NCERT Exemplar Solutions Class 12 Physics Chapter 10 Wave Optics

These NCERT Exemplar solutions for Class 12 Physics Chapter 10, Wave Optics, give step-by-step answers to all 23 questions: 5 MCQs, 4 multiple-correct MCQs, 6 very short, 3 short and 5 long answer questions. They cover Huygens' principle and wavefronts, Young's double-slit experiment, coherence, single-slit diffraction, resolving power, polarisation and Brewster's angle, thin-film interference and negative refraction. Each answer is followed by a short Teacher's Note to build understanding and an Examination Note on how to present the answer for better marks.

Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)

Question 1: Consider a light beam incident from air to a glass slab at Brewster's angle as shown in the figure. A polaroid is placed in the path of the emergent ray at point P and rotated about an axis passing through the centre and perpendicular to the plane of the polaroid.
PN (a) For a particular orientation, there shall be darkness as observed through the polaroid
(b) The intensity of light as seen through the polaroid shall be independent of the rotation
(c) The intensity of light as seen through the polaroid shall go through a minimum but not zero for two orientations of the polaroid
(d) The intensity of light as seen through the polaroid shall go through a minimum for four orientations of the polaroid
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (c) The intensity of light as seen through the polaroid shall go through a minimum but not zero for two orientations of the polaroid

Explanation:
1. At Brewster's angle the reflected beam is completely plane polarised, with its electric vector perpendicular to the plane of incidence. The light incident from air is unpolarised, so the reflected beam carries away only part of the light (only the perpendicular component).
2. The transmitted (refracted) beam therefore contains all of the parallel component and the rest of the perpendicular component: it is partially polarised, not unpolarised and not completely polarised. After emerging from the slab it is still partially polarised.
3. When a polaroid is rotated in a partially polarised beam, the intensity varies between a maximum and a non-zero minimum. A full turn of 360° gives two maxima and two minima, so the intensity goes through a minimum, but not zero, for two orientations of the polaroid: (c).

Teacher's Note:
1. Darkness would need completely polarised light, and no variation would mean unpolarised light.
2. Intensity through a polaroid in a partially polarised beam follows I = Imin + (Imax − Imin)cos²α.

Examination Note: Say that the transmitted beam is partially polarised; this single phrase explains why the minimum is not zero.

 

Question 2: Consider sunlight incident on a slit of width 104 Å. The image seen through the slit shall
(a) be a fine sharp slit white in colour at the centre
(b) a bright slit white at the centre diffusing to zero intensities at the edges
(c) a bright slit white at the centre diffusing to regions of different colours
(d) only be a diffused slit white in colour
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (c) a bright slit white at the centre diffusing to regions of different colours

Explanation:
1. Slit width a = 104 Å = 10−6 m = 1 μm. The wavelengths of visible light are 4000 Å to 8000 Å, so the slit width is only about 1.3 to 2.5 times the wavelength: diffraction is strong.
2. For single-slit diffraction the first minimum is at \( \sin\theta = \lambda/a \), which is different for different colours (about 24° for violet and about 53° for red). So the light spreads out widely instead of forming a sharp image.
3. At the centre of the pattern (θ = 0) all colours have their maxima, so the central region is bright and white. Away from the centre, the different colours spread by different angles, so the edges of the pattern show different colours: (c).

Teacher's Note:
1. A slit much wider than the wavelength gives a sharp geometrical image; a slit comparable to the wavelength gives a broad diffraction pattern.
2. Red light diffracts more than violet light, so the outer parts of the pattern are coloured.

Examination Note: Compare the slit width (1 μm) with the wavelength (0.4 to 0.8 μm) first; then say white at the centre because every colour has its central maximum there, and coloured at the edges.

 

Question 3: Consider a ray of light incident from air onto a slab of glass (refractive index n) of width d, at an angle θ. The phase difference between the ray reflected by the top surface of the glass and the bottom surface is (λ is the wavelength of light inside the glass)
(a) \( \dfrac{4\pi d}{\lambda}\left(1 - \dfrac{1}{n^2}\sin^2\theta\right)^{1/2} + \pi \)
(b) \( \dfrac{4\pi d}{\lambda}\left(1 - \dfrac{1}{n^2}\sin^2\theta\right)^{1/2} \)
(c) \( \dfrac{4\pi d}{\lambda}\left(1 - \dfrac{1}{n^2}\sin^2\theta\right)^{1/2} + \dfrac{\pi}{2} \)
(d) \( \dfrac{4\pi d}{\lambda}\left(1 - \dfrac{1}{n^2}\sin^2\theta\right)^{1/2} + 2\pi \)
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (a) \( \dfrac{4\pi d}{\lambda}\left(1 - \dfrac{1}{n^2}\sin^2\theta\right)^{1/2} + \pi \)

Explanation:
1. Let the refraction angle be r, so \( \sin r = \dfrac{\sin\theta}{n} \) and \( \cos r = \sqrt{1 - \dfrac{\sin^2\theta}{n^2}} \).
2. The ray reflected from the bottom surface travels an extra path inside the glass, and (after allowing for the shorter path of the other ray in air) the effective path difference is \( 2nd\cos r \) in terms of the wavelength in air λ0. In terms of the wavelength in glass, \( \lambda = \lambda_0/n \), the phase difference due to the path is \( \dfrac{2\pi}{\lambda_0}\,2nd\cos r = \dfrac{4\pi d}{\lambda}\cos r \).
3. Reflection from the top surface (air to glass, a denser medium) introduces a phase change of π. Reflection at the bottom surface (glass to air) introduces no change.
4. Net phase difference: \( \dfrac{4\pi d}{\lambda}\left(1 - \dfrac{1}{n^2}\sin^2\theta\right)^{1/2} + \pi \). So (a) is correct.

Teacher's Note:
1. Phase change of π on reflection occurs only when light is reflected from a denser medium (higher refractive index).
2. The same idea gives the condition for thin-film colours: 2nd cos r = (m + ½)λ0 for a bright film.

Examination Note: Remember both parts: the path term 4πd cos r/λ and the extra π from the reflection at the air-glass surface.

 

Question 4: In a Young's double-slit experiment, the source is white light. One of the holes is covered by a red filter and another by a blue filter. In this case,
(a) there shall be alternate interference patterns of red and blue
(b) there shall be an interference pattern for red distinct from that for blue
(c) there shall be no interference fringes
(d) there shall be an interference pattern for red mixing with one for blue
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (c) there shall be no interference fringes

Explanation:
1. For a sustained interference pattern, the two sources must be coherent: same frequency (wavelength) and a constant phase difference.
2. After the filters, one slit emits only red light and the other only blue light. These have different frequencies, so the phase difference between the two waves changes rapidly and continuously with time.
3. Therefore the waves are not coherent and no interference fringes are formed; the screen is simply illuminated (c).

Teacher's Note:
1. Different colours cannot interfere with each other, because their frequencies differ.
2. In Young's experiment, both slits must receive light from the same source through the same filter.

Examination Note: State the condition for coherence (same frequency, constant phase difference) and show that red and blue light violate it.

 

Question 5: The figure shows a standard two-slit arrangement with slits S1, S2; P1, P2 are the two minima points on either side of P. At P2 on the screen, there is a hole and behind P2 is a second 2-slit arrangement with slits S3, S4 and a second screen behind them.
SS1S2P1PP2S3S4Second screenScreen (a) There would be no interference pattern on the second screen but it would be lighted
(b) The second screen would be totally dark
(c) There would be a single bright point on the second screen
(d) There would be a regular two slit pattern on the second screen
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (d) There would be a regular two slit pattern on the second screen

Explanation:
1. By Huygens' principle, every point of the opening acts as a source of secondary wavelets. The small hole at P2 therefore behaves as a fresh, small source of light for the slits S3 and S4.
2. The light which passes through a small hole is spatially coherent: the same wavefront falls on S3 and S4, so they act as two coherent sources.
3. Hence a regular two-slit interference pattern forms on the second screen (d). It is faint, because P2 lies at a minimum of the first pattern, but its character is the same as that of a standard two-slit pattern.

Teacher's Note:
1. Any small aperture illuminated by light acts as a coherent source, which is the basic idea of Young's own single slit placed before the double slit.
2. The coherence of S3 and S4 comes from the single hole behind which both are placed.

Examination Note: Quote Huygens' principle and say that the hole acts as a new coherent source; the pattern is formed because S3 and S4 are illuminated by the same source.

 

Multiple Choice Questions (More Than One Option)

Question 6: Two sources S1 and S2 of intensity I1 and I2 are placed in front of a screen [Fig. (a)]. The pattern of intensity distribution seen in the central portion is given by Fig. (b). In this case, which of the following statements are true?
S1S2x(a)x(b) (a) S1 and S2 have the same intensities
(b) S1 and S2 have a constant phase difference
(c) S1 and S2 have the same phase
(d) S1 and S2 have the same wavelength
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (a) S1 and S2 have the same intensities, (b) S1 and S2 have a constant phase difference, (d) S1 and S2 have the same wavelength

Explanation:
1. The resultant intensity is \( I = I_1 + I_2 + 2\sqrt{I_1I_2}\cos\phi \). The minimum value is \( (\sqrt{I_1} - \sqrt{I_2})^2 \). In the figure every minimum is exactly zero, which needs \( I_1 = I_2 \): (a) is true.
2. A steady, regularly spaced fringe pattern appears only if the phase difference between the sources stays constant in time: (b) is true. Constant phase difference also needs the same frequency, so the same wavelength: (d) is true.
3. A constant phase difference need not be zero. A non-zero constant phase difference would just shift the pattern sideways, so the figure does not prove that the sources are in phase: (c) cannot be concluded.

Teacher's Note:
1. Zero minima mean the two amplitudes are equal.
2. Coherence = same wavelength + constant phase difference.

Examination Note: Relate each of the three observed features (zero minima, steady fringes, regular spacing) to a property of the sources.

 

Question 7: Consider sunlight incident on a pinhole of width 103 Å. The image of the pinhole seen on a screen shall be
(a) a sharp white ring
(b) different from a geometrical image
(c) a diffused central spot, white in colour
(d) diffused coloured region around a sharp central white spot
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (b) different from a geometrical image, (c) a diffused central spot, white in colour

Explanation:
1. The pinhole is 103 Å = 0.1 μm wide, much smaller than the wavelength of visible light (4000 Å to 8000 Å). Diffraction is very strong, and since λ/a > 1 there is no first minimum at all.
2. The light spreads out over a very wide region instead of forming a small geometrical image of the hole: the image is different from a geometrical image (b).
3. The spread is nearly the same for all colours and there is no sharp structure, so the central spot is diffused and, because every colour is present at the centre, it appears white (c). Options (a) and (d) require fringes with a sharp central spot, which need a hole larger than the wavelength.

Teacher's Note:
1. Compare with Q.2: a slit comparable to the wavelength gives white centre with coloured edges; a hole much smaller than λ gives a broad, nearly uniform white spot.
2. The hole acts almost like a point source of spherical wavelets.

Examination Note: Compare the hole size with the wavelength first. Mention that no minima exist when λ/a > 1.

 

Question 8: Consider the diffraction pattern for a small pinhole. As the size of the hole is increased,
(a) the size decreases
(b) the intensity increases
(c) the size increases
(d) the intensity decreases
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (a) the size decreases, (b) the intensity increases

Explanation:
1. The angular size of the central bright spot is about \( \theta \approx \dfrac{1.22\lambda}{a} \) for a hole of diameter a. As a increases, the diffraction spot gets smaller: (a).
2. A larger hole lets more light through, and this light is concentrated in a smaller area on the screen. So the intensity at the centre increases: (b).

Teacher's Note:
1. A bigger hole means less diffraction: the pattern approaches the geometrical shadow.
2. Intensity = power per unit area; power goes up while area goes down.

Examination Note: Give the relation θ ≈ 1.22λ/a for the size and argue for the intensity from 'more light, smaller area'.

 

Question 9: For light diverging from a point source,
(a) the wavefront is spherical
(b) the intensity decreases in proportion to the distance squared
(c) the wavefront is parabolic
(d) the intensity at the wavefront does not depend on the distance
Show Answer & Explanation

Answer: (a) the wavefront is spherical, (b) the intensity decreases in proportion to the distance squared

Explanation:
1. A point source emits light equally in all directions, so the surfaces of constant phase are spheres centred on the source: the wavefront is spherical (a).
2. If the power of the source is P, the intensity at distance r is \( I = \dfrac{P}{4\pi r^2} \), so the intensity decreases in proportion to the distance squared, i.e. as \( 1/r^2 \) (b).
3. The wavefront is not parabolic (c), and the intensity does depend on the distance (d).

Teacher's Note:
1. Wavefronts from a distant point source are almost plane over a small area.
2. 'Decreases in proportion to the distance squared' in (b) means an inverse-square law.

Examination Note: State the inverse-square law I = P/4πr² and the spherical wavefront; these two results earn the marks.

 

Very Short Answer Type Questions

Question 10. Is Huygens' principle valid for longitudinal sound waves?
Answer:
Yes. Huygens' principle is a statement about how any wave disturbance spreads: each point of a wavefront acts as a source of secondary wavelets, and the new wavefront is their envelope.
For sound waves from a point source the disturbance travels outwards equally in all directions, so the wavefronts are spheres. Their formation, reflection and refraction follow Huygens' construction in the same manner as for light. The principle is valid for longitudinal waves as well.
In simple words: Huygens' construction applies to every kind of wave, whether transverse or longitudinal.

Teacher's Note:
1. The principle does not depend on the direction of the vibration relative to the direction of propagation.
2. Polarisation, however, is possible only for transverse waves, not for sound.

Examination Note: Answer 'Yes' and give the reason in one sentence: the construction depends only on wavefronts and secondary wavelets.

 

Question 11. Consider a point at the focal point of a convergent lens. Another convergent lens of short focal length is placed on the other side. What is the nature of the wavefronts emerging from the final image?
Answer:
A point source at the focal point of the first lens gives, after the lens, a parallel beam, that is, plane wavefronts.
The second convergent lens focuses this parallel beam to a point (its focus), which is the final image. The wavefront emerging from the second lens is a sphere converging towards that image point.
The wavefront is spherical, with its centre at the final image; after passing through the image it diverges as a spherical wavefront.
In simple words: A lens turns plane wavefronts into converging spherical ones and spherical ones into plane ones; the final image is a point, so the wavefront around it is spherical.

Teacher's Note:
1. Rays are always perpendicular to the wavefront; rays that all meet at a point mean spherical wavefronts around that point.
2. A lens changes the curvature of the wavefront.

Examination Note: Describe the wavefront at each stage: spherical, then plane, then converging spherical.

 

Question 12. What is the shape of the wavefront on earth for sunlight?
Answer:
The sun is a very distant source. Treating it as a point source, the wavefronts are spheres centred on the sun, with a radius equal to the earth-sun distance (about 1.5 × 1011 m).
A small portion of such a huge sphere is almost flat, so on the earth the wavefronts of sunlight are almost plane.
In simple words: The sun is so far away that the small piece of its spherical wavefront which reaches us is practically flat.

Teacher's Note:
1. The same reasoning is used for starlight and for parallel beams in many experiments.
2. Rays are normal to the wavefronts, hence rays from the sun are almost parallel.

Examination Note: State 'plane (nearly)' and give the reason: very large radius of curvature.

 

Question 13. Why is the diffraction of sound waves more evident in daily experience than that of light waves?
Answer:
Diffraction is appreciable when the size of the obstacle or opening is comparable with the wavelength.
Audible sound (20 Hz to 20 kHz, with speed about 330 m/s) has wavelengths from about 17 m down to about 1.7 cm. These are comparable with the size of doors, windows and other objects around us.
The wavelength of visible light is only about 4 × 10−7 m to 7 × 10−7 m, which is far smaller than ordinary obstacles and openings. Therefore, diffraction of sound is easily observed (we hear around corners), while diffraction of light is not noticed in everyday life.
In simple words: Sound has wavelengths of centimetres to metres, similar to everyday objects, whereas light has wavelengths of less than a micrometre.

Teacher's Note:
1. This is why you can hear someone around a corner but cannot see them.
2. Light shows diffraction clearly only with very narrow slits or fine obstacles.

Examination Note: Give the condition 'size comparable with wavelength' and compare the two wavelength ranges with numbers.

 

Question 14. The human eye has an approximate angular resolution of φ = 5.8 × 10−4 rad and a typical photoprinter prints a minimum of 300 dpi (dots per inch, 1 inch = 2.54 cm). At what minimal distance z should a printed page be held so that one does not see the individual dots?
Answer:
Distance between two neighbouring dots: \( l = \dfrac{2.54\ \text{cm}}{300} = 8.5\times10^{-3}\ \text{cm} \).
At a distance z the dots subtend an angle \( \phi = \dfrac{l}{z} \). The dots cannot be seen separately when this angle is not more than the resolution of the eye.
\( z = \dfrac{l}{\phi} = \dfrac{8.47\times10^{-3}\ \text{cm}}{5.8\times10^{-4}} \approx 14.6\ \text{cm} \)
The page should be held at least about 15 cm (14.6 cm) from the eye.
In simple words: If the page is held farther than about 15 cm, neighbouring dots are closer than the eye can resolve, and the print looks continuous.

Teacher's Note:
1. Use φ = l/z (arc = radius × angle) for small angles.
2. Resolution limit of the eye is roughly 1 arc-minute (about 3 × 10−4 rad); the given value is slightly different.

Examination Note: Convert inches to centimetres first and apply φ = l/z; give the answer with a unit and as a minimum distance.

 

Question 15. A polaroid (I) is placed in front of a monochromatic source. Another polaroid (II) is placed in front of this polaroid (I) and rotated till no light passes. A third polaroid (III) is now placed in between (I) and (II). In this case, will light emerge from (II)? Explain.
Answer:
Polaroid (I) converts the unpolarised light of the source into plane polarised light. When (II) is rotated till no light passes, the pass axes of (I) and (II) are at 90° (crossed).
Now place (III) between them with its pass axis at an angle α to that of (I). The light leaving (III) has intensity \( I_1\cos^2\alpha \) (Malus' law), polarised along the axis of (III). This light meets (II), whose axis is at \( (90^\circ - \alpha) \) to the axis of (III), so the final intensity is \( I_1\cos^2\alpha\,\sin^2\alpha = \dfrac{I_1}{4}\sin^2 2\alpha \).
Yes, light emerges from (II) for every orientation of (III), except when its axis is parallel to that of (I) or of (II) (α = 0° or 90°), when no light emerges. The emerging intensity is greatest, I1/4, when the axis of (III) is at 45° to the others.
In simple words: The middle polaroid rotates the plane of vibration of the light, so some component is now able to pass through the last polaroid.

Teacher's Note:
1. Two crossed polaroids block light; a third one at 45° between them lets a quarter of the light of the first polaroid through.
2. Each polaroid keeps only the component along its own axis.

Examination Note: Apply Malus' law twice and state the exceptional orientations (axis of III parallel to I or II).

 

Short Answer Type Questions

Question 16. Can reflection result in plane polarised light if the light is incident on the interface from the side with higher refractive index?
Answer:
Yes. Reflected light is completely plane polarised when the angle of incidence is the Brewster angle \( i_B \), where \( \tan i_B = \dfrac{n_2}{n_1} \). For incidence from the denser medium (n1 > n2) we have \( \tan i_B < 1 \).
We must check that this angle is smaller than the critical angle \( i_c \) (otherwise there would be total internal reflection and no refracted beam): \( \sin i_c = \dfrac{n_2}{n_1} \) and \( \sin i_B = \dfrac{\tan i_B}{\sqrt{1 + \tan^2 i_B}} = \dfrac{n_2}{\sqrt{n_1^2 + n_2^2}} \).
Since \( \sqrt{n_1^2 + n_2^2} > n_1 \), we get \( \sin i_B < \dfrac{n_2}{n_1} = \sin i_c \), so \( i_B < i_c \) always.
Hence the Brewster angle exists below the critical angle, and the reflected light is completely plane polarised there, with the transmitted light partially polarised.
In simple words: Brewster's law works from either side of an interface; for light going from a denser to a rarer medium the Brewster angle is always smaller than the critical angle.

Teacher's Note:
1. At the Brewster angle the reflected and refracted rays are perpendicular to each other.
2. Light going from glass to air polarises at tan iB = 1/1.5, i.e. iB ≈ 33.7°, while the critical angle is about 41.8°.

Examination Note: Prove that iB < ic; this one inequality answers the question completely.

 

Question 17. For the same objective, find the ratio of the least separation between two points to be distinguished by a microscope for light of 5000 Å and electrons accelerated through 100 V used as the illuminating substance.
Answer:
The resolving power of a microscope is \( \dfrac{1}{d_{min}} = \dfrac{2n\sin\beta}{1.22\lambda} \), so \( d_{min} = \dfrac{1.22\lambda}{2n\sin\beta} \). For the same objective, \( d_{min} \propto \lambda \).
Light: \( \lambda_l = 5000\ \text{Å} = 5\times10^{-7}\ \text{m} \).
Electrons accelerated through 100 V: \( \lambda_e = \dfrac{12.27}{\sqrt{V}}\ \text{Å} = \dfrac{12.27}{10}\ \text{Å} = 1.227\ \text{Å} \approx 0.12\ \text{nm} \).
\( \dfrac{d_{min}(\text{electrons})}{d_{min}(\text{light})} = \dfrac{\lambda_e}{\lambda_l} = \dfrac{1.227}{5000} \approx 2.5\times10^{-4} \).
Ratio (light : electrons) ≈ 4 × 103 : 1. The electron microscope can resolve points that are about 4000 times closer together.
In simple words: Electrons accelerated through 100 V have a wavelength about 4000 times shorter than green light, so an electron microscope resolves about 4000 times finer detail.

Teacher's Note:
1. Smaller wavelength means better resolution; this is the main advantage of an electron microscope.
2. The de Broglie wavelength of an electron accelerated through V volts is 12.27/√V Å.

Examination Note: Find the electron wavelength with 12.27/√V and state the ratio in one clear direction (light : electron) so that there is no confusion.

 

Question 18. Consider a two slit interference arrangement (see the figure) such that the distance of the screen from the slits is half the distance between the slits. Obtain the value of D in terms of λ such that the first minima on the screen falls at a distance D from the centre O.
SCS1S2T1T2OPScreen →D
Answer:
Let the slit separation be S1S2 = 2D, since the screen is at distance D from the slits, which is half the slit separation. Let P be the first minimum, at a distance x = D above O. T1 is the point of the screen opposite to S1 (at height D above O).
Then \( T_1P = D - x = 0 \) and \( T_2P = D + x = 2D \). Distances: \( S_1P = \sqrt{D^2 + (D-x)^2} = D \) and \( S_2P = \sqrt{D^2 + (D+x)^2} = \sqrt{D^2 + 4D^2} = \sqrt{5}\,D \).
For the first minimum the path difference is \( \dfrac{\lambda}{2} \): \( S_2P - S_1P = \sqrt{5}\,D - D = \dfrac{\lambda}{2} \).
\[ D = \dfrac{\lambda}{2(\sqrt{5} - 1)} = \dfrac{\lambda}{2\times1.236} \approx 0.4\,\lambda \]
D ≈ 0.4 λ (0.404 λ).
In simple words: With the slits 2D apart and the screen D away, the first dark point is at a height D when D is about 0.4 of a wavelength.

Teacher's Note:
1. For the n-th minimum the path difference is (2n − 1)λ/2.
2. The slits here are less than one wavelength apart, which is why the path difference can never exceed 2D = 0.8λ.

Examination Note: Write S1P and S2P using Pythagoras, put the difference equal to λ/2 (first minimum) and solve for D.

 

Long Answer Type Questions

Question 19. The figure shows a two slit arrangement with a source which emits unpolarised light. P is a polariser with axis whose direction is not given. If I0 is the intensity of the principal maxima when no polariser is present, calculate in the present case, the intensity of the principal maxima as well as of the first minima.
SS1S212P
Answer:
Let each of the beams from S1 and S2 be unpolarised, i.e. made of two independent, equally strong, mutually perpendicular components. Let the intensity of each component of each beam be i. Let φ be the phase difference between the two beams at a point on the screen.
Without the polariser: each component interferes with its own counterpart: \( I_{comp} = 2i(1 + \cos\phi) \). Adding the two independent components: \( I = 4i(1 + \cos\phi) \). At the principal maxima (φ = 0): \( I_0 = 8i \); at the minima the intensity is zero.
With the polariser P in the path of S2: beam 2 is left with only the component along the axis of P (intensity i). Beam 1 still has both components.
The component along the axis of P: both beams contribute i each, giving \( 2i(1 + \cos\phi) \). The perpendicular component exists only in beam 1 and has no partner to interfere with, so it gives a constant intensity i.
Total intensity: \( I = 2i(1 + \cos\phi) + i = i(3 + 2\cos\phi) \). This does not depend on which direction the axis of P points.
Principal maxima (φ = 0): \( I = 5i = \dfrac{5}{8}I_0 \). First minima (φ = π): \( I = i = \dfrac{I_0}{8} \).
In simple words: The polariser removes half the light of one beam, so the fringes become less sharp: the maxima fall to 5/8 of I0 and the minima are no longer dark but 1/8 of I0.

Teacher's Note:
1. Two beams interfere only through the components which have the same polarisation.
2. The unpaired component acts as a uniform background which spoils the contrast.

Examination Note: Define I0 in terms of i, work out the intensity formula I = i(3 + 2cos φ) and substitute φ = 0 and φ = π.

 

Question 20. A small transparent slab of refractive index μ = 1.5 and thickness L = d/4 is placed along AS2 (see the figure). AC = CO = D, S1C = S2C = d << D.
ACOP1S1S2L = d/4θAC = CO = D, S1C = S2C = d What will be the distance from O of the principal maxima and of the first minima on either side of the principal maxima obtained in the absence of the glass slab?
Answer:
The slits are 2d apart (S1C = S2C = d) and the screen is at a distance D ≫ d. For a point at angle θ above O, the path difference of the two routes (A to the point via S2 minus via S1) is \( 2d\sin\theta + (\mu - 1)L \), because the slab adds an extra optical path (μ − 1)L to the route through S2. Here \( L = d/4 \), so \( (\mu - 1)L = 0.5 \times \dfrac{d}{4} = \dfrac{d}{8} \).
Principal maximum (path difference zero): \( 2d\sin\theta_0 + \dfrac{d}{8} = 0 \Rightarrow \sin\theta_0 = -\dfrac{1}{16} \). Distance from O: \( OP = D\tan\theta_0 \approx -\dfrac{D}{16} \), that is, the central maximum is shifted by D/16 below O (towards the side of the slab).
First minima (path difference \( \pm\dfrac{\lambda}{2} \)): \( 2d\sin\theta_1 + \dfrac{d}{8} = \pm\dfrac{\lambda}{2} \Rightarrow \sin\theta_1 = \pm\dfrac{\lambda}{4d} - \dfrac{1}{16} \).
For small angles the positions are \( y = D\left(\pm\dfrac{\lambda}{4d} - \dfrac{1}{16}\right) \): one minimum at a distance \( \dfrac{\lambda D}{4d} \) above the principal maximum (that is, at \( \left(\dfrac{\lambda}{4d} - \dfrac{1}{16}\right)D \) above O) and the other at the same distance \( \dfrac{\lambda D}{4d} \) below it (at \( \left(\dfrac{\lambda}{4d} + \dfrac{1}{16}\right)D \) below O).
Example: if λ = d, then \( \sin\theta_1 = \dfrac{3}{16} \) and \( -\dfrac{5}{16} \), giving positions \( \dfrac{3D}{\sqrt{247}} \approx 0.19D \) above O and \( \dfrac{5D}{\sqrt{231}} \approx 0.33D \) below O.
In simple words: The slab delays the light through S2, so the whole fringe pattern slides by D/16 towards the slab side, and the first dark fringes are a quarter-fringe-width on each side of the new central bright fringe.

Teacher's Note:
1. Inserting a slab of thickness t and index μ shifts the fringes towards the slab by an amount equal to (μ − 1)t of path.
2. The fringe width is unchanged by the slab; only the pattern moves.

Examination Note: Write the path difference with the slab term, set it to 0 for the maximum and to ±λ/2 for the minima. Give the answer in terms of D, d and λ.

 

Question 21. Four identical monochromatic sources A, B, C, D as shown in the figure produce waves of the same wavelength λ and are coherent. Two receivers R1 and R2 are at great but equal distances from B. (AB = BC = BD = λ/2.)
ABCDR1R2λ/2λ/2λ/2 (i) Which of the two receivers picks up the larger signal? (ii) Which of the two receivers picks up the larger signal when B is turned off? (iii) Which of the two receivers picks up the larger signal when D is turned off? (iv) Which of the two receivers can distinguish which of the sources B or D has been turned off?
Answer:
Take the amplitude from each source at a distant receiver as a and measure phases relative to B. The path from a source to a receiver differs from that of B by λ/2 for a phase difference of π (and λ for 2π).
Receiver R1 (far away on the line A-B-C, on the A side): the path of A is shorter than that of B by λ/2 (phase +π), the path of C is longer by λ/2 (phase −π), and the path of D is the same as that of B (the extra distance is about λ²/8d, negligible). Amplitudes: A = −a, B = +a, C = −a, D = +a. Sum \( = 0 \).
Receiver R2 (far away, on the line through B and D, on the side opposite to D): A, B and C are at the same distance (phase 0), while D is farther by λ/2 (phase π). Amplitudes: A = +a, B = +a, C = +a, D = −a. Sum \( = 2a \), intensity \( \propto 4a^2 \).
(i) R2 picks up the larger signal (R1 receives zero).
(ii) B turned off: at R1: A + C + D = −a − a + a = −a; at R2: A + C + D = a + a − a = a. Both receive amplitude a, so the two receivers pick up the same signal.
(iii) D turned off: at R1: A + B + C = −a + a − a = −a; at R2: A + B + C = 3a. R2 picks up the larger signal (intensity 9a² against a²).
(iv) With B off, R1 and R2 read a² and a²; with D off they read a² and 9a². R1 gives the same reading (a²) in both cases, so it cannot tell which source was turned off. R2 can distinguish: it receives a² if B was turned off and 9a² if D was turned off.
In simple words: By adding the four waves with the right phases, R1 gets zero from the full set, R2 gets double the single-source amplitude, and the receiver R2 is the only one that can tell whether B or D has been switched off.

Teacher's Note:
1. A path difference of λ/2 means opposite sign; of λ, the same sign.
2. Draw a small table with the amplitudes (−a, +a, −a, +a at R1; +a, +a, +a, −a at R2) to avoid slips.

Examination Note: Tabulate the amplitude of every source at both receivers, then answer (i) to (iv) from the table. Remember that intensity is proportional to the square of the net amplitude.

 

Question 22. The optical properties of a medium are governed by the relative permittivity (εr) and relative permeability (μr). The refractive index is defined as \( \sqrt{\mu_r\varepsilon_r} = n \). For ordinary material, εr > 0 and μr > 0 and the positive sign is taken for the square root. In 1964, a Russian scientist V. Veselago postulated the existence of material with εr < 0 and μr < 0. Since then, such metamaterials have been produced in laboratories and their optical properties studied. For such materials \( n = -\sqrt{\mu_r\varepsilon_r} \). As light enters a medium of such refractive index the phases travel away from the direction of propagation. (i) According to the description above show that if rays of light enter such a medium from air (refractive index = 1) at an angle θ in 2nd quadrant, then the refracted beam is in the 3rd quadrant. (ii) Prove that Snell's law holds for such a medium.
Answer:
AirMedium (n < 0)ordinary mediumθiθrNincidentrefracted
Let |n| = \( \sqrt{\mu_r\varepsilon_r} \), so the refractive index of the medium is \( n = -|n| \). Parallel rays fall on the boundary from air. Let AB be an incident wavefront, with A on the boundary, and let the ray through B reach the boundary at C. Let DE be the refracted wavefront, with E on the refracted ray through A and D on the refracted ray through C. Points of one wavefront have the same phase, so the optical path from the wavefront AB to the wavefront DE must be the same along both rays.
Along the ray through A: optical path \( = n\,AE = -|n|\,AE \). Along the ray through B: optical path \( = BC\ (\text{in air}) + n\,CD = BC - |n|\,CD \).
Equating: \( -|n|\,AE = BC - |n|\,CD \Rightarrow BC = |n|\,(CD - AE) \).
(i) BC is a positive length, so \( CD > AE \). The wavefront DE is perpendicular to the refracted rays, and \( CD - AE = AC\sin\theta_r \) is positive only if the refracted rays lean back towards the side from which the light came, i.e. the refracted rays go on the same side of the normal as the incident ray. If the refracted ray went into the 4th quadrant (as in an ordinary medium), we would get \( CD - AE = -AC\sin\theta_r < 0 \) and hence BC < 0, which is impossible. So the refracted beam lies in the 3rd quadrant.
(ii) From the figure, \( BC = AC\sin\theta_i \) and \( CD - AE = AC\sin\theta_r \) (θr being the magnitude of the angle of refraction). So \( AC\sin\theta_i = |n|\,AC\sin\theta_r \), i.e.
\[ \dfrac{\sin\theta_i}{\sin\theta_r} = |n| = \sqrt{\mu_r\varepsilon_r} \]
If the angle of refraction is measured as negative (because the ray is on the same side of the normal as the incident ray), this is exactly Snell's law, sin θi / sin θr = n, with n negative. Hence Snell's law holds for the medium.
In simple words: In a medium with negative refractive index the refracted ray bends to the same side of the normal as the incident ray, but the law sin θi = n sin θr still holds with n taken as negative.

Teacher's Note:
1. Wavefronts are surfaces of equal phase; equal phase means equal optical path length.
2. A negative index makes the optical path in the medium count negatively, which is why the geometry must change.

Examination Note: Use the equal-optical-path argument for the wavefront, show BC = |n|(CD − AE), and argue the sign for part (i) and the geometry for part (ii).

 

Question 23. To ensure almost 100% transmittivity, photographic lenses are often coated with a thin layer of dielectric material. The refractive index of this material is intermediate between that of air and glass (which makes the optical element of the lens). A typically used dielectric film is MgF2 (n = 1.38). What should the thickness of the film be so that at the centre of the visible spectrum (5500 Å) there is maximum transmission.
Answer:
Air, n = 1Film, n = 1.38Glass, n = 1.5r1r2id
The coated lens (glass, n = 1.5) has a thin film (n = 1.38) of thickness d on its surface. Light is reflected partly at the air-film surface (ray r1) and partly at the film-glass surface (ray r2). For maximum transmission the reflected rays r1 and r2 must interfere destructively.
Both reflections are from a medium of lower to one of higher refractive index (air to film, and film to glass since 1.38 < 1.5), so each has a phase change of π and there is no net phase difference due to reflection.
For nearly normal incidence (i = r = 0) the path difference is \( 2nd \) (twice the optical thickness). For destructive interference, \( 2nd = \dfrac{\lambda}{2} \), so \( d = \dfrac{\lambda}{4n} \).
\[ d = \dfrac{5500\ \text{Å}}{4\times1.38} \approx 996\ \text{Å} \approx 1000\ \text{Å} = 100\ \text{nm} \]
The film should be about 1000 Å (100 nm) thick, a quarter of a wavelength of light in the film (generally an odd multiple of λ/4n would also work).
In simple words: A quarter-wave film makes the two reflected rays cancel, so the light that would be reflected is transmitted instead.

Teacher's Note:
1. Because the film index (1.38) is between those of air (1) and glass (1.5), both reflections have the same π phase change.
2. The coating is exact for one wavelength (here the middle of the visible range); other colours are cancelled less completely, which gives the purple tint of coated lenses.

Examination Note: Mention the phase change on both reflections (so that it cancels) before writing 2nd = λ/2 and the final result d = λ/4n.