid 2, at depth \( \dfrac h3 + O_1 \) below the upper surface of liquid 2. Seen from liquid 3: \( O_2 = \left(\dfrac h3 + O_1\right)\dfrac{\mu_3}{\mu_2} = \dfrac h3\left(\dfrac{\mu_3}{\mu_2}+\dfrac{\mu_3}{\mu_1}\right) \).
This is the object for liquid 3, at depth \( \dfrac h3 + O_2 \). Seen from air (index 1): \( O_3 = \dfrac{1}{\mu_3}\left(\dfrac h3 + O_2\right) \).
\( O_3 = \dfrac h3\left(\dfrac1{\mu_1}+\dfrac1{\mu_2}+\dfrac1{\mu_3}\right) \)
In simple words: Each layer of thickness h/3 and index μ makes the dot appear (h/3)/μ deep, and the apparent depths add.

Teacher's Note:
1. The image formed by one layer acts as the object for the next layer above it.
2. Check: if all three indices equal μ, the answer becomes h/μ, the usual apparent depth.

Examination Note: Show the chain of images layer by layer; the sum of (thickness / index) is the quick check.

 

Question 21. For a glass prism (μ = √3), the angle of minimum deviation is equal to the angle of the prism. Find the angle of the prism.
Answer:
For a prism, \( \mu = \dfrac{\sin\left(\dfrac{A+D_m}{2}\right)}{\sin\dfrac A2} \). Here \( D_m = A \), so \( \mu = \dfrac{\sin A}{\sin (A/2)} \).
Using \( \sin A = 2\sin\dfrac A2\cos\dfrac A2 \): \( \mu = 2\cos\dfrac A2 \).
\( \sqrt3 = 2\cos\dfrac A2 \Rightarrow \cos\dfrac A2 = \dfrac{\sqrt3}{2} \Rightarrow \dfrac A2 = 30^\circ \).
A = 60°
In simple words: Put Dm = A in the prism formula; it reduces to μ = 2 cos(A/2).

Teacher's Note:
1. With Dm = A the prism formula takes the simple form μ = 2cos(A/2).
2. Check: for A = 60° and μ = √3, sin 60° / sin 30° = √3.

Examination Note: Substitute Dm = A at the start and use the double angle formula.

 

Short Answer Type Questions

Question 22. A short object of length L is placed along the principal axis of a concave mirror away from focus. The object distance is u. If the mirror has a focal length f, what will be the length of the image? You may take L << |v − f|.
Answer:
Let the ends of the object be at \( u_1 = u - \dfrac L2 \) and \( u_2 = u + \dfrac L2 \), so \( |u_1-u_2| = L \). From the mirror formula \( \dfrac1u+\dfrac1v=\dfrac1f \), \( v = \dfrac{fu}{u-f} \) (magnitudes).
The images of the two ends are at \( v_1 = \dfrac{f(u-L/2)}{u-f-L/2} \) and \( v_2 = \dfrac{f(u+L/2)}{u-f+L/2} \).
The length of the image is \( L' = |v_1 - v_2| = \dfrac{f^2L}{(u-f)^2 - L^2/4} \).
Since the object is short, \( L^2/4 \ll (u-f)^2 \), so \( L' = \dfrac{f^2}{(u-f)^2}\,L \).
In simple words: The image of a short object along the axis is stretched or shrunk by the factor f²/(u − f)², which is the square of the lateral magnification.

Teacher's Note:
1. Differentiating v = fu/(u − f) with respect to u gives the same result in one line: |dv/du| = f²/(u − f)².
2. The factor equals m², where m = f/(u − f) is the lateral magnification.

Examination Note: Either find v for both ends and subtract, or differentiate; state the approximation L << (u − f).

 

Question 23. A circular disc of radius R is placed co-axially and horizontally inside an opaque hemispherical bowl of radius a (figure). The far edge of the disc is just visible when viewed from the edge of the bowl. The bowl is filled with transparent liquid of refractive index μ and the near edge of the disc becomes just visible. How far below the top of the bowl is the disc placed?
90–αACidMRRBaOaαα
Answer:
Let the disc be at a depth d below the top (the plane of the rim). Let O be the centre of the top, M the point of the rim from which the disc is seen, and A and B the far and near edges of the disc, at distances R on either side of the axis. Then A is at horizontal distance \( a+R \) from M and B is at horizontal distance \( a-R \) from M.
Without liquid, the line of sight is AM. It makes an angle α with the vertical at M, where \( \sin\alpha = \dfrac{a+R}{\sqrt{d^2+(a+R)^2}} \).
With liquid, the ray from B reaches M along BM, with angle of incidence i given by \( \sin i = \dfrac{a-R}{\sqrt{d^2+(a-R)^2}} \). It leaves along the same line of sight as before, so the refraction angle in air is again α.
Snell's law at the surface: \( \mu\sin i = \sin\alpha \), that is \( \mu\dfrac{a-R}{\sqrt{d^2+(a-R)^2}} = \dfrac{a+R}{\sqrt{d^2+(a+R)^2}} \).
Squaring and collecting the terms in \( d^2 \): \( d^2\left[(a+R)^2-\mu^2(a-R)^2\right] = (\mu^2-1)(a^2-R^2)^2 \).
\( d = \dfrac{(a^2-R^2)\sqrt{\mu^2-1}}{\sqrt{(a+R)^2-\mu^2(a-R)^2}} \)
In simple words: The line of sight to the far edge before filling and the ray from the near edge after filling are the same ray outside the liquid; Snell's law at the surface then fixes the depth d.

Teacher's Note:
1. The angles are measured from the vertical, which is the normal to the plane surface of the liquid.
2. Check with numbers: for a = 10, R = 4, μ = 1.4 the formula gives d = 7.35, and then μ sin i = sin α = 0.885 on both sides.

Examination Note: Define the two angles from the geometry, write Snell's law once, and square carefully to remove the roots.

 

Question 24. A thin convex lens of focal length 25 cm is cut into two pieces 0.5 cm above the principal axis. The top part is placed at (0, 0) and an object placed at (−50 cm, 0). Find the coordinates of the image.
0.5OO′50.0
Answer:
Cutting the lens does not change its focal length, so the top part still has f = 25 cm. The principal axis of this piece lies 0.5 cm below its cut edge, which is on the x-axis. So the object at (−50, 0) is 0.5 cm above the principal axis, at an object distance u = −50 cm.
Lens formula: \( \dfrac1v = \dfrac1u+\dfrac1f = -\dfrac1{50}+\dfrac1{25} = \dfrac1{50} \), so v = +50 cm.
Magnification \( m = \dfrac vu = \dfrac{50}{-50} = -1 \), so the image is 0.5 cm below the principal axis. The principal axis is itself 0.5 cm below the x-axis, so the image is 1 cm below the x-axis.
The image is at (50 cm, −1 cm).
In simple words: The image is real, inverted, of the same size and 50 cm from the lens; its height is measured from the axis of the lens, not from the cut edge.

Teacher's Note:
1. The cut piece behaves like the full lens for the rays that fall on it; its focal length and its principal axis are unchanged.
2. The image of the cut lens is only fainter, since fewer rays pass through it.

Examination Note: Say where the principal axis of the piece is, then find v and m; give the coordinates with respect to the x-axis.

 

Question 25. In many experimental set-ups, the source and screen are fixed at a distance say D and the lens is movable. Show that there are two positions for the lens for which an image is formed on the screen. Find the distance between these points and the ratio of the image sizes for these two points.
Answer:
Let the lens be at a distance u from the source (taking magnitudes), so the image distance is \( v = D-u \). Lens formula: \( \dfrac1u+\dfrac1{D-u}=\dfrac1f \), which gives \( u^2 - Du + Df = 0 \).
\( u = \dfrac{D \pm \sqrt{D^2-4Df}}{2} \). Two real values exist (two positions of the lens), provided \( D \gt 4f \). They are also the same as the two values of v, since the object and image positions can be interchanged (reversibility).
Distance between the two positions: \( d = u_2 - u_1 = \) \( \sqrt{D^2-4Df} \).
First position: \( u_1 = \dfrac{D-d}{2},\ v_1 = \dfrac{D+d}{2} \), so \( m_1 = \dfrac{v_1}{u_1} = \dfrac{D+d}{D-d} \). Second position: \( u_2 = \dfrac{D+d}{2},\ v_2 = \dfrac{D-d}{2} \), so \( m_2 = \dfrac{D-d}{D+d} \).
Ratio of the image sizes (larger to smaller): \( \dfrac{I_1}{I_2} = \dfrac{m_1}{m_2} = \left(\dfrac{D+d}{D-d}\right)^2 \)
In simple words: The lens forms a sharp image at two positions, one giving a magnified image and the other a diminished one; the two sizes differ by the factor ((D + d)/(D − d))².

Teacher's Note:
1. The product m1m2 = 1, so the object size is the geometric mean of the two image sizes.
2. This is the displacement method for finding f: f = (D² − d²)/(4D).

Examination Note: Show the quadratic in u, the condition D > 4f, and the two sets of (u, v) values; then write the ratio.

 

Question 26. A jar of height h is filled with a transparent liquid of refractive index μ (figure). At the centre of the jar on the bottom surface is a dot. Find the minimum diameter of a disc, such that when placed on the top surface symmetrically about the centre, the dot is invisible.
dhii
Answer:
Let d be the diameter of the disc. The dot cannot be seen from above if every ray from it that reaches the top surface outside the disc is totally internally reflected. The ray that just reaches the edge of the disc must strike the surface at the critical angle C, with \( \sin C = \dfrac1\mu \).
The ray from the dot to the edge of the disc makes an angle i = C with the vertical, so \( \tan i = \dfrac{d/2}{h} \).
\( \tan C = \dfrac{\sin C}{\cos C} = \dfrac{1/\mu}{\sqrt{1-1/\mu^2}} = \dfrac{1}{\sqrt{\mu^2-1}} \).
\( \dfrac d2 = \dfrac{h}{\sqrt{\mu^2-1}} \), so \( d = \dfrac{2h}{\sqrt{\mu^2-1}} \).
In simple words: The disc must cover the circle on the surface inside which light from the dot can escape; the edge of this circle is where the angle of incidence equals the critical angle.

Teacher's Note:
1. Light striking the surface inside this circle has an angle of incidence less than C and is refracted out; outside it, the light is totally reflected.
2. The result agrees with the usual 'circle of light' of radius h tan C.

Examination Note: Link the edge of the disc to the critical angle and use tan C = 1/√(μ² − 1).

 

Long Answer Type Questions

Question 27. A myopic adult has a far point at 0.1 m. His power of accomodation is 4 D. (i) What power lenses are required to see distant objects? (ii) What is his near point without glasses? (iii) What is his near point with glasses? (Take the image distance from the lens of the eye to the retina to be 2 cm.)
Answer:
The distance from the eye lens to the retina is 0.02 m, which corresponds to \( \dfrac1{0.02} = 50 \) D in the lens formula \( P = \dfrac1u + \dfrac1v \). For a normal relaxed eye looking at infinity the power is \( P = 0 + 50 = 50 \) D.
(i) For the myopic eye with the object at its far point (0.1 m), the relaxed power is \( P_f = \dfrac1{0.1}+\dfrac1{0.02} = 10+50 = 60 \) D. To see distant objects the combination of the eye and the glasses must have a power of 50 D: \( 60 + P_g = 50 \), so \( P_g = -10 \) D. A concave lens of power −10 D (focal length 10 cm) is needed.
(ii) The eye can add 4 D of power, so its largest power is \( 60 + 4 = 64 \) D. At the near point \( x_n \): \( \dfrac1{x_n}+50 = 64 \), so \( \dfrac1{x_n} = 14 \) and \( x_n = \dfrac1{14}\ \text{m} \approx 7.1\ \text{cm} \).
(iii) With the glasses, the relaxed eye and lens together have 50 D, and the largest power is \( 50+4 = 54 \) D. At the new near point \( x_n' \): \( \dfrac1{x_n'}+50=54 \), so \( \dfrac1{x_n'} = 4 \) and \( x_n' = 0.25 \) m = 25 cm.
In simple words: The glasses of −10 D let the eye see far objects, and the same 4 D of accommodation then brings the near point to 25 cm.

Teacher's Note:
1. The power of the eye (about 50 D when relaxed) is the sum of 1/u and 1/v, with v fixed at 2 cm by the position of the retina.
2. The glasses are taken to be in contact with the eye lens, so the powers add.

Examination Note: Work in dioptres throughout: write each power as 1/u + 50, and give the sign of the lens in (i).

 

Question 28. Show that for a material with refractive index μ ≥ √2, light incident at any angle shall be guided along a length perpendicular to the incident face.
CDBArφ
Answer:
Let a ray enter the face AB at an angle of incidence i and be refracted at an angle r. The ray then meets the side face AC at an angle of incidence \( \phi = 90^\circ - r \), since the faces are perpendicular.
For the ray to be guided along the length (total internal reflection at AC) we need φ to be at least the critical angle C: \( \sin\phi \ge \dfrac1\mu \), that is \( \cos r \ge \dfrac1\mu \).
The condition is hardest to meet when r is largest, which happens for the largest angle of incidence \( i = 90^\circ \): \( \mu\sin r = 1 \), so \( \sin r = \dfrac1\mu \) and \( \cos r = \sqrt{1-\dfrac1{\mu^2}} \).
Then \( \sqrt{1-\dfrac1{\mu^2}} \ge \dfrac1\mu \Rightarrow 1-\dfrac1{\mu^2} \ge \dfrac1{\mu^2} \Rightarrow \mu^2 \ge 2 \).
For smaller i, r is smaller and φ is larger, so the condition holds for them as well. Hence for \( \mu \ge \sqrt2 \) every ray is guided.
In simple words: It is enough to test the ray that grazes the entrance face (i = 90°); if it is guided, all other rays are.

Teacher's Note:
1. This is the principle of an optical fibre: the core must have a high enough refractive index for the light to stay inside.
2. The same argument with the angle of acceptance gives the numerical aperture of a fibre.

Examination Note: Find the worst case (i = 90°), apply the critical angle condition, and finish with μ² ≥ 2.

 

Question 29. The mixture a pure liquid and a solution in a long vertical column (i.e., horizontal dimensions << vertical dimensions) produces diffusion of solute particles and hence a refractive index gradient along the vertical dimension. A ray of light entering the column at right angles to the vertical is deviated from its original path. Find the deviation in travelling a horizontal distance d << h, the height of the column.
θydy(+)ydydxθθ+ d
Answer:
Treat the column as a stack of thin horizontal layers, whose refractive index \( \mu(y) \) changes slowly with the height y. Let θ be the angle between the ray and the vertical, and let the ray go from height y to \( y+dy \) while it moves a horizontal distance dx (figure).
Snell's law for the thin layer: \( \mu(y)\sin\theta = \mu(y+dy)\sin(\theta+d\theta) \). Expanding with \( \mu(y+dy) = \mu + \dfrac{d\mu}{dy}dy \): \( 0 = \mu\cos\theta\,d\theta + \sin\theta\,\dfrac{d\mu}{dy}dy \).
So \( d\theta = -\dfrac1\mu\dfrac{d\mu}{dy}\tan\theta\,dy \). From the figure \( \tan\theta = \dfrac{dx}{dy} \), so \( d\theta = -\dfrac1\mu\dfrac{d\mu}{dy}\,dx \).
The ray enters at right angles to the vertical and the deviation is small, so \( \theta \approx 90^\circ \), and \( \mu \) and \( \dfrac{d\mu}{dy} \) are nearly constant over the distance d. Integrating from 0 to d:
\( \Delta\theta = -\dfrac1\mu\dfrac{d\mu}{dy}\,d \)
The magnitude of the deviation is (d/μ)|dμ/dy|, and the minus sign shows that the ray bends towards the region of larger refractive index.
In simple words: In a medium whose refractive index changes with height, the ray curves towards the higher index; for a short horizontal path the deviation is (d/μ) times the rate of change of μ with height.

Teacher's Note:
1. Apply Snell's law to one thin layer and then add up (integrate) the small bends.
2. This is the same effect that gives a mirage: the ray bends towards the denser air layer.

Examination Note: Write Snell's law for the thin layer, expand to first order, use tan θ = dx/dy, and integrate over d.

 

Question 30. If light passes near a massive object, the gravitational interaction causes a bending of the ray. This can be thought of as happening due to a change in the effective refractive index of the medium given by n(r) = 1 + 2GM / rc2 where r is the distance of the point of consideration from the centre of the mass of the massive body, G is the universal gravitational constant, M the mass of the body and c the speed of light in vacuum. Considering a spherical object find the deviation of the ray from the original path as it grazes the object.
θθ+dθrrRMdr
Answer:
Consider two thin spherical shells at distances r and \( r+dr \) from the centre of the object. Let the ray make an angle θ with the radial direction at r and \( \theta+d\theta \) at \( r+dr \) (figure). Snell's law: \( n(r)\sin\theta = n(r+dr)\sin(\theta+d\theta) \).
Expanding to first order: \( 0 = n\cos\theta\,d\theta + \sin\theta\,\dfrac{dn}{dr}dr \), so \( d\theta = -\dfrac1n\dfrac{dn}{dr}\tan\theta\,dr \).
Since \( n = 1+\dfrac{2GM}{rc^2} \approx 1 \) (weak field), \( -\dfrac{dn}{dr} = \dfrac{2GM}{c^2r^2} \) and \( d\theta = \dfrac{2GM}{c^2r^2}\tan\theta\,dr \).
Take the ray as a straight line passing the centre at the closest distance R (for a grazing ray, R is the radius of the object). Measure x along the ray from the point of closest approach. Then \( r^2 = x^2+R^2 \), \( \tan\theta = \dfrac Rx \) and \( r\,dr = x\,dx \), so \( \tan\theta\,dr = \dfrac{R}{r}dx \).
Hence \( d\theta = \dfrac{2GMR}{c^2}\dfrac{dx}{(x^2+R^2)^{3/2}} \). Total bending from \( x=-\infty \) to \( x=+\infty \): \( \theta_0 = \dfrac{2GMR}{c^2}\displaystyle\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\dfrac{dx}{(x^2+R^2)^{3/2}} \).
Put \( x = R\tan\phi \): \( \displaystyle\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\dfrac{dx}{(x^2+R^2)^{3/2}} = \dfrac1{R^2}\int_{-\pi/2}^{\pi/2}\cos\phi\,d\phi = \dfrac{2}{R^2} \).
\( \theta_0 = \dfrac{2GMR}{c^2}\cdot\dfrac2{R^2} = \dfrac{4GM}{Rc^2} \), the ray bending towards the object.
In simple words: A ray passing at distance R from a mass M is bent by 4GM/(Rc²) towards the mass, which is twice the value that a simple Newtonian estimate gives.

Teacher's Note:
1. The same equation as in the previous question, dθ = −(1/n)(dn/dr) tan θ dr, is being used, but with a radial change of index.
2. The substitution x = R tan φ turns the integral into the integral of cos φ.

Examination Note: Write Snell's law for the thin shell, find dθ in terms of x, and show the substitution before the final result.

 

Question 31. An infinitely long cylinder of radius R is made of an unusual exotic material with refractive index −1 (figure). The cylinder is placed between two planes whose normals are along the y-direction. The centre of the cylinder O lies along the y-axis. A narrow laser beam is directed along the y-direction from the lower plate. The laser source is at a horizontal distance x from the diameter in the y direction. Find the range of x such that light emitted from the lower plane does not reach the upper plane.
Rxoθrθiθrθr
Answer:
The beam, parallel to the y-axis and at a distance x from the diameter, meets the cylinder at a point where the angle of incidence \( \theta_i \) satisfies \( \sin\theta_i = \dfrac xR \).
For \( n=-1 \), Snell's law gives \( \sin\theta_i = -\sin\theta_r \): the refracted ray is on the same side of the normal as the incident ray, with \( |\theta_r| = \theta_i \). At the entry point the ray is turned through \( 2\theta_i \).
Inside the cylinder the chord makes equal angles with the normals at its two ends, so at the exit point the ray is turned again by \( 2\theta_i \) in the same sense. The total deviation of the ray from its original direction (+y) is \( 4\theta_i \).
The ray does not reach the upper plane when it ends up travelling downwards or sideways, that is when \( \dfrac\pi2 \le 4\theta_i \le \dfrac{3\pi}2 \). This gives \( \dfrac\pi8 \le \theta_i \le \dfrac{3\pi}8 \).
With \( \sin\theta_i = \dfrac xR \): \( R\sin\dfrac\pi8 \le x \le R\sin\dfrac{3\pi}8 \), that is about \( 0.38R \le x \le 0.92R \) (for the beam on either side of the diameter, taking x as a distance).
In simple words: Each surface turns the ray by twice the angle of incidence, so the total turn is 4θi; the ray misses the upper plate when this turn is between 90° and 270°.

Teacher's Note:
1. For ordinary glass of positive index the ray at each surface would turn by only the difference between the angles of incidence and refraction.
2. Check: x = 0 gives no deviation, so the ray goes straight to the upper plate; x close to R gives a turn close to 360° and it also reaches the plate.

Examination Note: Find the total deviation 4θi first, then write the condition for the ray not to move upwards and convert to x with sin θi = x/R.

 

Question 32. (i) Consider a thin lens placed between a source (S) and an observer (O) (Figure). Let the thickness of the lens vary as \( w(b) = w_0 - \dfrac{b^2}{\alpha} \), where b is the vertical distance from the pole, w0 is a constant. Using Fermat's principle i.e., the time of transit for a ray between the source and observer is an extremum, find the condition that all paraxial rays starting from the source will converge at a point O on the axis. Find the focal length.
P1SuvOb(ii) A gravitational lens may be assumed to have a varying width of the form \( w(b) = k_1\ln\left(\dfrac{k_2}{b}\right) \) for \( b_{min} \lt b \lt b_{max} \) and \( w(b) = k_1\ln\left(\dfrac{k_2}{b_{min}}\right) \) for \( b \lt b_{min} \). Show that an observer will see an image of a point object as a ring about the centre of the lens with an angular radius \( \beta = \sqrt{\dfrac{(n-1)k_1\dfrac uv}{u+v}} \).
Answer:
(i) Take a ray from S that passes through the lens at a height b (the point \( P_1 \)). The time from S to \( P_1 \) is \( \dfrac{\sqrt{u^2+b^2}}{c} \approx \dfrac uc\left(1+\dfrac{b^2}{2u^2}\right) \) for \( b \ll u \). Similarly from \( P_1 \) to O it is \( \dfrac vc\left(1+\dfrac{b^2}{2v^2}\right) \).
The extra optical path in the lens of thickness w(b) and index n is \( (n-1)w(b) \), so the extra time is \( \dfrac{(n-1)w(b)}{c} \). The total time is \( t = \dfrac1c\left[u+v+\dfrac{b^2}2\left(\dfrac1u+\dfrac1v\right)+(n-1)\left(w_0-\dfrac{b^2}\alpha\right)\right] \).
By Fermat's principle all paraxial rays take the same time (an extremum for every b), so \( \dfrac{dt}{db} = 0 \) for every b: \( \dfrac bc\left[\left(\dfrac1u+\dfrac1v\right)-\dfrac{2(n-1)}\alpha\right] = 0 \).
The condition for all paraxial rays to converge at O is \( \dfrac1u+\dfrac1v = \dfrac{2(n-1)}{\alpha} \), that is \( \alpha = 2(n-1)D \) with \( \dfrac1D = \dfrac1u+\dfrac1v \). Comparing with the lens formula \( \dfrac1u+\dfrac1v=\dfrac1f \): \( f = D = \dfrac{\alpha}{2(n-1)} \).
(ii) For the gravitational lens, \( w(b) = k_1\ln\dfrac{k_2}b \) in the range \( b_{min} \lt b \lt b_{max} \), so \( t = \dfrac1c\left[u+v+\dfrac{b^2}{2D}+(n-1)k_1\ln\dfrac{k_2}{b}\right] \).
Fermat's principle: \( \dfrac{dt}{db} = 0 \Rightarrow \dfrac bD-\dfrac{(n-1)k_1}b = 0 \Rightarrow b^2 = (n-1)k_1D \), so \( b = \sqrt{(n-1)k_1D} \).
Only the rays that pass the lens at this one distance b from its centre satisfy Fermat's principle, and the same holds in every direction round the axis. These rays form a circle on the lens, so the observer sees the image as a ring.
The observer is at a distance v from the lens, so the angular radius is \( \beta \approx \dfrac bv = \dfrac{\sqrt{(n-1)k_1D}}{v} \). With \( D = \dfrac{uv}{u+v} \):
\( \beta = \sqrt{\dfrac{(n-1)k_1\dfrac uv}{u+v}} \)
In simple words: In (i) the rays all take equal time when the thickness falls as b²/α with α = 2(n − 1)D, which is the focusing condition of a lens; in (ii) the logarithmic thickness has only one ring of rays with equal time, giving a ring-shaped image.

Teacher's Note:
1. Fermat's principle says that the actual path has an extremum of time. Setting dt/db = 0 is how we use it.
2. The thickness of a thin lens enters only through the extra optical path (n − 1)w(b), because the air path it replaces is already counted.

Examination Note: Write the total time carefully with the three terms, differentiate with respect to b, and give both results with the substitution 1/D = 1/u + 1/v.