These NCERT Exemplar solutions for Class 12 Physics Chapter 11, Dual Nature of Radiation and Matter, give step-by-step answers to all 29 questions: 8 MCQs, 5 multiple-correct MCQs, 5 very short, 6 short and 5 long answer questions. They cover the de Broglie wavelength, photon momentum and energy, the photoelectric effect and stopping potential graphs, the Davisson–Germer experiment, the Heisenberg uncertainty principle and Bragg diffraction of neutrons. Each answer is followed by a short Teacher's Note to build understanding and an Examination Note on how to present the answer for better marks.
Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)
(a) H
(b) H1/2
(c) H0
(d) H−1/2
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (d) H−1/2
Explanation:
1. Speed after falling through height H: \( v = \sqrt{2gH} \).
2. de Broglie wavelength: \( \lambda = \dfrac{h}{mv} = \dfrac{h}{m\sqrt{2gH}} \).
3. h, m and g are constants, so \( \lambda \propto \dfrac{1}{\sqrt{H}} = H^{-1/2} \).
Teacher's Note:
1. The wavelength depends on momentum, so first find the speed from the free-fall formula.
2. For "proportional to" questions, put every constant into one symbol and read off the power of the variable.
Examination Note: Write λ = h/mv, substitute v = √(2gH) and state the proportionality in one line; this takes seconds and avoids guessing between H1/2 and H−1/2.
(a) 1.2 nm
(b) 1.2 × 10−3 nm
(c) 1.2 × 10−6 nm
(d) 1.2 × 10 nm
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) 1.2 × 10−3 nm
Explanation:
1. The photon must supply at least the binding energy: E = 1 MeV = 106 eV.
2. Use \( hc = 1240\ \text{eV nm} \): \( \lambda = \dfrac{hc}{E} = \dfrac{1240}{10^{6}}\ \text{nm} = 1.24\times10^{-3}\ \text{nm} \).
Teacher's Note:
1. Remember hc ≈ 1240 eV nm; it turns a photon energy in eV directly into a wavelength in nm.
2. A 1 MeV photon is a gamma ray, so a wavelength far smaller than 1 nm is what you should expect.
Examination Note: Convert the energy to eV first and then apply hc = 1240 eV nm. Mixing MeV with eV is the most common slip in this type of question.
(a) no electrons will be emitted as only photons can emit electrons
(b) electrons can be emitted but all with an energy, E0
(c) electrons can be emitted with any energy, with a maximum of E0 − φ (φ is the work function)
(d) electrons can be emitted with any energy, with a maximum of E0
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (d) electrons can be emitted with any energy, with a maximum of E0
Explanation:
1. Beam electrons collide with the metal. Some are scattered back out, and some knock out electrons of the metal.
2. In these collisions the energy is shared in all possible ways, so the electrons coming out have energies from almost zero up to a maximum of E0. No electron can leave with more than E0, by energy conservation.
3. Options (a) and (b) are wrong because electrons are emitted with a spread of energies. Option (c) would hold only if a metal electron took the entire energy, but a scattered beam electron can leave with up to E0.
Teacher's Note:
1. This is not the photoelectric effect: a photon is absorbed completely, whereas an electron can bounce off and keep most of its energy.
2. Think of it as secondary emission: many outgoing electrons, with energies between 0 and E0.
Examination Note: If a question changes the incident particle from a photon to an electron, do not use hν − φ. Say clearly that energy is shared in collisions, so the maximum is E0.
(a) will be larger than the earlier value
(b) will be the same as the earlier value
(c) will be less than the earlier value
(d) will depend on the target
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (c) will be less than the earlier value
Explanation:
1. The figure shows the Davisson–Germer experiment, which verified the wave nature of electrons.
2. The wavelength of the accelerated electrons is \( \lambda = \dfrac{12.27}{\sqrt{V}}\ \text{Å} \), so a larger V gives a smaller λ.
3. The diffraction maximum satisfies \( 2d\sin\theta = \lambda \), so sin θ is proportional to λ.
4. A smaller λ therefore gives a smaller θ. The maximum moves to a smaller angle.
Teacher's Note:
1. Chain of reasoning: more voltage gives more speed, which gives a shorter wavelength, which gives a smaller diffraction angle.
2. The same logic is used in the electron microscope: faster electrons have shorter wavelength and resolve finer detail.
Examination Note: Draw this chain as arrows (V ↑ → λ ↓ → θ ↓) in your explanation. In board papers a short, correctly linked chain earns full marks.
(a) λp = λn > λe > λα
(b) λα < λp = λn < λe
(c) λe < λp = λn > λα
(d) λe = λp = λn = λα
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) λα < λp = λn < λe
Explanation:
1. For kinetic energy K, momentum is \( p = \sqrt{2mK} \), so \( \lambda = \dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mK}} \).
2. For the same K, \( \lambda \propto \dfrac{1}{\sqrt{m}} \): the heavier the particle, the shorter its wavelength.
3. Masses: mα > mp ≈ mn > me. Hence λα < λp = λn < λe.
Teacher's Note:
1. For the same energy, use \( \lambda \propto 1/\sqrt{m} \); for the same speed, use \( \lambda \propto 1/m \); for the same momentum, the wavelengths are equal.
2. Proton and neutron masses are almost equal, so their wavelengths are treated as equal.
Examination Note: Start from λ = h/√(2mK), state which quantity is constant, and then rank the masses. State the final order explicitly.
(a) remains constant
(b) increases with time
(c) decreases with time
(d) increases and decreases periodically
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) remains constant
Explanation:
1. The magnetic force on the electron is \( \vec F = -e(\vec v \times \vec B) \), which is always perpendicular to \( \vec v \).
2. A force perpendicular to the velocity does no work, so the speed and the momentum magnitude stay constant.
3. Hence \( \lambda = h/mv \) remains constant.
Teacher's Note:
1. A magnetic field changes the direction of motion but never the speed of a charged particle.
2. Constant speed means constant kinetic energy, constant momentum magnitude and constant λ.
Examination Note: Give the one-line reason: the magnetic force does no work, so the speed does not change. This earns the mark; the cross product is optional.
(a) \( \dfrac{\lambda_0}{1+\dfrac{eE_0 t}{m v_0}} \)
(b) \( \lambda_0\left(1+\dfrac{eE_0 t}{m v_0}\right) \)
(c) λ0
(d) λ0 t
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) \( \dfrac{\lambda_0}{1+\dfrac{eE_0 t}{m v_0}} \)
Explanation:
1. Initial wavelength: \( \lambda_0 = h/(m v_0) \).
2. Force on the electron: \( \vec F = -e\vec E = +eE_0\,\hat i \), along the direction of motion, so acceleration \( a = eE_0/m \).
3. Speed at time t: \( v = v_0 + \dfrac{eE_0}{m}t = v_0\left(1+\dfrac{eE_0 t}{m v_0}\right) \).
4. \( \lambda = \dfrac{h}{mv} = \dfrac{\lambda_0}{1+\dfrac{eE_0 t}{m v_0}} \).
Teacher's Note:
1. An electron has negative charge, so it is pushed opposite to the field. The field here points along −x, so the electron speeds up.
2. More speed means more momentum and a shorter wavelength.
Examination Note: Check the sign of the force before choosing the option. Here the electron speeds up, so λ must decrease; this alone eliminates option (b).
(a) λ0
(b) \( \lambda_0\sqrt{1+\dfrac{e^2E_0^2t^2}{m^2v_0^2}} \)
(c) \( \dfrac{\lambda_0}{\sqrt{1+\dfrac{e^2E_0^2t^2}{m^2v_0^2}}} \)
(d) \( \dfrac{\lambda_0}{\left(1+\dfrac{e^2E_0^2t^2}{m^2v_0^2}\right)} \)
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (c) \( \dfrac{\lambda_0}{\sqrt{1+\dfrac{e^2E_0^2t^2}{m^2v_0^2}}} \)
Explanation:
1. Force on the electron: \( \vec F = -eE_0\,\hat j \), so acceleration \( -\dfrac{eE_0}{m}\hat j \), perpendicular to the initial velocity.
2. At time t: \( v_x = v_0 \) and \( v_y = -\dfrac{eE_0 t}{m} \).
3. Speed: \( v = \sqrt{v_x^2+v_y^2} = v_0\sqrt{1+\dfrac{e^2E_0^2t^2}{m^2v_0^2}} \).
4. \( \lambda = \dfrac{h}{mv} = \dfrac{\lambda_0}{\sqrt{1+\dfrac{e^2E_0^2t^2}{m^2v_0^2}}} \).
Teacher's Note:
1. Motion along x is unchanged; the field only adds a y-component. Combine the two components with Pythagoras to get the speed.
2. Compare with the previous question: there the field was along the motion, here it is at right angles.
Examination Note: Resolve the velocity into components, find the resultant speed and then put it in λ = h/mv. Mention that the final speed is greater than v0, so λ is less than λ0.
Multiple Choice Questions (More Than One Option Correct)
(a) λ = 10 nm
(b) λ = 10−1 nm
(c) λ = 10−4 nm
(d) λ = 10−6 nm
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (c) λ = 10−4 nm, (d) λ = 10−6 nm
Explanation:
1. From λ = h/mv, the speed is \( v = \dfrac{h}{m\lambda} \), with h = 6.6 × 10−34 J s and m = 9.1 × 10−31 kg.
2. (a) λ = 10−8 m gives v ≈ 7.3 × 104 m/s. (b) λ = 10−10 m gives v ≈ 7.3 × 106 m/s.
3. (c) λ = 10−13 m gives v ≈ 7.3 × 109 m/s. (d) λ = 10−15 m gives v ≈ 7.3 × 1011 m/s.
4. Relativistic corrections matter when v is comparable to c = 3 × 108 m/s. Cases (c) and (d) give a speed far above c, so the classical formula fails there. Options (c) and (d) are correct.
Teacher's Note:
1. The speed 7.3 × 109 m/s is larger than c, which is impossible. This shows the non-relativistic formula cannot be used, so relativistic treatment is needed.
2. In general, very short wavelengths mean very high momentum, which means speeds close to c.
Examination Note: Show the calculation of v for each option in one line and compare it with 3 × 108 m/s. Write the conclusion as "(c) and (d)" with the reason.
(a) their momenta are the same
(b) their energies are the same
(c) energy of A1 is less than the energy of A2
(d) energy of A1 is more than the energy of A2
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) their momenta are the same, (c) energy of A1 is less than the energy of A2
Explanation:
1. Momentum is \( p = h/\lambda \). Equal λ means equal momentum, so (a) is correct.
2. Kinetic energy is \( E = \dfrac{p^2}{2m} \). With p equal, \( E \propto 1/m \).
3. Since m1 > m2, we get E1 < E2, so (c) is correct.
Teacher's Note:
1. Three useful pairs: same λ means same p; same K gives λ ∝ 1/√m; same speed gives λ ∝ 1/m.
2. Between two particles of equal momentum, the lighter one carries more kinetic energy.
Examination Note: Begin with p = h/λ and then use E = p²/2m. Two lines of working are enough for the full explanation.
(a) \( \dfrac{E_e}{E_p} = 10^{-4} \)
(b) \( \dfrac{E_e}{E_p} = 10^{-2} \)
(c) \( \dfrac{p_e}{m_e c} = 10^{-2} \)
(d) \( \dfrac{p_e}{m_e c} = 10^{-4} \)
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) \( \dfrac{E_e}{E_p} = 10^{-2} \), (c) \( \dfrac{p_e}{m_e c} = 10^{-2} \)
Explanation:
1. Electron: \( \lambda_e = \dfrac{h}{m_e v_e} = \dfrac{100\,h}{m_e c} \) and \( E_e = \tfrac12 m_e v_e^2 = \dfrac{m_e c^2}{2\times10^{4}} \).
2. Photon: \( \lambda_p = 2\lambda_e = \dfrac{200\,h}{m_e c} \), so \( E_p = \dfrac{hc}{\lambda_p} = \dfrac{m_e c^2}{200} \).
3. \( \dfrac{E_e}{E_p} = \dfrac{200}{2\times10^{4}} = 10^{-2} \), so (b) is correct.
4. \( p_e = m_e v_e = \dfrac{m_e c}{100} \), so \( \dfrac{p_e}{m_e c} = 10^{-2} \) and (c) is correct.
Teacher's Note:
1. Use the right energy formula for each object: ½mv² for the electron and hc/λ for the photon.
2. Express everything in terms of me and c so that the ratio simplifies cleanly.
Examination Note: Keep the electron and the photon calculations in separate lines. Examiners look for the correct energy expression of each before the ratio is taken.
(a) decreases with increasing n, with ν fixed
(b) decreases with n fixed, ν increasing
(c) remains constant with n and ν changing such that nν = constant
(d) increases when the product nν increases
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) decreases with increasing n, with ν fixed, (b) decreases with n fixed, ν increasing, (c) remains constant with n and ν changing such that nν = constant
Explanation:
1. Heat needed to melt 1 kg of ice is fixed: Q = mL (L = latent heat of fusion).
2. Energy delivered by the photons in time T is \( n\,T\,h\nu \).
3. Equating, \( T = \dfrac{mL}{n h \nu} \), so \( T \propto \dfrac{1}{n\nu} \).
4. T falls when n increases (a) or when ν increases (b), and is unchanged if nν is constant (c). It does not increase when nν increases, so (d) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Total energy supplied per second is n × hν, which is the power of the source.
2. Time is inversely proportional to power: more power, less time.
Examination Note: Write T = mL/(nhν) and read each option from it. A single formula answers all four parts.
(a) The particle could be moving in a circular orbit with origin as centre
(b) The particle could be moving in an elliptic orbit with origin as its focus
(c) When the de Broglie wavelength is λ1, the particle is nearer the origin than when its value is λ2
(d) When the de Broglie wavelength is λ2, the particle is nearer the origin than when its value is λ1
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) The particle could be moving in an elliptic orbit with origin as its focus, (d) When the de Broglie wavelength is λ2, the particle is nearer the origin than when its value is λ1
Explanation:
1. λ = h/mv, so a wavelength that changes means the speed changes.
2. In a circular orbit the speed is constant, so λ would be constant. Option (a) is false.
3. In an elliptic orbit with the centre of force at a focus, the speed changes. By conservation of angular momentum the particle moves faster when it is nearer the focus (origin O) and slower when it is farther away.
4. Faster means smaller λ. So the smaller wavelength λ2 occurs when the particle is nearer the origin (P in the figure), and the larger λ1 when it is farther (A). Options (b) and (d) are true; (c) is false.
Teacher's Note:
1. The wavelength is inversely proportional to speed, so it is smallest where the particle moves fastest.
2. This is the same idea as a planet moving fastest at perihelion.
Examination Note: Link the three facts in order: λ ∝ 1/v, speed is greatest near the focus, so λ is least near the focus. Add a small labelled sketch of the ellipse.
Very Short Answer Type Questions
Question 14. A proton and an α-particle are accelerated, using the same potential difference. How are the de Broglie wavelengths λp and λα related to each other?
Answer:
A particle of charge q and mass m accelerated through potential V has kinetic energy qV, so \( \lambda = \dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mqV}} \).
Same V, so \( \lambda \propto \dfrac{1}{\sqrt{mq}} \).
\( \dfrac{\lambda_p}{\lambda_\alpha} = \sqrt{\dfrac{m_\alpha q_\alpha}{m_p q_p}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{4m_p\times 2e}{m_p\times e}} = \sqrt{8} \)
λp = √8 λα = 2√2 λα
In simple words: The proton's wavelength is about 2.8 times the α-particle's, because the α-particle is heavier and carries more charge.
Teacher's Note:
1. An α-particle has twice the charge and four times the mass of a proton, so mαqα = 8 mpqp.
2. The same formula λ = h/√(2mqV) also covers electrons accelerated through V.
Examination Note: Quote the formula λ = h/√(2mqV) first, then substitute the mass and charge ratios. State the ratio as a number.
Question 15. (i) In the explanation of the photoelectric effect, we assume one photon of frequency ν collides with an electron and transfers its energy. This leads to the equation for the maximum energy Emax of the emitted electron as \( E_{max} = h\nu - \phi_0 \), where φ0 is the work function of the metal. If an electron absorbs 2 photons (each of frequency ν), what will be the maximum energy for the emitted electron? (ii) Why is this fact (two-photon absorption) not taken into consideration in our discussion of the stopping potential?
Answer:
(i) Two photons give the electron energy 2hν, so \( E_{max} = 2h\nu - \phi_0 \).
(ii) The chance that one electron absorbs two photons at the same instant is extremely small at ordinary light intensities, so such emission is negligible. Each electron effectively absorbs one photon, and the stopping potential is explained by \( eV_0 = h\nu - \phi_0 \).
In simple words: Almost every electron meets only one photon, so the one-photon equation is the one that matters.
Teacher's Note:
1. Compare with the one-photon case: the only change is that the photon energy becomes 2hν.
2. Two-photon absorption becomes visible only with extremely intense light such as lasers.
Examination Note: In part (i) write the final equation clearly, and in part (ii) give the word "probability" as the reason.
Question 16. There are materials which absorb photons of shorter wavelength and emit photons of longer wavelength. Can there be stable substances which absorb photons of larger wavelength and emit light of shorter wavelength?
Answer:
No (for single-photon absorption).
A photon of shorter wavelength has more energy than one of longer wavelength. A material that absorbs a longer-wavelength photon and emits a shorter-wavelength one must therefore supply the extra energy from itself.
A stable substance has no such stored energy to give away, so it cannot do this. The reverse process is possible, since the extra energy is lost as heat.
In simple words: Light cannot gain energy from a stable material, so absorbed photons can only be re-emitted with the same or less energy.
Teacher's Note:
1. Use E = hc/λ: a shorter wavelength means a larger energy.
2. This is an application of energy conservation, not a new rule.
Examination Note: Give the answer first (No) and then the energy-conservation reason in one or two lines.
Question 17. Do all the electrons that absorb a photon come out as photoelectrons?
Answer:
No. Most electrons that absorb a photon lose the energy by collisions with other electrons and atoms inside the metal, and the energy goes into the metal as heat.
Only the few electrons near the surface whose energy, after such losses, is greater than the work function escape as photoelectrons.
In simple words: Absorbing a photon is not enough; the electron must also reach the surface with energy above the work function.
Teacher's Note:
1. The photoelectric current is therefore much smaller than the number of absorbed photons would suggest.
2. The work function is the minimum energy needed to leave the surface, not to absorb a photon.
Examination Note: Write "No" and give two reasons: loss of energy in collisions and the need to exceed the work function.
Question 18. There are two sources of light, each emitting with a power of 100 W. One emits X-rays of wavelength 1 nm and the other visible light at 500 nm. Find the ratio of the number of photons of X-rays to the photons of visible light of the given wavelength.
Answer:
Let n1 and n2 be the number of photons emitted per second by the X-ray source (λ1 = 1 nm) and the visible source (λ2 = 500 nm).
Power = (number per second) × (energy of one photon): \( P = n_1\dfrac{hc}{\lambda_1} = n_2\dfrac{hc}{\lambda_2} \).
\( \dfrac{n_1}{n_2} = \dfrac{\lambda_1}{\lambda_2} = \dfrac{1}{500} \)
n1 : n2 = 1 : 500
In simple words: An X-ray photon carries 500 times more energy, so the same power needs 500 times fewer photons.
Teacher's Note:
1. For equal power, the number of photons per second is directly proportional to the wavelength.
2. The actual power (100 W) cancels out, so it is not needed in the final ratio.
Examination Note: Start with P = n hc/λ for each source and divide. Note that 100 W cancels out.
Short Answer Type Questions
Answer:
The photon's momentum is not shared by the photoelectron alone. The incident photon gives its momentum to the metal as a whole (mainly through the nuclei and the lattice), while the electron leaves in a different direction with its own momentum.
The metal is very massive, so it takes up the unbalanced momentum with negligible kinetic energy \( p^2/2M \). Hence momentum is conserved for the system of photon, electron and metal, and the energy balance of the photoelectric equation is unaffected.
In simple words: The heavy metal absorbs the leftover momentum, so the electron and photon directions need not match.
Teacher's Note:
1. Conservation of momentum must be applied to the whole system, including the metal.
2. A very large mass takes up momentum but gains almost no energy, which is why we usually ignore it.
Examination Note: Include the phrase "momentum is transferred to the metal as a whole". Mention that its kinetic energy is negligible to justify the photoelectric equation.
Question 20. Consider a metal exposed to light of wavelength 600 nm. The maximum energy of the electron doubles when light of wavelength 400 nm is used. Find the work function in eV.
Answer:
Maximum kinetic energy: \( K = \dfrac{hc}{\lambda} - \phi \). Use \( hc = 1240\ \text{eV nm} \).
\( K_{600} = \dfrac{1240}{600} - \phi \) and \( K_{400} = \dfrac{1240}{400} - \phi \), with \( K_{400} = 2K_{600} \).
\( \dfrac{1240}{400} - \phi = 2\left(\dfrac{1240}{600} - \phi\right) \Rightarrow \phi = \dfrac{2\times1240}{600} - \dfrac{1240}{400} \)
\( \phi = 4.133 - 3.1 = 1.03\ \text{eV} \)
Work function φ ≈ 1.03 eV
In simple words: Write down the two photoelectric equations, apply the doubling condition, and the work function comes out as about 1 eV.
Teacher's Note:
1. The doubling condition is the only link between the two equations; use it to eliminate K.
2. If hc = 1230 eV nm is used, the answer is 1.02 eV. Both values are acceptable as the question asks for an estimate.
Examination Note: Use hc = 1240 eV nm in these problems, which saves converting to joules. Show both equations, the doubling condition and the final answer with its unit.
Question 21. Assuming an electron is confined to a 1 nm wide region, find the uncertainty in momentum using the Heisenberg uncertainty principle (Δx × Δp ≈ h). You can assume the uncertainty in position Δx as 1 nm. Assuming p ≈ Δp, find the energy of the electron in electron volts.
Answer:
Given Δx = 1 nm = 10−9 m, with Δx Δp ≈ h as the question states.
\( \Delta p = \dfrac{h}{\Delta x} = \dfrac{6.62\times10^{-34}}{10^{-9}} = 6.62\times10^{-25}\ \text{kg m/s} \)
\( E = \dfrac{p^2}{2m} = \dfrac{(6.62\times10^{-25})^2}{2\times9.1\times10^{-31}} = 2.4\times10^{-19}\ \text{J} \)
\( E = \dfrac{2.4\times10^{-19}}{1.6\times10^{-19}} \approx 1.5\ \text{eV} \)
Δp ≈ 6.6 × 10−25 kg m/s and E ≈ 1.5 eV
In simple words: Squeezing an electron into a space of 1 nm forces its momentum to be uncertain by about 6.6 × 10−25 kg m/s, which corresponds to roughly 1.5 eV.
Teacher's Note:
1. Follow the relation given in the question. If the form Δx Δp ≈ h/2π is used instead, then Δp ≈ 1.05 × 10−25 kg m/s and E ≈ 3.8 × 10−2 eV.
2. The smaller the region, the larger the momentum (and energy) of the confined electron.
Examination Note: Always use the form of the uncertainty relation that the question states. Show Δp, then E = p²/2m, then convert joules to eV by dividing by 1.6 × 10−19.
Question 22. Two monochromatic beams A and B of equal intensity I hit a screen. The number of photons hitting the screen by beam A is twice that by beam B. Then, what inference can you make about their frequencies?
Answer:
Let nA and nB be the photons per second from the two beams, with nA = 2nB.
Intensity = (photons per second) × (energy per photon) per unit area, and the intensities are equal: \( n_A h\nu_A = n_B h\nu_B \).
\( \dfrac{\nu_B}{\nu_A} = \dfrac{n_A}{n_B} = 2 \)
νB = 2νA: beam B has twice the frequency of beam A.
In simple words: Beam B has fewer but more energetic photons, so its frequency is double.
Teacher's Note:
1. Equal intensity means equal energy per second. Fewer photons therefore means each photon carries more energy.
2. Intensity depends on the number of photons; the energy of each photon depends on frequency.
Examination Note: Start from the statement "equal intensity means equal n hν" and divide. Write the conclusion in words as well.
Question 23. Two particles A and B of de Broglie wavelengths λ1 and λ2 combine to form a particle C. The process conserves momentum. Find the de Broglie wavelength of the particle C. (The motion is one-dimensional.)
Answer:
Momentum of a particle is \( p = h/\lambda \). Conservation of momentum: \( p_C = p_A + p_B \), taking signs for direction.
Case 1: A and B move in the same direction. \( \dfrac{h}{\lambda_C} = \dfrac{h}{\lambda_1} + \dfrac{h}{\lambda_2} \Rightarrow \lambda_C = \dfrac{\lambda_1\lambda_2}{\lambda_1+\lambda_2} \)
Case 2: A and B move in opposite directions. \( \dfrac{h}{\lambda_C} = \left|\dfrac{h}{\lambda_1} - \dfrac{h}{\lambda_2}\right| \Rightarrow \lambda_C = \dfrac{\lambda_1\lambda_2}{|\lambda_1-\lambda_2|} \)
In simple words: Wavelengths combine like resistances in parallel, \( 1/\lambda_C = 1/\lambda_1 + 1/\lambda_2 \), when the particles move the same way.
Teacher's Note:
1. Because momentum is a vector, the direction of each particle decides whether the momenta add or subtract.
2. When the opposite directions have equal wavelengths, C is at rest and λC is infinite.
Examination Note: Give both cases. A good answer states the sign convention and writes each result clearly.
Question 24. A neutron beam of energy E scatters from atoms on a surface with a spacing d = 0.1 nm. The first maximum of intensity in the reflected beam occurs at θ = 30°. What is the kinetic energy E of the neutron beam in eV?
Answer:
Bragg's law: \( 2d\sin\theta = n\lambda \), with n = 1, d = 0.1 nm and θ = 30°.
\( \lambda = 2\times0.1\ \text{nm}\times\sin30^\circ = 0.1\ \text{nm} = 10^{-10}\ \text{m} \)
Momentum: \( p = \dfrac{h}{\lambda} = \dfrac{6.62\times10^{-34}}{10^{-10}} = 6.62\times10^{-24}\ \text{kg m/s} \)
\( E = \dfrac{p^2}{2m_n} = \dfrac{(6.62\times10^{-24})^2}{2\times1.67\times10^{-27}} = 1.31\times10^{-20}\ \text{J} \)
\( E = \dfrac{1.31\times10^{-20}}{1.6\times10^{-19}} \approx 8.2\times10^{-2}\ \text{eV} \)
E ≈ 0.082 eV
In simple words: Slow neutrons of about 0.08 eV have a wavelength of 0.1 nm, which is comparable to the spacing of atoms, so they are diffracted by crystals.
Teacher's Note:
1. First find λ from the diffraction condition, then convert it into momentum and then energy.
2. Check the powers of ten when converting joules to eV: 1.31 × 10−20 J is 0.082 eV, not a value near 0.2 eV.
Examination Note: Write Bragg's law, find λ, then use E = h²/(2mλ²). Check the power of ten while converting joules into eV, as that is where most slips happen.
Long Answer Type Questions
Question 25. Consider a thin target (10−2 m square, 10−3 m thickness) of sodium, which produces a photocurrent of 100 μA when a light of intensity 100 W/m2 (λ = 660 nm) falls on it. Find the probability that a photoelectron is produced when a photon strikes a sodium atom. [Take density of Na = 0.97 kg/m3]
Answer:
Volume of target \( V = (10^{-2})^2\times10^{-3} = 10^{-7}\ \text{m}^3 \); area \( A = 10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2 \).
Number of atoms in the target. 23 kg of Na (1 kmol) has 6 × 1026 atoms, so the volume per atom is \( \dfrac{23}{0.97\times6\times10^{26}} = 3.95\times10^{-26}\ \text{m}^3 \). Hence \( N_{atoms} = \dfrac{10^{-7}}{3.95\times10^{-26}} = 2.53\times10^{18} \).
Photons falling per second. Energy per second = IA = nhc/λ, so \( n = \dfrac{IA\lambda}{hc} = \dfrac{100\times10^{-4}\times660\times10^{-9}}{6.62\times10^{-34}\times3\times10^{8}} = 3.3\times10^{16}\ \text{s}^{-1} \).
Photoelectrons emitted per second. Current \( i = 100\ \mu\text{A} = 10^{-4}\ \text{A} = (\text{electrons per second})\times e \). If P is the probability per atom per photon, electrons per second = P × n × Natoms.
\( 10^{-4} = P\times(3.3\times10^{16})\times(2.53\times10^{18})\times(1.6\times10^{-19}) \)
\( P = \dfrac{10^{-4}}{(3.3\times10^{16})(2.53\times10^{18})(1.6\times10^{-19})} \approx 7.5\times10^{-21} \)
Probability P ≈ 7.5 × 10−21
In simple words: Only about one photon in 1020 frees an electron from a sodium atom, which is why the chance of two photons helping the same atom is negligible.
Teacher's Note:
1. The question asks for the chance per atom per photon, so divide the electrons per second by the number of photons per second and the number of atoms.
2. Such a tiny P shows why two-photon absorption can be ignored in the photoelectric effect (see Question 15).
Examination Note: Set the answer out in four labelled steps: atoms, photons per second, electrons per second and probability. Carry the powers of ten carefully and give the final answer in standard form.
Answer:
When the electron is at distance x from the plate, the attractive force is \( F = \dfrac{1}{4}\dfrac{q^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 x^2} \). An external agent must pull against it.
\( W = \int_{d}^{\infty} F\,dx = \dfrac{q^2}{16\pi\varepsilon_0}\int_{d}^{\infty}\dfrac{dx}{x^2} = \dfrac{q^2}{16\pi\varepsilon_0}\left[-\dfrac{1}{x}\right]_{d}^{\infty} = \dfrac{q^2}{16\pi\varepsilon_0 d} \)
With \( \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} = 9\times10^{9} \), q = 1.6 × 10−19 C and d = 10−10 m:
\( W = \dfrac{(9\times10^{9})(1.6\times10^{-19})^2}{4\times10^{-10}} = 5.76\times10^{-19}\ \text{J} = \dfrac{5.76\times10^{-19}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}\ \text{eV} = 3.6\ \text{eV} \)
W = q²/(16πε0d) = 3.6 eV
In simple words: It takes about 3.6 eV to pull an electron completely away from the plate. This is of the same order as the work function of a typical metal.
Teacher's Note:
1. Work against a variable force is found by integration: sum F dx from d to infinity.
2. This is the picture of the work function: the energy needed to take an electron away from the metal surface.
Examination Note: Write the integral with limits, show the result in symbols first and substitute numbers last. Convert joules to eV at the end by dividing by 1.6 × 10−19.
(i) Which material A or B has a higher work function? (ii) Given the electric charge of an electron = 1.6 × 10−19 C, find the value of h obtained from the experiment for both A and B. Comment on whether it is consistent with Einstein's theory.
Answer:
(i) The threshold frequency is where the line meets the frequency axis: ν0A = 5 × 1014 Hz and ν0B = 10 × 1014 Hz. Since φ = hν0, the larger threshold frequency means the larger work function. Material B has the higher work function.
(ii) From \( eV_{stop} = h\nu - \phi \), the slope of the Vstop–ν line is \( h/e \).
Material A: Vstop = 2 V at ν = 10 × 1014 Hz, so slope = \( \dfrac{2}{(10-5)\times10^{14}} \) and \( h = \dfrac{2\times1.6\times10^{-19}}{5\times10^{14}} = 6.4\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s} \).
Material B: Vstop = 2.5 V at ν = 15 × 1014 Hz, so slope = \( \dfrac{2.5}{(15-10)\times10^{14}} \) and \( h = \dfrac{2.5\times1.6\times10^{-19}}{5\times10^{14}} = 8\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s} \).
Comment. According to Einstein's theory the slope h/e is the same for every metal, so the two lines must be parallel and give the same h (6.63 × 10−34 J s). Here the two values differ (6.4 × 10−34 and 8 × 10−34 J s), so the experimental results are not consistent with the theory.
In simple words: The slope of the stopping-potential graph gives h/e. It should be the same for every metal, but these two lines have different slopes, so the data do not agree with theory.
Teacher's Note:
1. The intercept on the frequency axis gives the threshold frequency; the slope gives h/e.
2. Parallel lines for different metals are the key prediction of Einstein's equation. Different slopes mean something is wrong with the experiment.
Examination Note: Read the values from the graph carefully and show the slope calculation for both materials. End with the comparison to the accepted value of h and the word "not consistent".
Question 28. A particle A with a mass mA is moving with a velocity v and hits a particle B (mass mB) at rest (one-dimensional motion). Find the change in the de Broglie wavelength of the particle A. Treat the collision as elastic.
Answer:
Let the velocities after the collision be v1 (A) and v2 (B).
Momentum: \( m_A v = m_A v_1 + m_B v_2 \Rightarrow m_A(v - v_1) = m_B v_2 \) ...(i)
Kinetic energy: \( \tfrac12 m_A v^2 = \tfrac12 m_A v_1^2 + \tfrac12 m_B v_2^2 \Rightarrow m_A(v^2 - v_1^2) = m_B v_2^2 \) ...(ii)
Dividing (ii) by (i): \( v + v_1 = v_2 \) ...(iii). Solving (i) and (iii): \( v_1 = \dfrac{m_A - m_B}{m_A + m_B}\,v \).
Initial wavelength \( \lambda_i = \dfrac{h}{m_A v} \). Final wavelength (for mA > mB, A keeps moving forward): \( \lambda_f = \dfrac{h}{m_A v_1} = \dfrac{h(m_A+m_B)}{m_A(m_A-m_B)v} \).
\( \Delta\lambda = \lambda_f - \lambda_i = \dfrac{h}{m_A v}\left[\dfrac{m_A+m_B}{m_A-m_B} - 1\right] = \dfrac{2h\,m_B}{m_A v\,(m_A - m_B)} \)
Δλ = 2hmB / [mA v (mA − mB)]. If mA < mB, A rebounds, and using |v1| gives \( \Delta\lambda = \dfrac{2h}{v\,(m_B - m_A)} \).
In simple words: A loses speed in the collision, so its de Broglie wavelength increases by the amount found above.
Teacher's Note:
1. Elastic collision problems always use two equations: momentum conservation and kinetic energy conservation.
2. Use the speed (a positive number) in the de Broglie formula, because wavelength cannot be negative.
Examination Note: Show both conservation laws, the intermediate result for v1 and then the final expression in a single line. A full derivation like this earns the full marks in a 5-mark question.
(i) Estimate the number of photons emitted by the bulb per second. [Assume no other losses] (ii) Will there be photoelectric emission? (iii) How much time would be required by the atomic disk to receive energy equal to the work function (2 eV)? (iv) How many photons would an atomic disk receive within the time duration calculated in (iii) above? (v) Can you explain how the photoelectric effect was observed instantaneously?
Answer:
Given P = 20 W, λ = 5000 Å = 5 × 10−7 m, d = 2 m, φ = 2 eV = 3.2 × 10−19 J, r = 1.5 Å = 1.5 × 10−10 m.
(i) \( n' = \dfrac{P}{hc/\lambda} = \dfrac{P\lambda}{hc} = \dfrac{20\times5\times10^{-7}}{6.62\times10^{-34}\times3\times10^{8}} \approx 5\times10^{19}\ \text{photons/s} \)
(ii) Energy of each photon: \( \dfrac{hc}{\lambda} = \dfrac{1240}{500} = 2.48\ \text{eV} \). This is greater than the work function 2 eV, so photoelectric emission is possible.
(iii) The light spreads over a sphere of radius d, so the power falling on one atomic disk is \( \dfrac{P}{4\pi d^2}\times\pi r^2 = \dfrac{Pr^2}{4d^2} = \dfrac{20\times(1.5\times10^{-10})^2}{4\times2^2} \approx 2.8\times10^{-20}\ \text{W} \).
Time to collect 2 eV: \( \Delta t = \dfrac{3.2\times10^{-19}}{2.8\times10^{-20}} = \dfrac{4\phi d^2}{P r^2} \approx 11.4\ \text{s} \). The time required is about 11 s.
(iv) \( N = n'\times\dfrac{r^2}{4d^2}\times\Delta t = 5\times10^{19}\times\dfrac{(1.5\times10^{-10})^2}{16}\times11.4 \approx 0.8 \). About one photon falls on the atomic disk in this time.
(v) According to the wave picture, an electron would need about 11 s to gather enough energy, so emission would be delayed. Experiments show emission starts almost instantly (within about 10−9 s). The reason is the photon picture: energy arrives in packets, and a single photon of energy 2.48 eV gives all its energy to one electron in one collision, so there is no waiting time to collect energy.
In simple words: Wave theory predicts an 11-second delay, but a photon delivers its energy in one go, which is why photoelectric emission is instantaneous.
Teacher's Note:
1. Parts (iii) and (iv) agree with each other: about one photon of 2.48 eV supplies the 2 eV that is needed.
2. Part (v) is the classic argument for the particle nature of light.
Examination Note: Set out each part with its own label and answer. Do the (iii) calculation with symbols first, \( \Delta t = 4\phi d^2/Pr^2 \), and conclude (v) with the contrast between the wave and photon explanations.