These NCERT Exemplar solutions for Class 12 Physics Chapter 3, Current Electricity, give step-by-step answers to all 31 questions: 6 MCQs, 5 multiple-correct MCQs, 10 very short, 6 short and 4 long answer questions. They cover current density and drift velocity, resistivity and its temperature dependence, combination of cells and resistors, Kirchhoff's rules, the Wheatstone bridge, the meter bridge and the potentiometer. Each answer is followed by a short Teacher's Note to build understanding and an Examination Note on how to present the answer for better marks.
Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)
(a) source of emf
(b) electric field produced by charges accumulated on the surface of wire
(c) the charges just behind a given segment of wire which push them just the right way by repulsion
(d) the charges ahead
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) electric field produced by charges accumulated on the surface of wire
Explanation:
1. Current density \( \vec j = \sigma \vec E \) points along the electric field inside the wire.
2. When the wire bends, the field inside it must bend too, so that it stays along the wire at every point.
3. This field is set up by the charges that accumulate on the surface of the wire (and at its bends). They adjust themselves so that the field always points along the wire, making the current direction follow the wire.
Teacher's Note:
1. The battery only maintains the potential difference; it cannot decide the direction of the field at each bend. Surface charges do that job.
2. Because the current has the same value in every cross-section (steady state), only the direction of j changes along the bend.
Examination Note: Name the agent in one line: surface charges produce an electric field that is always tangential to the wire. Do not choose option (a); a source of emf drives the current but does not steer it.
(a) Two equivalent emf εeq of the two cells is between ε1 and ε2, i.e., ε1 < εeq < ε2
(b) The equivalent emf εeq is smaller than ε1
(c) The εeq is given by εeq = ε1 + ε2 always
(d) εeq is independent of internal resistances r1 and r2
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) Two equivalent emf εeq of the two cells is between ε1 and ε2, i.e., ε1 < εeq < ε2
Explanation:
1. For two cells in parallel (same polarity): \( \varepsilon_{eq} = \dfrac{\varepsilon_1 r_2 + \varepsilon_2 r_1}{r_1 + r_2} \).
2. This is a weighted average of ε1 and ε2 with positive weights \( r_2 \) and \( r_1 \). A weighted average always lies between the two values, so \( \varepsilon_1 < \varepsilon_{eq} < \varepsilon_2 \).
3. The result depends on r1 and r2, so (d) is wrong; the emfs do not add in parallel, so (c) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Cells in parallel do not add emf; the stronger cell partly charges the weaker one, so the combined emf is in between.
2. If r1 = r2, the equivalent emf is simply the average of the two emfs.
Examination Note: Quote the parallel-combination formula and state that it is a weighted mean of the two emfs. A one-line reason is enough for a 1-mark MCQ.
(a) He should measure l1 more accurately
(b) He should change S to 1000 Ω and repeat the experiment
(c) He should change S to 3 Ω and repeat the experiment
(d) He should give up hope of a more accurate measurement with a meter bridge
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (c) He should change S to 3 Ω and repeat the experiment
Explanation:
1. At the balance point \( \dfrac{R}{S} = \dfrac{l_1}{100 - l_1} = \dfrac{2.9}{97.1} \approx \dfrac{1}{33} \), so R ≈ S/33 ≈ 3 Ω.
2. A meter bridge is most accurate when the null point is near the middle of the wire (l1 close to 50 cm), which needs R and S to be nearly equal.
3. So S should be reduced to about 3 Ω and the experiment repeated. Increasing S to 1000 Ω would push the null point even closer to the end.
Teacher's Note:
1. Near the ends of the wire a small error in length produces a large percentage error in R.
2. First do a rough trial, then choose S close to the rough value of R.
Examination Note: Say that the null point should lie near the 50 cm mark and S should be comparable to R. Estimating R ≈ 3 Ω from the first trial earns the explanation mark.
(a) The battery that runs the potentiometer should have voltage of 8 V
(b) The battery of potentiometer can have a voltage of 15 V and R adjusted so that the potential drop across the wire slightly exceeds 10 V
(c) The first portion of 50 cm of wire itself should have a potential drop of 10 V
(d) Potentiometer is usually used for comparing resistances and not voltages
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) The battery of potentiometer can have a voltage of 15 V and R adjusted so that the potential drop across the wire slightly exceeds 10 V
Explanation:
1. A potentiometer can balance a cell only if the potential drop across the whole wire is greater than the emf of that cell.
2. Here the larger emf is 10 V, so the driver battery must exceed 10 V (8 V is not enough). With a 15 V battery and a rheostat adjusted to make the drop across the wire slightly more than 10 V, both cells can be balanced.
3. A 10 V drop across only the first 50 cm would give a very large potential gradient and a poor accuracy, and a potentiometer is used for comparing emfs, not resistances.
Teacher's Note:
1. The wire should carry a drop just above the larger emf, so that the null point lies at a long length and the percentage error is small.
2. The rheostat R in the driver circuit is used to fix the potential gradient.
Examination Note: State the condition: potential drop across the potentiometer wire must be greater than the emf to be measured. This single condition rejects options (a), (c) and (d).
(a) maximum when the battery is connected across 1 cm × \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) cm faces
(b) maximum when the battery is connected across 10 cm × 1 cm faces
(c) maximum when the battery is connected across 10 cm × \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) cm faces
(d) same irrespective of the three faces
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) maximum when the battery is connected across 1 cm × \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) cm faces
Explanation:
1. Resistance \( R = \rho \dfrac{l}{A} \): it is largest when the length l is greatest and the area A is smallest.
2. Connecting across the 1 cm × ½ cm faces makes the current flow along the full 10 cm length through the smallest area, \( A = 0.5\ \text{cm}^2 \).
3. Check: \( R_a = \rho\dfrac{10}{0.5} = 20\rho,\ R_b = \rho\dfrac{0.5}{10} = 0.05\rho,\ R_c = \rho\dfrac{1}{5} = 0.2\rho \) (in cm units). Hence (a) gives the maximum.
Teacher's Note:
1. The length is always measured between the two faces joined to the battery, and the area is that of the face.
2. The same rod can therefore have resistances that differ by a factor of 400.
Examination Note: Compute R for each pair of faces; the numbers (20ρ, 0.05ρ, 0.2ρ) make the choice unarguable.
(a) Drift velocity alone
(b) Thermal velocity alone
(c) Both drift velocity and thermal velocity
(d) Neither drift nor thermal velocity
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) Drift velocity alone
Explanation:
1. The current in a conductor is \( I = n e A v_d \), where vd is the drift velocity.
2. So the current is proportional to the drift velocity alone.
3. The thermal velocity is random in direction and averages to zero over all electrons, so it contributes no net current.
Teacher's Note:
1. Thermal speeds are about 105 m/s but are random; drift speeds are only about 10−4 m/s but are directed.
2. The directed part of the motion is what carries net charge across a cross-section.
Examination Note: Write I = neAvd and add one sentence that thermal motion averages to zero.
Multiple Choice Questions (More Than One Option)
(a) conservation of current density vector
(b) conservation of charge
(c) the fact that the momentum with which a charged particle approaches a junction is unchanged (as a vector) as the charged particle leaves the junction
(d) the fact that there is no accumulation of charges at a junction
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) conservation of charge, (d) the fact that there is no accumulation of charges at a junction
Explanation:
1. The junction rule states that the algebraic sum of the currents meeting at a junction is zero.
2. In a steady state, charge cannot be created or destroyed, nor can it pile up at a junction; whatever charge flows in per second flows out. So it expresses conservation of charge (b) and the absence of charge accumulation at the junction (d).
3. Current density as a vector is not conserved at a junction because the directions change, and momentum of the charge carriers is not conserved either, so (a) and (c) are wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Think of water pipes meeting at a joint: the water entering per second equals the water leaving per second.
2. The loop rule, in contrast, expresses conservation of energy.
Examination Note: Link the junction rule to conservation of charge in a single sentence. Examiners reward the pair: junction rule gives charge conservation, loop rule gives energy conservation.
(a) Potential drop across AB is nearly constant as R′ is varied
(b) Current through R′ is nearly a constant as R′ is varied
(c) Current I depends sensitively on R′
(d) \( I \geq \dfrac{V}{r+R} \) always
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) Potential drop across AB is nearly constant as R′ is varied, (d) \( I \geq \dfrac{V}{r+R} \) always
Explanation:
1. R′ is in parallel with R, so \( R_{AB} = \dfrac{RR'}{R+R'} \) is always less than R.
2. Hence the total current \( I = \dfrac{V}{r + R_{AB}} \geq \dfrac{V}{r+R} \). This proves (d).
3. Since R′ ≥ R0 >> R, \( R_{AB} \approx R \) for every R′. The current and the p.d. across AB, \( V_{AB} = V - Ir \approx V \) (as r << R), hardly change. This proves (a).
4. The current through R′ is \( V_{AB}/R' \), which falls from \( V/R_0 \) to 0 as R′ grows, so (b) is wrong. Since RAB ≈ R, I does not depend sensitively on R′, so (c) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. A very large resistance in parallel with a small one hardly changes the combination.
2. The equivalent resistance of a parallel combination is smaller than the smallest resistor present.
Examination Note: Use the fact that RAB < R to justify (d), and r << R << R0 to justify (a). Reject (b) and (c) with a reason each.
(a) number of charge carriers can change with temperature T
(b) time interval between two successive collisions can depend on T
(c) length of material can be a function of T
(d) mass of carriers is a function of T
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) number of charge carriers can change with temperature T, (b) time interval between two successive collisions can depend on T
Explanation:
1. Resistivity is \( \rho = \dfrac{m}{n e^2 \tau} \), where n is the number density of carriers and τ is the time between successive collisions.
2. In semiconductors and insulators n rises rapidly with temperature, so ρ falls. In metals n is nearly constant, but τ decreases as T increases, so ρ rises.
3. Length change with T is tiny and is not part of ρ; the mass of the carriers does not depend on T. So only (a) and (b).
Teacher's Note:
1. Metals: ρ increases with T because of more frequent collisions. Semiconductors: ρ decreases with T because more carriers are freed.
2. The formula ρ = m/ne²τ tells you exactly which quantities can matter.
Examination Note: Begin with ρ = m/(ne²τ) and tie each of n and τ to temperature. This takes two lines and covers all the types of materials.
(a) The errors of measurement of the two students are the same
(b) Errors of measurement do depend on the accuracy with which R2 and R1 can be measured
(c) If the student uses large values of R2 and R1, the currents through the arms will be feeble. This will make determination of null point accurately more difficult
(d) Wheatstone bridge is a very accurate instrument and has no errors of measurement
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (b) Errors of measurement do depend on the accuracy with which R2 and R1 can be measured, (c) If the student uses large values of R2 and R1, the currents through the arms will be feeble. This will make determination of null point accurately more difficult
Explanation:
1. At balance \( R = \dfrac{R_2}{R_1}R_3 \). For both students \( R = 2 \times 5 = 10\ \Omega \), so the result is the same, but their errors need not be.
2. The error in R depends on the percentage errors in R2, R1 and R3, i.e. on how accurately these can be measured. So (b) is correct and (a) is wrong.
3. With R2 = 1000 Ω and R1 = 500 Ω the current in the arms is very small, so the galvanometer deflection near balance is feeble and the null point is hard to locate accurately. So (c) is correct.
4. No instrument is free from error, so (d) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. A Wheatstone bridge is most sensitive when all four arms have comparable resistances.
2. Same ratio does not mean same accuracy: sensitivity also depends on the current.
Examination Note: Show that both students get 10 Ω and then explain why the errors can still differ: instrument accuracy and feeble current. Always reject the claim that a method is error-free.
(a) The meter bridge can have no other neutral point for this set of resistances
(b) When the jockey contacts a point on the meter wire to the left of D, current flows to B from the wire
(c) When the jockey contacts a point on the meter wire to the right of D, current flows from B to the wire through the galvanometer
(d) When R is increased, the neutral point shifts to the left
Show Answer & Explanation
Answer: (a) The meter bridge can have no other neutral point for this set of resistances, (b) When the jockey contacts a point on the meter wire to the left of D, current flows to B from the wire, (c) When the jockey contacts a point on the meter wire to the right of D, current flows from B to the wire through the galvanometer
Explanation:
1. The wire has uniform resistance, so the potential falls steadily from A to C. Point B has one fixed potential, and only one point on the wire can have that same potential. So there is no other neutral point (a).
2. Take A as the end at the higher potential. To the right of D the wire point is at a lower potential than B, so current flows from B to the wire through the galvanometer (c). To the left of D the wire point is at a higher potential than B, so current flows into B from the wire (b).
3. At balance \( \dfrac{R}{S} = \dfrac{l_1}{100 - l_1} \). If R is increased, l1 increases, so the neutral point shifts to the right, not to the left. So (d) is wrong.
Teacher's Note:
1. Statements (b) and (c) always go together: they describe the same fact for the two sides of D.
2. Potential varies uniformly along the wire, which is why the neutral point is unique.
Examination Note: Use the idea of uniform potential fall along the wire to settle (a), (b) and (c), and use R/S = l1/(100 − l1) to reject (d).
Very Short Answer Type Questions
Question 12. Is the motion of a charge across a junction momentum conserving? Why or why not?
Answer:
No, it is not momentum conserving.
The drift velocity of electrons in a wire is fixed by the electric field, \( v_d = \dfrac{eE\tau}{m} \), and not by conservation of momentum.
At a junction the charges that arrive pile up on the surface and produce an extra electric field. This field changes the direction of the electrons, and the electrons also collide with the ions of the lattice, which take up momentum. So the momentum of the moving charge is not conserved.
In simple words: At a junction, surface charges and the lattice change the direction of the charge carriers, so their momentum is not conserved.
Teacher's Note:
1. Momentum conservation applies to an isolated system; here the electrons exchange momentum with the lattice and with the field.
2. Charge, not momentum, is what is conserved at a junction.
Examination Note: Give a clear No, followed by two reasons: extra field due to accumulated charges and collisions with the lattice.
Question 13. The relaxation time τ is nearly independent of applied E field whereas it changes significantly with temperature T. First fact is (in part) responsible for Ohm's law whereas the second fact leads to variation of ρ with temperature. Elaborate why.
Answer:
Resistivity is \( \rho = \dfrac{m}{n e^2 \tau} \).
Independence from E (Ohm's law): the drift speed of electrons (about 1 mm/s) is tiny compared with their random thermal speed (about 105 m/s). Applying or changing the field alters the electron speed only by a negligible fraction, so the time between collisions τ stays the same. Hence ρ is constant at a given temperature, i.e. \( V \propto I \) (Ohm's law).
Dependence on T: a change of temperature changes the thermal speed and the vibration of the ions considerably, which changes the collision frequency. In a metal, as T increases, collisions become more frequent, τ decreases, and so ρ = m/(ne²τ) increases.
In simple words: The electric field hardly changes τ, so a metal obeys Ohm's law; the temperature changes τ a lot, so the resistivity depends on temperature.
Teacher's Note:
1. Compare the sizes: drift speed ~ 10−3 m/s, thermal speed ~ 105 m/s.
2. For metals ρ rises with T because τ falls; n stays almost constant.
Examination Note: Quote ρ = m/(neτ) with the correct e² and explain both facts in terms of τ. Marks are for linking each fact to the right consequence.
Question 14. What are the advantages of the null-point method in a Wheatstone bridge? What additional measurements would be required to calculate Runknown by any other method?
Answer:
Advantages of the null-point method:
1. At balance no current flows through the galvanometer, so the result does not depend on the resistance of the galvanometer or on the emf and internal resistance of the battery.
2. The galvanometer is used only to detect zero current, so it need not be calibrated; the method is simple and gives an accurate result from the balance condition \( \dfrac{P}{Q} = \dfrac{R}{S} \).
Other method: without balancing, the unknown resistance can be found by applying Kirchhoff's laws to the bridge. This needs the currents in all the arms and in the galvanometer, together with the resistance of the galvanometer and the emf (and internal resistance) of the battery, all measured accurately.
In simple words: In the null method the galvanometer only has to show 'no current', so many sources of error drop out; any other method needs several extra accurate measurements.
Teacher's Note:
1. The balance condition involves only the four resistances in the arms.
2. A deflection method needs a calibrated galvanometer; a null method does not.
Examination Note: Give two advantages and then list the extra quantities (currents, galvanometer resistance, emf and internal resistance). A short list scores the full marks.
Question 15. What is the advantage of using thick metallic strips to join wires in a potentiometer?
Answer:
A potentiometer has several long wires (for example, each of length 1 m) joined end to end. The joining strips are made thick, so their resistance is negligible.
As the strips drop practically no potential, the null-point length is read only along the straight wires and the potential drop is proportional to the length measured. The strips need not be counted in the length l, which makes the measurement easy and accurate.
In simple words: Thick strips have almost no resistance, so only the wire lengths matter for potential drop.
Teacher's Note:
1. Potential drop along a uniform wire is proportional to its length; a thick strip would break this proportionality if it had resistance.
2. The joining strips just provide a convenient way to fold the long wire into a compact board.
Examination Note: Write that the strips have negligible resistance, so no potential drop occurs across them and the length is measured on the wires only.
Question 16. For wiring in the home, one uses Cu wires or Al wires. What considerations are involved in this?
Answer:
The main considerations are:
1. Good conductivity (low resistivity): copper (ρ ≈ 1.7 × 10−8 Ω m) and aluminium (ρ ≈ 2.7 × 10−8 Ω m) both conduct well, so little power is lost as heat.
2. Cost and availability: both are abundant and much cheaper than silver, which conducts even better.
3. Practical properties: both are ductile and can be drawn into thin wires. Aluminium is lighter and cheaper but needs a thicker wire for the same resistance.
In simple words: Household wires are made of metals that conduct well, are cheap, easy to draw into wires and easily available.
Teacher's Note:
1. Silver is the best conductor but is too costly to use for wiring.
2. The resistance of a wire is R = ρl/A, so a metal with larger ρ needs a larger cross-section.
Examination Note: Mention conductivity and cost as the two main criteria; adding availability and ductility earns the extra mark.
Question 17. Why are alloys used for making standard resistance coils?
Answer:
Alloys such as manganin and constantan have a very small temperature coefficient of resistance. So the resistance of the coil stays almost constant even when the temperature changes slightly.
They also have a high resistivity. Since \( R = \rho \dfrac{l}{A} \), a coil of high resistance can be made from a short length of wire of a given cross-section.
In simple words: Alloys keep their resistance steady with temperature and offer a high resistance in a small length.
Teacher's Note:
1. A standard resistor must give the same value every time it is used.
2. Another useful property of such alloys is that they are not easily oxidised.
Examination Note: Give two reasons: small temperature coefficient and high resistivity.
Question 18. Power P is to be delivered to a device via transmission cables having resistance Rc. If V is the voltage across the device and I the current through it, find the power wasted and how it can be reduced.
Answer:
Current drawn by the device: \( I = \dfrac{P}{V} \).
Power wasted in the cables: \( P_{loss} = I^2 R_c = \dfrac{P^2 R_c}{V^2} \).
For a given P, the loss is proportional to 1/V². So the loss can be reduced by transmitting the power at a high voltage (and hence a low current), and by using cables of low resistance.
In simple words: A higher transmission voltage means a smaller current and hence much less heating loss in the cables.
Teacher's Note:
1. Doubling the voltage cuts the loss to one quarter.
2. This is the reason why power is transmitted at very high voltages and stepped down near the user.
Examination Note: State Ploss = I²Rc = P²Rc/V² and conclude that high V reduces the loss.
Answer:
Increasing R reduces the current in the main circuit, so the potential drop across wire AB falls. The potential gradient \( k \) (volt per unit length) along AB decreases.
At the balance point \( E = k l \). For a given emf E, a smaller k needs a larger length l.
The balance point J shifts towards B.
In simple words: A smaller potential gradient needs a longer length of wire to balance the same cell, so the null point moves towards B.
Teacher's Note:
1. Check with an extreme case: if R is very large, the current is almost zero and the wire has almost no gradient, so the balance point goes to the far end.
2. The rheostat R is used to set the potential gradient.
Examination Note: Link the chain: R up, current down, k down, l = E/k up. Four linked steps are what the examiner looks for.
(i) Which terminal, positive or negative, of the cell E1 is connected at X in case (i) and how is E1 related to E? (ii) Which terminal of the cell E1 is connected at X in case (ii)?
Answer:
(i) Take A as the end of the wire connected to the positive terminal of the driver cell, so that the potential rises from B towards A. The galvanometer circuit has the cell E1 and the part AJ of the wire in opposition if the positive terminal of E1 is joined to X (towards A). The net emf in that circuit is \( E_1 - V_{AJ} \).
As J moves from A towards B, VAJ increases, so the net emf and the deflection decrease. The deflection stays one-sided only if E1 is larger than the potential drop across the whole wire. So the positive terminal of E1 is connected at X, and E1 > E.
(ii) If the negative terminal of E1 is connected at X, the net emf is \( E_1 + V_{AJ} \), which increases as J moves away from A. This gives a deflection that increases as the jockey is moved towards B. So the negative terminal of E1 is connected at X.
In simple words: When the cell and the wire portion oppose each other the deflection falls as J moves; when they help each other it rises.
Teacher's Note:
1. Opposing emfs subtract, helping emfs add.
2. A one-sided deflection means the null point lies outside the wire.
Examination Note: State your assumption about which end of the wire is at the higher potential and then argue with 'net emf = E1 ∓ VAJ'.
Question 21. A cell of emf E and internal resistance r is connected across an external resistance R. Plot a graph showing the variation of potential difference across R versus R.
Answer:
Current in the circuit: \( I = \dfrac{E}{R + r} \). Potential difference across R:
\[ V = IR = \dfrac{E}{1 + \dfrac{r}{R}} \]
For R = 0, V = 0. As R increases, V rises, quickly at first and then slowly. For R >> r, V approaches E but never exceeds it. The graph is a curve that starts at the origin and flattens out towards the dashed line V = E.
In simple words: The p.d. across the external resistor grows with R and tends to the emf E for very large R.
Teacher's Note:
1. At R = r the voltage is exactly E/2.
2. When R is infinite (open circuit) the current is zero and the voltmeter reads E.
Examination Note: Label both axes, mark the asymptote V = E and start the curve from the origin. Do not draw the curve crossing the line V = E.
Short Answer Type Questions
Question 22. First a set of n equal resistors of R each are connected in series to a battery of emf E and internal resistance R. A current I is observed to flow. Then, the n resistors are connected in parallel to the same battery. It is observed that the current is increased 10 times. What is n?
Answer:
Series: total resistance \( R + nR \), so \( I = \dfrac{E}{R + nR} = \dfrac{E}{R(1+n)} \).
Parallel: the resistors give \( R/n \), so \( 10 I = \dfrac{E}{R + R/n} = \dfrac{E\,n}{R(n+1)} \).
Dividing: \( 10 = \dfrac{n/(n+1)}{1/(n+1)} = n \).
n = 10
In simple words: With the internal resistance equal to R, the ratio of the two currents works out to be n itself, so n is 10.
Teacher's Note:
1. Check: series current = E/(11R); parallel current = E/(R + 0.1R) = E/(1.1R) = 10 × E/(11R).
2. In a series combination the internal resistance adds to nR; in a parallel combination it adds to R/n.
Examination Note: Write both currents with the internal resistance included, divide them, and the (n + 1) cancels. A common slip is to ignore the internal resistance.
Question 23. Let there be n resistors R1 ... Rn with Rmax = max (R1 ... Rn) and Rmin = min (R1 ... Rn). Show that when they are connected in parallel, the resultant resistance RP < Rmin and when they are connected in series, the resultant resistance RS > Rmax. Interpret the result physically.
Answer:
Parallel: \( \dfrac{1}{R_P} = \dfrac{1}{R_1} + \dfrac{1}{R_2} + \dots + \dfrac{1}{R_n} \). Multiply both sides by Rmin:
\[ \dfrac{R_{min}}{R_P} = \dfrac{R_{min}}{R_1} + \dfrac{R_{min}}{R_2} + \dots + \dfrac{R_{min}}{R_n} \]
One of the terms on the right is \( R_{min}/R_{min} = 1 \) and all other terms are positive, so \( \dfrac{R_{min}}{R_P} > 1 \), i.e. RP < Rmin (for n ≥ 2).
Series: \( R_S = R_1 + R_2 + \dots + R_n \). One of the terms is Rmax and the others are positive, so RS > Rmax.
Physical interpretation: in a parallel combination, the branch of resistance Rmin alone would take a certain current from the battery. The other branches provide extra paths, so the total current is more than that, and hence the equivalent resistance is less than Rmin. In series, the current has to pass through Rmax and also through all the other resistors, so the opposition is more than that of Rmax alone.
In simple words: Adding paths side by side always makes it easier for current to flow (less resistance), while adding resistors one after another always makes it harder (more resistance).
Teacher's Note:
1. Parallel resistance is always smaller than the smallest resistor; series resistance is always larger than the largest.
2. Check with 2 Ω and 3 Ω: parallel 1.2 Ω (less than 2 Ω), series 5 Ω (more than 3 Ω).
Examination Note: Use the trick of multiplying by Rmin so that one term becomes exactly 1. State that n ≥ 2, otherwise the inequality becomes an equality.
Answer:
Total emf in the circuit (the cells are in opposition): \( 6 - 4 = 2\ \text{V} \), total resistance \( 2 + 8 = 10\ \Omega \).
Current: \( I = \dfrac{6-4}{2+8} = 0.2\ \text{A} \), flowing in the direction set by the larger emf E1.
E2 is being driven backwards by E1, so across the terminals of E2 (points A and B): \( V_B - V_A = E_2 + I r_2 = 4 + 0.2 \times 8 = 5.6\ \text{V} \).
Check using E1: \( V_B - V_A = E_1 - I r_1 = 6 - 0.2 \times 2 = 5.6\ \text{V} \).
The potential difference between A and B is 5.6 V (B is at the higher potential).
In simple words: The cell with the larger emf pushes the current through the weaker one, so the terminal voltage of the weaker cell is larger than its emf: 4 V + 1.6 V = 5.6 V.
Teacher's Note:
1. For a cell being charged, terminal voltage = emf + Ir; for a cell supplying current, terminal voltage = emf − Ir.
2. Doing the calculation through both cells and getting the same 5.6 V is a good check.
Examination Note: Show I first, then the terminal voltage of one cell, and verify with the other cell. Mixing up the sign of Ir is the usual slip.
Answer:
Total emf \( = E + E = 2E \); total resistance \( = R + r_1 + r_2 \). Current: \( I = \dfrac{2E}{R + r_1 + r_2} \).
Potential difference across the first cell: \( V_1 = E - I r_1 = E - \dfrac{2E r_1}{R + r_1 + r_2} \).
Put \( V_1 = 0 \): \( 1 = \dfrac{2 r_1}{R + r_1 + r_2} \Rightarrow R + r_1 + r_2 = 2 r_1 \).
R = r1 − r2 (possible only if r1 > r2).
In simple words: Choose the external resistance equal to the difference of the internal resistances, and the first cell's terminal voltage drops to zero.
Teacher's Note:
1. The terminal voltage is E − Ir, so it vanishes when the 'lost volts' Ir1 equal E.
2. The answer is meaningful only when r1 > r2, since R cannot be negative.
Examination Note: Write the terminal voltage V = E − Ir1 first and then put it equal to zero. Note the condition r1 > r2 to score the last mark.
Question 26. Two conductors are made of the same material and have the same length. Conductor A is a solid wire of diameter 1 mm. Conductor B is a hollow tube of outer diameter 2 mm and inner diameter 1 mm. Find the ratio of resistance RA to RB.
Answer:
Resistance \( R = \rho \dfrac{l}{A} \). Same ρ and l, so \( R \propto \dfrac{1}{A} \).
Area of A: \( \pi (0.5)^2 = 0.25\pi\ \text{mm}^2 \).
Area of B: \( \pi (1^2 - 0.5^2) = 0.75\pi\ \text{mm}^2 \).
\( \dfrac{R_A}{R_B} = \dfrac{A_B}{A_A} = \dfrac{0.75\pi}{0.25\pi} = 3 \)
RA : RB = 3 : 1
In simple words: The hollow tube has three times the cross-section of the thin solid wire, so it has one-third of the resistance.
Teacher's Note:
1. For the hollow tube the area is the area of the outer circle minus the area of the hole.
2. Use radii (0.5 mm and 1 mm), not diameters, in πr².
Examination Note: Write the area of the tube as π(ro² − ri²) and convert diameters to radii; the ratio comes out without any unit conversion because it is a ratio.
Question 27. Suppose there is a circuit consisting of only resistances and batteries. Suppose one is to double (or increase it to n times) all voltages and all resistances. Show that currents are unaltered. Do this for the circuit of Examples 3.7 in the NCERT Textbook for Class XII.
Answer:
Any circuit made of batteries and resistors can be reduced to one equivalent battery of emf \( V_{eff} \) with internal resistance \( R_{eff} \), connected to an equivalent external resistance \( R \).
Current: \( I = \dfrac{V_{eff}}{R_{eff} + R} \).
If all emfs and all resistances become n times: \( V_{eff}' = nV_{eff},\ R_{eff}' = nR_{eff},\ R' = nR \).
\[ I' = \dfrac{n V_{eff}}{n R_{eff} + n R} = \dfrac{V_{eff}}{R_{eff} + R} = I \]
So the current does not change. The same argument applies to every circuit, including the circuit of the textbook example, because it can always be reduced to this form (equivalently, in every Kirchhoff equation each term gets multiplied by the same factor n, which cancels).
In simple words: If voltages and resistances are all scaled by the same factor, Ohm's law I = V/R gives the same current.
Teacher's Note:
1. Kirchhoff's loop equations are linear: multiplying every emf and every resistance by n multiplies every term by n, so the currents stay the same.
2. Only the potential differences and the power (P = VI) change.
Examination Note: Present the general proof with Veff, Reff and R, then add a sentence applying it to the given circuit.
Long Answer Type Questions
Answer:
Let the current in the external resistor R be I, and the currents in the cells be I1 (10 V cell) and I2 (2 V cell), as shown. Junction rule: \( I_1 = I + I_2 \), so \( I_2 = I_1 - I \).
Loop through the 10 V cell and R: \( 10 = I R + 10 I_1 \). ... (i)
Loop through the 2 V cell and R: \( 2 = 5 I_2 - I R = 5(I_1 - I) - I R \), i.e. \( 4 = 10 I_1 - 10 I - 2 I R \). ... (ii)
From (i), \( 10 I_1 = 10 - I R \). Substitute in (ii): \( 4 = 10 - I R - 10 I - 2 I R \Rightarrow 6 = 3 I R + 10 I \Rightarrow 2 = I\left( R + \dfrac{10}{3} \right) \).
Compare with \( V = I (R + R_{eff}) \) for an equivalent cell. Veff = 2 V and Reff = 10/3 Ω.
Check with the formula for opposing cells in parallel: \( V_{eff} = \dfrac{10 \times 5 - 2 \times 10}{10 + 5} = 2\ \text{V} \) and \( R_{eff} = \dfrac{10 \times 5}{10 + 5} = \dfrac{10}{3}\ \Omega \).
In simple words: The two cells are joined with opposite polarity, so they act like one cell of 2 V with an internal resistance of 10/3 Ω.
Teacher's Note:
1. The effective internal resistance of cells in parallel is the parallel combination of the individual internal resistances: 10 × 5/15.
2. With opposite connection the stronger cell wins and the equivalent emf is the difference weighted by the resistances.
Examination Note: Write two loop equations with a clear current direction and eliminate I1. Compare the final line with V = I(R + Reff) to read off both answers.
Question 29. A room has AC run for 5 hours a day at a voltage of 220 V. The wiring of the room consists of Cu of 1 mm radius and a length of 10 m. Power consumption per day is 10 commercial units. What fraction of it goes in the joule heating in wires? What would happen if the wiring is made of aluminium of the same dimensions? [ρCu = 1.7 × 10−8 Ω m, ρAl = 2.7 × 10−8 Ω m]
Answer:
Energy per day = 10 units = 10 kWh in 5 hours, so the power used = 2 kW = 2000 W.
Current: \( I = \dfrac{P}{V} = \dfrac{2000}{220} \approx 9.09\ \text{A} \).
Resistance of the copper wiring: \( R = \rho \dfrac{l}{A} = \dfrac{1.7\times10^{-8} \times 10}{\pi \times (10^{-3})^2} \approx 0.054\ \Omega \).
Power lost as heat: \( P_{Cu} = I^2 R = (9.09)^2 \times 0.054 \approx 4.5\ \text{W} \).
Fraction lost: \( \dfrac{4.5}{2000} \approx 2.2 \times 10^{-3} \), i.e. about 0.22 %.
Aluminium: resistance is larger in the ratio \( \dfrac{2.7}{1.7} \approx 1.6 \), so \( P_{Al} \approx 1.59 \times 4.5 \approx 7.1\ \text{W} \). The fraction lost is \( \dfrac{7.1}{2000} \approx 0.36\ \% \).
So with aluminium the heat loss in the wires is about 1.6 times as large (about 0.36 % of the power instead of 0.22 %); it is still small but the wire gets warmer, and this is why thicker aluminium wire is used.
In simple words: Only about a fifth of one percent of the power is wasted as heat in copper wires; aluminium wires of the same size waste about 1.6 times as much.
Teacher's Note:
1. The heat produced depends on I²R, and R depends on ρ, so power loss is proportional to resistivity for the same current.
2. 1 commercial unit = 1 kWh = 3.6 × 106 J.
Examination Note: Convert units first (10 units in 5 h gives 2 kW). Show I, R, I²R and the fraction in that order. The answer is a small percentage, so check that the decimal point is correct.
Answer:
Let R′ be the resistance of the potentiometer wire, which consists of four equal segments of 100 cm each (400 cm in all). With the series resistor R, the current is \( I = \dfrac{10}{R + R'} \), and the potential drop across the wire is \( V_w = \dfrac{10 R'}{R + R'} \).
Case 1 (R = 50 Ω): no null point could be found for E1 ≈ 8 V, so the drop across the whole wire was less than 8 V: \( \dfrac{10 R'}{50 + R'} < 8 \Rightarrow 10R' < 400 + 8R' \Rightarrow R' < 200\ \Omega \).
Case 2 (R = 10 Ω): the null point is on the last (4th) segment. So the drop across the full wire is more than 8 V, \( \dfrac{10 R'}{10 + R'} > 8 \Rightarrow 10R' > 80 + 8R' \Rightarrow R' > 40\ \Omega \). The drop across the first three segments is \( \tfrac{3}{4} V_w < \tfrac{3}{4} \times 10 = 7.5\ \text{V} < 8\ \text{V} \) automatically, so no further condition arises.
Resistance of the wire: 40 Ω < R′ < 200 Ω.
Potential gradient in case 2: \( k = \dfrac{V_w}{4\ \text{m}} \). The smallest value is \( \dfrac{8}{4} = 2\ \text{V/m} \) (when Vw = 8 V). The largest value occurs for R′ = 200 Ω: \( V_w = \dfrac{10 \times 200}{210} \approx 9.52\ \text{V} \), so \( k \approx 2.38\ \text{V/m} \).
So 2 V/m < k < 2.4 V/m (approximately).
In simple words: The wire must be long enough to give more than 8 V across it with R = 10 Ω, but not so long that 8 V could be balanced with R = 50 Ω; this restricts the resistance to between 40 Ω and 200 Ω.
Teacher's Note:
1. A null point is possible only if the potential drop across the wire exceeds the emf to be measured.
2. For a null point on the 4th segment, the drop across 3 segments must be smaller than E1 and the drop across all 4 must be larger.
Examination Note: Write both conditions as inequalities, solve each, and give the final answer as a range. Remember to divide by the total length (4 m) for the potential gradient.
(b) Electrons give up energy at the rate of RI2 per second to the thermal energy. What time scale would number associated with energy in problem (a)? n = number of electrons/volume = 1029/m3. Length of circuit = 10 cm, cross-section = A = (1 mm)2.
Answer:
(a) Current: \( I = \dfrac{V}{R} = \dfrac{6}{6} = 1\ \text{A} \).
Drift speed: \( v_d = \dfrac{I}{n e A} = \dfrac{1}{10^{29} \times 1.6\times10^{-19} \times 10^{-6}} = 6.25\times10^{-5}\ \text{m/s} \).
Number of electrons in the circuit: \( N = n A l = 10^{29} \times 10^{-6} \times 0.1 = 10^{22} \).
Energy absorbed (kinetic energy of the drift motion): \( K = N \times \tfrac{1}{2} m v_d^2 = 10^{22} \times \tfrac{1}{2} \times 9.1\times10^{-31} \times (6.25\times10^{-5})^2 \approx 1.8\times10^{-17}\ \text{J} \).
(b) Heat is generated at the rate \( P = I^2 R = 1^2 \times 6 = 6\ \text{W} \). Time scale: \( t = \dfrac{K}{P} = \dfrac{1.8\times10^{-17}}{6} \approx 3\times10^{-18}\ \text{s} \).
This is an extremely short time (of the order of 10−18 s), so the electrons reach the steady drift motion almost instantly after the circuit is switched on.
In simple words: The energy needed to set the electrons drifting is only about 10−17 J, which the battery supplies in a tiny fraction of a second.
Teacher's Note:
1. The drift speed is only about 0.06 mm/s, so the kinetic energy of drifting electrons is very small.
2. Almost all the energy given by the battery goes into heat, not into the kinetic energy of the drift.
Examination Note: Calculate vd, then the number of electrons, then the energy, and finally divide by the power. Keep the powers of ten under control, since this is where most marks are lost.