These NCERT Exemplar solutions for Class 12 Physics Chapter 13, Nuclei, give step-by-step answers to all 26 questions: 7 MCQs, 3 multiple-correct MCQs, 5 very short, 5 short and 6 long answer questions. They cover radioactive decay and half-life, binding energy and nuclear stability, beta and gamma emission, chain decay, carbon dating and the shell model. Each answer is followed by a short Teacher's Note to build understanding and an Examination Note on how to present the answer for better marks.
Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)
(a) all the containers will have 5000 atoms of the material
(b) all the containers will contain the same number of atoms of the material but that number will only be approximately 5000
(c) the containers will in general have different numbers of the atoms of the material but their average will be close to 5000
(d) none of the containers can have more than 5000 atoms
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (c) the containers will in general have different numbers of the atoms of the material but their average will be close to 5000
Explanation:
1. Radioactive decay is a random (statistical) process. In one half-life each atom has a probability of one half of decaying, but which atoms decay is a matter of chance.
2. So the number left differs from container to container by small random amounts, while the average over a large number of containers is close to 5000.
Teacher's Note:
1. The half-life gives the expected number, not the exact number, for a small sample.
2. The law of decay is accurate only for a large number of atoms.
Examination Note: Use the word 'statistical': the average is 5000, individual containers vary.
(a) M = mproton + melectron
(b) \( M = m_{proton} + m_{electron} - \dfrac{B}{c^2} \) (B = 13.6 eV).
(c) M is not relate to the mass of the hydrogen atom.
(d) \( M = m_{proton} + m_{electron} - \dfrac{|V|}{c^2} \) (|V| = magnitude of the potential energy of electron in the H-atom).
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) \( M = m_{proton} + m_{electron} - \dfrac{B}{c^2} \) (B = 13.6 eV).
Explanation:
1. The mass of a bound system is less than the sum of the masses of its parts by the binding energy divided by \( c^2 \). The binding energy of the hydrogen atom is B = 13.6 eV.
2. So the mass of the atom is \( M = m_p + m_e - \dfrac{B}{c^2} \): (b). The potential energy |V| = 27.2 eV is twice the binding energy (the kinetic energy of the electron makes up the difference), so (d) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Mass defect = binding energy / c², for atoms as well as for nuclei.
2. For the atom the effect is tiny (13.6 eV against about 938 MeV), but it is the correct form.
Examination Note: Use mass defect = B/c² and note that B, not |V|, is the binding energy.
(a) do not change for any type of radioactivity
(b) change for α and β-radioactivity but not for γ-radioactivity
(c) change for α-radioactivity but not for others
(d) change for β-radioactivity but not for others
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) change for α and β-radioactivity but not for γ-radioactivity
Explanation:
1. In α-decay the nuclear charge falls by 2e and in β-decay it changes by 1e. The electrons of the atom then move in the field of a different nuclear charge, so their energy levels change.
2. A γ-ray carries no charge and the nuclear charge is the same before and after, so the electronic energy levels do not change.
Teacher's Note:
1. Electronic energy levels depend on the nuclear charge Z.
2. γ-emission only moves the nucleus to a lower energy state.
Examination Note: Link the change of the levels to the change of nuclear charge.
(a) \( Q_1 = (M_x-M_y)c^2 \) and \( Q_2 = [M_x-M_y-2m_e]c^2 \)
(b) \( Q_1 = (M_x-M_y)c^2 \) and \( Q_2 = (M_x-M_y)c^2 \)
(c) \( Q_1 = (M_x-M_y-2m_e)c^2 \) and \( Q_2 = (M_x-M_y+2m_e)c^2 \)
(d) \( Q_1 = (M_x-M_y+2m_e)c^2 \) and \( Q_2 = (M_x-M_y+2m_e)c^2 \)
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) \( Q_1 = (M_x-M_y)c^2 \) and \( Q_2 = [M_x-M_y-2m_e]c^2 \)
Explanation:
1. β− decay: \( {}^A_ZX \to {}^A_{Z+1}Y + e^- + \bar\nu \). Using nuclear masses, \( Q_1 = [m_N(X) - m_N(Y) - m_e]c^2 \). Writing nuclear masses as atomic mass minus Z electron masses, \( m_N(X) = M_x - Zm_e \) and \( m_N(Y) = M_y-(Z+1)m_e \), so \( Q_1 = (M_x-M_y)c^2 \).
2. β+ decay: \( {}^A_ZX \to {}^A_{Z-1}Y + e^+ + \nu \). \( Q_2 = [m_N(X)-m_N(Y)-m_e]c^2 \) with \( m_N(Y) = M_y-(Z-1)m_e \) gives \( Q_2 = (M_x-M_y-2m_e)c^2 \).
Teacher's Note:
1. The extra 2me in β+ decay is one electron mass for the emitted positron and one for the extra electron left behind in the atom.
2. Q is always the energy released, so it must be positive for the decay to occur.
Examination Note: Convert to nuclear masses, count the electron masses, and show both results.
(a) Triton energy is less than that of a He3 nucleus
(b) the electron created in the beta decay process cannot remain in the nucleus
(c) both the neutons in triton have to decay simultaneously resulting in a nucleus with 3 protons, which is not a He nucleus
(d) free neutrons decay due to external perturbations which is absent in triton nucleus
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) Triton energy is less than that of a He3 nucleus
Explanation:
1. A neutron inside a nucleus can decay only if the nucleus formed after the decay has a lower energy than the one before. The question says that the triton does not change into He3, so the energy reason is that the triton has lower energy than the He3 nucleus: (a).
2. (b) is not the reason, because electrons created in beta decay leave the nucleus at once. (c) and (d) are not true: one neutron decaying gives a 2-proton, 1-neutron nucleus, and decay needs no outside disturbance.
Teacher's Note:
1. The condition for any decay is that the total energy of the products is less than that of the parent.
2. In practice the energy difference between the triton and He3 is very small, and tritium does change into He3 very slowly (half-life about 12 years); the question asks only for the energy argument.
Examination Note: Give the energy condition for decay and reject the other three options in a line each.
(a) neutrons are heavier than protons
(b) electrostatic force between protons are repulsive
(c) neutrons decay into protons through beta decay
(d) nuclear forces between neutrons are weaker than that between protons
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) electrostatic force between protons are repulsive
Explanation:
1. Protons repel each other by the electrostatic force, which has a long range and acts between every pair of protons in the nucleus. In a heavy nucleus this repulsion becomes large.
2. The nuclear force is attractive between a neutron and a proton and also between like nucleons, but it has a short range. Extra neutrons add attraction without adding repulsion, so they keep a heavy nucleus stable.
Teacher's Note:
1. The electrostatic energy grows roughly as Z², but the nuclear attraction grows only in proportion to A.
2. This is why the N/Z ratio of stable nuclei rises from 1 to about 1.5.
Examination Note: Contrast the long-range repulsion between protons with the short-range attraction of nuclear forces.
(a) they will break up
(b) elastic collision of neutrons with heavy nuclei will not slow them down
(c) the net weight of the reactor would be unbearably high
(d) substances with heavy nuclei do not occur in liquid or gaseous state at room temperature
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) elastic collision of neutrons with heavy nuclei will not slow them down
Explanation:
1. In an elastic collision a neutron loses the most energy when it hits a particle of nearly equal mass; for equal masses in a head-on collision the velocities are exchanged.
2. A neutron striking a heavy nucleus just bounces back with almost the same speed, losing very little energy. So heavy nuclei cannot slow the neutrons down.
Teacher's Note:
1. Water, heavy water and graphite are used as moderators because they contain light nuclei.
2. A light moderator takes away a large fraction of the neutron energy per collision.
Examination Note: Say that the fraction of energy lost in an elastic collision is small for a heavy target.
Multiple Choice Questions (More Than One Option)
(a) nuclear forces have short range
(b) nuclei are positively charged
(c) the original nuclei must be completely ionized before fusion can take place
(d) the original nuclei must first break up before combining with each other
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) nuclear forces have short range, (b) nuclei are positively charged
Explanation:
1. Nuclei are positively charged, so two of them repel strongly by the Coulomb force. They must be brought very close (a few fm) to fuse: (b).
2. The nuclear force that binds them acts only over a very short range (a few fm), so it takes effect only after the Coulomb barrier has been overcome. This needs very high energy, that is very high temperature: (a).
3. Complete ionisation and breaking up of the nuclei before fusion are not required: (c) and (d) are wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Fusion in the Sun and in a hydrogen bomb needs temperatures of the order of 107 K or higher.
2. The same Coulomb barrier makes fusion much harder than fission.
Examination Note: Name both causes: the Coulomb barrier and the short range of nuclear forces.
(a) Initial rate of decay of A is twice the initial rate of decay of B and λA = λB
(b) Initial rate of decay of A is twice the initial rate of decay of B and λA > λB
(c) Initial rate of decay of B is twice the initial rate of decay of A and λA > λB
(d) Initial rate of decay of B is same as the rate of decay of A at t = 2 h and λB < λA
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) Initial rate of decay of A is twice the initial rate of decay of B and λA > λB, (d) Initial rate of decay of B is same as the rate of decay of A at t = 2 h and λB < λA
Explanation:
1. The decay rates are \( R_A = R_{A0}e^{-\lambda_At} \) and \( R_B = R_{B0}e^{-\lambda_Bt} \). They are equal when \( \dfrac{R_{A0}}{R_{B0}} = e^{(\lambda_A-\lambda_B)t} \), which needs a positive time t.
2. (a) The ratio is 2, but the right side is 1 for \( \lambda_A=\lambda_B \): never equal.
3. (b) \( 2 = e^{(\lambda_A-\lambda_B)t} \) gives \( t = \dfrac{\ln 2}{\lambda_A-\lambda_B} \gt 0 \): possible.
4. (c) The ratio is 1/2 but the right side is greater than 1 (as \( \lambda_A \gt \lambda_B \)): never equal.
5. (d) \( R_{B0} = R_{A0}e^{-2\lambda_A} \) (t in hours). Setting \( R_A = R_B \) gives \( t = \dfrac{2\lambda_A}{\lambda_A-\lambda_B} \gt 0 \): possible.
Teacher's Note:
1. The rate that is larger at the start must fall faster to catch up, so its λ must be larger.
2. Write the condition as one equation for t and ask whether t is positive.
Examination Note: Put the two exponentials equal and examine the sign of t in each case.
(a) Decay constant of A is greater than that of B, hence A always decays faster than B
(b) Decay constant of B is greater than that of A but its decay rate is always smaller than that of A
(c) Decay constant of A is greater than that of B but it does not always decay faster than B
(d) Decay constant of B is smaller than that of A but still its decay rate becomes equal to that of A at a later instant
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (c) Decay constant of A is greater than that of B but it does not always decay faster than B, (d) Decay constant of B is smaller than that of A but still its decay rate becomes equal to that of A at a later instant
Explanation:
1. The decay rate is \( R = R_0e^{-\lambda t} \). The curve of A starts higher but falls more steeply (relative to its value) than that of B, so \( \lambda_A \gt \lambda_B \).
2. The two curves cross at the point P. Before P the rate of A is greater, and after P the rate of B is greater. So A does not always decay faster than B: (c), and at P the two rates are equal: (d).
3. (a) and (b) are wrong, because (a) says A is always faster and (b) says B has the larger λ.
Teacher's Note:
1. The decay constant is the fractional rate of fall of the curve, not its height.
2. A sample with a smaller λ but more atoms at the start can have the larger rate for a long time.
Examination Note: Compare the steepness of the curves for λ and the crossing point for the rates.
Very Short Answer Type Questions
Question 11. \( {}^3_2\text{He} \) and \( {}^3_1\text{H} \) nuclei have the same mass number. Do they have the same binding energy?
Answer:
No. \( {}^3_2\text{He} \) has two protons and one neutron, and \( {}^3_1\text{H} \) has one proton and two neutrons.
The helium nucleus has two protons repelling each other, and this electrostatic repulsion reduces its binding energy. \( {}^3_1\text{H} \) has no proton-proton repulsion.
The binding energy of \( {}^3_1\text{H} \) (about 8.5 MeV) is greater than that of \( {}^3_2\text{He} \) (about 7.7 MeV).
In simple words: The nuclear forces are the same for the two nuclei, but the Coulomb repulsion between the two protons lowers the binding energy of helium-3.
Teacher's Note:
1. Isobars have the same A but different Z; their binding energies differ mainly by the Coulomb energy.
2. Nuclei with the same number of nucleons need not have the same binding energy.
Examination Note: Say no, and give the reason in terms of the repulsion of the two protons.
Question 12. Draw a graph showing the variation of decay rate with number of active nuclei.
Answer:
The rate of decay is \( -\dfrac{dN}{dt} = \lambda N \), or \( \dfrac{dN}{dt} = -\lambda N \). The decay constant λ is a constant for a given material.
So dN/dt is directly proportional to N: the graph of dN/dt against N is a straight line through the origin with slope −λ (the activity −dN/dt gives a line of positive slope λ).
In simple words: The more active nuclei there are, the faster the decay: the rate is directly proportional to N.
Teacher's Note:
1. The slope of the line gives the decay constant: λ = −slope.
2. If the activity −dN/dt is plotted instead of dN/dt, the line is above the axis with positive slope λ.
Examination Note: Write dN/dt = −λN, state that it is a straight line through the origin, and label the axes.
Question 13. Which sample A or B shown in figure has shorter mean-life?
Answer:
The decay rate is \( \dfrac{dN}{dt} \propto e^{-\lambda t} \), so the larger the decay constant, the faster the rate falls with time.
In the figure, the rate for A falls only to about half of its starting value over the time shown, while the rate for B falls to about a quarter of its starting value. So B falls more steeply: \( \lambda_B \gt \lambda_A \).
The mean life is \( \tau = \dfrac1\lambda \), so \( \tau_B \lt \tau_A \): sample B has the shorter mean life.
In simple words: A larger decay constant means a faster fall and a shorter mean life; sample B falls faster.
Teacher's Note:
1. Mean life τ = 1/λ and half-life T = 0.693 τ, so a short mean life means a short half-life.
2. Compare the fractional fall of each curve, not the heights.
Examination Note: Link the steepness of the fall to λ, then use τ = 1/λ.
Question 14. Which one of the following cannot emit radiation and why? Excited nucleus, excited electron.
Answer:
An excited nucleus returns to a lower state by emitting γ-radiation, with photon energies of the order of MeV, as the energy gaps between nuclear levels are of this size.
An electron in an excited atomic level has energy gaps of only a few eV (up to keV for inner electrons), so the photons it emits have energies of the order of eV, in the visible and ultraviolet region.
The excited electron cannot emit radiation of the γ type, since its energy levels are only a few eV apart and not MeV apart.
In simple words: Nuclear transitions are in MeV and atomic transitions in eV, so only the excited nucleus can give γ-rays.
Teacher's Note:
1. The energy of a photon is the difference of the two levels, E = hν.
2. Compare the sizes: 1 MeV is a million times 1 eV.
Examination Note: Give the energy scales of the two kinds of transitions (MeV and eV).
Question 15. In pair annihilation, an electron and a positron destroy each other to produce gamma radiations. How is the momentum conserved?
Answer:
The reaction is \( e^- + e^+ \to \gamma + \gamma \).
Take the frame in which the electron and the positron are (nearly) at rest. The total momentum before the annihilation is zero.
A single photon would carry momentum, so the momentum could not be conserved. Two photons of equal energy (0.511 MeV each) travelling in opposite directions have equal and opposite momenta, which add to zero, so the momentum is conserved.
In simple words: Two gamma photons fly off back to back, so their momenta cancel as the initial momentum was zero.
Teacher's Note:
1. Energy is also conserved: the rest energy of the pair, 2 × 0.511 MeV, becomes the energy of the two photons.
2. Pair production is the reverse process and needs a nearby nucleus to take up momentum.
Examination Note: Write the reaction and say that the photons move in opposite directions.
Short Answer Type Questions
Question 16. Why do stable nuclei never have more protons than neutrons?
Answer:
Protons are positively charged and repel one another electrically, and this repulsion acts over the whole nucleus.
The nuclear force is a short-range attraction. In nuclei with more than 10 protons or so the repulsion becomes so large that an excess of neutrons, which give only attractive nuclear forces and no repulsion, is needed to keep the nucleus stable.
So stable nuclei (apart from very light ones) have more neutrons than protons.
In simple words: Neutrons add binding without adding repulsion, so heavier stable nuclei need more neutrons than protons.
Teacher's Note:
1. The only stable nuclei with more protons than neutrons are 1H and 3He.
2. In light nuclei the number of neutrons is nearly equal to the number of protons.
Examination Note: Contrast the repulsion between protons with the short range of the attraction.
Question 17. Consider a radioactive nucleus A which decays to a stable nucleus C through the following sequence \( A \to B \to C \). Here B is an intermediate nuclei which is also radioactive. Considering that there are N0 atoms of A initially, plot the graph showing the variation of number of atoms of A and B versus time.
Answer:
For A: \( N_A = N_0e^{-\lambda_At} \), which is N0 at t = 0 and falls exponentially to zero.
For B: \( \dfrac{dN_B}{dt} = \lambda_AN_A - \lambda_BN_B \). At t = 0, \( N_B = 0 \); B is produced from A and decays itself. The solution is \( N_B = \dfrac{N_0\lambda_A}{\lambda_B-\lambda_A}\left(e^{-\lambda_At}-e^{-\lambda_Bt}\right) \).
NB rises from 0 to a maximum at \( t_m = \dfrac{\ln(\lambda_B/\lambda_A)}{\lambda_B-\lambda_A} \) (where \( \lambda_AN_A = \lambda_BN_B \)) and then falls to zero. The curves are shown in the figure (drawn for \( \lambda_A = 2\lambda_B \)).
In simple words: The number of A atoms only falls; the number of B atoms first rises (B is made faster than it decays), reaches a maximum, and then falls to zero.
Teacher's Note:
1. At the maximum of the B curve, the rate of formation of B equals its rate of decay.
2. The stable nucleus C only increases, reaching N0 at the end.
Examination Note: Write the two equations for NA and NB and draw the curves with NB starting from zero.
Question 18. A piece of wood from the ruins of an ancient building was found to have a 14C activity of 12 disintegrations per minute per gram of its carbon content. The 14C activity of the living wood is 16 disintegrations per minute per gram. How long ago did the tree, from which the wooden sample came, die? Given half-life of 14C is 5760 yr.
Answer:
Given R = 12 per min per g, \( R_0 = 16 \) per min per g, \( T_{1/2} = 5760 \) yr. The decay law: \( R = R_0e^{-\lambda t} \), so \( e^{\lambda t} = \dfrac{R_0}{R} = \dfrac{16}{12} = \dfrac43 \).
\( t = \dfrac{1}{\lambda}\ln\dfrac43 = \dfrac{T_{1/2}}{\ln2}\ln\dfrac43 = \dfrac{5760\times0.2877}{0.6931} \).
\( t \approx 2391 \) yr (about 2.4 thousand years).
In simple words: The activity has dropped to three quarters of its value in living wood, and this takes about 0.415 half-lives, i.e. about 2391 years.
Teacher's Note:
1. Carbon dating assumes that the ratio of 14C to 12C in living matter stays constant, and the decay starts when the tree dies.
2. Use λ = 0.693/T1/2 and natural logarithms.
Examination Note: Write the decay law, take the natural logarithm, and substitute λ = 0.693/T1/2.
Question 19. Are the nucleons fundamental particles, or do they consist of still smaller parts? One way to find out is to try to probe a nucleon just as Rutherford probed an atom. What should be the kinetic energy of an electron for it to be able to probe a nucleon? Assume the diameter of a nucleon to be approximately 10−15 m.
Answer:
To see details inside a nucleon, the de Broglie wavelength of the electron must be at most the size of the nucleon: \( \lambda \approx 10^{-15} \) m. Its momentum is \( p = \dfrac h\lambda \).
This momentum corresponds to \( pc = \dfrac{hc}{\lambda} = \dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}\times3\times10^{8}}{10^{-15}\ \text{J}} = \dfrac{2\times10^{-10}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}\ \text{eV} \approx 1.2\times10^{9}\ \text{eV} \).
Since pc is about 1200 MeV, much more than the rest energy of the electron (0.51 MeV), the electron is ultra-relativistic and its kinetic energy is nearly equal to pc.
KE \( \approx 1.2\times10^{9} \) eV \( \approx 10^{9} \) eV (about 1 GeV)
In simple words: To probe a region of size 10−15 m an electron needs an energy of about a billion electron volts.
Teacher's Note:
1. The non-relativistic formula p²/2m would be wrong here; the energy is far above the rest energy.
2. Electron scattering experiments at such energies showed that the proton has an inner structure.
Examination Note: Use λ = h/p, notice that the electron is relativistic, and take KE ≈ pc = hc/λ.
Question 20. A nuclide 1 is said to be the mirror isobar of nuclide 2 if Z1 = N2 and Z2 = N1. (a) What nuclide is a mirror isobar of 2311Na? (b) Which nuclide out of the two mirror isobars have greater binding energy and why?
Answer:
(a) For \( {}^{23}_{11}\text{Na} \): \( Z_1 = 11 \) and \( N_1 = 23-11 = 12 \). The mirror isobar has \( Z_2 = N_1 = 12 \) and \( N_2 = Z_1 = 11 \), which is \( {}^{23}_{12}\text{Mg} \).
(b) Nuclear forces do not depend on charge, so the two nuclei have the same nuclear attraction. They differ only in the electrostatic repulsion between protons, which is larger for Mg (12 protons) than for Na (11 protons).
This lowers the binding energy of Mg. \( {}^{23}_{11}\text{Na} \) has the greater binding energy (about 186.6 MeV against about 181.7 MeV for \( {}^{23}_{12}\text{Mg} \)).
In simple words: Both nuclei have 23 nucleons with the same nuclear force; the one with more protons has more repulsion and so is less tightly bound.
Teacher's Note:
1. Mirror nuclei are a good test of the charge independence of the nuclear force.
2. Mg-23 is also unstable, and decays to Na-23 by positron emission.
Examination Note: Swap Z and N for (a); for (b) argue from the Coulomb repulsion.
Long Answer Type Questions
Question 21. Sometimes a radioactive nucleus decays into a nucleus which itself is radioactive. An example is \( {}^{38}\text{S} \xrightarrow{\ 2.48\ \text{h}\ } {}^{38}\text{Cl} \xrightarrow{\ 0.62\ \text{h}\ } {}^{38}\text{Ar (stable)} \). Assume that we start with 1000 38S nuclei at time t = 0. The number of 38Cl is of count zero at t = 0 and will again be zero at t = ∞. At what value of t, would the number of counts be a maximum?
Answer:
Let \( N_1 \) be the number of S nuclei and \( N_2 \) the number of Cl nuclei, with decay constants \( \lambda_1 = \dfrac{0.693}{2.48} \) and \( \lambda_2 = \dfrac{0.693}{0.62} \) per hour. \( N_1 = N_0e^{-\lambda_1t} \).
\( \dfrac{dN_2}{dt} = \lambda_1N_1 - \lambda_2N_2 = \lambda_1N_0e^{-\lambda_1t}-\lambda_2N_2 \). Solving with \( N_2(0)=0 \):
\( N_2 = \dfrac{N_0\lambda_1}{\lambda_2-\lambda_1}\left(e^{-\lambda_1t}-e^{-\lambda_2t}\right) \)
For the maximum, \( \dfrac{dN_2}{dt} = 0 \): \( -\lambda_1e^{-\lambda_1t}+\lambda_2e^{-\lambda_2t} = 0 \), so \( e^{(\lambda_2-\lambda_1)t} = \dfrac{\lambda_2}{\lambda_1} \).
\( t_m = \dfrac{\ln(\lambda_2/\lambda_1)}{\lambda_2-\lambda_1} \). Here \( \dfrac{\lambda_2}{\lambda_1} = \dfrac{2.48}{0.62} = 4 \) and \( \lambda_2-\lambda_1 = 0.693\left(\dfrac1{0.62}-\dfrac1{2.48}\right) = 0.838\ \text{h}^{-1} \).
\( t_m = \dfrac{\ln 4}{0.838} = \dfrac{1.386}{0.838} \). \( t_m \approx 1.65 \) h (the maximum number of Cl nuclei is then about 157).
In simple words: The number of Cl nuclei rises as long as S makes Cl faster than Cl decays, and is greatest when the two rates are equal, about 1.65 hours after the start.
Teacher's Note:
1. For a chain A → B → C do not use the simple decay law for B: its number is fed by A as well.
2. At the maximum, λ1N1 = λ2N2.
Examination Note: Set up dN2/dt, solve it with N2(0) = 0, then put dN2/dt = 0 and substitute the decay constants (not the half-lives).
Question 22. Deuteron is a bound state of a neutron and a proton with a binding energy B = 2.2 MeV. A γ-ray of energy E is aimed at a deuteron nucleus to try to break it into a (neutron + proton) such that the n and p move in the direction of the incident γ-ray. If E = B, show that this cannot happen. Hence, calculate how much bigger than B must be E for such a process to happen.
Answer:
Let each nucleon have mass m. Energy conservation: \( E - B = K_n + K_p = \dfrac{p_n^2}{2m}+\dfrac{p_p^2}{2m} \) (i). Momentum conservation (both move along the γ-ray): \( p_n+p_p = \dfrac Ec \) (ii).
If E = B, (i) gives \( p_n^2+p_p^2 = 0 \), so \( p_n = p_p = 0 \). But (ii) needs \( p_n+p_p = E/c \neq 0 \). So the process cannot happen.
Let \( E = B + X \), with X the extra energy. From (ii), \( p_n = \dfrac Ec - p_p \); put it in (i): \( X = \dfrac{(E/c-p_p)^2+p_p^2}{2m} \), i.e. \( 2p_p^2 - \dfrac{2E}{c}p_p + \dfrac{E^2}{c^2}-2mX = 0 \).
For a real value of \( p_p \) the discriminant must not be negative: \( \dfrac{4E^2}{c^2} - 8\left(\dfrac{E^2}{c^2}-2mX\right) \ge 0 \), that is \( 16mX \ge \dfrac{4E^2}{c^2} \).
\( X \ge \dfrac{E^2}{4mc^2} \approx \dfrac{B^2}{4mc^2} \) (since \( X \ll B \)). With \( mc^2 \approx 938 \) MeV: \( X \approx \dfrac{(2.2)^2}{4\times938} \) MeV.
\( X \approx 1.3\times10^{-3} \) MeV \( \approx 1.3 \) keV. So E must exceed B by at least about 1.3 keV.
In simple words: The γ-ray carries momentum E/c, so the nucleons must also move after the break-up; this needs a little kinetic energy over and above B, at least about 1.3 keV.
Teacher's Note:
1. The quadratic must have real roots: this condition gives the smallest possible X.
2. The result is a small fraction (about 0.06 per cent) of B, so E ≈ B in the final formula.
Examination Note: Treat energy and momentum conservation together, and use the discriminant for the minimum X.
Question 23. The deuteron is bound by nuclear forces just as H-atom is made up of p and e bound by electrostatic forces. If we consider the force between neutron and proton in deuteron as given in the form a coulomb potential but with an effective charge e′ \( F = \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\cdot\dfrac{e'^2}{r} \) estimate the value of (e′/e) given that the binding energy of a deuteron is 2.2 MeV.
Answer:
The binding energy of the hydrogen atom is \( E = \dfrac{me^4}{8\varepsilon_0^2h^2} = 13.6 \) eV (i), where m is the electron mass (strictly the reduced mass, nearly m).
For the deuteron, replace e by e′ and the electron mass by the reduced mass of the neutron and proton: \( m' = \dfrac{M\times M}{M+M} = \dfrac M2 = \dfrac{1836m}{2} = 918m \).
Binding energy of the deuteron: \( \dfrac{918m\,e'^4}{8\varepsilon_0^2h^2} = 2.2 \) MeV (ii).
Dividing (ii) by (i): \( 918\left(\dfrac{e'}{e}\right)^4 = \dfrac{2.2\times10^6}{13.6} \), so \( \left(\dfrac{e'}{e}\right)^4 = \dfrac{2.2\times10^6}{13.6\times918} = 176.2 \).
\( \dfrac{e'}{e} = (176.2)^{1/4} \approx 3.6 \)
In simple words: The nuclear force between a neutron and a proton is like a Coulomb force with an effective charge about 3.6 times the electronic charge.
Teacher's Note:
1. The energy scales as m e⁴, so one ratio of energies gives the fourth power of the ratio of charges.
2. The reduced mass of two equal masses is half of one mass.
Examination Note: Compare with the hydrogen atom by taking a ratio, replacing m by the reduced mass 918 m.
Question 24. Before the neutrino hypothesis, the beta decay process was thought to be the transition \( n \to p + \bar e \). If this was true, show that if the neutron was at rest, the proton and electron would emerge with fixed energies and calculate them. Experimentally, the electron energy was found to have a large range.
Answer:
Let the neutron be at rest: \( E_n = m_nc^2 \) and momentum zero. Momentum conservation gives \( \vec p_p = -\vec p_e \), so both have the same magnitude p.
Energy conservation: \( \sqrt{m_p^2c^4+p^2c^2}+\sqrt{m_e^2c^4+p^2c^2} = m_nc^2 \). This is one equation for one unknown p, so p has a single fixed value, and the energies of the proton and electron are fixed.
Solving, the energy of the electron is \( E_e = \dfrac{(m_n^2+m_e^2-m_p^2)c^2}{2m_n} \). With \( m_nc^2 = 939.57 \) MeV, \( m_pc^2 = 938.27 \) MeV, \( m_ec^2 = 0.511 \) MeV:
\( E_e \approx 1.29 \) MeV, that is a kinetic energy of about 0.78 MeV; the momentum is \( pc = \sqrt{E_e^2-m_e^2c^4} \approx 1.19 \) MeV.
The proton has total energy \( \sqrt{(938.27)^2+(1.19)^2} \approx 938.27 \) MeV, so its kinetic energy is only about \( \dfrac{p^2}{2m_p} \approx 0.75 \) keV.
So the electron would always come out with 0.78 MeV of kinetic energy. Experiments show a continuous range of electron energies from zero up to this value; the missing energy and momentum are carried by a third particle, the neutrino.
In simple words: A decay into two particles from rest has only one possible sharing of the energy, so a continuous range of electron energies shows that a third particle takes part.
Teacher's Note:
1. The total energy released is (mn − mp − me)c² ≈ 0.78 MeV, and almost all of it goes to the electron because the proton is so heavy.
2. Pauli proposed the neutrino to save the conservation of energy and momentum.
Examination Note: Show that momentum conservation leaves only one unknown, so the energies are fixed; give the numbers and the conclusion.
Question 25. The activity R of an unknown radioactive nuclide is measured at hourly intervals. The result found are tabulated as follows
(i) Plot the graph of R versus t and calculate half-life from the graph. (ii) Plot the graph of \( \ln\left(\dfrac{R}{R_0}\right) \) versus t and obtain the value of half-life from the graph.t (h) 0 1 2 3 4 R (MBq) 100 35.36 12.51 4.42 1.56
Answer:
The values of \( \ln(R/R_0) \) are: t = 1 h: −1.04; t = 2 h: −2.08; t = 3 h: −3.12; t = 4 h: −4.16.
(i) The graph of R against t is an exponential curve (figure). Read off the time at which the activity falls to half of 100 MBq, i.e. 50 MBq: this is at \( t \approx 0.67 \) h. \( T_{1/2} \approx 0.67 \) h \( \approx 40 \) min.
(ii) From \( R = R_0e^{-\lambda t} \): \( \ln\dfrac{R}{R_0} = -\lambda t \). The graph of \( \ln(R/R_0) \) against t is a straight line through the origin with slope \( -\lambda \) (figure).
Slope \( = \dfrac{-4.16-0}{4-0} = -1.04\ \text{h}^{-1} \), so \( \lambda = 1.04\ \text{h}^{-1} \).
\( T_{1/2} = \dfrac{0.693}{\lambda} = \dfrac{0.693}{1.04} \approx 0.67 \) h \( \approx 40 \) min, the same as from the first graph.
In simple words: Both graphs give a half-life of about 40 minutes; the straight-line graph of ln(R/R0) against t is more accurate because the slope is easy to measure.
Teacher's Note:
1. Plotting a logarithm turns an exponential decay into a straight line.
2. The activity falls by the same factor (about 2.83) every hour, so one half-life is 1/1.5 of an hour, that is 40 minutes.
Examination Note: Show a table of ln(R/R0), the two graphs with labelled axes, and the half-life from each.
Question 26. Nuclei with magic number of proton Z = 2, 8, 20, 28, 50, 52 and magic number of neutrons N = 2, 8, 20, 28, 50, 82 and 126 are found to be very stable. (i) Verify this by calculating the proton separation energy Sp for 120Sn (Z = 50) and 121Sb (Z = 51). The proton separation energy for a nuclide is the minimum energy required to separate the least tightly bound proton from a nucleus of that nuclide. It is given by \( S_p = (M_{Z-1,N}+M_H-M_{Z,N})c^2 \). Given, 119In = 118.9058 u, 120Sn = 119.902199 u, 121Sb = 120.903824 u, 1H = 1.0078252 u. (ii) What does the existence of magic number indicate?
Answer:
(i) For \( {}^{120}\text{Sn} \): removing a proton leaves \( {}^{119}\text{In} \). \( S_p(\text{Sn}) = (118.9058+1.0078252-119.902199)c^2 = 0.0114262\,c^2 \).
For \( {}^{121}\text{Sb} \): removing a proton leaves \( {}^{120}\text{Sn} \). \( S_p(\text{Sb}) = (119.902199+1.0078252-120.903824)c^2 = 0.0062002\,c^2 \).
Using \( 1\ \text{u} = 931.5 \) MeV/c²: \( S_p(\text{Sn}) \approx 10.6 \) MeV and \( S_p(\text{Sb}) \approx 5.8 \) MeV.
Sp(Sn) is much greater than Sp(Sb): it takes far more energy to remove a proton from tin (Z = 50, a magic number) than from antimony (Z = 51). So the nucleus with a magic number of protons is the more tightly bound and more stable.
(ii) The existence of magic numbers shows that the nucleus has a shell structure, like the shell structure of the electrons in an atom. Filled shells give specially stable nuclei; this also explains the peaks in the binding energy per nucleon curve.
In simple words: It takes about twice as much energy to remove a proton from tin as from antimony, because tin has a closed shell of 50 protons.
Teacher's Note:
1. The mass of the atom of the lighter element plus the mass of H, minus the mass of the heavier atom, gives the mass equivalent of Sp: the electron masses balance.
2. Compare in the same way with the neutron separation energy to see the effect of magic numbers of neutrons.
Examination Note: Show both subtractions, convert to MeV, compare them and name the shell model in (ii).