These NCERT Exemplar solutions for Class 12 Physics Chapter 5, Magnetism and Matter, give step-by-step answers to all 25 questions: 5 MCQs, 5 multiple-correct MCQs, 5 very short, 5 short and 5 long answer questions. They cover the magnetic dipole and the earth's magnetism, declination and dip, Gauss's law and Ampere's law for dipole fields, the origin of magnetism, para-, dia- and ferromagnetic behaviour, Curie's law and magnetic shielding. Each answer is followed by a short Teacher's Note to build understanding and an Examination Note on how to present the answer for better marks.
Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)
(a) is non-zero and points in the z-direction by symmetry
(b) points along the axis of the toroid (m = m φ̂)
(c) is zero, otherwise there would be a field falling as \( \dfrac{1}{r^3} \) at large distances outside the toroid
(d) is pointing radially outwards
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (c) is zero, otherwise there would be a field falling as \( \dfrac{1}{r^3} \) at large distances outside the toroid
Explanation:
1. In an ideal toroid the magnetic field is confined entirely inside the turns, in the form of closed circular lines. There is no field outside the toroid.
2. If the toroid had a non-zero magnetic moment, it would behave like a dipole at large distances and produce a field varying as \( 1/r^3 \) outside. No such field exists.
3. Hence the net magnetic moment of a toroid is zero.
Teacher's Note:
1. The current in a toroid goes round a closed ring, so for every part of the winding there is a part that cancels its dipole effect at far points.
2. Remember: zero field outside a toroid means zero dipole moment.
Examination Note: Link the answer to the field outside: a dipole would give a 1/r3 field, a toroid gives none, so m = 0.
(a) the declination varies between 11.3° W to 11.3° E
(b) the least declination is 0°
(c) the plane defined by dipole axis and the earth axis passes through Greenwich
(d) declination averaged over the earth must always be negative
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) the declination varies between 11.3° W to 11.3° E
Explanation:
1. Declination is the angle between the geographic meridian and the magnetic meridian at a place.
2. The magnetic dipole axis is tilted by 11.3° from the axis of rotation of the earth. So the magnetic north can lie up to 11.3° to the east or to the west of the geographic north, and the declination varies between 11.3° W and 11.3° E (a place such as Mumbai lies in the plane of the two axes, where it is nearly zero).
3. Option (b) gives only one value, not the variation which the data fix. Option (c) is wrong because in the given data the plane of the two axes passes through Mumbai, not Greenwich. Option (d) is wrong because there is no reason for the average to be negative; east and west deviations are equally likely.
Teacher's Note:
1. Declination is zero only for places lying in the plane that contains both the rotation axis and the dipole axis.
2. The tilt of 11.3° sets the largest possible deviation of the compass needle from geographic north (in the low-latitude region).
Examination Note: Define declination and connect the 11.3° tilt to its range in one line.
(a) magnetic moment of each molecule is zero
(b) the individual molecules have non-zero magnetic moment which are all perfectly aligned
(c) domains are partially aligned
(d) domains are all perfectly aligned
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (d) domains are all perfectly aligned
Explanation:
1. A permanent magnet is made of a ferromagnetic substance, which retains its magnetism for a long time at room temperature.
2. The atoms of a ferromagnetic material have magnetic moments. Because of a strong interaction between neighbouring atoms, they align spontaneously over small regions called domains.
3. In a permanent magnet the moments of the domains are all aligned in the same direction. So (d) is the choice.
Teacher's Note:
1. Domains are tiny regions (about 1 mm across), each fully magnetised. In an unmagnetised piece they point in random directions; in a magnet they are aligned.
2. Option (a) describes a diamagnetic substance and (b) mistakenly says that molecules, not domains, are the unit of alignment.
Examination Note: Mention 'domains' and 'ferromagnetic' to earn the explanation mark.
(a) case (i) contradicts Gauss' law for electrostatic fields
(b) case (ii) contradicts Gauss' law for magnetic fields
(c) case (i) agrees with \( \oint \mathbf{E}\cdot d\mathbf{l} = 0 \)
(d) case (ii) contradicts \( \oint \mathbf{H}\cdot d\mathbf{l} = I_{en} \)
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) case (ii) contradicts Gauss' law for magnetic fields
Explanation:
1. Gauss' law for electric fields relates the flux to the enclosed charge, \( \oint \mathbf E \cdot d\mathbf S = q/\varepsilon_0 \). The plates carry charge, so a uniform E between them does not violate it; (a) is wrong.
2. If E is constant between the plates and abruptly zero outside, then for a loop crossing the edge, \( \oint \mathbf E\cdot d\mathbf l \neq 0 \). So case (i) actually contradicts this law, which means (c) is wrong.
3. Gauss' law for magnetic fields says \( \oint \mathbf B \cdot d\mathbf S = 0 \): field lines are closed loops. In the idealised solenoid the lines run through the inside and simply stop at the ends (zero outside), with no return path. This violates the law, so (b) is right.
4. Ampere's law \( \oint \mathbf H\cdot d\mathbf l = I_{en} \) is satisfied by the field nI inside, so (d) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Real fields 'fringe' at the edges of a capacitor and outside a solenoid; the idealisation hides that.
2. Magnetic field lines never start or end, which is the content of Gauss' law for magnetism.
Examination Note: State Gauss' law for magnetism, ∮B·dS = 0, and say that lines cannot end at the ends of the solenoid. Check each option and reject with a reason.
(a) \( \dfrac{32}{3} \) A m−1
(b) \( \dfrac{2}{3} \) A m−1
(c) 6 A m−1
(d) 2.4 A m−1
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) \( \dfrac{2}{3} \) A m−1
Explanation:
1. Curie's law: \( M \propto \dfrac{B}{T} \).
2. \( \dfrac{M_2}{M_1} = \dfrac{B_2}{B_1} \times \dfrac{T_1}{T_2} = \dfrac{0.2}{0.6} \times \dfrac{4}{16} = \dfrac{1}{3}\times\dfrac{1}{4} = \dfrac{1}{12} \).
3. \( M_2 = 8 \times \dfrac{1}{12} = \dfrac{2}{3}\ \text{A m}^{-1} \).
Teacher's Note:
1. Curie's law is valid for paramagnetic substances; magnetisation rises with the field and falls with temperature.
2. Here the field falls by 3 and the temperature rises by 4, so M falls by 12 times.
Examination Note: Write the proportionality M ∝ B/T first and then take the ratio; do not mix the temperature in °C with kelvin.
Multiple Choice Questions (More Than One Option)
(a) Lines of B are necessarily continuous across S
(b) Some lines of B must be discontinuous across S
(c) Lines of H are necessarily continuous across S
(d) Lines of H cannot all be continuous across S
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) Lines of B are necessarily continuous across S, (d) Lines of H cannot all be continuous across S
Explanation:
1. Lines of B form closed loops (\( \oint \mathbf B\cdot d\mathbf S = 0 \)), so they continue unbroken from inside the material to outside. This makes (a) correct and (b) wrong.
2. The two fields are related by \( \mathbf B = \mu_0(\mathbf H + \mathbf M) \). Outside the material M = 0, so H = B/μ0; inside, \( \mathbf H = \mathbf B/\mu_0 - \mathbf M \), which differs because of M.
3. As the magnetisation changes abruptly at the surface, the lines of H cannot all be continuous there (for a bar magnet they begin on the north pole and end on the south pole). So (d) is correct and (c) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. B lines have no beginning or end; H lines can start and end on poles.
2. H is 'smooth' only if M is zero, i.e. outside the material.
Examination Note: Say that B is solenoidal (closed lines) while H = B/μ0 − M changes with M across the surface.
(a) atomic currents
(b) Pauli exclusion principle
(c) polar nature of molecules
(d) intrinsic spin of electron
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) atomic currents, (d) intrinsic spin of electron
Explanation:
1. Electrons revolve around the nucleus, which constitutes a tiny current loop called an atomic current, and each such loop has a magnetic moment.
2. In addition, every electron has an intrinsic spin that carries a magnetic moment of its own.
3. These two (orbital atomic currents and intrinsic spin) are the primary origins of magnetism. The polar nature of molecules concerns electric dipoles, not magnetic ones.
Teacher's Note:
1. Total atomic magnetic moment = orbital part + spin part.
2. In many atoms the moments of paired electrons cancel; only unpaired spins give a net moment.
Examination Note: Name both sources, orbital motion (atomic currents) and spin, and reject the polar nature of molecules as an electric concept.
(a) The H field in the solenoid is (nearly) unchanged but the B field decreases drastically
(b) The H and B fields in the solenoid are nearly unchanged
(c) The magnetisation in the core reverses direction
(d) The magnetisation in the core diminishes by a factor of about 108
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) The H field in the solenoid is (nearly) unchanged but the B field decreases drastically, (d) The magnetisation in the core diminishes by a factor of about 108
Explanation:
1. \( H = nI = 1000 \times 1 = 1000\ \text{A m}^{-1} \). It depends only on the winding current, so H is unchanged by heating the core.
2. Below Tc: \( B = \mu_0 \mu_r H \) with μr = 1000. Above Tc the iron becomes paramagnetic, with μr ≈ 1, so B falls by a factor of about 1000. Hence B decreases drastically (a).
3. Magnetisation \( M = \chi H \). For a ferromagnet χ ≈ 103, while for a paramagnet χ ≈ 10−5. So M decreases by a factor of about \( 10^3/10^{-5} = 10^{8} \) (d).
4. The direction of M does not reverse (it stays along H), so (c) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Above the Curie temperature a ferromagnet turns into a paramagnet.
2. H depends on the free current; B and M depend on the core material.
Examination Note: Calculate H = nI first, then show that B falls with μr and M falls with χ. Quote χ values for both states.
(a) electrostatic field lines can end on charges and conductors have free charges
(b) lines of B can also end but conductors cannot end them
(c) lines of B cannot end on any material and perfect shielding is not possible
(d) shells of high permeability materials can be used to divert lines of B from the interior region
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) electrostatic field lines can end on charges and conductors have free charges, (c) lines of B cannot end on any material and perfect shielding is not possible, (d) shells of high permeability materials can be used to divert lines of B from the interior region
Explanation:
1. Electric field lines can end on charges, and a conductor has free charges that rearrange so as to cancel the field inside it: perfect electrostatic shielding is possible (a).
2. Magnetic field lines are closed loops; they cannot end on any material, so they cannot be completely stopped. Perfect magnetostatic shielding is therefore not possible (c).
3. The best one can do is to surround the region by a shell of a high-permeability material (such as soft iron or mu-metal), which draws the lines of B through its walls and diverts them away from the interior (d). Option (b) is wrong because lines of B cannot end.
Teacher's Note:
1. A Faraday cage works for electric fields but not for a steady magnetic field.
2. Soft iron cases are used to protect sensitive instruments from stray magnetic fields.
Examination Note: Contrast the two: electric lines end on free charges (complete shielding); magnetic lines never end (only diversion by high-permeability material).
(a) is always zero
(b) can be zero at specific points
(c) can be positive or negative
(d) is bounded
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) can be zero at specific points, (c) can be positive or negative, (d) is bounded
Explanation:
1. For a dipole, the dip δ at a place is given by \( \tan\delta = 2\tan\lambda_m \), where λm is the magnetic latitude of the place.
2. The dipole axis is tilted by 11.3° from the earth's axis, so the geographical equator does not coincide with the magnetic equator. The two equators cross at two points, where the dip is zero (b).
3. Along the geographical equator, the magnetic latitude goes from +11.3° to −11.3°, so the dip is positive at some places and negative at others (c). Because λm stays within ±11.3°, the dip is limited to about ±22° (tan δ = 2 tan 11.3° ≈ 0.4, δ ≈ 21.8°) (d). It is not always zero, so (a) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Dip is zero on the magnetic equator and 90° at the magnetic poles.
2. The relation tan δ = 2 tan λm follows from the dipole field components.
Examination Note: Use tan δ = 2 tan λm and the 11.3° tilt to justify all three correct options. A bounded range of about ±22° (21.8°) is a good supporting number.
Very Short Answer Type Questions
Question 11. A proton has spin and magnetic moment just like an electron. Why then is its effect neglected in magnetism of materials?
Answer:
The magnetic moment associated with a spinning charge is proportional to \( \dfrac{e}{m} \): \( \mu \propto \dfrac{eh}{4\pi m} \).
So \( \dfrac{\mu_p}{\mu_e} \approx \dfrac{m_e}{m_p} \approx \dfrac{1}{1836} \), i.e. of the order of 10−3.
The proton is about 1836 times heavier than the electron, so its magnetic moment is of the order of a thousand times smaller. Compared with the electron's contribution, it is negligible in the magnetism of materials.
In simple words: A proton is much heavier than an electron, so its magnetic moment is only about a thousandth of the electron's and can be ignored.
Teacher's Note:
1. The unit of atomic magnetic moment is the Bohr magneton, which has the electron mass in the denominator.
2. Nuclear magnetic moments matter only in special techniques such as NMR.
Examination Note: Show μ ∝ 1/m and quote the mass ratio of about 1836 to close the argument.
Question 12. A permanent magnet in the shape of a thin cylinder of length 10 cm has M = 106 A/m. Calculate the magnetisation current IM.
Answer:
Magnetisation M is the magnetic moment per unit volume. For a thin cylinder, the surface (magnetisation) current per unit length equals M: \( M = \dfrac{I_M}{l} \).
\( I_M = M\,l = 10^6 \times 0.1 = 10^5\ \text{A} \).
IM = 105 A
In simple words: A magnet with M = 106 A/m and 10 cm length behaves as if a current of 105 A circulates along its surface.
Teacher's Note:
1. Check the units: (A/m) × m = A.
2. This equivalent surface current is what makes a magnet behave like a solenoid.
Examination Note: Convert 10 cm into metres before multiplying; the unit conversion is the commonly lost mark.
Question 13. Explain quantitatively the order of magnitude difference between the diamagnetic susceptibility of N2 (~ 5 × 10−9) (at STP) and Cu (~ 10−5).
Answer:
Susceptibility is χ = M/H, where M is the magnetic moment per unit volume. For similar atoms, M per unit volume is proportional to the number of atoms (or molecules) per unit volume, which is proportional to the mass density. So χ ∝ density.
Density of N2 at STP: \( \rho_{N_2} = \dfrac{28\ \text{g}}{22400\ \text{cm}^3} = 1.25\times10^{-3}\ \text{g cm}^{-3} \). Density of copper: \( \rho_{Cu} \approx 9\ \text{g cm}^{-3} \).
\( \dfrac{\rho_{N_2}}{\rho_{Cu}} = \dfrac{1.25\times10^{-3}}{9} \approx 1.4\times10^{-4} \).
Ratio of the given susceptibilities: \( \dfrac{\chi_{N_2}}{\chi_{Cu}} = \dfrac{5\times10^{-9}}{10^{-5}} = 5\times10^{-4} \).
The two ratios are of the same order (10−4). The difference of about 104 between the susceptibilities of nitrogen gas and copper is therefore explained by the difference in the number of atoms per unit volume (the gas is far less dense than the solid).
In simple words: Nitrogen gas at STP is about ten thousand times less dense than copper, so it has about ten thousand times smaller diamagnetic susceptibility.
Teacher's Note:
1. The same idea explains why gases are almost non-magnetic compared with solids.
2. Counting atoms per unit volume (3 × 10−4 for N2 molecules relative to Cu atoms) gives an even closer match.
Examination Note: State χ ∝ density, compute both densities with units, and compare the ratios. Concluding that they agree in order of magnitude is the needed final statement.
Question 14. From the molecular viewpoint, discuss the temperature dependence of susceptibility for diamagnetism, paramagnetism and ferromagnetism.
Answer:
Diamagnetism: it arises from the orbital motion of electrons, which develops a moment opposite to the applied field in every atom. This effect does not depend on the thermal motion, so the susceptibility of a diamagnetic material is almost independent of temperature.
Paramagnetism: atoms have permanent moments, which the applied field tries to align. Thermal agitation disturbs the alignment. As the temperature rises, the alignment decreases and the susceptibility falls, following Curie's law \( \chi = \dfrac{C}{T} \).
Ferromagnetism: atoms in domains are aligned by strong mutual interaction. As temperature rises, the alignment is destroyed and the susceptibility decreases; above the Curie temperature Tc the material becomes paramagnetic, and \( \chi = \dfrac{C}{T - T_c} \) (Curie–Weiss law).
In simple words: Only diamagnetism does not care about temperature; in both paramagnets and ferromagnets, heating disturbs the alignment of atomic moments and lowers the susceptibility.
Teacher's Note:
1. Diamagnetic susceptibility is negative and very small; paramagnetic is small and positive; ferromagnetic is large and positive.
2. Ferromagnetism disappears at the Curie temperature.
Examination Note: Give one line for each type, naming the cause (orbital motion or aligned moments) and the trend with temperature. Writing the Curie and Curie–Weiss laws gains marks.
Question 15. A ball of superconducting material is dipped in liquid nitrogen and placed near a bar magnet. (i) In which direction will it move? (ii) What will be the direction of its magnetic moment?
Answer:
(i) A superconducting material is a perfect diamagnetic substance (χ = −1). Cooled in liquid nitrogen it behaves as a diamagnetic material. When placed near a bar magnet it is magnetised in the opposite sense, so it is repelled: the ball moves away from the magnet.
(ii) The induced magnetic moment of the ball is opposite to the direction of the magnetic field of the bar magnet at the position of the ball.
In simple words: A diamagnetic or superconducting ball is pushed away from a magnet and its induced moment points against the magnet's field.
Teacher's Note:
1. Diamagnetic materials move from a stronger to a weaker field region.
2. This opposition to the field is also the reason a magnet can float over a superconductor.
Examination Note: State both results explicitly: repelled, and moment opposite to the field. The reason given is that the material is diamagnetic.
Short Answer Type Questions
Question 16. Verify the Gauss's law for magnetic field of a point dipole of dipole moment m at the origin for the surface which is a sphere of radius R.
Answer:
We must show that \( \oint \mathbf B \cdot d\mathbf S = 0 \) over the sphere. Take the dipole moment m along the z-axis and a point P on the sphere at polar angle θ from the axis (distance R from the origin).
The field of a point dipole has a radial and a tangential component: \( B_r = \dfrac{\mu_0}{4\pi}\dfrac{2m\cos\theta}{R^3} \), \( B_\theta = \dfrac{\mu_0}{4\pi}\dfrac{m\sin\theta}{R^3} \).
The tangential component lies in the surface and gives no flux. A surface element on the sphere is \( dS = R^2 \sin\theta\, d\theta\, d\phi \) along the outward radius.
\[ \oint \mathbf B\cdot d\mathbf S = \int_0^{2\pi} d\phi \int_0^{\pi} \dfrac{\mu_0}{4\pi}\dfrac{2m\cos\theta}{R^3}\, R^2\sin\theta\, d\theta = \dfrac{\mu_0 m}{2\pi R}\,(2\pi) \left[\dfrac{\sin^2\theta}{2}\right]_0^{\pi} = 0 \]
The flux through the sphere is zero, which verifies Gauss's law for magnetism: the flux entering the surface in one hemisphere equals the flux leaving in the other.
In simple words: Whatever flux of a dipole's field goes out through one half of the sphere comes back in through the other half, so the net flux is zero.
Teacher's Note:
1. The integral of sin θ cos θ from 0 to π vanishes because the northern and southern halves cancel.
2. Gauss's law for magnetism holds for any closed surface because magnetic monopoles do not exist.
Examination Note: Write both components of the dipole field, use the surface element R² sin θ dθ dφ and take the limits θ from 0 to π and φ from 0 to 2π. Mistaking the limits is the usual slip.
Answer:
The system stays at rest in a slowly varying field, whatever the field is, so the net force and the net torque on it must be zero. The torque is \( \boldsymbol\tau = \mathbf m_{net}\times\mathbf B \), which vanishes for every B only if the net magnetic moment is zero: \( \mathbf m_1 + \mathbf m_2 + \mathbf m_3 = 0 \).
Three magnets of equal strength whose vector sum is zero must have moments 120° apart (they form an equilateral triangle when placed head to tail).
Given N at the top, the other two magnets must point with their north poles at the two lower ends. Hence the upper ends of the remaining two magnets are south poles, and the lower ends (left and right) are north poles.
In simple words: Three equal magnets cancel each other's moment only when their north poles are 120° apart, so the two lower ends are north poles.
Teacher's Note:
1. Equal vectors at 120° to each other add up to zero.
2. Zero net moment means no torque in any field.
Examination Note: Say 'net moment must be zero' and justify the 120° arrangement with the vector triangle; then label the figure.
Question 18. Suppose we want to verify the analogy between electrostatic and magnetostatic by an explicit experiment. Consider the motion of (i) electric dipole p in an electrostatic field E and (ii) magnetic dipole M in a magnetic field B. Write down a set of conditions on E, B, p, M so that the two motions are verified to be identical. (Assume identical initial conditions.)
Answer:
Torque on an electric dipole: \( \boldsymbol\tau = \mathbf p \times \mathbf E \), magnitude \( pE\sin\theta \). Torque on a magnetic dipole: \( \boldsymbol\tau = \mathbf M \times \mathbf B \), magnitude \( MB\sin\theta \).
For the same initial angle θ and the same moment of inertia, the motions are identical when the torques are equal at every instant: \( pE = MB \).
Choose the fields proportional: \( \mathbf E = c\,\mathbf B \) (c is a constant with the dimensions of velocity, m/s, at every point). Then \( p\,cB = MB \), i.e. \( p = \dfrac{M}{c} \).
Conditions: E = cB at every point and p = M/c, with the same moment of inertia and initial conditions. (With these the forces in non-uniform fields, \( (\mathbf p\cdot\nabla)\mathbf E \) and \( \nabla(\mathbf M\cdot\mathbf B) \), also correspond.)
In simple words: If the electric field is made c times the magnetic field and the electric dipole is made 1/c times the magnetic dipole, the electric dipole moves just like the magnetic one.
Teacher's Note:
1. The constant c has the unit of speed because E/B is in m/s.
2. Equal torques and equal moments of inertia give equal angular motion.
Examination Note: State clearly the two conditions, E = cB and p = M/c, and mention that the moments of inertia must also be the same.
Question 19. A bar magnet of magnetic moment M and moment of inertia I (about centre, perpendicular to length) is cut into two equal pieces, perpendicular to length. Let T be the period of oscillations of the original magnet about an axis through the mid-point, perpendicular to length, in a magnetic field B. What would be the similar period T′ for each piece?
Answer:
For the original magnet: \( T = 2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{I}{MB}} \), with \( I = \dfrac{m l^2}{12} \) (m = mass, l = length).
Each piece has mass m/2 and length l/2: \( I' = \dfrac{(m/2)(l/2)^2}{12} = \dfrac{1}{8}\cdot\dfrac{m l^2}{12} = \dfrac{I}{8} \).
The magnetic moment is halved (pole strength is unchanged, the distance between the poles is halved): \( M' = \dfrac{M}{2} \).
\[ T' = 2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{I/8}{(M/2)B}} = 2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{I}{4MB}} = \dfrac{T}{2} \]
T′ = T/2
In simple words: Cutting the magnet in two halves its magnetic moment but makes its moment of inertia one-eighth, so the oscillation is twice as fast.
Teacher's Note:
1. Moment of inertia goes as mass × length², so halving both gives 1/8.
2. Pole strength stays the same; only the separation between the poles halves.
Examination Note: Compute I′ and M′ separately and substitute; check that the final factor is √(2/8) = 1/2.
Question 20. Use (i) the Ampere's law for H and (ii) continuity of lines of B, to conclude that inside a bar magnet, (a) lines of H run from the N-pole to S-pole, while (b) lines of B must run from the S-pole to N-pole.
Answer:
(b) Lines of B: the lines of B are continuous closed loops. Outside the bar magnet they run from the N-pole to the S-pole. To form closed loops, inside the magnet they must run from the S-pole to the N-pole.
(a) Lines of H: there is no free current, so by Ampere's law \( \oint \mathbf H\cdot d\mathbf l = 0 \) for any closed loop. Take a loop that goes from S to N inside the magnet (path 1) and returns from N to S outside (path 2).
Outside the magnet \( \mathbf H = \mathbf B/\mu_0 \) points along the lines from N to S, so on the return path \( \int_{2} \mathbf H\cdot d\mathbf l > 0 \).
Since the total is zero, \( \int_{1} \mathbf H\cdot d\mathbf l = -\int_{2}\mathbf H\cdot d\mathbf l < 0 \). Thus, along the path from S to N inside the magnet, H has a component opposite to the path, i.e. H points from the N-pole to the S-pole inside the magnet.
So inside a bar magnet H runs from N to S while B runs from S to N.
In simple words: Because B lines are closed, they go S to N inside a magnet; because the total of H·dl around a loop is zero, H must go the opposite way, N to S.
Teacher's Note:
1. Inside a magnet B and H are opposite in direction: B = μ0(H + M), and M (which points S to N) is larger than H.
2. Outside the magnet B and H are in the same direction.
Examination Note: Present the argument in two parts: (b) from closed B-lines, (a) from ∮H·dl = 0 using a loop partly inside and partly outside the magnet.
Long Answer Type Questions
(i) the z-axis from z = a > 0 to z = R, (ii) along the quarter circle of radius R and centre at the origin in the first quadrant of xz-plane, (iii) along the x-axis from x = R to x = a, and (iv) along the quarter circle of radius a and centre at the origin in the first quadrant of xz-plane.
Answer:
On the z-axis (axial line of the dipole) the field is \( B = \dfrac{\mu_0}{4\pi}\dfrac{2M}{z^3} = \dfrac{\mu_0 M}{2\pi z^3} \), along +z.
(i) P to Q along the z-axis (z = a to z = R): \( \int \mathbf B\cdot d\mathbf l = \int_a^R \dfrac{\mu_0 M}{2\pi z^3}dz = \dfrac{\mu_0 M}{2\pi}\left[-\dfrac{1}{2z^2}\right]_a^R = \dfrac{\mu_0 M}{4\pi}\left(\dfrac{1}{a^2} - \dfrac{1}{R^2}\right) \).
(ii) Arc Q to S of radius R (θ from 0 to π/2): at a point of the arc the tangential component is \( B_\theta = \dfrac{\mu_0}{4\pi}\dfrac{M\sin\theta}{R^3} \) and the radial component does no work. With \( dl = R\,d\theta \): \( \int \mathbf B\cdot d\mathbf l = \int_0^{\pi/2}\dfrac{\mu_0 M\sin\theta}{4\pi R^3}R\,d\theta = \dfrac{\mu_0 M}{4\pi R^2}\left[-\cos\theta\right]_0^{\pi/2} = \dfrac{\mu_0 M}{4\pi R^2} \).
(iii) S to T along the x-axis (x = R to x = a): points on the x-axis lie on the equatorial line, where the field is \( \dfrac{\mu_0 M}{4\pi x^3} \) along −z, perpendicular to the path. So \( \int \mathbf B\cdot d\mathbf l = 0 \).
(iv) Arc T to P of radius a (θ from π/2 to 0): the same integrand with the limits reversed: \( \int_{\pi/2}^{0}\dfrac{\mu_0 M\sin\theta}{4\pi a^3}\,a\,d\theta = -\dfrac{\mu_0 M}{4\pi a^2} \).
Total: \( \oint \mathbf B\cdot d\mathbf l = \dfrac{\mu_0 M}{4\pi}\left(\dfrac{1}{a^2}-\dfrac{1}{R^2}\right) + \dfrac{\mu_0 M}{4\pi R^2} + 0 - \dfrac{\mu_0 M}{4\pi a^2} = 0 \).
No current passes through the closed curve C, so Ampere's law \( \oint \mathbf B\cdot d\mathbf l = \mu_0 I_{en} = 0 \) is verified.
In simple words: The four pieces of the loop integral cancel exactly, as they must, because the loop encloses no current.
Teacher's Note:
1. On the axis the angle between B and dl is 0°; on the equator it is 90°, so the line integral vanishes on that part.
2. Going around the loop in reverse direction on the inner arc gives the negative of the integral on the outer arc's matching form.
Examination Note: Break the loop into four parts and name the dipole-field component used in each part. Check that the four results add to zero.
Question 22. What are the dimensions of χ, the magnetic susceptibility? Consider an H-atom. Give an expression for χ, up to a constant, by constructing a quantity of dimensions of χ, out of parameters of the atom e, m, v, R and μ0. Here, m is the electronic mass, v is electronic velocity, R is Bohr radius. Estimate the number so obtained and compare with the value of |χ| ~ 10−5 for many solid materials.
Answer:
χ = M/H is the ratio of two quantities (magnetisation and magnetising field) with the same units (A/m), so χ is dimensionless.
From the Biot–Savart law \( B = \dfrac{\mu_0 I\,dl}{4\pi r^2} \): \( [\mu_0] = \dfrac{[B][L^2]}{[I\,dl]} = \dfrac{(M T^{-1}Q^{-1})L^2}{(QT^{-1})L} = [M L Q^{-2}] \), where Q is charge.
Try \( \chi = \mu_0\, e^{2}\, m^{a} v^{b} R^{c} \), with \( [e^2] = Q^2 \). The charge cancels in \( \mu_0 e^2 \): \( [\mu_0 e^2] = [ML] \).
Mass: \( 1 + a = 0 \Rightarrow a = -1 \). Time: \( -b = 0 \Rightarrow b = 0 \). Length: \( 1 + b + c = 0 \Rightarrow c = -1 \).
\( \chi \sim \dfrac{\mu_0 e^2}{mR} \) (the velocity v cannot appear).
Numerically (taking R ≈ 10−10 m): \( \chi \sim \dfrac{(4\pi\times10^{-7})(1.6\times10^{-19})^2}{(9.1\times10^{-31})(10^{-10})} \approx 3.5\times10^{-4} \).
This is about 30 times larger than the typical measured |χ| ~ 10−5 of solids, so it gives the right order of magnitude for a single atom; the observed value is smaller because the atomic effects partly cancel and the atoms in a solid are shared.
In simple words: Susceptibility has no dimensions; combining μ0, e, m and R in the only dimensionless way gives μ0e²/(mR), about 10−4, which is close to the observed 10−5.
Teacher's Note:
1. The charge dimension cancels only in the combination μ0e².
2. Since no time dimension is available, the velocity v does not enter the expression.
Examination Note: Show the dimensional equations for M, L and T separately and solve for the powers; check the estimate with SI values.
Question 23. Assume the dipole model for the earth's magnetic field B, which is given by BV = vertical component of the magnetic field = \( \dfrac{\mu_0}{4\pi}\dfrac{2m\cos\theta}{r^3} \) and BH = horizontal component of the magnetic field = \( \dfrac{\mu_0}{4\pi}\dfrac{m\sin\theta}{r^3} \), with θ = 90° − latitude as measured from the magnetic equator. Find the loci of points for which (a) |B| is minimum, (b) dip angle is zero and (c) dip angle is 45°.
Answer:
(a) \( |B| = \sqrt{B_V^2 + B_H^2} = \dfrac{\mu_0}{4\pi}\dfrac{m}{r^3}\sqrt{4\cos^2\theta + \sin^2\theta} = \dfrac{\mu_0 m}{4\pi r^3}\sqrt{1 + 3\cos^2\theta} \).
For a given r, |B| is least when cos θ = 0, i.e. θ = 90°. The locus of minimum |B| is the magnetic equator, where \( |B| = \mu_0 m/4\pi r^3 \).
(b) Dip angle: \( \tan\delta = \dfrac{B_V}{B_H} = 2\cot\theta \). For δ = 0 we need cot θ = 0, i.e. θ = 90°. The locus is again the magnetic equator.
(c) For a dip of 45° (or −45°), \( \tan\delta = \pm 1 \), so \( 2\cot\theta = \pm 1 \Rightarrow \tan\theta = \pm 2 \). Thus \( \theta = \tan^{-1}2 \approx 63.4^\circ \) (and \( 180^\circ - 63.4^\circ = 116.6^\circ \) in the other hemisphere).
The locus is the pair of circles on the sphere at angle tan−1 2 from the dipole axis, that is at about 26.6° north and south of the magnetic equator.
In simple words: The field strength and the dip are both least on the magnetic equator, and the dip is 45° on the circles at about 26.6° latitude on either side of it.
Teacher's Note:
1. Check: at the equator |B| = μ0m/4πr³; at the poles it is twice as large.
2. tan δ = 2 tan (latitude) is a standard result of the dipole model.
Examination Note: Start from the components, write |B| = (μ0m/4πr³)√(1 + 3cos²θ) and tan δ = 2 cot θ, and read off all three loci from these two lines.
Question 24. Consider the plane S formed by the dipole axis and the axis of the earth. Let P be a point on the magnetic equator and in S. Let Q be the point of intersection of the geographical and magnetic equators. Obtain the declination and dip angles at P and Q.
Answer:
At P: P lies in the plane S, which contains both the geographic axis and the magnetic axis. So the magnetic meridian and the geographic meridian coincide at P: declination = 0. P is on the magnetic equator, so the field is horizontal: dip = 0.
At Q: Q is on the magnetic equator, so dip = 0. Q is also on the geographic equator, 90° of longitude away from the plane S. The magnetic axis is tilted by 11.3° from the geographic axis, so at Q the compass needle (horizontal field) is turned by the full tilt: declination = 11.3° (towards the west at one of the two such points and towards the east at the other).
In simple words: At P the two meridians coincide, so the declination is zero; at Q the full tilt of the magnetic axis shows up as a declination of 11.3°; the dip is zero at both points because both lie on the magnetic equator.
Teacher's Note:
1. Declination is zero on the plane through both axes and greatest on the points 90° away from it.
2. Dip is zero at every point on the magnetic equator.
Examination Note: Give each of the four values, declination and dip at P and at Q, in a short table or line each, with a one-line reason.
Question 25. There are two current carrying planar coils made each from identical wires of length L. C1 is circular (radius R) and C2 is square (side a). They are so constructed that they have the same frequency of oscillation when they are placed in the same uniform B and carry the same current. Find a in terms of R.
Answer:
Both coils are made from wire of the same length L, so they have the same mass M and carry the same current I. The circular coil has \( n_1 = \dfrac{L}{2\pi R} \) turns and the square coil has \( n_2 = \dfrac{L}{4a} \) turns.
Magnetic moments: \( m_1 = n_1 I \pi R^2 = \dfrac{LIR}{2} \) and \( m_2 = n_2 I a^2 = \dfrac{LIa}{4} \).
Moments of inertia about a diameter (an axis in the plane through the centre): circular coil \( I_1 = \dfrac{MR^2}{2} \); square coil (wire frame) \( I_2 = \dfrac{Ma^2}{6} \).
Frequency \( f = \dfrac{1}{2\pi}\sqrt{\dfrac{mB}{I}} \). Equal frequencies need \( \dfrac{I_1}{m_1} = \dfrac{I_2}{m_2} \):
\[ \dfrac{MR^2/2}{LIR/2} = \dfrac{Ma^2/6}{LIa/4} \Rightarrow \dfrac{R}{1} = \dfrac{2a}{3} \]
a = 3R/2 = 1.5 R
In simple words: To oscillate at the same rate, the square coil's side must be one and a half times the radius of the circular coil.
Teacher's Note:
1. The frequency of small oscillations of a magnetic moment in a field is (1/2π)√(mB/I).
2. For a wire frame, any in-plane axis through the centre of a square gives I = Ma²/6, as the square has four-fold symmetry.
Examination Note: List m and I for both coils, equate I/m and solve. Take care to use the moment of inertia of a wire frame, not of a plate.