Get the most accurate RBSE Solutions for Class 11 English Chapter 2 Living Or Dead here. Updated for the 2026-27 academic session, these solutions are based on the latest RBSE textbooks for Class 11 English. Our expert-created answers for Class 11 English are available for free download in PDF format.
Detailed Chapter 2 Living Or Dead RBSE Solutions for Class 11 English
For Class 11 students, solving RBSE textbook questions is the most effective way to build a strong conceptual foundation. Our Class 11 English solutions follow a detailed, step-by-step approach to ensure you understand the logic behind every answer. Practicing these Chapter 2 Living Or Dead solutions will improve your exam performance.
Class 11 English Chapter 2 Living Or Dead RBSE Solutions PDF
Comprehension
(A) Tick the Correct Alternative:
Question 1. Jogmaya is Kadambini's.
(a) Sister
(b) Aunt.
(c) Sister-in-law
(d) Childhood friend
Answer: (d) Childhood friend
In simple words: In the story, Jogmaya is described as being a childhood friend to Kadambini. They have a long-standing history together from their younger days.
🎯 Exam Tip: Pay attention to character relationships and key descriptive words provided in the story to correctly identify connections between individuals.
Question 3. Kadambini plunges herself into a .......
(a) well
(b) river
(c) sea
(d) stream
Answer: (a) well
In simple words: Towards the end of the story, Kadambini, feeling lost and misunderstood, chooses to end her life by jumping into a well. This act shows her despair.
🎯 Exam Tip: Remember the critical turning points and dramatic events in the narrative, as these often highlight character choices and plot developments.
(B) Answer to the following questions should not exceed 10-15 words each:
Question 1. Why does Kadambini love her brother-in-law's son so much? कादम्बिनी अपने देवर के पुत्र को बहुत ज्यादा पसंद क्यों करती है?
Answer: Kadambini loves her brother-in-law's son a lot because she has brought him up and nurtured him. Her love comes from raising him herself, creating a deep bond.
कादम्बिनी अपने देवर के पुत्र को बहुत ज्यादा पसंद इसलिए करती है क्योंकि उसने उसका पालनपोषण किया है।
In simple words: Kadambini loves her brother-in-law's son greatly because she raised him as her own.
🎯 Exam Tip: When explaining character motivations, always connect their actions to their relationships or past experiences mentioned in the story.
Question 2. Why does the child ask Kadambini to go away? बच्चा कादम्बिनी को दूर जाने के लिए क्यों कहता है?
Answer: The child asks Kadambini to go away because he feels scared of her presence. The child's fear causes him to reject her.
बच्चा कादम्बिनी को दूर जाने के लिए इसलिए कहता है क्योंकि वह उससे डर गया है।
In simple words: The child tells Kadambini to leave because he is afraid of her.
🎯 Exam Tip: In questions about character interactions, identify the core emotion driving the action, such as fear or love.
Question 3. Why does Kadambini leave her friend's house? कादम्बिनी अपनी सहेली का घर क्यों छोड़ती है?
Answer: Kadambini leaves her friend's house because there is an argument between her friend and her husband. She feels uncomfortable with the tension between them.
Kadambini leaves her friend's house because there is a quarrel between her friend and her husband in her
In simple words: Kadambini leaves her friend's house due to a fight between her friend and the friend's husband.
🎯 Exam Tip: Note down the reasons behind characters' major decisions or movements, as these are crucial plot points.
Question 4. कादम्बिनी को क्या समझा जाता है जब वह वापिस अपने ससुराल जाती है?
Answer: When Kadambini goes back to her in-laws' house, she is seen as a departed soul. Her family members treat her as if she is a ghost or dead person.
Kadambini is regarded a dead soul after she goes fack to her in-laws' house.
कादम्बिनी को वापस अपने ससुराल जाने के बाद उसे एक मृतात्मा समझा जाता है।
In simple words: After returning to her in-laws' home, Kadambini is thought of as a dead soul.
🎯 Exam Tip: Understand how societal beliefs and superstitions influence characters' perceptions and treatment of others in the story.
Question 5. Why does zamindar decide to burn the body of Kadambini without ceremony? जमींदार कादम्बिनी के शव को बिना धार्मिक विधि के जलाने का निश्चय क्यों करता है?
Answer: The zamindar decides to burn Kadambini's body without any religious rites because he is worried about trouble from the police. He fears police harassment if he follows the traditional ceremonies.
Zamindar decides it because he is afraid of the police's harassment.
जमींदार ऐसा निर्णय इसलिए लेता है क्योंकि उसे पुलिस के उत्पीड़न का डर है।
In simple words: The zamindar decides to burn Kadambini's body quickly to avoid problems with the police.
🎯 Exam Tip: Always consider external factors like fear of authority or social consequences when analyzing characters' decisions.
(C) Answer to the following questions should not exceed 20-30 words each:
Question 1. Why does the author say, "If a woman fosters another's child, her love for him is all the more stronger?” लेखक क्यों कहता है, "अगर एक औरत दूसरे के बच्चे का पालन-पोषण करती है, उसके लिए उसका स्नेह और सभी से प्रबल होता है।"
Answer: The author says this because a woman who fosters a child has no claim of family relation or kinship over him, only the bond of pure affection. This selfless love makes the bond very powerful.
The author says so because she has no claim upon him, no claim of kinship, that is but simply the claim of love.
लेखक ऐसा इसलिए कहता है क्योंकि वह उस पर, उसकी रिश्तेदारी पर कोई अधिकार नहीं रखती है, वह केवल स्नेह का दावा रखती है।
In simple words: The author believes a woman's love for a fostered child is stronger because it's based purely on affection, not family ties.
🎯 Exam Tip: When analyzing author's quotes, identify the underlying theme or message being conveyed about human nature or relationships.
Question 2. Why do Nitai and Gurucharan abuse Bidhu and Banamali? नीताई तथा गुरुचरण, बिधू तथा बनमाली को क्यों गाली देते हैं?
Answer: Nitai and Gurucharan scold Bidhu and Banamali because they went to collect wood but did not return on time. Their delay causes frustration and anger.
Nitai and Gurucharan abuse Bidhu and Banamali because they have gone to fetch the wood but do not return at time.
नीताई तथा गुरुचरण, बिधू तथा बनमाली को गाली देते हैं क्योंकि वे लकड़ियाँ लाने के लिए गये हैं। लेकिन समय पर नहीं लौटते हैं।
In simple words: Nitai and Gurucharan are angry with Bidhu and Banamali because they are late returning with wood.
🎯 Exam Tip: Focus on immediate causes and effects in character interactions to understand conflicts and reactions.
Question 3. What is one of the maid servants reaction when she sees Kadambini back in the house?
Answer: When a maid servant sees Kadambini return, she drops the tray she is carrying. She is completely shocked and frightened, showing her belief that Kadambini is a ghost.
In simple words: A maid servant drops her tray out of shock and fear upon seeing Kadambini back.
🎯 Exam Tip: Character reactions, especially non-verbal ones, often reveal deeper emotions and beliefs within the story.
Question 4. Why is Sripati perplexed when he returns from Ranihat? श्रीपति हैरान क्यों होता है जब वह रानीहट से वापिस लौट आता है?
Answer: Sripati is confused when he comes back from Ranihat because he discovers that the woman living in his house is not actually Kadambini. This unexpected discovery leaves him very puzzled.
When Sripati returns from Ranihat, he is perplexed because he comes to know that the woman who is living in his house, is not Kadambini.
जब श्रीपति रानीहट से लौट आता है, वह हैरान है क्योंकि वह जान जाता है कि वह औरत जो उसके घर में रह रही है, कादम्बिनी नहीं है।
In simple words: Sripati is perplexed after returning from Ranihat because he finds out the woman in his house is not Kadambini.
🎯 Exam Tip: Look for plot twists or moments of revelation, as they are crucial for understanding the story's development.
Question 5. Why does Jogmaya upbraid her husband? जोगमाया अपने पति की भर्त्सना क्यों करती है?
Answer: Jogmaya scolds her husband because he did not suggest that Kadambini should leave their house. She is upset that he did not object to Kadambini's continued presence.
Jogmaya upbraids her husband because he has not hinted that Kadambini should go away. Even he does not protest her presence in the house.
जोगमाया अपने पति की भर्त्सना करती है क्योंकि उसने कोई भी संकेत नहीं दिया है कि कादम्बिनी को कहीं और जाना चाहिए। यहाँ तक कि वह उसकी मौजूदगी का भी विरोध नहीं करता है।
In simple words: Jogmaya scolds her husband because he did not tell Kadambini to leave or object to her being there.
🎯 Exam Tip: Pay attention to disagreements between characters to understand their differing viewpoints and the conflicts within the story.
(D) Answer to the following questions should not exceed 60-80 words each:
Question 1. Trace the journey of Kadambini from a loving, caring aunt to a dead, dreadful ghost. कादम्बिनी की एक स्नेही, परवाह करने वाली चाची से एक मृत, भयानक भूत तक की यात्रा की रूपरेखा प्रस्तुत कीजिए।
Answer: Kadambini, a widow, lives in the house of Saradsankar and deeply loves his son, whom she raised and who calls her 'Auntie'. One day, her heart seemingly stops beating, and she is taken for cremation. However, she is not truly dead, but has only suffered a momentary heart attack. When she returns to her in-laws' house, everyone, including the child, perceives her as a ghost and is terrified. This leads to her ultimately falling into a well and dying. Her tragic journey highlights the harsh realities and superstitions faced by women in her society.
Kadambini is a widow in the house of Saradsankar, the Ranihat zamindar. The child of her brother-in-law Saradsankar is her darling. She has fostered him. The child calls her 'Auntie, Auntie”. For some reason her heart stops beating. She is taken to funeral ground. In fact she is not dead. It has been because of heart beating. When she reaches her friend's house, she is considered a ghost. She returns to her in-law's house. All the members of the family are afraid of her. Even the child asks her to go away. At last she falls into a well and dies.
कादम्बिनी, रानीहट के जमींदार शारदाशंकर के घर में एक विधवा है। उसके देवर, शारदाशंकर का बच्चा, उसका लाडला है। उसने उसका पालन-पोषण किया है। बच्चा उसे चाची-चाची' पुकारता है। किसी कारणवश कादम्बिनी के हृदय की धड़कन बन्द हो जाती
In simple words: Kadambini transforms from a loving aunt who seemed to die and then returned, only to be feared as a ghost by her family, including the child she raised. This fear and rejection ultimately lead to her real death.
🎯 Exam Tip: When tracing a character's journey, highlight key turning points that change their status or the perception others have of them, as well as the societal context influencing these changes.
Question 2. Discuss 'Living or Dead?' as a story of love and betrayal. 'जीवित या मृत' कहानी का 'प्रेम और धोखा' के रूप में वर्णन करे।
Answer: "Living or Dead?" is a poignant tale about affection and deception. It depicts Kadambini's tragic shift from a devoted aunt to a perceived ghost. The story powerfully critiques a society that views a widow as a burden, emphasizing the oppression women face. Kadambini's struggle between the worlds of the living and the dead is vividly portrayed, highlighting our indifference towards living individuals while revering the deceased. The narrative begins with love but tragically concludes with betrayal, exposing deep societal flaws. This journey makes the reader think about how people are valued.
"Living or Dead' is a sensitive story about love and betrayal. It traces the journey of a widow Kadambini from a long, caring aunt to a dreaded ghost. It powerfully exposes the oppressiveness of a system that considers a woman as burden the moment – her husband dies. The pathos of Kadambini vacillating between the two worlds of living and dead is intensely brought out. A satire on society, the story hints at our callousness also in ignoring a living woman and showing reverence to the dead ones. It begins with love and ends at betrayal.
'जीवित या मृत' प्रेम तथा धोखा के बारे में एक संवेदनशील कहानी है। यह एक लम्बे समय से विधवा, कादम्बिनी की देखभाल करने वाली चाची से एक भयानक भूत की यात्रा की रूपरेखा प्रस्तुत करती है। यह एक ऐसी व्यवस्था जो एक औरत को अपने पति के देहान्त के क्षण से बोझ जैसा मानती है, के विषाद को प्रभावशाली ढंग से दर्शाती है। यह दो संसार 'जीवन तथा मरण' के बीच की दुविधा में पड़ी हुई कादम्बिनी की कारुणिकता को स्पष्ट करती है। समाज पर एक व्यंग्य यह कहानी जीवित औरत को नकारने की हमारी बेरुखी तथा मृत के प्रति सम्मान दर्शाती है। यह प्रेम से शुरू होती है तथा धोखे पर समाप्त हो जाती है।
In simple words: The story "Living or Dead?" explores themes of love and betrayal through Kadambini's journey, showing how society treats a widow as a burden and ignores her while she is alive, only to fear her as a ghost.
🎯 Exam Tip: When discussing themes, provide specific examples from the story to illustrate how love, betrayal, or societal critique are developed throughout the narrative.
(E) Say whether the following statements are True or False. Write 'T' for True and 'F' for False in the bracket:
Question 1. Say whether the following statements are True or False. Write 'T' for True and 'F' for False in the bracket:
1. Kadambini is a childless widow.
2. The child does not love Kadambini.
3. A Jackal takes away the body of Kadambini.
4. The child that Kadambini loves is the son of her brother.
5. By dying Kadambini gives proof that she is not dead.
Answer:
1. True
2. False
3. False
4. False
5. True
In simple words: This section checks your understanding of the story by asking you to decide if each given statement is correct (True) or incorrect (False). You must mark T or F next to each.
🎯 Exam Tip: Read each statement carefully and recall the events of the story to determine if it is factually correct or incorrect based on the narrative details.
RBSE Class 11 English Delight & Wisdom Chapter 2 Additional Questions
Question 2. When did Bidhu and Banamali begin to tremble? बिधू और बनमाली कब काँपने लगे?
Answer: Bidhu and Banamali started trembling when the dead body unexpectedly turned onto its side. They imagined that the bed had shaken slightly, which scared them deeply.
Bidhu and Banamali began to tremble when the dead body turned on its side. They fancied that the bed shook slightly.
जब लाश ने अपनी करवट बदली, बिधू और बनमाली काँपने लगे। उन्होंने सोचा कि बिस्तर थोड़ा-सा हिला था।
In simple words: Bidhu and Banamali started shaking when the dead body moved, making them think the bed shook.
🎯 Exam Tip: Identify the specific event that triggers a strong emotional or physical reaction in characters, as this often indicates a significant plot point.
Question 3. What did the four men decide when they could not find the dead body? जब चारों आदमी लाश को ढूंढ़ नहीं पाये, उन्होंने क्या निश्चय किया?
Answer: When the four men could not find the dead body, they decided to tell everyone that it had been cremated. This was their way of explaining the missing body to others.
When the four men could not find the dead body they decided to say that it had been burnt.
जब चारों आदमी लाश को ढूंढ़ नहीं पाये, उन्होंने यह कहने का निश्चय किया कि उसे जला दिया गया था।
In simple words: The four men decided to say the body had been burnt when they couldn't find it.
🎯 Exam Tip: Note down characters' solutions to problems, especially when they involve deception or covering up events.
Question 4. Why was Kadambini looking like a mad woman? कादम्बिनी एक पागल औरत जैसी क्यों दिख रही थी?
Answer: Kadambini looked like a mad woman because her clothes were covered in mud. Her appearance was so disheveled and strange that it might have caused people to be afraid of her.
Kadambini was looking like a mad woman because her clothes were clotted in the mud. Her apparition was such that folk might have been afraid of her.
कादम्बिनी एक पागल औरत जैसी दिख रही थी क्योंकि उसके कपड़ों में कीचड़ के थक्के बन गये थे। उसकी प्रेतछाया ऐसी थी कि लोग उससे डर सकते थे।
In simple words: Kadambini looked like a mad woman because her muddy clothes and strange appearance made people fear her.
🎯 Exam Tip: Descriptions of a character's physical state often reflect their internal turmoil or the challenging circumstances they are facing.
Question 5. Why did none of the door-keepers object Kadambini when she entered the house?
Answer: None of the door-keepers stopped Kadambini when she entered the house because her face was mostly covered. They mistook her for a maid or servant, and so allowed her to pass without question.
जब कादम्बिनी ने घर में प्रवेश किया, किसी भी द्वारपाल ने उसका विरोध नहीं किया क्योंकि उसके चेहरे पर मोटा-सा पर्दा था। उन्होंने उसे एक नौकर समझा।
In simple words: The door-keepers did not stop Kadambini because her face was covered, and they thought she was a servant.
🎯 Exam Tip: Details about disguises or misidentification often play a critical role in how characters move through the story without being recognized.
Question 6. What did Kadambini see in the lighted room? कादम्बिनी ने प्रकाशयुक्त कमरे में क्या देखा?
Answer: In the well-lit room, Kadambini saw the child sleeping soundly. She noticed his fists were clenched and his body looked weakened from a fever. This sight filled her with a mix of sadness and love.
In the lighted room, Kadambini saw the child sleeping, his fists clenched and his body wasted with fever.
प्रकाश वाले कमरे में कादम्बिनी ने बच्चे को सोते हुए देखा, उसकी मुट्ठियाँ भिंची हई थीं तथा उसके शरीर को बुखार से दुर्बल अवस्था में देखा।
In simple words: Kadambini saw the child sleeping in the bright room, with clenched fists and a fever-weakened body.
🎯 Exam Tip: Observe the details of a scene through a character's eyes to understand their emotions and the significance of what they see.
Question 7. What does Rabindranath Tagore say about love through his “Living or Dead” story? रबीन्द्रनाथ टैगोर अपनी कहानी 'जीवित या मृत' के माध्यम से प्रेम के बारे में क्या कहते हैं?
Answer: Rabindranath Tagore suggests that genuine love does not need any formal proof or social acceptance to exist. It simply cherishes its precious, uncertain existence with deep passion. The story highlights love's inherent value.
Rabindranath Tagore says that love cannot prove its claim by any document which society accepts, and does not wish to prove it. It merely worships with double passion its life's uncertain treasure.
रबीन्द्रनाथ टैगोर कहते हैं कि प्रेम अपना दावा किसी भी दस्तावेज से सिद्ध नहीं कर सकता है जिसे समाज स्वीकार करता है और इसे सिद्ध करने की इच्छा नहीं होती है। इसकी केवल दोगुने भावावेश से इसके अस्तित्व के अविश्वसनीय खजाने से पूजा की जाती है।
In simple words: Tagore shows that true love doesn't need proof or social approval; it simply treasures its presence.
🎯 Exam Tip: When analyzing an author's message about a theme, synthesize their ideas into a clear statement supported by the story's events.
Question 8. What did the four men notice after returning to the hut? झोंपड़ी में लौटने के बाद उन चारों व्यक्तियों ने क्या देखा?
Answer: After returning to the hut, the four men discovered that the dead body was gone, and only an empty bed remained. They also noticed fresh footprints of a woman in the mud near the door, suggesting someone had left recently.
When the four men returned to the hut, they found the dead body missing. There was only an empty bed. They saw newly made footprints on the mud at the door.
जब चारों आदमी झोंपड़ी में लौटे, उन्होंने लाश को गायब पाया, वहाँ केवल खाली बिस्तर था। उन्होंने दरवाजे के पास इकट्ठी हुई कीचड़ में किसी महिला के ताजे पदचिन्ह देखे।
In simple words: The four men returned to the hut to find the dead body missing, only an empty bed, and fresh female footprints by the door.
🎯 Exam Tip: Pay attention to investigative details, such as missing items or physical evidence, as they often reveal key plot developments or mysteries.
Question 9. What do the four men tell to the men who have arrived with wood?
🎯 Exam Tip: If a question lacks an answer in the source, it might be an open-ended discussion prompt. Focus on key details and infer plausible responses.
Question 10. How does Kadambini feel after snapping all the bonds? सभी बन्धनों को तोड़ डालने के बाद, कादम्बिनी कैसा महसूस करती है?
Answer: After breaking free from all her ties, Kadambini experiences immense strength and limitless freedom. She feels empowered to do whatever she desires and go wherever she pleases, finally feeling unburdened.
After snapping all the bonds, Kadambini feels that she has marvelous strength and endless freedom. She can do what she likes, go where she pleases.
सभी बन्धनों को तोड़ डालने के बाद, कादम्बिनी महसूस करती है कि उसके पास शानदार ताकत और बेहद आजादी है। वह वो कर सकती है जो वह चाहती है, वहाँ जा सकती है जहाँ जाना पसन्द करती
In simple words: Kadambini feels very strong and completely free after letting go of all her connections, able to do and go anywhere she wishes.
🎯 Exam Tip: Character emotions related to freedom or burden are important for understanding their psychological journey in the story.
Question 11. Why has there been quarrels between Kadambini and her friend Jogmaya? कादम्बिनी तथा उसकी सहेली जोगमाया के बीच झगड़े क्यों रहे हैं?
Answer: Kadambini and her friend Jogmaya have argued because Kadambini wants to show that her love for Jogmaya is boundless. However, Jogmaya complains that Kadambini does not reciprocate the same level of affection. This difference in perception leads to conflict.
There have been quarrels between Kadambini and her friend, Jogmaya because Kadambini has wished to make it clear that her love for her is unbounded while her friend complains that she does not return a love equal to her own.
कादम्बिनी तथा उसकी सहेली, जोगमाया के बीच झगड़े रहे हैं क्योंकि कादम्बिनी की यह स्पष्ट करने की इच्छा रही है कि उसका प्रेम उसके प्रति असीम है जबकि उसकी सहेली शिकायत करती है कि वह उसके जितना प्रेम नहीं करती है।
In simple words: Kadambini and Jogmaya argue because Kadambini shows endless love, but Jogmaya feels that love is not returned equally.
🎯 Exam Tip: Understand that misinterpretations of affection or perceived imbalances in relationships can often lead to conflicts between characters.
Question 12. What does Kadambini think about Jogmaya after reaching her house? कादम्बिनी, जोगमाया के बारे में उसके घर पर पहुँचने के बाद क्या सोचती है?
Answer: After arriving at Jogmaya's house, Kadambini thinks that Jogmaya has her own husband and a stable home. She realizes that her own existence is far removed from such domesticity. Kadambini believes she shares emotions and duties with people generally.
After reaching Jogmaya's house, Kadambini thinks about her that she has her husband and her home. She herself lives in a world far away from hers. She shares affection and duty with the people of the world.
जोगमाया के घर पहुँचने के बाद, कादम्बिनी उसके बारे में सोचती है कि उसके पास उसका पति तथा घर है। वह स्वयं उसके संसार से काफी दूर रहती है। वह संसार के लोगों के साथ अपना स्नेह तथा कर्तव्य आदान-प्रदान करती है।
In simple words: Upon reaching Jogmaya's house, Kadambini reflects that Jogmaya has a complete family life, while she herself lives a very different, detached life.
🎯 Exam Tip: Character reflections, especially when comparing their own situation to others, reveal their innermost thoughts and the themes of alienation or belonging.
Question 13. रबीन्द्रनाथ टैगोर पुरुष जाति के लिए कहता है कि वे नारी जाति के प्रति स्वाभाविक तरफदार होते हैं। जिसके लिए नारी उन्हें अपने आप उनके प्रति उत्तरदायी ठहराती है।
Answer: Rabindranath Tagore suggests that men often show a natural bias towards women, and women, in turn, hold them responsible for this predisposition. This dynamic highlights inherent societal expectations and gender roles.
for which women themselves hold them accountable.
In simple words: Tagore means that men naturally favor women, and women often blame men for this biased behavior.
🎯 Exam Tip: When interpreting an author's social commentary, focus on the power dynamics and responsibilities assigned to different groups.
Question 14. When does Kadambini understand that she has not died? कादम्बिनी कब समझती है कि वह मरी नहीं है?
Answer: Kadambini realizes she is not dead when she begins to feel familiar surroundings—the old room, the old objects, and the familiar love of the same child. This sense of recognition helps her comprehend her survival.
Kadambini understands that she has not died when she feels the old room, the old things, the same child, the same love etc. I
कादम्बिनी उस समय समझती है है कि वह मरी नहीं है जब वह उसी पुराने कमरे, पुरानी चीजों, उसी बच्चे, उसी प्रेम आदि को महसूस करती है।
In simple words: Kadambini understands she is alive when she recognizes her old room, belongings, and the child's love.
🎯 Exam Tip: Moments of realization are key in character development; they often occur when familiar sensory details provide comfort or clarity.
B. Answer to the following questions should not exceed 50-60 words each:
Question 1. What did Kadambini remember when her consciousness returned? कादम्बिनी ने क्या याद किया जब वह होश में लौट आई?
Answer: When Kadambini regained consciousness, she first saw complete darkness. She realized she wasn't in her usual spot and remembered her deathbed, a sharp pain in her chest, and a suffocating feeling. She recalled collapsing onto the bed while her sister-in-law warmed milk for the child. Everything after that was a blur, like overturned ink, making all her memories formless for a moment. Her return to consciousness was a confusing and disorienting experience.
When consciousness returned, she saw dense darkness on all sides. It occurred to her that she was not lying in her usual place. She remembered her death-bed, the sudden pain at her breast and the beginning of a choking sensation. Her elder sister-in-law was warming some milk for the child when she became faint and fell on the bed. After that everything was black as when an ink-pot is upset over an exercise-book. Her memory and consciousness, all the letters of the world's book, in a moment became formless.
जब होश आया, उसने चारों तरफ घना अंधेरा देखा। उसे सूझ गया कि वह अपने हमेशा वाले स्थान पर नहीं थी। उसने अपने मौत-बिस्तर, अपने सीने का अचानक दर्द तथा अपने सांस रुकने की सनसनी को याद किया। जब वह बेहोश हुई तथा बिस्तर पर गिर गई, उसकी बड़ी देवरानी बच्चे के लिए दूध गर्म कर रही थी। इसके बाद सब ओर अंधेरा छा गया जैसे एक स्याही की दवात एक अभ्यास पुस्तिका पर उल्टी हो जाती है। उसकी याददाश्त और होश, संसार की किताबों के अक्षर, सभी एक ही क्षण में आकारहीन हो गये।
In simple words: When Kadambini woke up, she remembered being in darkness, a chest pain, and falling onto her deathbed. All her memories felt jumbled and unclear for a moment.
🎯 Exam Tip: When describing a character's return to consciousness, detail their sensory perceptions and fragmented memories to convey the experience effectively.
Question 2. Discuss the first thought of Kadambini about returning to her home. कादम्बिनी का, अपने घर लौटने के बारे में प्रथम विचार का वर्णन कीजिए।
Answer: Kadambini's initial thought was to return home. However, she quickly reconsidered, thinking, "I am dead. How can I go home? This would bring disaster upon them. I have left the realm of the living; I am a ghost myself." Recalling her moment of apparent death in Saradsankar's bright room, she found herself in a distant, desolate, and overgrown burning ground. She recognized that she no longer belonged to ordinary society. This profound realization of her changed state fills her with sadness.
उसका पहला विचार घर लौटने का था । लेकिन फिर भी उसने विचार किया : "मैं मर गई हूँ। मैं घर कैसे लौट सकती हूँ? इससे उन पर आपदा आयेगी। मैं जीवितों के राज्य (स्थान) को छोड़ चुकी हूँ। मैं स्वयं का भूत हूँ।” शारदाशंकर के चमकीले रोशन-घर में अपनी मौत के क्षण को याद करती हुई, उसने अपने आपको एक दूर स्थान, बंजर, घने जलते हुए स्थल पर अकेली पाया। निश्चित रूप से वह सांसारिक समाज की सदस्या नहीं थी।
In simple words: Kadambini first wanted to go home but then realized she was considered dead. She felt she was a ghost and no longer belonged to the living world, which made her feel very lonely.
🎯 Exam Tip: Focus on the internal conflict and shifting perceptions a character experiences, especially when facing a major life-altering event like perceived death.
Question 3. Compare and contrast Mrs. Jogmaya and Mr. Sripati. श्रीमती जोगमाया तथा श्रीपति की तुलना करो।
Answer: Jogmaya is Kadambini's childhood friend; though they haven't met since youth, they exchange letters. She welcomes Kadambini but struggles with the reality of her friend's situation, fearing her after learning the truth. Jogmaya wants Kadambini to leave, becoming uneasy with her presence. In contrast, Mr. Sripati is her friend, who, after discovering the facts, makes clear and objective judgments. He is more rational and less emotionally swayed than his wife, who remains worried. Sripati tries to understand the situation calmly.
Jogmaya is the friend of Kadambini. They have not seen since the days of their youth, but time to time they have exchanged letters. When Kadambini comes to her, she is welcomed. But she is not at one with her friend, death is between them. Jogmaya starts knowing her facts. Now she is afraid of her. She wants to make her flee from the house. Mr. Sripati tells her that she is not real friend Kadambini. He takes each judgement after knowing the facts while her wife is uneasy.
जोगमाया, की तरह की सहेली है। उन्होंने अपनी युवावस्था के दिनों से एक-दूसरे को नहीं देखा है। लेकिन समय-समय पर उन्होंने पत्र व्यवहार रखा है। जब कादम्बिनी उसके घर आती है, उसका स्वागत किया जाती है। लेकिन वह अपनी सहेली के साथ अकेली नहीं है, उनके बीच में मृत्यु है। जोगमाया .उसकी सत्यता जानने लगती है। अब वह उससे डर जाती है। वह उसे घर से भगाना चाहती है। श्रीपति उसे बताता है कि वह उसकी वास्तविक सहेली, कादम्बिनी नहीं है। वह प्रत्येक निर्णय सत्यता जानने के बाद लेता है जबकि उसकी पत्नी बेचैन होती है।
In simple words: Jogmaya is Kadambini's friend who becomes scared and wants her to leave after knowing the truth. Mr. Sripati, her husband, is more rational and makes decisions based on facts, unlike his worried wife.
🎯 Exam Tip: When comparing characters, focus on their key traits, how they react to the same situation, and their differing emotional and logical approaches.
Question 4. What did Nitai, Gurucharan, Bidhu and Banamali do after taking the body into the hut? निताई, गुरुचरण, बिधू और बनमाली ने शव को झोंपड़ी में ले जाने के बाद क्या किया?
Answer: After bringing the body into the hut, Nitai, Gurucharan, Bidhu, and Banamali sat down to await the wood for the cremation. The long wait made Nitai and Gurucharan restless, so they left to check on the wood. Bidhu and Banamali stayed to guard the body. Their matches were damp and useless, and the lantern went out, plunging them into darkness. Fearful, they too eventually fled the hut. Their anxiety grew with the passing time.
Taking the body into the hut, they sat down to wait for the wood. The time seemed so long that Nitai and Gurucharan grew restless and went to see why it did not come. Bidhu and Banamali remained to watch over the body. Their matches and lamp were useless. The matches were damp and would not light for all their efforts, and the lantern went out. Five minutes seemed like an hour. Being afraid, they also leapt out of the hut.
शव को झोंपड़ी में ले जाकर, वे लकड़ी के इन्तजार में बैठ गये । समय इतना लम्बा प्रतीत हुआ कि निताई तथा गुरुचरण बेचैन हो गये और देखने के लिए चले गये कि लकड़ी क्यों नहीं आई। बिधू तथा बनमाली लाश को ध्यान रखने के लिए बने रहे। उनकी माचिस तथा
In simple words: The men took the body into the hut and waited for wood. Nitai and Gurucharan left to check on the wood, while Bidhu and Banamali guarded the body until their light failed, and they also ran away scared.
🎯 Exam Tip: Detail the sequence of events and the reasons behind characters' actions, particularly when fear or uncertainty drives their decisions.
Question 5. रबीन्द्रनाथ टैगोर के द्वारा स्पष्ट किये गये औरतों के प्रेम के रहस्य का वर्णन कीजिए।
Answer: Rabindranath Tagore states that women do not find mystery appealing in love. While uncertainty can be transformed into poetry or heroism, it has no practical use in daily household life. Thus, when a woman cannot understand something, she either discards it, reshapes it for her own purpose, or loses patience if she cannot manage it in either way. This highlights her need for clarity and control in relationships and life.
Rabindranath Tagore says that women do not love mystery, because though uncertainty may be transmuted into poetry, into heroism into scholarship. It cannot be turned to account in household work. So, when a woman cannot understand a thing, she either destroys and forgets it, or she shapes it anew for her own use. If she fails to deal with it in one of these ways, she loses her temper with it.
रबीन्द्रनाथ टैगोर कहता है कि औरतें प्रेम के रहस्य को पसन्द नहीं करती हैं क्योंकि यद्यपि अनिश्चितता को कविता में, वीरता में पाण्डित्य में, बदला जा सकता है। इसलिए जब कोई औरत एक चीज को नहीं समझ पाती है, वह या तो उसे भूल जाती है और समाप्त कर देती है या वह उसे अपने लिए एक नया आकार दे देती है। अगर वह इन तरीकों में से किसी भी समझौते में असफल हो जाती है तो वह इसके साथ अपना आपा खो देती है।
In simple words: Tagore explains that women dislike mystery in love because they need clear understanding for daily life. If they can't grasp something, they either get rid of it, adapt it, or become frustrated.
🎯 Exam Tip: When discussing an author's philosophical views, break down complex ideas into simpler statements, explaining how they apply to human nature or societal roles.
Free study material for English
RBSE Solutions Class 11 English Chapter 2 Living Or Dead
Students can now access the RBSE Solutions for Chapter 2 Living Or Dead prepared by teachers on our website. These solutions cover all questions in exercise in your Class 11 English textbook. Each answer is updated based on the current academic session as per the latest RBSE syllabus.
Detailed Explanations for Chapter 2 Living Or Dead
Our expert teachers have provided step-by-step explanations for all the difficult questions in the Class 11 English chapter. Along with the final answers, we have also explained the concept behind it to help you build stronger understanding of each topic. This will be really helpful for Class 11 students who want to understand both theoretical and practical questions. By studying these RBSE Questions and Answers your basic concepts will improve a lot.
Benefits of using English Class 11 Solved Papers
Using our English solutions regularly students will be able to improve their logical thinking and problem-solving speed. These Class 11 solutions are a guide for self-study and homework assistance. Along with the chapter-wise solutions, you should also refer to our Revision Notes and Sample Papers for Chapter 2 Living Or Dead to get a complete preparation experience.
FAQs
The complete and updated RBSE Solutions Class 11 English Delight & Wisdom Chapter 2 Living Or Dead is available for free on StudiesToday.com. These solutions for Class 11 English are as per latest RBSE curriculum.
Yes, our experts have revised the RBSE Solutions Class 11 English Delight & Wisdom Chapter 2 Living Or Dead as per 2026 exam pattern. All textbook exercises have been solved and have added explanation about how the English concepts are applied in case-study and assertion-reasoning questions.
Toppers recommend using RBSE language because RBSE marking schemes are strictly based on textbook definitions. Our RBSE Solutions Class 11 English Delight & Wisdom Chapter 2 Living Or Dead will help students to get full marks in the theory paper.
Yes, we provide bilingual support for Class 11 English. You can access RBSE Solutions Class 11 English Delight & Wisdom Chapter 2 Living Or Dead in both English and Hindi medium.
Yes, you can download the entire RBSE Solutions Class 11 English Delight & Wisdom Chapter 2 Living Or Dead in printable PDF format for offline study on any device.