IE Irodov Solutions Chapter 37 Molecules And Crystals

Step-by-Step IE Irodov Solutions for JEE Physics Chapter 37 Molecules And Crystals

Explore reliable textbook solutions for Chapter 37 Molecules And Crystals tailored for JEE learners using IE Irodov methodologies. Utilizing these Physics answers ensures thorough preparation and strengthens foundational knowledge before final school evaluations.

Download Chapter 37 Molecules And Crystals Textbook Solutions PDF

View or download the dedicated Chapter 37 Molecules And Crystals solution resource below. Engaging with these textbook answers under focused study conditions ensures continuous academic progress and mastery of the 2026 curriculum for Physics.

Molecules And Crystals - Questions 167-213

Molecules and Crystals (Part 1)

Question 167. Determine the angular rotation velocity of an S2 molecule promoted to the first excited rotational level if the distance between its nuclei is d = 189 pm.

Solution. In the first excited rotational level J = 1, so

EJ = 1 × 2 · ħ2/(2I) = ½ I ω2 (classically).

Thus ω = √2 · ħ/I.

Now I = Σ mi ri2 = (m/2)(d2/4) + (m/2)(d2/4) = m d2/4, where m is the mass of the molecule and ri is the distance of the atom from the axis.

Thus ω = 4√2 ħ/(m d2) = 1.56 × 1011 rad/s.

Teacher's Note: Equate quantum energy ħ²J(J+1)/2I at J=1 to classical ½Iω²; I is μd² with μ=m/4 here.

Exam Note: Quote E_J, then I = m d²/4.

Question 168. For an HCl molecule find the rotational quantum numbers of two neighbouring levels whose energies differ by 7.86 meV. The nuclei of the molecule are separated by the distance of 127.5 pm.

Solution. The axis of rotation passes through the centre of mass of the HCl molecule. The distances of the two atoms from the centre of mass are dH = (mCl/mHCl) d, dCl = (mH/mHCl) d.

Thus the moment of inertia about the axis is I = mH dH2 + mCl dCl2 = [mH mCl/(mH + mCl)] d2.

The energy difference between two neighbouring levels whose quantum numbers are J and J − 1 is

(ħ2/2I) · 2J = Jħ2/I = 7.86 meV.

Hence J = 3 and the levels have quantum numbers 2 and 3.

Teacher's Note: Neighbouring-level gap is ħ²J/I; compute I from the reduced mass, then solve for J.

Exam Note: Show μd², then J = 3.

Question 169. Find the angular momentum of an oxygen molecule whose rotational energy is E = 2.16 meV and the distance between the nuclei is d = 121 pm.

Solution. The angular momentum is M = √(2IE).

Now I = m d2/4 (m = mass of the O2 molecule ≈ 5.3 × 10−26 kg), so

M = 3.68 × 10−27 erg·s = 3.68 × 10−34 J·s = 3.49 ħ.

(This corresponds to J = 3.)

Teacher's Note: M = √(2IE) = ħ√(J(J+1)); 3.49ħ matches J = 3 since √12 = 3.46.

Exam Note: Compute I first, then M = √(2IE).

Question 170. Show that the frequency intervals between the neighbouring spectral lines of a true rotational spectrum of a diatomic molecule are equal. Find the moment of inertia and the distance between the nuclei of a CH molecule if the intervals between the neighbouring lines of the true rotational spectrum of these molecules are equal to Δω = 5.47 × 1012 s−1.

Solution. From EJ = (ħ2/2I) J(J + 1) and the selection rule ΔJ = 1 (J → J − 1) for a pure rotational spectrum we get

ω(J, J − 1) = ħJ/I.

Thus transition lines are equispaced in frequency: Δω = ħ/I.

In the case of the CH molecule I = ħ/Δω = 1.93 × 10−40 g·cm2 (= 1.93 × 10−47 kg·m2).

Also I = [mC mH/(mC + mH)] d2, so d = 1.117 × 10−8 cm = 111.7 pm (≈ 112 pm).

Teacher's Note: Successive lines differ by ħ/I; use reduced mass of C and H to turn I into d.

Exam Note: State ω(J,J−1)=ħJ/I, then Δω=ħ/I.

Question 171. For an HF molecule find the number of rotational levels located between the zeroth and first excited vibrational levels assuming rotational states to be independent of vibrational ones. The natural vibration frequency of this molecule is equal to 7.79 × 1014 rad/s, and the distance between the nuclei is 91.7 pm.

Solution. If the vibrational frequency is ω0 the excitation energy of the first vibrational level will be ħω0. Thus if there are J rotational levels contained in the band between the ground state and the first vibrational excitation, then

ħω0 = J(J + 1)ħ2/(2I),

where, as stated in the problem, we have ignored any coupling between the two. For the HF molecule I = [mH mF/(mH + mF)] d2 = 1.336 × 10−40 g·cm2.

Then J(J + 1) = 2Iω0/ħ = 197.4.

For J = 14, J(J + 1) = 210. For J = 13, J(J + 1) = 182. Thus there lie 13 levels between the ground state and the first vibrational excitation.

Teacher's Note: Rotational levels fit while ħ²J(J+1)/2I stays below ħω₀; pick the largest J with J(J+1) ≤ 197.

Exam Note: Compute 2Iω₀/ħ, bracket between 182 and 210.

Question 172. Evaluate how many lines there are in a true rotational spectrum of CO molecules whose natural vibration frequency is ω = 4.09 × 1014 s−1 and moment of inertia I = 1.44 × 10−39 g·cm2.

Solution. We proceed as above. Calculating 2Iω0/ħ we get 2Iω0/ħ = 1118.

Now this must equal J(J + 1) = (J + ½)2 − ¼ ≈ (J + ½)2.

Taking the square root we get J = 33.

Teacher's Note: Same band-limit idea as Q.171; for large J, J(J+1) ≈ (J+½)² gives the root quickly.

Exam Note: Give 2Iω₀/ħ = 1118, then J ≈ 33.

Question 173. Find the number of rotational levels per unit energy interval, dN/dE, for a diatomic molecule as a function of rotational energy E. Calculate that magnitude for an iodine molecule in the state with rotational quantum number J = 10. The distance between the nuclei of that molecule is equal to 267 pm.

Solution. From the formula J(J + 1)ħ2/(2I) = E we get J(J + 1) = 2IE/ħ2, or (J + ½)2 − ¼ = 2IE/ħ2.

Hence J = −½ + √(¼ + 2IE/ħ2).

Writing J + 1 = −½ + √(¼ + (2I/ħ2)(E + ΔE)), we find

1 = √(¼ + 2IE/ħ2 + 2IΔE/ħ2) − √(¼ + 2IE/ħ2)

= √(¼ + 2IE/ħ2) · [(1 + ΔE/(E + ħ2/8I))1/2 − 1]

= √(¼ + 2IE/ħ2) · ΔE/[2(E + ħ2/8I)]

= √(2I/ħ2) · ΔE/[2√(E + ħ2/8I)].

The quantity dN/dE is 1/ΔE. For large E it is

dN/dE = √(I/(2ħ2E)).

For an iodine molecule I = mI d2/2 = 7.57 × 10−38 g·cm2. Thus for J = 10, E = ħ2J(J + 1)/(2I) and

dN/dE = √(I/(2ħ2 · ħ2J(J + 1)/(2I))) = I/(√(J(J + 1)) ħ2).

Substitution gives dN/dE = 1.04 × 104 levels per eV.

Teacher's Note: Treat J as continuous in E: dN/dE = 1/ΔE between neighbouring levels, then substitute E for J = 10.

Exam Note: Show dN/dE = I/(ħ²√(J(J+1))).

Question 174. Find the ratio of energies required to excite a diatomic molecule to the first vibrational and to the first rotational level. Calculate that ratio for the following molecules:
Moleculeω, 1014 s−1d, pm
(a) H28.374
(b) HI4.35160
(c) I20.40267
Here ω is the natural vibration frequency of a molecule, d is the distance between nuclei.

Solution. For the first rotational level Erot = 2 · ħ2/(2I) = ħ2/I, and for the first vibrational level Evib = ħω.

Thus ξ = Evib/Erot = Iω/ħ. Here ω = frequency of vibration. Now I = μd2 = [m1m2/(m1 + m2)] d2.

(a) For the H2 molecule I = 4.58 × 10−41 g·cm2 and ξ = 36.

(b) For the HI molecule I = 4.247 × 10−40 g·cm2 and ξ = 175.

(c) For the I2 molecule I = 7.57 × 10−38 g·cm2 and ξ = 2872 (≈ 2.9 × 103; recalculation gives I = 7.51 × 10−38 g·cm2, ξ ≈ 2.85 × 103).

Teacher's Note: First rotational level (J=1) sits at ħ²/I; ratio Iω/ħ grows with mass, so heavy I₂ is far larger.

Exam Note: Write ξ = Iω/ħ and use reduced mass.

Question 175. The natural vibration frequency of a hydrogen molecule is equal to 8.25 × 1014 s−1, the distance between the nuclei is 74 pm. Find the ratio of the number of these molecules at the first excited vibrational level (v = 1) to the number of molecules at the first excited rotational level (J = 1) at a temperature T = 875 K. It should be remembered that the degeneracy of rotational levels is equal to 2J + 1.

Solution. The energy of the molecule in the first rotational level will be ħ2/I. The ratio of the number of molecules at the first excited vibrational level to the number of molecules at the first excited rotational level is

e−ħω/kT / [(2J + 1) e−ħ2J(J+1)/2IkT] = (1/3) e−ħω/kT × eħ2/IkT = (1/3) e−ħ(ω − 2B)/kT,

where B = ħ/2I.

For the hydrogen molecule I = ½ mH d2 = 4.58 × 10−41 g·cm2.

Substitution gives 3.04 × 10−4.

Teacher's Note: Boltzmann populations: weight each level by degeneracy (2J+1=3 for J=1) and e^(−E/kT).

Exam Note: Divide Boltzmann factors; include degeneracy 3.

Question 176. Derive Eq. (6.4c), making use of the Boltzmann distribution. From Eq. (6.4c) obtain the expression for molar vibration heat capacity CV,vib of diatomic gas. Calculate CV,vib for Cl2 gas at the temperature 300 K. The natural vibration frequency of these molecules is equal to 1.064 × 1014 s−1.

Solution. By definition

⟨E⟩ = Σ Ev e−Ev/kT / Σ exp(−Ev/kT) = −(∂/∂β) ln Σv=0∞ e−β(v+½)ħω, β = 1/kT

= −(∂/∂β) ln [e−½βħω · 1/(1 − e−βħω)]

= −(∂/∂β) [−½ħωβ − ln(1 − e−βħω)]

= ½ħω + ħω/(eħω/kT − 1).

Thus for one gram mole of diatomic gas

CV,vib = N ∂⟨E⟩/∂T = R (ħω/kT)2 eħω/kT / (eħω/kT − 1)2,

where R = Nk is the gas constant.

In the present case ħω/kT = 2.7088 and CV,vib = 0.56 R.

Teacher's Note: Sum the geometric series for the partition function, then differentiate: mean energy gives Einstein heat capacity.

Exam Note: Final: C = R x²eˣ/(eˣ−1)², x=ħω/kT.

Question 177. In the middle of the rotation–vibration band of emission spectrum of HCl molecule, where the "zeroth" line is forbidden by the selection rules, the interval between neighbouring lines is Δω = 0.79 × 1013 s−1. Calculate the distance between the nuclei of an HCl molecule.

Solution. In the rotation-vibration band the main transition is due to change in vibrational quantum number v → v − 1. Together with this, the rotational quantum number may change. The "zeroth" line 0 → 0 is forbidden in this case, so the neighbouring lines arise due to 1 → 0 or 0 → 1 in the rotational quantum number. Now

E = Ev + (ħ2/2I) J(J + 1).

Thus ħω = ħω0 + (ħ2/2I)(±2).

Hence Δω = 2ħ/I = 2ħ/(μd2), so d = √(2ħ/(μΔω)).

Substitution gives d = 0.128 nm.

Teacher's Note: The two central lines sit at ω₀ ± ħ/I, so their gap is 2ħ/I (the missing zeroth line).

Exam Note: Gap across band centre is 2ħ/I, not ħ/I.

Question 178. Calculate the wavelengths of the red and violet satellites, closest to the fixed line, in the vibration spectrum of Raman scattering by F2 molecules if the incident light wavelength is equal to λ0 = 404.7 nm and the natural vibration frequency of the molecule is ω = 2.15 × 1014 s−1.

Solution. If λR = wavelength of the red satellite and λV = wavelength of the violet satellite, then

2πħc/λR = 2πħc/λ0 − ħω and 2πħc/λV = 2πħc/λ0 + ħω.

Substitution gives λR = 424.3 nm, λV = 386.8 nm.

The two formulas can be combined to give λ = 2πc/(2πc/λ0 ∓ ω) = λ0/(1 ∓ λ0ω/2πc).

Teacher's Note: Red satellite: photon loses ħω to the molecule; violet: gains ħω. Work with photon energies, not wavelengths.

Exam Note: Subtract/add ħω to photon energy, then convert.

Question 179. Find the natural vibration frequency and the quasielastic force coefficient of an S2 molecule if the wavelengths of the red and violet satellites, closest to the fixed line, in the vibration spectrum of Raman scattering are equal to 346.6 and 330.0 nm.

Solution. As in the previous problem,

ω = πc (1/λV − 1/λR) = πc(λR − λV)/(λRλV) = 1.368 × 1014 rad/s.

The force constant κ is defined by κ = μω2, where μ = reduced mass of the S2 molecule.

Substitution gives κ = 5.01 N/cm (recalculation gives 4.96 N/cm ≈ 5.0 N/cm, i.e. about 5 × 102 N/m).

Teacher's Note: Subtracting the satellite photon energies gives 2ħω, hence the πc factor; κ = μω² with μ = m/2.

Exam Note: Remember the factor 2: gap is 2ħω.

Question 180. Find the ratio of intensities of the violet and red satellites, closest to the fixed line, in the vibration spectrum of Raman scattering by Cl2 molecules at a temperature T = 300 K if the natural vibration frequency of these molecules is ω = 1.06 × 1014 s−1. By what factor will this ratio change if the temperature is doubled?

Solution. The violet satellite arises from the transition 1 → 0 in the vibrational state of the scattering molecule while the red satellite arises from the transition 0 → 1. The intensities of these two transitions are in the ratio of initial populations of the two states, i.e. in the ratio e−ħω/kT.

Thus IV/IR = e−ħω/kT = 0.067.

If the temperature is doubled, the ratio increases to 0.259, an increase of 3.9 times.

Teacher's Note: Violet needs a molecule already excited, so its intensity relative to red follows the Boltzmann population ratio.

Exam Note: Answer 0.067; doubling T gives about 3.9 times.

Question 181. Consider the possible vibration modes in the following linear molecules: (a) CO2 (O—C—O); (b) C2H2 (H—C—C—H).

Solution. (a) CO2 (O—C—O). The molecule has 9 degrees of freedom, 3 for each atom. This means that it can have up to nine frequencies. 3 degrees of freedom correspond to rigid translation; the frequency associated with this is zero as the potential energy of the system cannot change under rigid translation. The potential energy will not change under rotations about axes passing through the C atom and perpendicular to the O—C—O line. Thus there can be at most four non-zero frequencies. We must look for modes different from the above.

One mode is ω1 (both O atoms move toward/away from the C atom symmetrically). Another mode is ω2 (the two O atoms move one way while C moves the other way). These are the only collinear modes. A third mode, ω3, is doubly degenerate: the O atoms move one way perpendicular to the line and the C atom the opposite way (vibration in and perpendicular to the plane of paper).

ω1ω2ω3

(b) C2H2 (H—C—C—H). There are 4 × 3 − 3 − 2 = 7 different vibrations. There are three collinear modes (ω1, ω2, ω3, arrows as in the figure below). Two other doubly degenerate frequencies, ω4 and ω5 (transverse), exist together with their counterparts in the plane perpendicular to the paper.

ω1ω2ω3ω4ω5

Teacher's Note: Count 3N minus translations (3) minus rotations (2 for linear molecules) to get vibrational modes.

Exam Note: State 3N−5 for linear molecules.

Question 182. Find the number of natural transverse vibrations of a string of length l in the frequency interval from ω to ω + dω if the propagation velocity of vibrations is equal to v. All vibrations are supposed to occur in one plane.

Solution. Suppose the string is stretched along the x axis from x = 0 to x = l with the end points fixed. Suppose y(x, t) is the transverse displacement of the element at x at time t. Then y(x, t) obeys

∂2y/∂t2 = v2 ∂2y/∂x2.

We look for a stationary wave solution of this equation, y(x, t) = A sin(ωx/v) sin(ωt + δ), where A and δ are constants. In this form y = 0 at x = 0. The further condition y = 0 at x = l implies ωl/v = Nπ, N > 0, or N = lω/(πv).

N is the number of modes of frequency ≤ ω. Thus dN = (l/πv) dω.

Teacher's Note: Fixed ends force ωl/v = Nπ; count integers N up to a given ω, then differentiate.

Exam Note: Boundary condition y(l)=0 gives N = lω/πv.

Question 183. There is a square membrane of area S. Find the number of natural vibrations perpendicular to its plane in the frequency interval from ω to ω + dω if the propagation velocity of vibrations is equal to v.

Solution. Let ξ(x, y, t) be the displacement of the element at (x, y) at time t. Then it obeys the equation

∂2ξ/∂t2 = v2(∂2ξ/∂x2 + ∂2ξ/∂y2),

where ξ = 0 at x = 0, x = l, y = 0 and y = l.

We look for a solution in the form ξ = A sin k1x sin k2y sin(ωt + δ). Then ω2 = v2(k12 + k22), with k1 = nπ/l, k2 = mπ/l.

We write this as n2 + m2 = (lω/πv)2. Here n, m > 0. Each pair (n, m) determines a mode. The total number of modes whose frequency is ≤ ω is the area of the quadrant of a circle of radius lω/(πv), i.e.

N = (π/4)(lω/πv)2.

Then dN = (l2/(2πv2)) ω dω = (S/(2πv2)) ω dω, where S = l2 is the area of the membrane.

Teacher's Note: Each (n, m) pair is one mode; count lattice points in a quarter circle in n–m space.

Exam Note: Take quarter-circle area, then differentiate.

Question 184. Find the number of natural transverse vibrations of a right angled parallelepiped of volume V in the frequency interval from ω to ω + dω if the propagation velocity of vibrations is equal to v.

Solution. For transverse vibrations of a 3-dimensional continuum (in the form of a cube say) we have the equation ∂2ξ/∂t2 = v2∇2ξ, div ξ = 0. Here ξ = ξ(x, y, z, t). We look for solutions in the form

ξ = A sin k1x sin k2y sin k3z sin(ωt + δ).

This requires ω2 = v2(k12 + k22 + k32). From the boundary condition that ξ = 0 for x = 0, x = l, y = 0, y = l, z = 0, z = l, we get k1 = n1π/l, k2 = n2π/l, k3 = n3π/l, where n1, n2, n3 are nonzero positive integers.

We then get n12 + n22 + n32 = (lω/πv)2.

Each triplet (n1, n2, n3) determines a possible mode and the number of such modes whose frequency is ≤ ω is the volume of the all-positive octant of a sphere of radius lω/(πv). Considering also the fact that the subsidiary condition div ξ = 0 implies two independent values of A for each choice of the wave vector (k1, k2, k3), we find

N(ω) = (1/8)(4π/3)(lω/πv)3 · 2 = Vω3/(3π2v3).

Thus dN = (Vω2/(π2v3)) dω.

Teacher's Note: Octant of a sphere counts wave vectors; the factor 2 comes from two transverse polarisations (div ξ = 0).

Exam Note: Include the factor 2 for polarisation.

Question 185. Assuming the propagation velocities of longitudinal and transverse vibrations to be the same and equal to v, find the Debye temperature (a) for a unidimensional crystal, i.e. a chain of identical atoms, incorporating n0 atoms per unit length; (b) for a two-dimensional crystal, i.e. a plane square grid consisting of identical atoms, containing n0 atoms per unit area; (c) for a simple cubic lattice consisting of identical atoms, containing n0 atoms per unit volume.

Solution. To determine the Debye temperature we cut off the high frequency modes in such a way as to get the total number of modes correctly.

(a) In a linear crystal with n0l atoms, the number of modes of transverse vibrations in any given plane cannot exceed n0l. Then n0l = (l/πv) ∫0ω0 dω = (l/πv) ω0. The cut-off frequency ω0 is related to the Debye temperature Θ by ħω0 = kΘ. Thus Θ = (ħ/k) π n0 v.

(b) In a square lattice, the number of modes of transverse oscillations cannot exceed n0S. Thus n0S = (S/2πv2) ∫0ω0 ω dω = (S/4πv2) ω02, or Θ = (ħ/k) ω0 = (ħ/k)(√(4π n0)) v.

(c) In a cubic crystal, the maximum number of transverse waves must be 2n0V (two for each atom). Thus 2n0V = (V/π2v3) ∫0ω0 ω2 dω = Vω03/(3π2v3).

Thus Θ = (ħ/k) v (6π2n0)1/3.

Teacher's Note: Cut off the mode count at the number of atoms times polarisations; dimension changes the power of ω in dN.

Exam Note: Equate total modes to atom count to find ω₀.

Molecules and Crystals (Part 2)

Question 186. Calculate the Debye temperature for iron in which the propagation velocities of longitudinal and transverse vibrations are equal to 5.85 and 3.23 km/s respectively.

Solution. We proceed as in the previous example. The total number of modes must be 3n0V (two transverse and one longitudinal per atom). On the other hand the number of transverse modes per unit frequency interval is given by dN⊥ = (Vω2/π2v⊥3) dω, while the number of longitudinal modes per unit frequency interval is given by dN∥ = (Vω2/2π2v∥3) dω.

The total number per unit frequency interval is dN = (Vω2/2π2)(2/v⊥3 + 1/v∥3) dω.

If the high frequency cut-off is at ω0 = kΘ/ħ, the total number of modes will be 3n0V = (V/6π2)(2/v⊥3 + 1/v∥3)(kΘ/ħ)3.

Here n0 is the number of iron atoms per unit volume. Thus

Θ = (ħ/k) [18π2n0 / (2/v⊥3 + 1/v∥3)]1/3.

For iron n0 = NA/(M/ρ) = ρNA/M (ρ = density, M = atomic weight of iron, NA = Avogadro number); n0 = 8.389 × 1022 per cc.

Substituting the data we get Θ = 469.1 K.

Teacher's Note: Add two transverse and one longitudinal branch with their own speeds; the cut-off ω₀ then fixes Θ.

Exam Note: Use 3n₀V total modes with both speeds.

Question 187. Evaluate the propagation velocity of acoustic vibrations in aluminium whose Debye temperature is Θ = 396 K.

Solution. We apply the same formula but assume v∥ ≈ v⊥. Then Θ = (ħ/k) v (6π2n0)1/3, or v = kΘ / [ħ(6π2n0)1/3].

For Al n0 = ρNA/M = 6.023 × 1022 per cc.

Thus v = 3.39 km/s.

The tabulated values are v∥ = 6.3 km/s and v⊥ = 3.1 km/s.

Teacher's Note: Single average speed gives Θ = (ħ/k)v(6π²n₀)^(1/3); invert it. Result sits between the two tabulated speeds.

Exam Note: Invert Debye formula; n₀ = ρN_A/M.

Question 188. Derive the formula expressing molar heat capacity of a unidimensional crystal, a chain of identical atoms, as a function of temperature T if the Debye temperature of the chain is equal to Θ. Simplify the obtained expression for the case T ≫ Θ.

Solution. In the Debye approximation the number of modes per unit frequency interval is given by dN = (l/πv) dω, 0 ≤ ω ≤ kΘ/ħ. But kΘ/ħ = πn0v. Thus dN = (l/πv) dω, 0 ≤ ω ≤ πn0v.

The energy per mode is ⟨E⟩ = ½ħω + ħω/(eħω/kT − 1).

Then the total internal energy of the chain is

U = (l/πv) ∫0πn0v ½ħω dω + (l/πv) ∫0πn0v ħω dω/(eħω/kT − 1)

= (lħ/4πv)(πn0v)2 + (l/πvħ)(kT)2 ∫0Θ/T x dx/(ex − 1)

= l n0 k · (ħ/k)(πn0v) · ¼ + l n0 k · T2/[(πn0vħ/k)] ∫0Θ/T x dx/(ex − 1).

We put l n0 = NA for 1 mole of the chain. Then

U = RΘ {¼ + (T/Θ)2 ∫0Θ/T x dx/(ex − 1)}.

Hence the molar heat capacity is, by differentiation,

CV = (∂U/∂T) = R [2(T/Θ) ∫0Θ/T x dx/(ex − 1) − (Θ/T)/(eΘ/T − 1)].

When T ≫ Θ, CV = R.

Teacher's Note: Debye model: integrate mode energy up to cut-off, then differentiate; at high T it reduces to R per chain mole.

Exam Note: At T≫Θ the integrand ≈1, giving C = R.

Question 189. In a chain of identical atoms the vibration frequency ω depends on wave number k as ω = ωmax sin(ka/2), where ωmax is the maximum vibration frequency, k = 2π/λ is the wave number corresponding to frequency ω, a is the distance between neighbouring atoms. Making use of this dispersion relation, find the dependence of the number of longitudinal vibrations per unit frequency interval on ω, i.e. dN/dω, if the length of the chain is l. Having obtained dN/dω, find the total number N of possible longitudinal vibrations of the chain.

Solution. If the chain has N atoms, we can assume atom number 0 and N + 1 held fixed. Then the displacement of the nth atom has the form un = A (sin(mπ/l · na)) sin ωt. Here k = mπ/l. Allowed frequencies then have the form ω = ωmax sin(ka/2). In our form only positive k values are allowed.

The number of modes in a wave number range dk is dN = l dk/π = (l/π)(dk/dω) dω. But dω = (a/2) ωmax cos(ka/2) dk. Hence dω/dk = (a/2)√(ωmax2 − ω2).

So dN = (2l/πa) dω/√(ωmax2 − ω2).

(b) The total number of modes is N = ∫0ωmax (2l/πa) dω/√(ωmax2 − ω2) = (2l/πa)(π/2) = l/a, i.e. the number of atoms in the chain.

Teacher's Note: Convert dN = l dk/π to frequency with dω/dk from the dispersion law; the integral is a standard arcsine.

Exam Note: Total modes must equal the atom count l/a.

Question 190. Calculate the zero-point energy per one gram of copper whose Debye temperature is Θ = 330 K.

Solution. Molar zero point energy is (9/8)RΘ. The zero point energy per gram of copper is 9RΘ/(8MCu), MCu being the atomic weight of the copper.

Substitution gives 48.6 J/g.

Teacher's Note: Debye zero-point energy is 9/8 RΘ per mole (9/8 NkΘ); divide by molar mass of Cu.

Exam Note: Divide (9/8)RΘ by M = 63.5 g/mol.

Question 191. Fig. 6.10 shows heat capacity of a crystal vs temperature in terms of the Debye theory. Here Ccl is classical heat capacity, Θ is the Debye temperature. Using this plot, find: (a) the Debye temperature for silver if at a temperature T = 65 K its molar heat capacity is equal to 15 J/(mol·K); (b) the molar heat capacity of aluminium at T = 80 K if at T = 250 K it is equal to 22.4 J/(mol·K); (c) the maximum vibration frequency for copper whose heat capacity at T = 125 K differs from the classical value by 25%.
0.00.00.20.20.40.40.60.60.80.81.01.0T/ΘC/C_cl

Fig. 6.10: C/Ccl against T/Θ (Debye theory).

Solution. (a) By Dulong and Petit's law, the classical heat capacity is 3R = 24.94 J/(K·mol). Thus C/Ccl = 0.6014. From the graph we see that this value of C/Ccl corresponds to T/Θ = 0.29. Hence Θ = 65/0.29 ≈ 224 K.

(b) 22.4 J/(mol·K) corresponds to 22.4/(3 × 8.314) = 0.898. From the graph this corresponds to T/Θ ≈ 0.65. This gives Θ = 250/0.65 ≈ 385 K. Then 80 K corresponds to T/Θ = 0.208. The corresponding value of C/Ccl is 0.42. Hence C = 10.5 J/(mol·K).

(c) We calculate Θ from the datum that C/Ccl = 0.75 at T = 125 K. The x-coordinate corresponding to 0.75 is 0.40. Hence Θ = 125/0.4 = 312.5 K. (Corrected: the book prints 3125 K, a misprint; 125/0.4 = 312.5 K.)

Now kΘ = ħωmax, so ωmax = 4.09 × 1013 rad/s.

(Values are read from the graph; the exact Debye function gives about 219 K, 371 K, 10.3 J/(mol·K) and 4.05 × 1013 rad/s.)

Teacher's Note: Convert data to C/C_cl and read T/Θ off the Debye curve; graph reading limits precision to a few percent.

Exam Note: Normalise by 3R, read T/Θ, then Θ = T/(T/Θ).

Question 192. Demonstrate that molar heat capacity of a crystal at a temperature T ≪ Θ, where Θ is the Debye temperature, is defined by Eq. (6.4f).

Solution. We use the formula (6.4d)

U = 9RΘ [1/8 + (T/Θ)4 ∫0Θ/T x3dx/(ex − 1)]

= 9RΘ [1/8 + {∫0∞ x3dx/(ex − 1)} (T/Θ)4 − (T/Θ)4 ∫Θ/T∞ x3dx/(ex − 1)].

In the limit T ≪ Θ the third term in the bracket is exponentially small together with its derivatives. Then we can drop the last term:

U = Const + (9R/Θ3) T4 ∫0∞ x3dx/(ex − 1).

Thus CV = (∂U/∂T)V = 36R (T/Θ)3 ∫0∞ x3dx/(ex − 1).

Now from the table in the book ∫0∞ x3dx/(ex − 1) = π4/15.

Thus CV = (12π4/5) R (T/Θ)3. (The R is missing in the book's printed final line; it is restored here since the 36R factor above carries it.)

Note. Call the third term in the bracket above U3. Then U3 = (T/Θ)4 ∫Θ/T∞ [x3/(2 sinh(x/2))] e−x/2 dx. The maximum value of x3/(2 sinh(x/2)) is a finite positive quantity C0 for 0 ≤ x < ∞. Thus U3 ≤ 2C0(T/Θ)4 e−Θ/2T, and we see that U3 is exponentially small as T → 0. So is dU3/dT.

Teacher's Note: At low T the upper limit Θ/T may be taken to infinity; the integral is π⁴/15, giving the T³ law.

Exam Note: Quote result C = (12π⁴/5)R(T/Θ)³.

Question 193. Can one consider the temperatures 20 and 30 K as low for a crystal whose heat capacities at these temperatures are equal to 0.226 and 0.760 J/(mol·K)?

Solution. At low temperatures C ∝ T3. This is also a test of the "lowness" of the temperature. We see that

(C2/C1)1/3 = (0.760/0.226)1/3 = 1.4982 ≈ 1.5 = T2/T1 = 30/20.

Thus the T3 law is obeyed and T1, T2 can be regarded as low.

Teacher's Note: Debye T³ law is the test: check whether (C₂/C₁)^(1/3) equals T₂/T₁.

Exam Note: Show cube root of heat-capacity ratio equals 1.5.

Question 194. Calculate the mean zero-point energy per one oscillator of a crystal in terms of the Debye theory if the Debye temperature of the crystal is equal to Θ.

Solution. The total zero-point energy of 1 mole of the solid is (9/8)RΘ. Dividing this by the number of modes 3N we get the average zero-point energy per mode. It is (3/8)kΘ.

Teacher's Note: Divide Debye zero-point energy (9/8)NkΘ by 3N modes; the answer is 3kΘ/8, not kΘ/2.

Exam Note: Answer (3/8)kΘ.

Question 195. Draw the vibration energy of a crystal as a function of frequency (neglecting the zero-point vibrations). Consider two cases: T = Θ/2 and T = Θ/4, where Θ is the Debye temperature.

Solution. In the Debye model dNω = Aω2 dω, 0 ≤ ω ≤ ωm. Then 3N = ∫0ωm dNω = Aωm3/3 (total number of modes is 3N). Thus A = 9N/ωm3.

We get, ignoring zero-point energy,

U = (9N/ωm3) ∫0ωm ω2 ħω dω/(eħω/kT − 1) = 9Nħωm ∫01 x3dx/(eħωmx/kT − 1), x = ω/ωm

= 9RΘ ∫01 x3dx/(exΘ/T − 1), Θ = ħωm/k.

Thus (1/9RΘ) dU(x)/dx = x3/(exΘ/T − 1) for 0 ≤ x ≤ 1. For T = Θ/2 this is x3/(e2x − 1); for T = Θ/4 it is x3/(e4x − 1). Plotting then gives the curves below.

0.00.20.40.60.81.00.00.10.20.30.4T = Θ/2: x³/(e²ˣ − 1)T = Θ/4: x³/(e⁴ˣ − 1)x = ω/ω_m(1/9RΘ) dU/dx

Teacher's Note: Energy per unit frequency is mode density ω² times Planck mean energy; lower T pushes the peak to low ω.

Exam Note: Plot x³/(e^{xΘ/T}−1) on 0 to 1.

Question 196. Evaluate the maximum values of energy and momentum of a phonon (acoustic quantum) in copper whose Debye temperature is equal to 330 K.

Solution. The maximum energy of the phonon is ħωm = kΘ = 28.4 meV on substituting Θ = 330 K.

To get the corresponding value of the maximum momentum we must know the dispersion relation ω = ω(k). For small |k| we know ω = v|k|, where v is the velocity of sound in the crystal. For an order-of-magnitude estimate we continue to use this result for high |k|. Then we estimate v from the values of the modulus of elasticity and density, v ~ √(E/ρ). We write E ~ 100 GPa, ρ = 8.9 × 103 kg/m3. Then v ~ 3 × 103 m/s.

Hence ħ|k|max ~ ħωm/v ~ 1.5 × 10−19 g·cm·s−1 (= 1.5 × 10−24 kg·m/s).

Teacher's Note: Maximum phonon energy is kΘ; momentum follows from ħω/v using an estimated sound speed (order of magnitude only).

Exam Note: Energy kΘ; momentum ħω_m/v, estimate only.

Question 197. Employing Eq. (6.4g), find at T = 0: (a) the maximum kinetic energy of free electrons in a metal if their concentration is equal to n; (b) the mean kinetic energy of free electrons if their maximum kinetic energy Tmax is known.

Solution. (a) From the formula dn = (√2 m3/2/π2ħ3) E1/2 dE the maximum value Emax of E is determined in terms of n by

n = (√2 m3/2/π2ħ3) ∫0Emax E1/2 dE = (√2 m3/2/π2ħ3)(2/3) Emax3/2,

or Emax3/2 = (ħ2/2m)3/2 (3π2n), i.e. Emax = (ħ2/2m)(3π2n)2/3.

(b) The mean kinetic energy is

⟨E⟩ = ∫0Emax E dn / ∫0Emax dn = ∫ E3/2 dE / ∫ E1/2 dE = (2/5)Emax5/2 / ((2/3)Emax3/2) = (3/5) Emax.

Teacher's Note: At T=0 fill states up to E_max with density ∝ √E; the mean is weighted by that density, giving 3/5.

Exam Note: Quote E_max=(ħ²/2m)(3π²n)^{2/3}, mean 3/5 of it.

Question 198. What fraction (in per cent) of free electrons in a metal at T = 0 has a kinetic energy exceeding half the maximum energy?

Solution. The fraction is η = ∫½EmaxEmax E1/2 dE / ∫0Emax E1/2 dE = 1 − 2−3/2 = 0.646, or 64.6 %.

Teacher's Note: Count states with density ∝ √E above E_max/2; the high-energy region still holds most electrons.

Exam Note: Evaluate 1 − 2^(−3/2).

Question 199. Find the number of free electrons per one sodium atom at T = 0 if the Fermi level is equal to EF = 3.07 eV and the density of sodium is 0.97 g/cm3.

Solution. We calculate the concentration n of electrons in the Na metal from Emax = EF = (ħ2/2m)(3π2n)2/3. For EF = 3.07 eV we get n = 2.447 × 1022 per cc (recalculation gives 2.44 × 1022).

From this we get the number of electrons per one Na atom as (n/ρ)(M/NA), where ρ = density of Na, M = molar weight in grams of Na, NA = Avogadro number.

We get 0.963 electrons per one Na atom (≈ 1, recalculation 0.961).

Teacher's Note: Invert E_F formula for electron density, then divide by atom density ρN_A/M; result about one per atom.

Exam Note: Answer ≈ 1 free electron per Na atom.

Question 200. Up to what temperature has one to heat classical electronic gas to make the mean energy of its electrons equal to that of free electrons in copper at T = 0? Only one free electron is supposed to correspond to each copper atom.

Solution. The mean kinetic energy of electrons in a Fermi gas is (3/5)EF. This must equal (3/2)kT. Thus T = 2EF/(5k).

We calculate EF first. For Cu n = NA/(M/ρ) = ρNA/M = 8.442 × 1022 per cc.

Then EF = 7.01 eV and T = 3.25 × 104 K.

Teacher's Note: Equate Fermi-gas mean energy 3E_F/5 with classical 3kT/2; ~10⁴ K shows electron gas is strongly degenerate.

Exam Note: Set (3/5)E_F = (3/2)kT.

Molecules and Crystals (Part 3)

Question 201. Calculate the interval (in eV units) between neighbouring levels of free electrons in a metal at T = 0 near the Fermi level, if the concentration of free electrons is n = 2.0 × 1022 cm−3 and the volume of the metal is V = 1.0 cm3.

Solution. We write the expression for the number of electrons as dN = (V√2 m3/2/π2ħ3) E1/2 dE.

Hence if ΔE is the spacing between neighbouring levels near the Fermi level we must have

2 = (V√2 m3/2/π2ħ3) EF1/2 ΔE

(2 on the left side is to take care of both spins). Thus ΔE = √2 π2ħ3 / (V m3/2 EF1/2).

But EF1/2 = (ħ/(√2 m1/2))(3π2n)1/3. So ΔE = 2π2ħ2 / (mV(3π2n)1/3).

Substituting the data we get ΔE = 1.79 × 10−22 eV.

Teacher's Note: Each level holds two electrons, so spacing is 2 divided by states per energy at E_F; it is tiny.

Exam Note: Remember spin factor 2 in counting levels.

Question 202. Making use of Eq. (6.4g), find at T = 0: (a) the velocity distribution of free electrons; (b) the ratio of the mean velocity of free electrons to their maximum velocity.

Solution. (a) From dn(E) = (√2 m3/2/π2ħ3) E1/2 dE, we get on using E = ½mv2, dn(E) = dn(v):

dn(v) = (√2 m3/2/π2ħ3) (1/√2) m1/2 v · mv dv = (m3/π2ħ3) v2 dv.

This holds for 0 < v < vF, where ½mvF2 = EF, and dn(v) = 0 for v > vF.

(b) The mean velocity is ⟨v⟩ = ∫0vF v3dv / ∫0vF v2dv = (3/4) vF.

∴ ⟨v⟩/vF = 3/4.

Teacher's Note: Change variable from E to v using dE = mv dv; the distribution is parabolic (∝v²) up to v_F.

Exam Note: Result: dn ∝ v²dv; mean = 3/4 v_F.

Question 203. On the basis of Eq. (6.4g) find the number of free electrons in a metal at T = 0 as a function of de Broglie wavelengths.

Solution. Using the formula of the previous section, dn(v) = (m3/π2ħ3) v2 dv. We put mv = 2πħ/λ, where λ = de Broglie wavelength, so m dv = −(2πħ/λ2) dλ.

Taking account of the fact that λ decreases when v increases we write

dn(λ) = −dn(v) = ((2π)3/(π2λ4)) dλ = (8π/λ4) dλ.

Teacher's Note: Substitute p = mv = h/λ; the minus sign only reflects λ falling as v rises, so use magnitude.

Exam Note: Use mv = 2πħ/λ and take |dv|.

Question 204. Calculate the electronic gas pressure in metallic sodium, at T = 0, in which the concentration of free electrons is n = 2.5 × 1022 cm−3. Use the equation for the pressure of ideal gas.

Solution. From the kinetic theory of gases we know p = (2/3) U/V. Here U is the total internal energy of the gas. This result is applicable to a Fermi gas also. Now at T = 0, U = U0 = N⟨E⟩ = nV⟨E⟩, so

p = (2/3) n⟨E⟩ = (2/3) n × (3/5)EF = (2/5) nEF = (ħ2/5m)(3π2)2/3 n5/3.

Substituting the values we get p = 4.92 × 104 atm (≈ 5.0 × 109 Pa).

Teacher's Note: Ideal-gas p = (2/3)(energy density) still holds for a Fermi gas; use ⟨E⟩ = 3E_F/5 at T = 0.

Exam Note: Final: p = (2/5)nE_F.

Question 205. The increase in temperature of a cathode in electronic tube by ΔT = 1.0 K from the value T = 2000 K results in the increase of saturation current by η = 1.4%. Find the work function of electron for the material of the cathode.

Solution. From Richardson's equation I = aT2e−A/kT, where A is the work function in eV. When T increases by ΔT, I increases to (1 + η)I. Then

1 + η = ((T + ΔT)/T)2 e−(A/k)(1/(T+ΔT) − 1/T) = (1 + ΔT/T)2 e(A/kT) · ΔT/(T+ΔT).

Expanding and neglecting higher powers of ΔT/T we get η = 2ΔT/T + (A/kT2) ΔT.

Thus A = kT (ηT/ΔT − 2).

Substituting we get A = 4.48 eV.

Teacher's Note: Take log-derivative of Richardson current: dI/I = (2/T + A/kT²)dT; solve for A.

Exam Note: Use small ΔT expansion; A = kT(ηT/ΔT − 2).

Question 206. Find the refractive index of metallic sodium for electrons with kinetic energy T = 135 eV. Only one free electron is assumed to correspond to each sodium atom.

Solution.

AEF−U0outsideinsideoutinsideαβ

The potential energy inside the metal is −U0 for the electron and it is related to the work function A by U0 = EF + A.

If T is the K.E. of electrons outside the metal, its K.E. inside the metal will be (T + U0). On entering the metal an electron cannot experience any tangential force, so the tangential component of momentum is unchanged. Then

√(2mT) sin α = √(2m(T + U0)) sin β.

Hence sin α/sin β = √(1 + U0/T) = n by the definition of refractive index.

In sodium with one free electron per Na atom: ne = 2.54 × 1022 per cc, EF = 3.15 eV, A = 2.27 eV (from table), U0 = 5.42 eV.

Hence n = √(1 + 5.42/135) = 1.02. (Corrected: the book prints "n = 102", a misprint; the formula gives 1.02.)

Teacher's Note: Tangential momentum is conserved at the surface; the electron gains kinetic energy U₀ = E_F + A on entering.

Exam Note: Note n is just above 1 for fast electrons.

Question 207. Find the minimum energy of electron-hole pair formation in an impurity-free semiconductor whose electric conductance increases η = 5.0 times when the temperature increases from T1 = 300 K to T2 = 400 K.

Solution. In a pure (intrinsic) semiconductor the conductivity is related to the temperature by the following formula very closely: σ = σ0 e−Δε/2kT, where Δε is the energy gap between the top of the valence band and the bottom of the conduction band; it is also the minimum energy required for the formation of an electron-hole pair. The conductivity increases with temperature and we have

η = e(Δε/2k)(1/T1 − 1/T2), or ln η = (Δε/2k)(T2 − T1)/(T1T2).

Hence Δε = [2kT1T2/(T2 − T1)] ln η.

Substitution gives Δε = 0.333 eV = Emin.

Teacher's Note: Intrinsic conductance ∝ exp(−Δε/2kT); take the ratio at two temperatures to eliminate σ₀.

Exam Note: Write σ ∝ e^(−Δε/2kT) before taking ratio.

Question 208. At very low temperatures the photoelectric threshold short wavelength in an impurity-free germanium is equal to λth = 1.7 μm. Find the temperature coefficient of resistance of this germanium sample at room temperature.

Solution. The photoelectric threshold determines the band gap Δε by Δε = 2πħc/λth.

On the other hand the temperature coefficient of resistance is defined by (ρ is resistivity) α = (1/ρ) dρ/dT = d ln ρ/dT = −d ln σ/dT, where σ is the conductivity. But ln σ = ln σ0 − Δε/2kT.

Then α = −Δε/(2kT2) = −πħc/(kT2λth) = −0.047 K−1 (at room temperature T = 300 K).

Teacher's Note: Band gap equals photon energy at threshold; differentiate ln σ = ln σ₀ − Δε/2kT for the coefficient.

Exam Note: Negative α: resistance falls as T rises.

Question 209. Fig. 6.11 illustrates logarithmic electric conductance as a function of reciprocal temperature (T−1 in kK−1 units) for some n-type semiconductor. Using this plot, find the width of the forbidden band of the semiconductor and the activation energy of donor levels.
012345024681/T (kK−1)ln σ

Fig. 6.11 (redrawn approximately from the book's graph).

Solution. At high temperatures (small values of T−1) most of the conductivity is intrinsic, i.e. it is due to the transition of electrons from the upper levels of the valence band into the lower levels of the conduction band. For this we can apply approximately the formula σ = σ0 exp(−Eg/2kT), or ln σ = ln σ0 − Eg/2kT.

From this we get the band gap Eg = −2k Δ ln σ/Δ(1/T). The slope must be calculated at small 1/T. Evaluation gives −Δ ln σ/Δ(1/T) = 7000 K. Hence Eg = 1.21 eV.

At low temperatures (high values of 1/T) the conductance is mostly due to impurities. If E0 is the ionization energy of donor levels then we can write the approximate formula (valid at low temperature) σ′ = σ′0 exp(−E0/2kT). So E0 = −2k Δ ln σ′/Δ(1/T). The slope must be calculated at low temperatures. Evaluation gives the slope −Δ ln σ′/Δ(1/T) = (1/3) × 1000 K.

Then E0 ≈ 0.057 eV.

Teacher's Note: Steep region (intrinsic) gives the gap, shallow region (impurity) gives donor energy; both use 2k × slope.

Exam Note: Energy = 2k × slope of each region.

Question 210. The resistivity of an impurity-free semiconductor at room temperature is ρ = 50 Ω·cm. It becomes equal to ρ1 = 40 Ω·cm when the semiconductor is illuminated with light, and t = 8 ms after switching off the light source the resistivity becomes equal to ρ2 = 45 Ω·cm. Find the mean lifetime of conduction electrons and holes.

Solution. We write the conductivity of the sample as σ = σi + σγ, where σi = intrinsic conductivity and σγ is the photoconductivity. At t = 0, assuming saturation we have 1/ρ1 = 1/ρ + σγ0, or σγ0 = 1/ρ1 − 1/ρ.

Time t after the light source is switched off we have, because of recombination of electrons and holes in the sample, σ = σi + σγ0 e−t/τ, where τ = mean lifetime of electrons and holes.

Thus 1/ρ2 = 1/ρ + (1/ρ1 − 1/ρ) e−t/τ, or 1/ρ2 − 1/ρ = (1/ρ1 − 1/ρ) e−t/τ, or

et/τ = (1/ρ1 − 1/ρ)/(1/ρ2 − 1/ρ) = ρ2(ρ − ρ1)/(ρ1(ρ − ρ2)).

Hence τ = t / ln{ρ2(ρ − ρ1)/(ρ1(ρ − ρ2))}.

Substitution gives τ = 9.87 ms ≈ 0.01 s.

Teacher's Note: Excess (photo) conductivity decays exponentially after light is off; subtract the dark value before taking the ratio.

Exam Note: Work with conductivities, not resistivities, in the exponent.

Question 211. In Hall effect measurements a plate of width h = 10 mm and length l = 50 mm made of p-type semiconductor was placed in a magnetic field with induction B = 5.0 kG. A potential difference V = 10 V was applied across the edges of the plate. In this case the Hall field is VH = 50 mV and resistivity ρ = 2.5 Ω·cm. Find the concentration of holes and hole mobility.

Solution.

+V0BExlh

We shall ignore minority carriers. Drifting holes experience a sideways force in the magnetic field and react by setting up a Hall electric field Ey to counterbalance it. Thus vxB = Ey = VH/h.

If the concentration of carriers is n then jx = nevx. Hence n = jx/(evx) = jx/(eVH/hB) = jxhB/(eVH).

Also using jx = σEx = Ex/ρ = V/(ρl) we get n = VhB/(eρlVH).

Substituting the data (note that in MKS units B = 5.0 kG = 0.5 T), ρ = 2.5 × 10−2 Ω·m, we get n = 4.99 × 1021 m−3 = 4.99 × 1015 per cm3.

Also the mobility is u0 = vx/Ex = (VH/(hB)) · (l/V) = VHl/(hBV).

Substitution gives u0 = 0.05 m2/(V·s).

Teacher's Note: Hall field balances the magnetic force (E_y = vB); then n follows from current density j = nev and ρ.

Exam Note: Convert kG to tesla before substituting.

Question 212. In Hall effect measurements in a magnetic field with induction B = 5.0 kG the transverse electric field strength in an impurity-free germanium turned out to be η = 10 times less than the longitudinal electric field strength. Find the difference in the mobilities of conduction electrons and holes in the given semiconductor.

Solution.

Exvx−vx+

If an electric field Ex is present in a sample containing equal amounts of both electrons and holes, the two drift in opposite directions. In the presence of a magnetic field Bz = B they set up Hall voltages in opposite directions. The net Hall electric field is given by

Ey = (vx+ − vx−)B = (u0+ − u0−)ExB.

But Ey/Ex = 1/η. Hence |u0+ − u0−| = 1/(ηB).

Substitution gives |u0+ − u0−| = 0.2 m2/(V·s) (B = 5.0 kG = 0.5 T). (The minus sign between the two mobilities is lost in the printed formula; it is restored here.)

Teacher's Note: Equal electron and hole numbers: their Hall fields oppose, so only the mobility difference survives.

Exam Note: Use B = 0.5 T; answer is a difference.

Question 213. The Hall effect turned out to be not observable in a semiconductor whose conduction electron mobility was η = 2.0 times that of the hole mobility. Find the ratio of hole and conduction electron concentrations in that semiconductor.

Solution.

EyExvx−vx+B

When the sample contains unequal number of carriers of both types whose mobilities are different, static equilibrium (i.e. no transverse movement of either electron or holes) is impossible in a magnetic field. The transverse electric field acts differently on electrons and holes. If the Ey that is set up is as shown, the net Lorentz force per unit charge (effective transverse electric field) on electrons is Ey − vx−B and on holes Ey + vx+B (we are assuming B = Bz). There is then a transverse drift of electrons and holes and the net transverse current must vanish in equilibrium. Using mobility,

u0−Nee(Ey − u0−ExB) + Nheu0+(Ey + u0+ExB) = 0,

or Ey = [(Neu0−2 − Nhu0+2)/(Neu0− + Nhu0+)] ExB.

On the other hand jx = (Neu0− + Nhu0+)eEx. Thus the Hall coefficient is

RH = Ey/(jxB) = (1/e)(Neu0−2 − Nhu0+2)/(Neu0− + Nhu0+)2.

We see that RH = 0 when Ne/Nh = (u0+/u0−)2 = 1/η2 = 1/4.

Hence the ratio of hole to electron concentrations is Nh/Ne = η2 = 4.

Teacher's Note: Hall coefficient vanishes when N_e u_e² = N_h u_h²; the faster carrier needs the smaller concentration.

Exam Note: State answer as hole:electron = 4:1.

JEE Mathematics: IE Irodov Solutions for IE Irodov Solutions Chapter 37 Molecules And Crystals

Complete Math Solutions for IE Irodov Solutions Chapter 37 Molecules And Crystals

Access the complete chapter-wise PDF for IE Irodov Solutions Chapter 37 Molecules And Crystals. These structured IE Irodov Solutions solutions for JEE Mathematics help students build foundational accuracy and prepare effectively for upcoming school evaluations.

Concept-Driven Math Answers

Clear, methodical explanations accompany every challenging problem within the text. Engaging with these detailed mathematical breakdowns lays a solid foundation for advanced learning and improves execution speed for upcoming exams.

Complete Your JEE Exam Preparation

Maximize your academic readiness by pairing these solutions with our official sample papers and interactive practice tests. All supplementary study materials for the 2026 session are available across our platform free of charge.

FAQs

What are these IE Irodov Solutions for JEE Physics?

They are chapter-wise solved questions from the IE Irodov book for JEE Physics. Each answer is explained step by step so you can check your work and revise.

Are the IE Irodov JEE Physics Solutions free to read?

Yes. All chapters can be read online for free on a phone, tablet or computer, and no sign-up is needed.

How should I use these IE Irodov solutions for JEE Physics?

Try each question on your own first, then read the solution. Use it to check your steps, correct mistakes and learn how a full answer is written.

Will practising IE Irodov JEE Physics questions help in exams?

Regular practice improves accuracy and speed and shows which topics need more revision. It works best alongside your textbook and class notes.

Are these solutions arranged chapter by chapter?

Yes. The chapter list on this page links to every chapter’s solved questions, so you can open the topic you are studying.

Which session are these JEE Physics Solutions for?

They are listed for the 2026-27 session. Check that the questions match the textbook edition you use.