IE Irodov Solutions Chapter 34 Scattering Of Particles Rutherford Bohr Atom Part 1

IE Irodov Solutions for JEE Physics: Chapter 34 Scattering Of Particles Rutherford Bohr Atom

Access comprehensive textbook solutions for Chapter 34 Scattering Of Particles Rutherford Bohr Atom using the IE Irodov reference material for JEE Physics. Designed to align with the 2026 academic curriculum, these detailed answers help students reinforce core academic concepts and master complex problem-solving methods.

Practice JEE Physics Solutions: Chapter 34 Scattering Of Particles Rutherford Bohr Atom

Navigate directly to the solved Physics textbook exercises using the digital viewer below. Each solution includes detailed step-by-step explanations, allowing students to instantly cross-check their work and identify areas requiring further revision.

Scattering of Particles. Rutherford-Bohr Atom - Questions 1 to 20

Scattering of Particles. Rutherford-Bohr Atom (Part 1)

Question 1. Employing Thomson's model, calculate the radius of a hydrogen atom and the wavelength of emitted light if the ionization energy of the atom is known to be equal to E = 13.6 eV.

Solution.

In Thomson's model the nucleus is a uniformly charged sphere of radius R and charge +e, with the electron at rest at its centre. The potential at the centre of a uniformly charged sphere is φ0 = (1/4πε0)·3e/(2R). The potential energy of the electron is −eφ0, and since the electron is at rest this is also its total energy. To ionize the atom an energy E = eφ0 is required, so

R = (1/4πε0)·3e²/(2E) = 0.159 nm.

(In Gaussian units the factor 1/4πε0 is missing.)

Light is emitted when the electron vibrates. Displace the electron by a small distance r from the centre. Inside the sphere the potential is φ(r) = (1/4πε0)(e/R)(3/2 − r²/2R²). The total energy is

½mṙ² − (1/4πε0)(e²/R)(3/2 − r²/2R²) = −eφ0 + δE,

or δE = ½mṙ² + (1/4πε0)(e²/2R³)r².

This is the energy of a harmonic oscillator of frequency ω, where ω² = (1/4πε0)·e²/(mR³). The vibrating electron emits radiation of frequency ω, so the wavelength is

λ = 2πc/ω = (2πc/e)·√(mR³)·(4πε0)1/2 = 0.237 μm.

(In Gaussian units the factor (4πε0)1/2 is missing.)

Teacher's Note: Potential energy at sphere centre gives R; small oscillations about the centre are simple harmonic, giving ω and λ.

Exam Note: Quote R = 0.159 nm, λ = 0.237 μm.

Question 2. An alpha particle with kinetic energy 0.27 MeV is deflected through an angle of 60° by a golden foil. Find the corresponding value of the aiming parameter.

Solution.

Equation (6.1a) of the book reads, in MKS units, tan(θ/2) = (q1q2/4πε0)/(2bT).

Thus b = (q1q2/4πε0)·cot(θ/2)/(2T).

For the α particle q1 = 2e, and for gold q2 = 79e. (In Gaussian units there is no factor 1/4πε0.)

Substituting, b = 0.731 pm.

Teacher's Note: Rutherford relation b = (q₁q₂/2T)·cot(θ/2); use Z = 2 and 79 with e² = 1.44 MeV·fm.

Exam Note: State formula, substitute Z values, answer 0.731 pm.

Question 3. To what minimum distance will an alpha particle with kinetic energy T = 0.40 MeV approach in the case of a head-on collision to (a) a stationary Pb nucleus; (b) a stationary free Li nucleus?

Solution.

(a) In the Pb case we ignore the recoil of the nucleus, both because Pb is quite heavy (APb = 208 = 52 × AHe) and because Pb is not free. For a head-on collision, at the distance of closest approach the kinetic energy of the α-particle must become zero (it turns back there). Then

2Ze²/(4πε0 rmin) = T, with Z = 82.

(No 4πε0 in Gaussian units.) Putting in the values, rmin = 0.591 pm.

(b) Here part of the energy is spent in the recoil of the Li nucleus. Let x1 be the coordinate of the α-particle and x2 that of the Li nucleus along the line joining them. The energy and momentum equations are

½m1ẋ1² + ½m2ẋ2² + 2×3e²/(4πε0|x1 − x2|) = T,

m1ẋ1 + m2ẋ2 = √(2m1T).

Here m1 = mass of the He++ nucleus, m2 = mass of the Li nucleus. Eliminating ẋ2:

T = ½m1ẋ1² + (1/2m2)(√(2m1T) − m1ẋ1)² + 6e²/((4πε0)(x1 − x2)).

Completing the square, this becomes

(m2/(m1 + m2))·T = (1/2m2)[√(m1(m1 + m2))·ẋ1 − √(m1/(m1 + m2))·√(2m1T)]² + 6e²/((4πε0)|x1 − x2|).

For the least distance of approach the second term on the right must be greatest, which implies that the first term vanishes. Thus

|x1 − x2|min = (6e²/((4πε0)T))·(1 + m1/m2).

Using m1/m2 = 4/7 and the other values, |x1 − x2|min = 0.034 pm.

(In Gaussian units the factor 4πε0 is absent.)

Teacher's Note: At closest approach kinetic energy is all potential (Pb); free light nucleus needs factor (1 + m₁/m₂).

Exam Note: Show energy balance; include recoil correction in part (b).

Question 4. An alpha particle with kinetic energy T = 0.50 MeV is deflected through an angle of θ = 90° by the Coulomb field of a stationary Hg nucleus. Find: (a) the least curvature radius of its trajectory; (b) the minimum approach distance between the particle and the nucleus.

Solution.

(All formulas in this part are given in the Gaussian system of units.) We ignore the recoil of the Hg nucleus.

(a) Let A be the point of closest approach to the centre C, with AC = rmin. (Figure in the book: the hyperbolic path of the particle with aiming parameter b, the point A on it, and the line CA of length rmin to the nucleus C.) At A the motion is instantaneously circular because the radial velocity vanishes. If v0 is the speed of the particle at A, then

(1) T = ½mv0² + Z1Z2e²/((4πε0)rmin)

(2) mv0rmin = √(2mT)·b

(3) mv0²/ρmin = Z1Z2e²/((4πε0)rmin²)

(3 is Newton's law; ρ = ρmin is the radius of curvature of the path at A, and ρ is minimum at A by symmetry.) Finally we have Eq. (6.1a) in the form

(4) b = (Z1Z2e²/((4πε0)2T))·cot(θ/2).

From (2) and (3): 2Tb²/ρmin = Z1Z2e²/(4πε0), or

ρmin = (Z1Z2e²/((4πε0)2T))·cot²(θ/2).

With Z1 = 2, Z2 = 80 we get ρmin = 0.231 pm.

(b) From (2) and (4),

rmin = (Z1Z2e²/((4πε0)√(2mT)))·cot(θ/2)/v0.

Substituting in (1): T = ½mv0² + √(2mT)·v0·tan(θ/2). Solving for v0,

v0 = √(2T/m)·(sec(θ/2) − tan(θ/2)).

Then

rmin = (Z1Z2e²/((4πε0)2T))·cot(θ/2)/(sec(θ/2) − tan(θ/2)) = (Z1Z2e²/((4πε0)2T))·cot(θ/2)·(sec(θ/2) + tan(θ/2)) = (Z1Z2e²/((4πε0)2T))·(1 + cosec(θ/2)) = 0.557 pm.

Teacher's Note: At closest approach motion is circular; combine energy, angular momentum and Newton's law to get ρ and r.

Exam Note: Write the three conservation equations before substituting.

Question 5. A proton with kinetic energy T and aiming parameter b was deflected by the Coulomb field of a stationary Au nucleus. Find the momentum imparted to the given nucleus as a result of scattering.

Solution.

By momentum conservation, p⃗ + P⃗i = p⃗′ + P⃗f (proton, Au before and after). Thus the momentum transferred to the gold nucleus is

ΔP⃗ = P⃗f − P⃗i = p⃗ − p⃗′.

Although the momentum transferred to the Au nucleus is not small, the energy associated with this recoil is quite small and its effect on the motion of the proton can be neglected to a first approximation. Then, with î the unit vector along the incident proton direction and ĵ normal to it on the side towards which the proton is scattered (θ is the scattering angle),

ΔP⃗ = √(2mT)(1 − cos θ) î + √(2mT) sin θ ĵ.

Thus |ΔP⃗| = 2√(2mT)·sin(θ/2).

Using tan(θ/2) = Ze²/((4πε0)2bT) for the proton, we get

|ΔP⃗| = 2√(2mT/(1 + (2bT(4πε0)/(Ze²))²)).

Teacher's Note: Momentum change of the proton equals minus that of the nucleus; magnitude 2p·sin(θ/2), with θ from b.

Exam Note: Give magnitude and eliminate θ using the Rutherford relation.

Question 6. A proton with kinetic energy T = 10 MeV flies past a stationary free electron at a distance b = 10 pm. Find the energy acquired by the electron, assuming the proton's trajectory to be rectilinear and the electron to be practically motionless as the proton flies by.

Solution.

The proton moving by the electron first accelerates it and then decelerates it, and it is not easy to calculate the energy lost by the proton, so energy conservation does not do the trick. Rather we must directly calculate the momentum acquired by the electron. By symmetry that momentum is along OA (A is the point of the proton's path nearest to the electron O, at distance b), and its magnitude is Pe = ∫F⊥dt, where F⊥ is the component along OA of the force on the electron. Thus

Pe = ∫−∞∞ (e²/4πε0)·(b/√(b² + v²t²))·(1/(b² + v²t²)) dt = (e²b/(4πε0v))·∫−∞∞ dx/(b² + x²)3/2.

Evaluate the integral by substituting x = b tan θ. Then Pe = 2e²/((4πε0)vb), and

Te = Pe²/2me = mpe⁴/((4πε0)²T b² me).

(In Gaussian units there is no factor (4πε0)².) Substituting the values, Te = 3.82 eV.

Teacher's Note: Impulse approximation: integrate the transverse Coulomb force along the straight path; then T = p²/2mₑ.

Exam Note: Final answer about 3.8 eV; show the impulse integral.

Question 7. A particle with kinetic energy T is deflected by a spherical potential well of radius R and depth U0, i.e. by the field in which the potential energy of the particle takes the form U = 0 for r > R and U = −U0 for r < R, where r is the distance from the centre of the well. Find the relationship between the aiming parameter b of the particle and the angle θ through which it deflects from the initial motion direction.

Solution.

Inside the well (figure in the book: the particle enters the sphere at angle of incidence α to the radius, refracts to angle φ, and leaves at the same angle α; the total deviation is θ) the kinetic energy of the particle is, by energy conservation, T + U0 and its momentum has the magnitude √(2m(T + U0)). On the boundary the force is radial, so the tangential component of the momentum does not change:

√(2mT)·sin α = √(2m(T + U0))·sin φ, so sin φ = √(T/(T + U0))·sin α = sin α/n,

where n = √(1 + U0/T). We also have θ = 2(α − φ). Therefore

sin(θ/2) = sin(α − φ) = sin α cos φ − cos α sin φ = sin α(cos φ − cos α/n),

or n sin(θ/2)/sin α = √(n² − sin²α) − cos α,

or (n sin(θ/2)/sin α + cos α)² = n² − sin²α,

or n² sin²(θ/2) cot²α + 2n sin(θ/2) cot α + 1 = n² cos²(θ/2),

hence cot α = (n cos(θ/2) − 1)/(n sin(θ/2)).

Hence sin α = n sin(θ/2)/√(1 + n² − 2n cos(θ/2)).

Finally, the aiming parameter is

b = R sin α = nR sin(θ/2)/√(1 + n² − 2n cos(θ/2)), where n = √(1 + U0/T).

Teacher's Note: Treat the well boundary like refraction with index n = √(1+U₀/T); tangential momentum is conserved.

Exam Note: Derive Snell-type law, then b = R sin α.

Question 8. A stationary ball of radius R is irradiated by a parallel stream of particles whose radius is r. Assuming the collision of a particle and the ball to be elastic, find: (a) the deflection angle θ of a particle as a function of its aiming parameter b; (b) the fraction of particles which after a collision with the ball are scattered into the angular interval between θ and θ + dθ; (c) the probability of a particle to be deflected, after a collision with the ball, into the front hemisphere (θ < π/2).

Solution.

It is implied that the ball is too heavy to recoil.

(a) The trajectory of the particle is symmetrical about the radius vector through the point of impact (figure in the book: the incident particle strikes the ball at a point whose radius makes angle φ with the incident direction, and the particle is reflected symmetrically about that radius). It is clear from the figure that θ = π − 2φ, or φ = π/2 − θ/2. Also b = (R + r) sin φ = (R + r) cos(θ/2), so θ = 2 arccos(b/(R + r)).

(b) With b defined above, the fraction of particles scattered between θ and θ + dθ (or the probability of the same) is

dP = |2πb db|/(π(R + r)²) = ½ sin θ dθ.

(c) This is P = ∫0π/2 ½ sin θ dθ = ½∫−10 d(−cos θ) = ½.

Teacher's Note: Elastic hard-sphere collision: effective radius R + r, reflection law gives θ = π − 2φ.

Exam Note: Use b = (R+r)cos(θ/2); the answer ½ is isotropic-like.

Question 9. A narrow beam of alpha particles with kinetic energy 1.0 MeV falls normally on a platinum foil 1.0 μm thick. The scattered particles are observed at an angle of 60° to the incident beam direction by means of a counter with a circular inlet area 1.0 cm² located at the distance 10 cm from the scattering section of the foil. What fraction of scattered alpha particles reaches the counter inlet?

Solution.

From formula (6.1b) of the book,

dN/N = n·(Ze²/((4πε0)2T))²·dΩ/sin⁴(θ/2).

We have put q1 = 2e, q2 = Ze here. Also n = number of Pt nuclei in the foil per unit area = (Atρ)·(NA/APt)·(1/A) = NAρt/APt, where Atρ is the mass of the foil and NA/APt is the number of nuclei per unit mass.

Using the values APt = 195, ρ = 21.5 × 10³ kg/m³, NA = 6.023 × 10²⁶ per kilomole, we get n = 6.641 × 10²² per m². Also dΩ = dSn/r² = 10⁻² sr. Substituting (Z = 78), we get

dN/N = 3.36 × 10⁻⁵.

Teacher's Note: Rutherford formula with n = areal density of nuclei = N_Aρt/A; dΩ = counter area/r².

Exam Note: Compute n and dΩ separately, then substitute Z = 78.

Question 10. A narrow beam of alpha particles with kinetic energy T = 0.50 MeV and intensity I = 5.0·10⁵ particles per second falls normally on a golden foil. Find the thickness of the foil if at a distance r = 15 cm from a scattering section of that foil the flux density of scattered particles at the angle θ = 60° to the incident beam is equal to J = 40 particles/(cm²·s).

Solution.

A scattered flux density J (particles per unit area per second) at distance r equals r²J particles scattered per unit time per steradian in the given direction.

Let n = concentration of the gold nuclei in the foil: n = NAρ/AAu. Then the number of Au nuclei per unit area of the foil is nd, where d = thickness of the foil. From Eq. (6.1b) (n → nd here)

r²J = dN = nd·I·(Ze²/((4πε0)2T))²·cosec⁴(θ/2),

where I is the number of α-particles falling on the foil per second. Hence

d = 4T²r²J·sin⁴(θ/2)/(nI(Ze²/4πε0)²).

Using Z = 79, AAu = 197, ρ = 19.3 × 10³ kg/m³, NA = 6.023 × 10²⁶ per kilomole and the other data, d = 1.47 μm.

Corrected: the book prints d = 1.47 pm, but the units are wrong. Recomputing gives d = 1.47 × 10⁻⁶ m = 1.47 μm (a foil 1.47 pm thick would be thinner than an atom).

Teacher's Note: Convert flux density to particles per steradian, then solve Rutherford formula for foil thickness d.

Exam Note: Watch units: cm² to m², result 1.47 μm.

Question 11. A narrow beam of alpha particles falls normally on a silver foil behind which a counter is set to register the scattered particles. On substitution of platinum foil of the same mass thickness for the silver foil, the number of alpha particles registered per unit time increased η = 1.52 times. Find the atomic number of platinum, assuming the atomic number of silver and the atomic masses of both platinum and silver to be known.

Solution.

From formula (6.1b) of the book we find

dNPt/dNAg = (nPt/nAg)·(ZPt²/ZAg²) = η.

But since the foils have the same mass thickness (ρd), we have nPt/nAg = AAg/APt (see problem 6.9). Hence

ZPt = ZAg·√(ηAPt/AAg).

Substituting ZAg = 47, AAg = 108, APt = 195 and η = 1.52, we get ZPt = 77.86 ≈ 78.

Corrected: the book prints the root as √(ηAAg/APt), which is inverted and would give 43. The result above follows from the preceding line, and the book's numerical answer 78 is right.

Teacher's Note: Same mass thickness means nuclei per area ∝ 1/A; scattering ∝ nZ², so Z ∝ √(ηA).

Exam Note: Derive Z_Pt from ratio; answer 78.

Question 12. A narrow beam of alpha particles with kinetic energy T = 0.50 MeV falls normally on a golden foil whose mass thickness is ρd = 1.5 mg/cm². The beam intensity is I0 = 5.0·10⁵ particles per second. Find the number of alpha particles scattered by the foil during a time interval τ = 30 min into the angular interval: (a) 59–61°; (b) over θ0 = 60°.

Solution.

(a) From Eq. (6.1b) we get

dN = I0τ·(ρd·NA/AAu)·(Ze²/((4πε0)2T))²·2π sin θ dθ/sin⁴(θ/2)

(we used dΩ = 2π sin θ dθ and N = I0τ). From the data dθ = 2° = 2/57.3 radian. Also ZAu = 79, AAu = 197. Putting in the values we get dN = 1.63 × 10⁶.

(b) This number is

N(θ0) = I0τ·(ρdNA/AAu)·(Ze²/((4πε0)2T))²·4π∫θ0π cos(θ/2) dθ/sin³(θ/2).

With x = sin(θ/2), dx = ½cos(θ/2)dθ, so ∫θ0π cos(θ/2)dθ/sin³(θ/2) = 2∫sin(θ0/2)1 dx/x³ = 1/sin²(θ0/2) − 1 = cot²(θ0/2), and the factors (½)²·4π combine to π. Thus

N(θ0) = πnd·(Ze²/((4πε0)T))²·I0τ·cot²(θ0/2),

where n is the concentration of nuclei in the foil (n = ρNA/AAu). Substitution gives N(θ0) = 2.02 × 10⁷.

Teacher's Note: Integrate dσ/dΩ over the angular window; for θ > θ₀ the integral gives cot²(θ₀/2).

Exam Note: Use dΩ = 2π sinθ dθ; state both counts.

Question 13. A narrow beam of protons with velocity v = 6·10⁶ m/s falls normally on a silver foil of thickness d = 1.0 μm. Find the probability of the protons to be scattered into the rear hemisphere (θ > 90°).

Solution.

The required probability can be written easily by analogy with (b) of the previous problem. It is

P = N(π/2)/(I0τ) = nd·(Ze²/((4πε0)2mv²))²·4π∫π/2π cos(θ/2) dθ/sin³(θ/2).

The integral is cot²(π/4) = 1 (as in the previous problem). Thus

P = πnd·(Ze²/((4πε0)mv²))².

Substitution gives, using n = ρAgNA/AAg = (10.5 × 10³ × 6.023 × 10²⁶)/108 (Z = 47), P = 0.006.

Teacher's Note: Rear-hemisphere probability is the θ₀ = 90° case of the cumulative formula; cot²45° = 1.

Exam Note: Substitute Z = 47, T = ½mv²; answer ≈ 0.006.

Question 14. A narrow beam of alpha particles with kinetic energy T = 600 keV falls normally on a golden foil incorporating n = 1.1·10¹⁹ nuclei/cm². Find the fraction of alpha particles scattered through the angles θ < θ0 = 20°.

Solution.

Because of the cosec⁴(θ/2) dependence of the scattering, the number of particles (or fraction) scattered through θ < θ0 cannot be calculated directly. But we can write this fraction as P(θ0) = 1 − Q(θ0), where Q(θ0) is the fraction of particles scattered through θ ≥ θ0. This fraction has been calculated before (see the results of 6.12(b)):

Q(θ0) = πn·(Ze²/((4πε0)T))²·cot²(θ0/2),

where n here is the number of nuclei per cm². Using the data (Z = 79) we get Q = 0.4. Thus P(θ0) = 0.6.

Teacher's Note: Small-angle fraction = 1 − fraction scattered beyond θ₀, since direct integration diverges.

Exam Note: Use complement; Q = 0.4 so P = 0.6.

Question 15. A narrow beam of protons with kinetic energy T = 1.4 MeV falls normally on a brass foil whose mass thickness is ρd = 1.5 mg/cm². The weight ratio of copper and zinc in the foil is equal to 7 : 3 respectively. Find the fraction of the protons scattered through the angles exceeding θ0 = 30°.

Solution.

The relevant fraction can be written down at once (see 6.12(b)), noting that the projectiles are protons:

ΔN/N = (e²/((4πε0)2T))²·π·cot²(θ0/2)·(n1Z1² + n2Z2²).

Here n1 (n2) is the number of Cu (Zn) nuclei per cm² of the foil and Z1 (Z2) is the atomic number of Cu (Zn). Now n1 = (ρdNA/M1)·0.7 and n2 = (ρdNA/M2)·0.3, where M1, M2 are the mass numbers of Cu and Zn.

Substituting Z1 = 29, Z2 = 30, M1 = 63.5, M2 = 65.4, we get ΔN/N = 1.40 × 10⁻³.

Corrected: the printed solution assigns the 0.7 (copper) fraction to Zn (Z = 30, M = 65.4) and prints 1.43 × 10⁻³. With copper correctly 70% and zinc 30% by weight, the value is 1.40 × 10⁻³ (checked numerically).

Teacher's Note: Sum Rutherford cross-sections over both elements, weighted by nuclei per area from mass fractions.

Exam Note: Assign 0.7 to Cu, 0.3 to Zn; answer 1.4×10⁻³.

Question 16. Find the effective cross section of a uranium nucleus corresponding to the scattering of alpha particles with kinetic energy T = 1.5 MeV through the angles exceeding θ0 = 60°.

Solution.

From the Rutherford scattering formula dσ/dΩ = (Ze²/((4πε0)2T))²·1/sin⁴(θ/2),

dσ = (Ze²/((4πε0)2T))²·2π sin θ dθ/sin⁴(θ/2) = (Ze²/((4πε0)T))²·π cos(θ/2) dθ/sin³(θ/2).

Integrating from θ = θ0 to θ = π, we get the required cross section

Δσ = π·(Ze²/((4πε0)T))²·cot²(θ0/2).

For the U nucleus Z = 92, and on putting the values we get Δσ = 737 b = 0.737 kb (1 b = 1 barn = 10⁻²⁸ m²).

Corrected: the printed final line omits the factor π in Δσ; the numerical answer 737 b includes it (π·(Ze²/T)²·cot²30° = 735 b with e² = 1.44 MeV·fm).

Teacher's Note: Integrate dσ over θ from θ₀ to π; result is π(Ze²/T)² cot²(θ₀/2), in barns.

Exam Note: Include π; convert fm² to barn (1 b = 100 fm²).

Question 17. The effective cross section of a gold nucleus corresponding to the scattering of monoenergetic alpha particles within the angular interval from 90° to 180° is equal to Δσ = 0.50 kb. Find: (a) the energy of alpha particles; (b) the differential cross section of scattering dσ/dΩ (kb/sr) corresponding to the angle θ = 60°.

Solution.

(a) From the previous formula Δσ = π·(Ze²/((4πε0)T))²·cot²(θ0/2), or

T = (Ze²/(4πε0))·cot(θ0/2)·√(π/Δσ).

Substituting the values with Z = 79 and θ0 = 90° we get T = 0.903 MeV.

(b) The differential scattering cross section is dσ/dΩ = C·cosec⁴(θ/2), where Δσ(θ > θ0) = 4πC·cot²(θ0/2). Thus from the given data C = 500/(4π) b = 39.79 b/sr. So

dσ/dΩ(θ = 60°) = 39.79 × 16 b/sr = 0.637 kb/sr.

Teacher's Note: Invert the cumulative cross-section formula for T; dσ/dΩ = C cosec⁴(θ/2) with C from Δσ.

Exam Note: Cosec⁴30° = 16; answers 0.903 MeV, 0.637 kb/sr.

Question 18. In accordance with classical electrodynamics an electron moving with acceleration w loses its energy due to radiation as dE/dt = −(2e²/3c³)w², where e is the electron charge, c is the velocity of light. Estimate the time during which the energy of an electron performing almost harmonic oscillations with frequency ω = 5·10¹⁵ s⁻¹ will decrease η = 10 times.

Solution.

The formula in MKS units is dE/dt = −(μ0e²/6πc)·w².

For an electron performing (linear) harmonic vibrations, w is in some definite direction with wx = −ω²x, say. Thus dE/dt = −(μ0e²ω⁴/6πc)·x².

If the radiation loss is small (ω not too large), the motion of the electron is always close to simple harmonic with slowly decreasing amplitude. Then we can write E = ½mω²a² and x = a cos ωt, and average the above equation ignoring the variation of a in any cycle. Using ⟨x²⟩ = ½a² we get

dE/dt = −(μ0e²ω⁴/6πc)·½a² = −(μ0e²ω²/6πmc)·E,

since E = ½mω²a² for a harmonic oscillator. This equation integrates to E = E0e−t/τ, where τ = 6πmc/(μ0e²ω²).

It is then seen that the energy decreases η times in

t0 = τ ln η = (6πmc/(μ0e²ω²))·ln η = 14.7 ns.

Teacher's Note: Averaged radiation loss gives dE/dt ∝ −E, an exponential decay; time = τ ln η.

Exam Note: Note ⟨x²⟩ = a²/2; answer 14.7 ns.

Question 19. Making use of the formula of the foregoing problem, estimate the time during which an electron moving in a hydrogen atom along a circular orbit of radius r = 50 pm would have fallen onto the nucleus. For the sake of simplicity assume the vector w to be permanently directed toward the centre of the atom.

Solution.

Moving around the nucleus, the electron radiates and its energy decreases, so the electron gets nearer the nucleus. By the statement of the problem we can assume that the electron is always moving in a circular orbit, and the radial acceleration by Newton's law is w = e²/((4πε0)mr²), directed inwards. Thus

dE/dt = −(μ0e⁶/6πc)·1/((4πε0)²m²r⁴).

On the other hand, in a circular orbit E = −e²/((4πε0)2r), so

(e²/((4πε0)2r²))·dr/dt = −μ0e⁶/((4πε0)²·6πc·m²r⁴),

or dr/dt = −μ0e⁴/((4πε0)·3πc·m²r²).

Integrating, r³ = r0³ − μ0e⁴t/(4π²ε0cm²), and the radius falls to zero in

t0 = 4π²ε0c·m²r0³/(μ0e⁴) = 13.1 ps.

Teacher's Note: Radiated power from circular-orbit acceleration, with E = −e²/2r, gives r³ decreasing linearly in time.

Exam Note: Final time 13.1 ps; show r³ integration.

Question 20. Demonstrate that the frequency ω of a photon emerging when an electron jumps between neighbouring circular orbits of a hydrogen-like ion satisfies the inequality ωn > ω > ωn+1, where ωn and ωn+1 are the frequencies of revolution of that electron around the nucleus along the circular orbits. Make sure that as n → ∞ the frequency of the photon ω → ωn.

Solution.

In a circular orbit mv²/r = Ze²/((4πε0)r²) and mvr = nħ. Then v = Ze²/((4πε0)nħ) and r = (n²/Z)·ħ(4πε0)/(me²).

The energy is En = ½mv² − Ze²/((4πε0)r) = (Ze²/4πε0)²·m/(2ħ²n²) − (Ze²/4πε0)²·m/(ħ²n²) = −m(Ze²/4πε0)²/(2ħ²n²),

and the circular frequency of this orbit is ωn = v/r = (Ze²/4πε0)²·m/(ħ³n³).

On the other hand, the frequency ω of the light emitted when the electron makes a transition n + 1 → n is ω = (Ze²/4πε0)²·(m/2ħ³)·(1/n² − 1/(n + 1)²).

Thus ωn > ω > ωn+1 will result if

1/n³ > ½(1/n² − 1/(n + 1)²) > 1/(n + 1)³.

Multiplying by n²(n + 1)², we have to prove (n + 1)²/n > (2n + 1)/2 > n²/(n + 1). This can be written as

n + 2 + 1/n > n + ½ > n − 1 + 1/(n + 1),

which is obvious (the left inequality because 2 + 1/n > ½, the right because 1/(n + 1) − 1 < −½ since n ≥ 1).

For large n, ωn/ωn+1 = ((n + 1)/n)³ ≈ 1 + 3/n → 1, and since ω lies between ωn+1 and ωn, ω/ωn → 1.

Teacher's Note: Compare ω = ΔE/ħ with orbital frequencies ∝ 1/n³; the inequality reduces to simple algebra (correspondence principle).

Exam Note: Show both frequencies, then prove two inequalities.

Step-by-Step IE Irodov Solutions for JEE Math

Complete Math Solutions for IE Irodov Solutions Chapter 34 Scattering Of Particles Rutherford Bohr Atom Part 1

Explore reliable mathematical solutions for IE Irodov Solutions Chapter 34 Scattering Of Particles Rutherford Bohr Atom Part 1 tailored for JEE learners. Utilizing these complete exercise answers ensures your preparation aligns exactly with standard academic requirements.

Mastering Core Concepts with IE Irodov Solutions

Beyond providing the final numerical answer, these guides break down the underlying mathematical principles. Cross-referencing completed work with these structured explanations helps eliminate calculation errors and reinforces conceptual clarity.

Additional Study Materials for 2026

Wrap up your chapter revision by testing your knowledge against standard objective question formats. Explore our full library of up-to-date syllabus details and mock evaluations to secure top grades in your math examinations.

FAQs

What are these IE Irodov Solutions for JEE Physics?

They are chapter-wise solved questions from the IE Irodov book for JEE Physics. Each answer is explained step by step so you can check your work and revise.

Are the IE Irodov JEE Physics Solutions free to read?

Yes. All chapters can be read online for free on a phone, tablet or computer, and no sign-up is needed.

How should I use these IE Irodov solutions for JEE Physics?

Try each question on your own first, then read the solution. Use it to check your steps, correct mistakes and learn how a full answer is written.

Will practising IE Irodov JEE Physics questions help in exams?

Regular practice improves accuracy and speed and shows which topics need more revision. It works best alongside your textbook and class notes.

Are these solutions arranged chapter by chapter?

Yes. The chapter list on this page links to every chapter’s solved questions, so you can open the topic you are studying.

Which session are these JEE Physics Solutions for?

They are listed for the 2026-27 session. Check that the questions match the textbook edition you use.