These NCERT Exemplar solutions for Class 12 Physics Chapter 1, Electric Charges and Fields, give step-by-step answers to all 31 questions: 7 MCQs, 6 multiple-correct MCQs, 6 very short, 6 short and 6 long answer questions. They cover Coulomb's law and superposition, electric field lines, Gauss' law and flux, induced charges on conductors, symmetry arguments and simple harmonic motion of charges in electric fields. Each answer is followed by a short Teacher's Note to build understanding and an Examination Note on how to present the answer for better marks.
Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)
(a) shall increase along the positive x-axis
(b) shall decrease along the positive x-axis
(c) shall point along the negative x-axis
(d) shall increase but the direction changes because of the intersection of Q with q2 and q3
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) shall increase along the positive x-axis
Explanation:
1. The positive charges q2 and q3 lie on the y-axis and pull q1 towards the +x direction, so the force between them and q1 is attractive. Hence q1 is a negative charge.
2. The new positive charge Q at (x, 0) lies on the +x side of q1, so it also attracts the negative charge q1 along +x.
3. Forces add by superposition, and the presence of Q does not change the forces due to q2 and q3. The total force on q1 increases along +x.
Teacher's Note:
1. Decide the sign of q1 from the given direction of the force before adding the new charge.
2. Coulomb forces on a charge from different sources simply add; one charge never alters the force due to another.
Examination Note: State that q1 is negative and that all three forces point along +x. Without this reasoning step the option cannot be defended.
(a) Figure (a)
(b) Figure (b)
(c) Figure (c)
(d) Figure (d)
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) Figure (a)
Explanation:
1. The free electrons of the sphere are attracted towards the positive charge, so the near side becomes negative and the far side becomes positive (induced charges).
2. Field lines start from the positive point charge and end on the negative induced charge on the near surface. Lines also leave the positive induced charge on the far side and go to infinity.
3. Field lines must meet the conducting surface at right angles and cannot enter the sphere, so there is no field inside. Only figure (a) shows all of this: in (b) the lines at the far side point inwards, and in (c) and (d) the lines pass through the sphere.
Teacher's Note:
1. Charging by induction: the sphere stays neutral overall but its charge separates.
2. Field lines never cross a conductor's interior; they stop on the surface at 90°.
Examination Note: When asked to pick a field-line diagram, check three things and write them: direction (positive to negative), lines normal to the conductor surface, and no lines inside the conductor.
(a) in Fig. (iv) is the largest
(b) in Fig. (iii) is the least
(c) in Fig. (ii) is same as Fig. (iii) but is smaller than Fig. (iv)
(d) is the same for all the figures
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (d) is the same for all the figures
Explanation:
1. By Gauss' law, the flux through a closed surface is \( \phi = \dfrac{q_{\text{enclosed}}}{\varepsilon_0} \).
2. Every surface in the four figures encloses the same single charge +q, so the flux is the same whatever the shape or size of the surface.
Teacher's Note:
1. Flux depends only on the charge inside, not on how big or how irregular the closed surface is.
2. Charges outside a closed surface add zero net flux, because each line that enters also leaves.
Examination Note: Write Gauss' law and say that every surface encloses the same charge +q. One line is enough for full marks.
(a) E on the LHS of the above equation will have a contribution from q1, q5 and q3 while q on the RHS will have a contribution from q2 and q4 only
(b) E on the LHS of the above equation will have a contribution from all charges while q on the RHS will have a contribution from q2 and q4 only
(c) E on the LHS of the above equation will have a contribution from all charges while q on the RHS will have a contribution from q1, q3 and q5 only
(d) Both E on the LHS and q on the RHS will have contributions from q2 and q4 only
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) E on the LHS of the above equation will have a contribution from all charges while q on the RHS will have a contribution from q2 and q4 only
Explanation:
1. In Gauss' law, q is the charge enclosed by S. From the figure, only q2 and q4 lie inside S; q1, q3 and q5 are outside it.
2. The electric field E at each point of the surface is the total field of all the charges, inside and outside S.
3. So E has a contribution from all charges, while q on the right-hand side comes from q2 and q4 only.
Teacher's Note:
1. The flux of charges outside S is zero overall, but their field is still present at every point of S.
2. Do not mix up the field on the surface (due to all charges) with the flux (due to the enclosed charge).
Examination Note: Use the phrase: field is due to all charges, flux is due to enclosed charges only.
(a) The dipole will not experience any force
(b) The dipole will experience a force towards right
(c) The dipole will experience a force towards left
(d) The dipole will experience a force upwards
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (c) The dipole will experience a force towards left
Explanation:
1. The field lines are closer together on the left and spread out towards the right, so the field is stronger on the left and weaker on the right.
2. The force on −p (left end) is opposite to the field, i.e. towards the left, and it is larger. The force on +p (right end) is towards the right but smaller.
3. The net force is towards the left.
Teacher's Note:
1. Crowded field lines mean a strong field and spread-out lines mean a weak field.
2. In a non-uniform field a dipole feels a net force; in a uniform field it feels only a torque.
Examination Note: Compare the magnitudes of the two forces on the two ends and state the direction of the larger one.
(a) directed perpendicular to the plane and away from the plane
(b) directed perpendicular to the plane but towards the plane
(c) directed radially away from the point charge
(d) directed radially towards the point charge
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) directed perpendicular to the plane and away from the plane
Explanation:
1. The point charge induces a negative charge on the near face of the plane and an equal positive charge on the far face.
2. The field just outside any conductor is perpendicular to its surface. On the far side the induced charge is positive, so the field is directed perpendicular to the plane and away from it.
Teacher's Note:
1. Induced charges: negative nearer to the +q and positive on the opposite face of an isolated (neutral) conductor.
2. The field at a conductor's surface is always normal to the surface.
Examination Note: Mention both facts: induction of charge, and the field being normal to the conductor's surface.
(a) perpendicular to the diameter
(b) parallel to the diameter
(c) at an angle tilted towards the diameter
(d) at an angle tilted away from the diameter
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) perpendicular to the diameter
Explanation:
1. Complete the sphere by adding a second, identical hemisphere that is the mirror image about the plane of the diameter. A point on the diameter inside the sphere then has zero total field.
2. The mirror image has the same component of field parallel to the diameter and the opposite perpendicular component. The two parallel components must therefore cancel to zero, so each is zero on its own.
3. Hence the field of one hemisphere at such a point has only a component perpendicular to the diameter.
Teacher's Note:
1. Symmetry (mirror image) arguments save long integrals.
2. A uniformly charged shell has zero field inside, which is the key fact used here.
Examination Note: Give the symmetry argument in two lines; do not attempt the integral.
Multiple Choice Questions (More Than One Option)
(a) the electric field inside the surface and on it is zero
(b) the electric field inside the surface is necessarily uniform
(c) the number of flux lines entering the surface must be equal to the number of flux lines leaving it
(d) all charges must necessarily be outside the surface
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (c) the number of flux lines entering the surface must be equal to the number of flux lines leaving it, (d) all charges must necessarily be outside the surface
Explanation:
1. The integral is the net flux. It is zero when the number of field lines entering the closed surface equals the number leaving it, so (c) is correct.
2. By Gauss' law the flux is q/ε0, where q is the net charge enclosed. Zero flux means zero net enclosed charge, so no net charge is inside the surface and (d) is accepted.
3. Zero flux does not make the field zero or uniform: the field can be non-zero at points of the surface, with inward and outward parts cancelling. So (a) and (b) are wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Zero net flux does not mean zero field: charges outside the surface still produce a field on it.
2. Option (d) is read as: no net charge is enclosed.
Examination Note: Link the zero flux to zero enclosed charge using Gauss' law, and say clearly that this does not make E zero.
(a) always continuous
(b) continuous if there is no charge at that point
(c) discontinuous only if there is a negative charge at that point
(d) discontinuous if there is a charge at that point
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) continuous if there is no charge at that point, (d) discontinuous if there is a charge at that point
Explanation:
1. The field at a point is the force per unit positive test charge placed there.
2. At a point where there is no charge, the field changes smoothly from place to place, so it is continuous.
3. At the position of a point charge the field jumps (it directs outwards for a positive charge from every side and is unbounded), so it is discontinuous. This is true for positive and negative charges alike.
Teacher's Note:
1. Think of the field of a point charge, which varies as 1/r² and has no meaning at r = 0.
2. Sign of the charge does not matter for continuity.
Examination Note: State both cases, with and without a charge at the point, to match options (b) and (d).
(a) \( \oint_S \vec E\cdot d\vec S \neq 0 \) on any surface
(b) \( \oint_S \vec E\cdot d\vec S = 0 \) if the charge is outside the surface
(c) \( \oint_S \vec E\cdot d\vec S \) could not be defined
(d) \( \oint_S \vec E\cdot d\vec S = \dfrac{q}{\varepsilon_0} \) if charges of magnitude q were inside the surface
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) \( \oint_S \vec E\cdot d\vec S = 0 \) if the charge is outside the surface, (d) \( \oint_S \vec E\cdot d\vec S = \dfrac{q}{\varepsilon_0} \) if charges of magnitude q were inside the surface
Explanation:
1. Gauss' law holds whatever kind of charge is present: the flux equals the enclosed charge divided by ε0.
2. If the charge lies outside the surface, the enclosed charge is zero and the flux is zero, so (b) is correct. If charge q is inside, the flux is q/ε0, so (d) is correct.
3. A surface that encloses no charge has zero flux, so (a) is wrong, and the flux is always well defined, so (c) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Gauss' law does not depend on having both positive and negative charges.
2. Surfaces enclosing no charge always give zero flux.
Examination Note: Quote Gauss' law and apply it to the two cases of charge outside and inside.
(a) the electric field is necessarily zero
(b) the electric field is due to the dipole moment of the charge distribution only
(c) the dominant electric field is \( \propto \dfrac{1}{r^3} \), for large r, where r is the distance from a origin in this region
(d) the work done to move a charged particle along a closed path, away from the region, will be zero
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (c) the dominant electric field is \( \propto \dfrac{1}{r^3} \), for large r, where r is the distance from a origin in this region, (d) the work done to move a charged particle along a closed path, away from the region, will be zero
Explanation:
1. A region of zero net charge behaves like a set of dipoles. Its field at large distance falls as 1/r³, like the field of a dipole, so (c) is correct.
2. The electrostatic field is conservative, so the work done on a charge around any closed path is zero, so (d) is correct.
3. The field outside is not zero, so (a) is wrong. Option (b) is wrong because the field is not due to the dipole moment alone.
Teacher's Note:
1. A single charge gives 1/r², a dipole gives 1/r³. Zero net charge removes the 1/r² term.
2. Work around a closed path is zero for every electrostatic field.
Examination Note: Say that the net charge is zero so the leading term is the dipole term, then add that the field is conservative.
(a) total flux through the surface of the sphere is \( \dfrac{-Q}{\varepsilon_0} \)
(b) field on the surface of the sphere is \( \dfrac{-Q}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 R^2} \)
(c) flux through the surface of sphere due to 5Q is zero
(d) field on the surface of sphere due to −2Q is same everywhere
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) total flux through the surface of the sphere is \( \dfrac{-Q}{\varepsilon_0} \), (c) flux through the surface of sphere due to 5Q is zero
Explanation:
1. The charges inside the Gaussian sphere are Q and −2Q. The enclosed charge is Q − 2Q = −Q, so the total flux is −Q/ε0, and (a) is correct.
2. The charge 5Q lies outside the sphere, so its flux through the surface is zero: (c) is correct.
3. The field on the surface is due to all three charges and is not uniform, so (b) is wrong. The charge −2Q is not at the centre, so its field is not the same everywhere on the surface, and (d) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Flux depends only on the enclosed charge; field depends on every charge.
2. Only a charge at the centre gives a field of the same magnitude all over the sphere.
Examination Note: Show the enclosed charge Q − 2Q = −Q before writing the flux.
(a) if q > 0 and is displaced away from the centre in the plane of the ring, it will be pushed back towards the centre
(b) if q < 0 and is displaced away from the centre in the plane of the ring, it will never return to the centre and will continue moving till it hits the ring
(c) if q < 0, it will perform SHM for small displacement along the axis
(d) q at the centre of the ring is in an unstable equilibrium within the plane of the ring for q > 0
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) if q > 0 and is displaced away from the centre in the plane of the ring, it will be pushed back towards the centre, (b) if q < 0 and is displaced away from the centre in the plane of the ring, it will never return to the centre and will continue moving till it hits the ring, (c) if q < 0, it will perform SHM for small displacement along the axis
Explanation:
1. By symmetry the force on q at the centre is zero. Now displace q a little in the plane of the ring. The part of the ring that is now nearer to q exerts the larger force (force varies as 1/r²).
2. If q > 0, the nearer part repels it, so it is pushed back to the centre: (a) is correct, and (d) is wrong because the equilibrium is stable in the plane.
3. If q < 0, the nearer part attracts it still more, so it moves away from the centre until it hits the ring: (b) is correct.
4. For q < 0 displaced a small distance z along the axis, the pull of the ring is towards the centre and proportional to z (for z << R). This gives SHM, so (c) is correct.
Teacher's Note:
1. The field inside a ring is not zero except at the centre; the field inside a charged spherical shell is zero, but a ring is not a shell.
2. Along the axis the restoring force is \( F \approx -\dfrac{Qq}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 R^3}\,z \), the same form as Hooke's law.
Examination Note: Treat the three cases separately: in-plane with q > 0, in-plane with q < 0 and along the axis with q < 0.
Very Short Answer Type Questions
Question 14. An arbitrary surface encloses a dipole. What is the electric flux through this surface?
Answer:
By Gauss' law, \( \phi = \dfrac{q_{\text{enclosed}}}{\varepsilon_0} \).
A dipole has charges +q and −q, so the net enclosed charge is q − q = 0.
\( \phi = \dfrac{0}{\varepsilon_0} = \) 0
In simple words: The flux through any closed surface around a dipole is zero because the two charges cancel.
Teacher's Note:
1. The total charge of a dipole is zero, whatever its size or orientation.
2. The field is not zero on the surface, but the net outward flux is zero.
Examination Note: Write Gauss' law, add the charges inside, and conclude zero flux.
Answer:
The charge +Q at the centre induces a charge −Q on the inner surface of the shell. The shell is neutral, so a charge +Q appears on the outer surface.
(i) Inner surface: \( \sigma_1 = \dfrac{-Q}{4\pi R_1^2} \)
(ii) Outer surface: \( \sigma_2 = \dfrac{+Q}{4\pi R_2^2} \)
In simple words: The charge Q attracts an equal and opposite charge to the inner surface and pushes the same amount to the outer surface; divide each charge by the area of its sphere.
Teacher's Note:
1. The field inside the metal must be zero, so the inner surface must carry exactly −Q (Gauss' law on a sphere inside the metal).
2. Total charge on the shell is unchanged, so the outer surface carries +Q.
Examination Note: Draw the small diagram showing −Q on the inner and +Q on the outer surface, then divide by 4πR² for each.
Question 16. The dimensions of an atom are of the order of an Angstrom. Thus, there must be large electric fields between the protons and electrons. Why, then, is the electrostatic field inside a conductor zero?
Answer:
The large fields exist only inside individual atoms, over distances of about 1 Å, and point in all directions. An atom as a whole is neutral.
The field we speak of inside a conductor is the average field over a region containing very many atoms. In electrostatic equilibrium the free electrons rearrange themselves till the net field of the excess charges is zero inside the metal.
Hence the electrostatic field inside a conductor is zero, even though strong fields exist within each atom.
In simple words: Strong fields exist inside each atom, but when averaged over the metal they cancel, so a conductor shows no net field inside.
Teacher's Note:
1. Free electrons keep moving until the net force on them is zero; at that point there is no field inside.
2. Charge that is in excess can only stay on the outer surface of the conductor.
Examination Note: Say that the atomic fields are microscopic and average to zero, whereas the field in a conductor is the macroscopic net field of excess charges.
Question 17. If the total charge enclosed by a surface is zero, does it imply that the electric field everywhere on the surface is zero? Conversely, if the electric field everywhere on a surface is zero, does it imply that net charge inside is zero?
Answer:
(i) No. By Gauss' law \( \oint \vec E\cdot d\vec S = q/\varepsilon_0 \), zero enclosed charge gives only zero net flux. The field on the surface is due to all charges, inside and outside, and can be non-zero. Example: a closed surface around an electric dipole encloses zero charge but the field on it is not zero.
(ii) Yes. If E = 0 at every point of the surface, the flux is zero, so q/ε0 = 0 and the net charge enclosed is zero.
In simple words: Zero net charge inside gives zero net flux but not zero field; zero field everywhere on the surface does give zero net charge.
Teacher's Note:
1. Flux is a sum over the whole surface, and positive and negative contributions can cancel.
2. The converse is true because if every term of the sum is zero, the sum is zero.
Examination Note: Answer both parts separately, give the dipole example for the first and use E = 0 in Gauss' law for the second.
Answer:
Field lines start on the positive charges and go to infinity.
Near the curved surface they are perpendicular to the surface, directed radially outwards (the top view shows them as straight lines radiating from the circle).
At the two ends the lines are curved, bending outwards away from the axis (side view).
In simple words: The lines leave the cylinder at right angles to its surface and spread out into space, bending outwards at the ends.
Teacher's Note:
1. Field lines are always normal to a charged conducting-like surface.
2. Lines never cross each other, and the further they spread, the weaker the field.
Examination Note: Draw a clear side view and top view, with arrows pointing away from the cylinder.
(a) A a corner of the cube (b) B mid-point of an edge of the cube (c) C centre of a face of the cube (d) D mid-point of B and C
Answer:
Imagine the charge at the centre of a symmetric arrangement of identical cubes and use Gauss' law: the total flux of q is q/ε0, shared equally among the cubes that meet at the charge.
(a) At a corner: 8 cubes share the charge. Flux through the cube = \( \dfrac{q}{8\varepsilon_0} \).
(b) At the mid-point of an edge: 4 cubes share it. Flux = \( \dfrac{q}{4\varepsilon_0} \).
(c) At the centre of a face: 2 cubes share it. Flux = \( \dfrac{q}{2\varepsilon_0} \).
(d) D lies on the same face (between B and C), so again 2 cubes share it. Flux = \( \dfrac{q}{2\varepsilon_0} \).
In simple words: A charge on a corner, an edge or a face is shared between 8, 4 or 2 cubes, so the cube gets one eighth, one quarter or one half of q/ε0.
Teacher's Note:
1. The same idea gives the 1/8 for a corner: eight cubes meet at a point and together enclose the charge completely.
2. If the charge were at the centre of the cube, the flux would be the full q/ε0.
Examination Note: Name the number of cubes sharing the charge in each case; the fractions follow at once.
Short Answer Type Questions
Question 20. A paisa coin is made up of Al-Mg alloy and weighs 0.75 g. It has a square shape and its diagonal measures 17 mm. It is electrically neutral and contains equal amounts of positive and negative charges. Treating the paisa coins made up of only Al, find the magnitude of equal number of positive and negative charges. What conclusion do you draw from this magnitude?
Answer:
Mass of coin = 0.75 g, atomic mass of Al = 26.9815 g, Avogadro number NA = 6.023 × 1023, atomic number of Al = 13.
Number of Al atoms: \( N = \dfrac{6.023\times10^{23}}{26.9815}\times0.75 = 1.674\times10^{22} \).
Each atom has 13 protons and 13 electrons, so the magnitude of positive (or negative) charge is \( q = N\,Z\,e = 1.674\times10^{22}\times13\times1.6\times10^{-19}\ \text{C} = 3.48\times10^{4}\ \text{C} \approx \) 34.8 kC.
Conclusion: ordinary neutral matter contains an enormous amount of positive and negative charge, which cancel each other.
In simple words: A small coin holds about 35 kC of each kind of charge; it appears neutral only because the two amounts are exactly equal.
Teacher's Note:
1. 1 mole of any element has NA atoms, so atoms = (mass / atomic mass) × NA.
2. The charge 34.8 kC is comparable to the charge that a thundercloud carries.
Examination Note: Show the number of atoms, the factor 13 for the protons per atom and the final value with unit; then write the conclusion in one sentence.
Question 21. Consider a coin of Question 20. It is electrically neutral and contains equal amounts of positive and negative charge of magnitude 34.8 kC. Suppose that these equal charges were concentrated in two point charges separated by (i) 1 cm (~ ½ × diagonal of the one paisa coin) (ii) 100 m (~ length of a long building) (iii) 106 m (radius of the earth). Find the force on each such point charge in each of the three cases. What do you conclude from these results?
Answer:
Using \( F = \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\dfrac{q^2}{r^2} \) with q = 3.48 × 104 C and \( \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} = 9\times10^{9}\ \text{N m}^2\text{C}^{-2} \):
(i) r = 10−2 m: \( F_1 = \dfrac{9\times10^{9}\times(3.48\times10^{4})^2}{(10^{-2})^2} = 1.09\times10^{23}\ \text{N} \)
(ii) r = 100 m: \( F_2 = \dfrac{9\times10^{9}\times(3.48\times10^{4})^2}{(100)^2} = 1.09\times10^{15}\ \text{N} \)
(iii) r = 106 m: \( F_3 = \dfrac{9\times10^{9}\times(3.48\times10^{4})^2}{(10^{6})^2} = 1.09\times10^{7}\ \text{N} \)
Conclusion: even at the distance of the radius of the earth the force is huge. So the positive and negative charges in ordinary matter cannot be separated to any appreciable extent; matter stays electrically neutral.
In simple words: If all the positive and all the negative charge of one coin were separated, they would pull on each other with an enormous force, so such a separation never happens.
Teacher's Note:
1. Coulomb forces are very large compared with everyday forces; that is why neutral matter is so stable.
2. Force falls as 1/r², so a factor of 108 in distance gives 1016 in force.
Examination Note: Write the formula once, substitute in all three cases in a table or three lines, and give the conclusion in words.
(i) What is the net electric field on the Cl atom due to eight Cs atoms? (ii) Suppose that the Cs atom at the corner A is missing. What is the net force now on the Cl atom due to seven remaining Cs atoms?
Answer:
(i) The Cl− ion is at the centre of the cube, at the same distance from all eight Cs+ ions at the corners. The fields of diagonally opposite ions are equal and opposite, so they cancel in pairs. The net field is zero.
(ii) With the ion at A missing, the net force on Cl− equals the force that the missing ion would have exerted, reversed in direction (since all eight together give zero).
Distance from the centre to a corner: \( r = \sqrt{3}\times0.20\ \text{nm} = 0.346\times10^{-9}\ \text{m} \).
\( F = \dfrac{e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} = \dfrac{9\times10^{9}\times(1.6\times10^{-19})^2}{(0.346\times10^{-9})^2} = \) 1.92 × 10−9 N, directed along the body diagonal away from A (towards the opposite corner).
In simple words: Eight equal ions around the centre cancel; remove one and what is left is the force of that one ion, reversed.
Teacher's Note:
1. Half the diagonal of the cube is \( \tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}a \), here \( \tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}\times0.40 = 0.346 \) nm.
2. This is a standard example of the symmetry (superposition) argument: all eight minus one equals the negative of one.
Examination Note: In (ii), first explain the argument (total is zero, so the rest equals the negative of the missing one), then calculate and give the direction.
Question 23. Two charges q and −3q are placed fixed on x-axis separated by distance d. Where should a third charge 2q be placed such that it will not experience any force?
Answer:
Let A hold q and B hold −3q, with AB = d. The third charge 2q is in equilibrium only outside the pair, on the side of the smaller charge q, i.e. to the left of A. (Between the charges both forces would point the same way, and on the far side of −3q the larger charge would always win.)
Let the charge 2q be at a distance x to the left of A. The repulsion due to q (towards the left) balances the attraction due to −3q (towards the right):
\( \dfrac{2q\cdot q}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 x^2} = \dfrac{2q\cdot 3q}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 (x+d)^2} \Rightarrow (x+d)^2 = 3x^2 \Rightarrow x + d = \sqrt3\,x \)
\( x = \dfrac{d}{\sqrt3-1} = \dfrac{d(\sqrt3+1)}{2} = \dfrac{d}{2}\,(1+\sqrt3) \approx 1.37\,d \)
So the charge 2q must be placed at a distance \( \tfrac{d}{2}(1+\sqrt3) \) from q, on the left of q, on the line joining the charges.
In simple words: For opposite charges of unequal size, the balance point lies outside the pair and nearer to the smaller charge.
Teacher's Note:
1. Between the two charges, q repels 2q and −3q attracts it in the same direction, so no balance is possible there.
2. The sign of the third charge does not change the position, only the direction of the forces.
Examination Note: Explain why the point is outside the pair (one line), write the balance equation and reject the negative root.
(i) Which charges are positive? (ii) Which charge has the largest magnitude? Why? (iii) In which region of the picture could the electric field be zero? Justify your answer. (a) Near A (b) Near B (c) Near C (d) Nowhere
Answer:
(i) Field lines start from positive charges. Lines emerge from A and from C, while the lines drawn towards B end on it. So A and C are positive (B is negative).
(ii) The number of lines is proportional to the magnitude of the charge. The most lines emerge from C, so C has the largest magnitude.
(iii) The field can vanish only at a neutral point, where the fields of the charges cancel. Between two like (positive) charges A and C, the fields point in opposite directions and so can cancel. As C is much stronger than A, the neutral point must lie closer to the weaker charge. So the field could be zero (a) near A.
In simple words: Count the lines to compare charges; a neutral point lies between two like charges, close to the smaller one.
Teacher's Note:
1. Lines never cross, so a point where lines of two charges would meet head-on is where the field can be zero.
2. Neutral point formula for two like charges: the distances are in the ratio \( \sqrt{q_1} : \sqrt{q_2} \).
Examination Note: Answer the three parts separately and give the reason (number of lines, like charges, nearer to the weaker one).
(a) (i) What will be the electric field at O, the centre of the pentagon? (ii) What will be the electric field at O if the charge from one of the corners (say A) is removed? (iii) What will be the electric field at O if the charge q at A is replaced by −q? (b) How would your answer to (a) be affected if the pentagon is replaced by an n-sided regular polygon with charge q at each of its corners?
Answer:
(a)(i) O is at the same distance r from all five charges, and the five field vectors are equal in magnitude and symmetrically placed, so they cancel. E = 0.
(ii) Since all five together give zero, the other four give a field equal and opposite to that of the charge at A. The field of q at A at point O has magnitude \( \dfrac{q}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} \) and points from A to O, so the required field is \( E = \dfrac{q}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} \) directed along OA (from O towards A).
(iii) Replacing q by −q at A is the same as removing q and adding −q. The field of the four remaining charges is \( \dfrac{q}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} \) along OA, and the −q at A attracts towards A with the same magnitude along OA. Total: \( E = \dfrac{2q}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} \) along OA.
(b) For any regular n-sided polygon with q at every corner, the symmetry argument still holds, so the field at the centre is zero; in (ii) and (iii) the results are the same as above (they do not depend on n, except that r is the distance from the centre to a corner).
In simple words: By symmetry, all identical charges at the corners of a regular polygon give zero field at the centre; removing or changing one charge leaves only its effect.
Teacher's Note:
1. Treat 'remove a charge' as 'add an equal and opposite charge'. This reduces every part to one calculation.
2. The result in (ii) and (iii) holds for all n, so the polygon may be a triangle, square or hexagon.
Examination Note: Use the superposition idea explicitly: total = (all q) + correction. It keeps the working to two lines.
Long Answer Type Questions
Question 26. In 1959 Lyttleton and Bondi suggested that the expansion of the universe could be explained if matter carried a net charge. Suppose that the universe is made up of hydrogen atoms with a number density N, which is maintained a constant. Let the charge on the proton be ep = −(1 + y)e where e is the electronic charge. (a) Find the critical value of y such that expansion may start. (b) Show that the velocity of expansion is proportional to the distance from the centre.
Answer:
Set-up. Take the universe as a uniform sphere of radius R holding N hydrogen atoms per unit volume. Here e is the (negative) charge of the electron, so the proton charge is \( -(1+y)e \) and the net charge of a hydrogen atom is \( e_H = e_p + e = -ye \). Its magnitude is y|e|, and it is positive. The charge density is \( \rho = N\,y|e| \).
(a) Gauss' law on a sphere of radius R: \( E\,(4\pi R^2) = \dfrac{1}{\varepsilon_0}\cdot\dfrac{4}{3}\pi R^3 N y|e| \Rightarrow E = \dfrac{N y|e|R}{3\varepsilon_0} \).
Coulomb (repulsive) force on one atom at the surface: \( F_C = y|e|\,E = \dfrac{N y^2 e^2 R}{3\varepsilon_0} \).
Gravitational field at the surface (mass of an atom taken as the proton mass mp): \( g = \dfrac{G}{R^2}\cdot\dfrac43\pi R^3 N m_p = \dfrac{4\pi}{3}G N m_p R \), so the attractive force is \( F_G = \dfrac{4\pi}{3}G N m_p^2 R \).
Expansion can start when \( F_C \ge F_G \). At the critical value: \( \dfrac{N y^2e^2R}{3\varepsilon_0} = \dfrac{4\pi}{3}GNm_p^2R \Rightarrow y^2 = 4\pi\varepsilon_0 G\left(\dfrac{m_p}{e}\right)^2 \).
\( y^2 = \dfrac{1}{9\times10^{9}}\times6.67\times10^{-11}\times\left(\dfrac{1.67\times10^{-27}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}\right)^2 \approx 8\times10^{-37} \Rightarrow y \approx 9\times10^{-19}\approx \) 10−18 (order of magnitude).
(b) Net force on an atom at distance R from the centre: \( F = F_C - F_G = \left(\dfrac{N y^2e^2}{3\varepsilon_0} - \dfrac{4\pi}{3}G N m_p^2\right)R \). With acceleration \( d^2R/dt^2 \): \( \dfrac{d^2R}{dt^2} = \alpha^2 R \), where \( \alpha^2 = \dfrac{1}{m_p}\left(\dfrac{N y^2e^2}{3\varepsilon_0} - \dfrac{4\pi}{3}G N m_p^2\right) > 0 \) for y above the critical value.
The expanding solution is \( R = A e^{\alpha t} \), so the velocity is \( v = \dfrac{dR}{dt} = \alpha A e^{\alpha t} = \alpha R \). Hence v ∝ R: the velocity of expansion is proportional to the distance from the centre.
In simple words: Expansion starts when the repulsion due to the tiny net charge of each atom exceeds gravity, which needs y of only about 10−18; then the speed grows in proportion to the distance, like Hubble's law.
Teacher's Note:
1. The ratio of electric to gravitational force between two protons is about 1036, so a very small charge imbalance is enough.
2. Both forces grow in proportion to R, so the equation of motion has the form d²R/dt² = α²R, whose growing solution is an exponential.
Examination Note: Show the two forces on an atom at the surface, equate them for the critical y, then write the equation of motion and its solution to finish part (b).
Question 27. Consider a sphere of radius R with charge density distributed as \( \rho(r) = kr \) for r ≤ R and = 0 for r > R. (a) Find the electric field at all points r. (b) Suppose the total charge on the sphere is 2e where e is the electron charge. Where can two protons be embedded such that the force on each of them is zero. Assume that the introduction of the proton does not alter the negative charge distribution.
Answer:
(a) The field is radial. Take a concentric Gaussian sphere of radius r.
For r ≤ R, enclosed charge: \( q(r) = \int_0^r kr'\,4\pi r'^2\,dr' = \pi k r^4 \). Gauss' law: \( E\,4\pi r^2 = \dfrac{\pi k r^4}{\varepsilon_0} \Rightarrow \) \( E = \dfrac{k r^2}{4\varepsilon_0} \) (r ≤ R).
For r > R, enclosed charge is the whole charge \( \pi k R^4 \): \( E = \dfrac{k R^4}{4\varepsilon_0 r^2} \) (r > R). The field is directed radially outwards for k > 0.
(b) The two protons can be in equilibrium only if the sphere attracts them, so the sphere is negatively charged with total charge of magnitude 2e (e = magnitude of the electron charge). Then \( \pi k R^4 = 2e \Rightarrow k = \dfrac{2e}{\pi R^4} \) (magnitude).
By symmetry the protons must lie on opposite ends of a diameter, each at distance r from the centre (so their separation is 2r).
Attraction on proton 1 by the sphere (r < R): \( F_1 = \dfrac{e\,k r^2}{4\varepsilon_0} = \dfrac{e^2 r^2}{2\pi\varepsilon_0 R^4} \). Repulsion by proton 2: \( F_2 = \dfrac{e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 (2r)^2} = \dfrac{e^2}{16\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} \).
Net force zero: \( \dfrac{e^2r^2}{2\pi\varepsilon_0R^4} = \dfrac{e^2}{16\pi\varepsilon_0r^2} \Rightarrow r^4 = \dfrac{R^4}{8} \Rightarrow \) \( r = \dfrac{R}{8^{1/4}} \approx 0.59\,R \).
So the two protons sit on a diameter, on opposite sides of the centre, each at a distance \( R/8^{1/4} \) from it.
In simple words: Use Gauss' law with the charge inside radius r; for part (b) balance the pull of the negative sphere on each proton against the push of the other proton.
Teacher's Note:
1. For a non-uniform charge density, the charge inside radius r must be found by integrating over thin shells of volume 4πr²dr.
2. Placing the protons on a diameter ensures the force of one on the other is along the same line as the pull of the sphere.
Examination Note: Write the shell integral clearly: the 4πr² factor is the most common thing forgotten, and the answer to (b) must give r in terms of R.
Question 28. Two fixed, identical conducting plates (α and β), each of surface area S are charged to −Q and q, respectively, where Q > q > 0. A third identical plate (γ), free to move, carrying charge Q as shown in the figure, is located on the other side of the plate with charge q at a distance d. The third plate is released and collides with the plate β. Assume that the collision is elastic and the time of collision is sufficient to redistribute charge amongst β and γ. (a) Find the electric field acting on the plate γ before collision. (b) Find the charges on β and γ after the collision. (c) Find the velocity of the plate γ after the collision and at a distance d from the plate β.
Answer:
Treat each large plate as an infinite sheet: the field of a plate carrying charge Q' is \( \dfrac{Q'}{2\varepsilon_0 S} \), directed away from it if positive and towards it if negative.
(a) At γ, the field of α (charge −Q) is \( \dfrac{Q}{2\varepsilon_0S} \) towards α, i.e. to the left. The field of β (charge q) is \( \dfrac{q}{2\varepsilon_0S} \) away from β, i.e. to the right. Net field: \( E_1 = \dfrac{Q-q}{2\varepsilon_0 S} \) directed to the left (towards β and α), since Q > q.
(b) When β and γ touch they form one conductor at one potential, so the field between them is zero. Let β carry q1 and γ carry q2 after contact. At a point between them: the field of α is \( \dfrac{Q}{2\varepsilon_0S} \) to the left, of β is \( \dfrac{q_1}{2\varepsilon_0S} \) to the right and of γ is \( \dfrac{q_2}{2\varepsilon_0S} \) to the left. For zero field: \( q_1 = Q + q_2 \).
Charge is conserved: \( q_1 + q_2 = Q + q \). Solving, \( q_1 = Q + \dfrac{q}{2} \) (on β) and \( q_2 = \dfrac{q}{2} \) (on γ).
(c) Before collision, force on γ (charge Q) is \( F_1 = QE_1 = \dfrac{Q(Q-q)}{2\varepsilon_0 S} \) towards β. It travels the distance d, so the work done is \( F_1d \). The elastic collision reverses its velocity without changing its speed.
After the collision, the field at γ is the sum of the field of α, \( \dfrac{Q}{2\varepsilon_0S} \) to the left, and of β, \( \dfrac{Q+q/2}{2\varepsilon_0S} \) to the right: \( E_2 = \dfrac{q}{4\varepsilon_0S} \) to the right. The force on γ (charge q/2) is \( F_2 = \dfrac{q}{2}E_2 = \dfrac{q^2}{8\varepsilon_0S} \) to the right, which does work \( F_2d \) as γ moves away through the distance d.
Work–energy theorem: \( \dfrac12 mv^2 = (F_1+F_2)d = \dfrac{d}{2\varepsilon_0S}\left[Q(Q-q)+\dfrac{q^2}{4}\right] = \dfrac{d}{2\varepsilon_0 S}\left(Q-\dfrac q2\right)^2 \)
\( v = \left(Q - \dfrac{q}{2}\right)\sqrt{\dfrac{d}{m\varepsilon_0 S}} \), directed away from β (to the right).
In simple words: Before the collision γ is pulled towards β; after sharing charge it is pushed away, and both the pull and the push add to its kinetic energy.
Teacher's Note:
1. Contact makes β and γ one conductor, so there is no field between them and the total charge Q + q is redistributed.
2. The field of an infinite sheet does not depend on distance, so the force is constant and work = force × d.
Examination Note: Write the three stages in order (before, at, after the collision) and add the work done in the two stages; the perfect square (Q − q/2)² is the expected form.
Question 29. There is another useful system of units, besides the SI/MKS. A system, called the CGS (Centimetre-Gram-Second) system. In this system, Coulomb's law is given by \( \vec F = \dfrac{Qq}{r^2}\hat r \) where the distance r is measured in cm (= 10−2 m), F in dynes (= 10−5 N) and the charges in electrostatic units (es units), where 1 es unit of charge \( = \dfrac{1}{[3]}\times10^{-9}\ \text{C} \). The number [3] actually arises from the speed of light in vacuum which is now taken to be exactly given by c = 2.99792458 × 108 m/s. An approximate value of c, then, is c = 3 × 108 m/s. (i) Show that the Coulomb's law in CGS units yields 1 esu of charge = 1 (dyne)1/2 cm. Obtain the dimensions of units of charge in terms of mass M, length L and time T. Show that it is given in terms of fractional powers of M and L. (ii) Write 1 esu of charge = x C, where x is a dimensionless number. Show that this gives \( \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} = \dfrac{10^{-9}}{x^2}\dfrac{\text{N m}^2}{\text{C}^2} \). With \( x = \dfrac{1}{[3]}\times10^{-9} \), we have \( \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} = [3]^2\times10^{9}\dfrac{\text{N m}^2}{\text{C}^2} \), \( \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} = (2.99792458)^2\times10^{9}\dfrac{\text{N m}^2}{\text{C}^2} \) (exactly).
Answer:
(i) In CGS, \( F = \dfrac{Qq}{r^2} \). For two equal charges of 1 esu at 1 cm, F = 1 dyne: \( 1\ \text{dyne} = \dfrac{(1\ \text{esu})^2}{(1\ \text{cm})^2} \Rightarrow 1\ \text{esu} = (1\ \text{dyne})^{1/2}\times1\ \text{cm} \).
Dimensions: \( [\text{dyne}] = [MLT^{-2}] \), so \( [\text{esu}] = [MLT^{-2}]^{1/2}\,L = \) M1/2L3/2T−1. This has fractional powers 1/2 of M and 3/2 of L.
(ii) Let 1 esu = x C. Two charges of 1 esu at 1 cm exert the force 1 dyne = 10−5 N. In SI units, two charges xC at a distance 10−2 m: \( \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\dfrac{x^2}{(10^{-2})^2} = 10^{-5} \Rightarrow \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} = \dfrac{10^{-9}}{x^2}\ \dfrac{\text{N m}^2}{\text{C}^2} \).
Putting \( x = \dfrac{10^{-9}}{[3]} \): \( \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} = 10^{-9}\times\dfrac{[3]^2}{10^{-18}} = [3]^2\times10^{9}\ \dfrac{\text{N m}^2}{\text{C}^2} \).
With the exact value [3] → 2.99792458: \( \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} = (2.99792458)^2\times10^{9} = 8.98755\times10^{9}\ \dfrac{\text{N m}^2}{\text{C}^2} \).
In simple words: In CGS units Coulomb's law has no constant, so the unit of charge is defined from force and length alone, which gives it fractional powers of M and L.
Teacher's Note:
1. The factor 9 × 109 in SI is the approximation [3]² = 9 of (2.9979)² = 8.98755.
2. 1 esu of charge ≈ 3.34 × 10−10 C.
Examination Note: Start from F = Qq/r² for 1 esu at 1 cm to get the unit, then take the dimensions of dyne; each step is one line.
Question 30. Two charges −q each are fixed separated by distance 2d. A third charge q of mass m placed at the mid-point is displaced slightly by x (x << d) perpendicular to the line joining the two fixed charged as shown in figure. Show that q will perform simple harmonic oscillation of time period \( T = \left[\dfrac{8\pi^3\varepsilon_0 m d^3}{q^2}\right]^{1/2} \).
Answer:
Let the fixed charges −q be at A and B (AB = 2d), O the mid-point, and P the position of q after a displacement x perpendicular to AB. Then \( AP = BP = r = \sqrt{d^2 + x^2} \).
The attractive force of each fixed charge on q is \( F = \dfrac{q^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} \). The components parallel to AB cancel. The components along PO add: \( F' = 2F\cos\theta = 2\cdot\dfrac{q^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0r^2}\cdot\dfrac{x}{r} = \dfrac{2q^2x}{4\pi\varepsilon_0(d^2+x^2)^{3/2}} \).
For x << d: \( F' \approx \dfrac{2q^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 d^3}\,x = Kx \), where \( K = \dfrac{q^2}{2\pi\varepsilon_0 d^3} \).
The force is proportional to the displacement and directed towards O (restoring), so the motion is simple harmonic with \( \omega = \sqrt{K/m} \).
\( T = 2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{m}{K}} = 2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{2\pi\varepsilon_0 m d^3}{q^2}} = \) \( \left[\dfrac{8\pi^3\varepsilon_0 m d^3}{q^2}\right]^{1/2} \)
In simple words: For small x the pull towards the mid-point is proportional to x, which is the condition for SHM; the period follows from T = 2π√(m/K).
Teacher's Note:
1. Approximation used: (d² + x²)3/2 ≈ d³ when x << d.
2. If the third charge were displaced along the line joining the charges, the equilibrium would be unstable instead.
Examination Note: State the two conditions clearly: force is proportional to x and directed towards the equilibrium point; then quote T = 2π√(m/K).
Question 31. Total charge −Q is uniformly spread along length of a ring of radius R. A small test charge +q of mass m is kept at the centre of the ring and is given a gentle push along the axis of the ring. (a) Show that the particle executes a simple harmonic oscillation. (b) Obtain its time period.
Answer:
Let the charge q be displaced by a small distance z along the axis from the centre. Take two small, diametrically opposite elements of the ring (at A and B). Each has charge dQ and is at distance \( r = \sqrt{R^2+z^2} \) from q.
The attractive force of each element on q has a component along the axis, towards the centre, of \( dF\cos\theta \) with \( \cos\theta = z/r \). The components perpendicular to the axis cancel for each opposite pair.
Adding over the whole ring, \( F = \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\dfrac{Qq}{r^2}\cdot\dfrac{z}{r} = \dfrac{Qq\,z}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 (R^2+z^2)^{3/2}} \), directed towards the centre.
(a) For z << R: \( F \approx \dfrac{Qq}{4\pi\varepsilon_0R^3}\,z = Kz \). The force is proportional to the displacement and opposite to it (towards the centre), so the motion is simple harmonic, with \( K = \dfrac{Qq}{4\pi\varepsilon_0R^3} \).
(b) \( \omega = \sqrt{K/m} \), so \( T = 2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{m}{K}} = \) \( 2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{4\pi\varepsilon_0 m R^3}{Qq}} \).
In simple words: Along the axis the ring pulls the charge back towards the centre with a force proportional to the displacement, which is exactly Hooke's law.
Teacher's Note:
1. Only the axial components survive; the sideways components of opposite elements cancel.
2. Because the ring charge is negative and q is positive the force is attractive, so it is restoring. For a positive ring charge the centre would be unstable along the axis.
Examination Note: Write the exact force first, then apply the small-z approximation, and finish with T = 2π√(m/K).