UP Board Solutions Class 12 English Chapter 4 A Special Experience

UP Board Class 12th English Short Stories Chapter 4 A Special Experience Questions and Answers

English Class 12 UP Board Chapter 4 Question Answer

कक्षा 12 अंग्रेजी पाठ 4 के प्रश्न उत्तर

Story at a Glance

In this story Prem Chand describes the experiences of two families. One day the husband of the narrator of the story served ‘sherbat’ and ‘pun’ to the freedom fighters. So he was sentenced for one year’s rigorous imprisonment. The narrator was not perturbed. She felt proud of her husband and wanted to touch his feet. She celebrated her husband’s going to jail by distributing sweets among the freedom fighters.

She was quite alone in her house. So she informed her father and father-in-law and requested them to help. But both refused. Her father-in-law was afraid lest his pension be stopped and her father was afraid lest his promotion and increment be stopped. Two policemen in white clothes watched her house every time. She was very much afraid yet she determined to preserve her femininity at all costs. Babu Gyan Chand, a school

teacher, was the best friend of her husband. When he came to know about it, he came to her with his wife. They requested her to live with them. She agreed. There also she saw two policemen watching the house of Babu Gyan Chand. The narrator did not like that her hosts should be in trouble. But Gyan Chand’s wife was not troubled at all.

One evening when Gyan Babu returned from his college, he was very much perturbed. His principal had asked him to turn the lady out of his house. She was the wife of a freedom fighter. It was the order of the Commissioner. But Gyan babu did not yield before them. He resigned from his post. His resignation opened the eyes of the principal. He and the Commissioner both asked him many questions and were satisfied that Gyan Babu had no connection with the movement of freedom.

कहानी पर एक दृष्टि

इस कहानी में प्रेमचन्द ने उन दो परिवारों के अनुभवों का वर्णन किया है जिनका अपने देश की स्वतन्त्रता के लिए योगदान प्रशंसनीय था। एक दिन कहानी का वर्णन करने वाली स्त्री के पति ने स्वतन्त्रता सेनानियों को 'शरबत' और 'पान' भेंट किया। इसलिए उसे एक वर्ष के कठोर कारावास का दण्ड दिया गया। वह तनिक भी विचलित नहीं हुई। उसने अपने पति पर बड़े गर्व का अनुभव किया और उसके पैर छूना चाहती थी। उसने अपने पति के जेल जाने के अवसर पर स्वतन्त्रता सेनानियों में मिठाइयाँ बाँटीं।

वह अपने मकान में बिल्कुल अकेली थी। इसलिए उसने अपने पिता एवं ससुर को सूचित किया और उनसे सहायता की प्रार्थना की। किन्तु दोनों ने मना कर दिया। उसके ससुर को यह भय था कि कहीं उसकी पेंशन न रुक जाए और उसके पिता को यह भय था कि कहीं उसकी प्रोन्नति एवं वेतन-वृद्धि न रुक जाए। सादे कपड़े पहने हुए दो पुलिस के सिपाही उसके घर पर हर समय पहरा देते थे। उसे बहुत भय था फिर भी उसने प्रत्येक दशा में स्त्रीत्व की रक्षा करने का निश्चय किया।

बाबू ज्ञान चन्द, जो एक स्कूल अध्यापक थे, उसके पति के घनिष्ठ मित्र थे। जब उन्हें इस बात का पता चला तब वे अपनी पत्नी के साथ उसके घर पर आए। उन्होंने उसे अपने साथ रहने की सलाह दी। वह सहमत हो गई। वहाँ भी उसने बाबू ज्ञान चन्द के मकान पर दो सिपाहियों को पहरा देते हुए देखा। उस स्त्री को यह अच्छा न लगा कि उसके मेजबान परेशानी में पड़ें। किन्तु ज्ञान चन्द की पत्नी इस बात से बिल्कुल भी परेशान नहीं थी। एक दिन शाम को ज्ञान बाबू अपने कॉलेज से बहुत परेशानी में लौटे। उनके प्रधानाचार्य ने उन्हें कहा कि वे उस स्त्री को अपने घर से निकाल दें। वह एक स्वतन्त्रता सेनानी की पत्नी है। यह कमिश्नर का आदेश था। किन्तु ज्ञान बाबू उनके सामने झुके नहीं। उन्होंने अपने पद से त्याग-पत्र दे दिया। उनके त्याग-पत्र ने प्रधानाचार्य की आँखें खोल दीं। उन्होंने तथा कमिश्नर ने उनसे अनेक प्रश्न पूछे और सन्तुष्ट हो गए कि ज्ञान बाबू का स्वतन्त्रता आन्दोलन से कोई सम्बन्ध नहीं है।

Understanding the Text

Short Answer Type Questions

Answer Two Of The Following Questions In Not More Than 30 Words Each:

Question 1. Who was jailed and why ?
(कैद की सजा किसको हुई और क्यों ?)
Answer: The husband of the narrator of this story was jailed. He had served sherbat and pan to the freedom fighters, which was considered a supportive act toward the national movement. This act of hospitality was deemed rebellious by the British authorities, leading to his arrest and subsequent imprisonment.
In simple words: The narrator's husband was sent to jail because he welcomed and served refreshments to the freedom fighters. The government punished him for supporting those fighting for the country's independence.

🎯 Exam Tip: Clearly state both parts of the question: who was jailed (the narrator's husband) and the specific reason (serving sherbat and pan to freedom fighters) to secure full marks.

Question 2. Who is the narrator of the story?
Answer: The narrator of the story is a woman whose husband was jailed. She shares her personal feelings of pride and struggle during this difficult time. (कहानी का वर्णन करने वाली एक महिला है जिसके पति को कारावास का दण्ड दिया गया।)
In simple words: The story is told by a proud wife whose husband was sent to prison because he supported the freedom fighters.

🎯 Exam Tip: Clearly identify the narrator as the wife of the jailed man to show a clear understanding of the story's perspective.

Question 3. When do you think the incident took place?
(a) before 1947
(b) after 1947
(c) in 1947
(d) in 1857
Answer: (a) before 1947
In simple words: The story happens during India's struggle for independence, which means it took place before India became free in 1947.

🎯 Exam Tip: Remember that any story involving active British rule and freedom struggles of this nature is set before India's independence in 1947.

Question 4. What were the political agitators fighting for? [2018]
Answer: The political agitators were fighting for the freedom of India. They wanted their motherland to be independent and self-governed. (राजनीतिक आन्दोलनकारी भारत की स्वतन्त्रता के लिए लड़ रहे थे।)
In simple words: The freedom fighters were protesting and fighting to make India a free country, independent of British control.

🎯 Exam Tip: Mention "freedom of India" or "independence" as these are the key terms the examiner looks for.

Question 5. Why did the lady want to rush forward and touch the feet of her husband?
Answer: Her husband had served the political agitators. It was the great work of patriotism. So the lady was very proud of her husband. She wanted to rush forward and touch his feet to show her deep respect. (उसके पति ने राजनीतिक आन्दोलनकारियों की सेवा की थी । यह देशभक्ति का एक महान कार्य था । इस कारण उस स्त्री को अपने पति पर बहुत अभिमान था । वह आगे बढ़कर उसके चरण-स्पर्श करना चाहती थी ।)
In simple words: She was very proud of her husband's patriotic work and wanted to touch his feet to show her respect and love for his bravery.

🎯 Exam Tip: Highlight the husband's patriotism and the wife's feeling of pride as the main reasons for her action.

Question 6. How did the wife celebrate her husband’s going to jail?
Answer: The wife celebrated her husband’s going to jail by distributing sweets among the freedom fighters. She also addressed a meeting organised by Congress and pledged to follow satyagraha. (पत्नी ने अपने पति के जेल जाने के अवसर को स्वतन्त्रता सेनानियों में मिठाई बाँटकर मनाया । कांग्रेस के द्वारा संगठित एक जनसभा में उसने भाषण भी दिया और सत्याग्रह का अनुसरण करने का वायदा किया ।)
In simple words: Instead of crying, she happily distributed sweets to freedom fighters, spoke at a meeting, and promised to support the peaceful protest movement.

🎯 Exam Tip: Be sure to mention both key actions: distributing sweets and addressing the Congress meeting to pledge for satyagraha.

Question 7. How did the father and father-in-law of the narrator respond to her telegrams? And why?
Answer: Both her father and father-in-law responded very coldly and refused to help her. They did so because they were terrified of the British government and did not want to face any legal trouble or social boycott for supporting a rebel's family. (कहानी का वर्णन करने वाली स्त्री के पिता एवं ससुर ने उसके तारों का बहुत ठंडा उत्तर दिया और मदद करने से मना कर दिया क्योंकि वे ब्रिटिश सरकार से डरते थे।)
In simple words: Her father and father-in-law refused to help her because they were scared that the British government would punish them for helping the family of a freedom fighter.

🎯 Exam Tip: Explain both the response (refusal to help) and the reason (fear of the British government) clearly to get full marks.

Question 8. Why didn’t the father-in-law of the lady whose husband had been given a year’s hard labour for a petty offence of serving sherbat and pan to the political agitations, help her as depicted in Prem Chand’s story, ‘A Special Experience’?
(प्रेमचन्द की कहानी 'A Special Experience' में उस स्त्री की, जिसके पति को राजनीतिक आन्दोलनकारियों को शरबत एवं पान प्रस्तुत करने के लिए एक वर्ष का सश्रम कारावास का दण्ड दिया गया था, उसके ससुर ने क्यों मदद नहीं की?)
Answer: The father-in-law did not help her because he had a small Government pension. He was afraid that if he helped her, his pension would be cut off. (उसके ससुर को शासकीय सेवानिवृत्ति वेतन मिलता था। उनको डर था कि यदि उन्होंने उसकी मदद की तो उनकी सेवानिवृत्ति वेतन बन्द हो जाएगी। इसी कारण उन्होंने उसकी मदद नहीं की।)
In simple words: The father-in-law refused to help because he was worried the government would stop paying his pension if he supported her.

🎯 Exam Tip: Clearly state the father-in-law's financial dependency on his government pension as the primary reason for his refusal to help.

Question 9. Who were the two persons watching her from the door?
(वे दो व्यक्ति कौन थे जो दरवाजे से उस पर निगाह रख रहे थे?)
(a) Constables
(b) Gyan Babu and his wife
(c) Neighbours
(d) The Principal and the Police Commissioner
Answer: (a) Constables
In simple words: Two police constables were keeping a close watch on her from the doorway.

🎯 Exam Tip: Pay close attention to the characters mentioned in the story to easily identify who was monitoring the lady.

Question 10. How did the wife react to her husband’s imprisonment? [2009, 17, 18]
(पत्नी ने अपने पति के जेल जाने पर क्या प्रतिक्रिया व्यक्त की?)
Answer: On her husband’s imprisonment the wife was very bold and courageous. She was full of patriotism. She was so proud of her husband that she wanted to touch his feet. She distributed sweets among the freedom fighters. But she was a lady and was all alone in the house. So she determined to preserve her femininity at all costs. (अपने पति के जेल जाने पर पत्नी बहुत बहादुर और साहसी थी। वह देशभक्ति से परिपूर्ण थी। उसे अपने पति पर इतना गर्व था कि वह उसके चरण-स्पर्श करना चाहती थी। उसने स्वतन्त्रता सेनानियों को मिठाइयाँ बाँटीं। किन्तु वह एक स्त्री थी और घर में बिल्कुल अकेली थी। इसलिए उसने अपने स्त्रीत्व की सुरक्षा करने का दृढ़ निश्चय कर लिया था।)
In simple words: The wife showed great courage and pride in her husband's sacrifice for the country. Even though she was alone and scared, she stayed strong and celebrated his bravery.

🎯 Exam Tip: Highlight key traits like courage, patriotism, and her determination to protect her dignity to score full marks.

Question 11. ‘The lady was upset again after eight days.’ Why?
(‘वह स्त्री आठ दिन के बाद पुनः परेशान हो गयी।’ क्यों?)
Answer: The lady was living with the family of Gyan Chand. After eight days, she realized that her presence was causing them immense anxiety and fear of police trouble, making her feel like an unwanted burden. (वह स्त्री ज्ञान चन्द के परिवार के साथ रह रही थी। आठ दिनों के बाद उसे महसूस हुआ कि उसकी उपस्थिति उनके लिए पुलिस की परेशानी और अत्यधिक चिंता का कारण बन रही है, जिससे वह पुनः परेशान हो गई।)
In simple words: She became sad again after eight days because she saw that her hosts were living in constant fear of the police because of her.

🎯 Exam Tip: Explain the conflict between the hosts' desire to help and their fear of government retaliation to provide a complete answer.

Question 12. What perturbed Gyan Babu one evening?
(कौ न-सी बा त ने ज्ञा न बा बू को एक दि न शा म को परेशा न कर दि या ?)
Answer: One evening the principal told Gyan Babu that he should turn the lady out of his house. It was the order of Commissioner. So Gyan Babu had a quarrel with the principal and he was perturbed. He felt a deep moral conflict between obeying his superiors and doing what was right. (एक दि न शा म को प्रधा ना चा र्य ने ज्ञा न बा बू को बता या कि वह उस स्त्री को अपने घर से नि का ल दें। यह कमि श्नर की आज्ञा थी । इसलि ए ज्ञा न बा बू का प्रधा ना चा र्य से झगड़ा हुआ और वे इसी का रण परेशा न थे।)
In simple words: Gyan Babu was troubled because the principal ordered him to kick the lady out of his house on the Commissioner's orders. This led to an argument between Gyan Babu and the principal.

🎯 Exam Tip: Clearly mention both the principal's order and the Commissioner's involvement to secure full marks.

Question 13. Why was the narrator restless the whole night?
(कहा नी का वर्णन करने वा ली स्त्री पूरी रा त क्यों बेचैन रही ?)
Answer: The narrator’s father and father-in-law refused to help her when her husband was in jail. Her husband’s friend helped her by keeping her in his house. But now by the order of the Commissioner his service was to be lost. It was only due to her. So the narrator was very restless the whole night. She felt immense guilt for causing trouble to the only family that supported her. (कहा नी का वर्णन करने वा ली स्त्री के पि ता तथा ससुर दोनों ने उस समय उसकी सहा यता करने से मना कर दि या जब उसका पति जेल में था । उसके पति के मि त्र ने उसे अपने मका न में रखकर उसकी सहा यता की । कि न्तु अब कमि श्नर की आज्ञा से उसकी नौ करी जा ने वा ली थी । ऐसा उसी स्त्री के का रण हो रहा था । इस का रण वह स्त्री पूरी रा त बेचैन रही ।)
In simple words: The narrator was worried because her presence was causing her host, Gyan Babu, to lose his job. She felt responsible for his trouble since her own family had already abandoned her.

🎯 Exam Tip: Highlight the contrast between the refusal of her relatives and the selfless help of her husband's friend.

Question 14. What disturbed Gyan Babu once in the story “A Special Experience’? How did he face the situation?
(A Special Experience’ ना मक कहा नी में कि स बा त ने ज्ञा न बा बू को एक बा र परेशा न कि या ? उसने इस परि स्थि ति का कैसे सा मना कि या ?)
Or
How had Gyan Babu to put in his resignation? [2011]
(ज्ञा न बा बू को अपना त्या ग-पत्र क्यों देना पड़ा ?)
Answer: When the principal told Gyan Babu to turn out the wife of the jailed freedom fighter from his house, he got disturbed. He faced the situation successfully by handing his resignation to the principal. He chose his principles and patriotism over his job security. (जब प्रधा ना चा र्य ने ज्ञा न बा बू से कहा कि वह स्वतन्त्रता सेनानी की पत्नी को घर से नि का ल दें, तो वह परेशा न हो गया । उसने अपना त्या ग-पत्र प्रधा ना चा र्य को सौंप कर स्थिति का सफलतापूर्वक सामना किया ।)
In simple words: Gyan Babu was asked to evict a freedom fighter's wife from his home. Instead of obeying this unjust order, he chose to resign from his job to protect her.

🎯 Exam Tip: When answering 'Or' questions, ensure your response addresses both parts of the prompt clearly, emphasizing his act of resignation.

Question. Why did Gyan Babu’s wife tell him to put in his resignation ? [2012, 17]
Answer: Gyan Babu’s wife asked him to tell the principal that he was not going to turn that lady out of the house. If he did not agree, he should submit his resignation. She stood firmly by her moral values despite the risk of losing their livelihood.
In simple words: Gyan Babu's wife wanted him to stand up to the principal and refuse to kick the lady out of their house, even if it meant losing his job.

🎯 Exam Tip: Clearly state the condition given by the wife to the principal to secure full marks.

Question 16. How did the resignation of Gyan Babu affect the principal ? [2010, 17, 18]
Answer: The resignation of Gyan Babu made the principal come to his senses. He discussed the matter with the Commissioner and decided not to punish Gyan Babu. This sudden decision made the principal realize the gravity of the situation.
In simple words: Gyan Babu's resignation made the principal realize his mistake, so he talked to the Commissioner and decided not to punish him.

🎯 Exam Tip: Highlight the change in the principal's attitude and his discussion with the Commissioner.

Question 17. Who was Gyan Babu ? Why did he tender his resignation ?
Answer: Gyan Babu was a school teacher. He refused his principal to turn out the lady from his house whose husband was in jail. So he tendered his resignation. He chose his moral duty of helping someone in need over his professional security.
In simple words: Gyan Babu was a school teacher who resigned because he refused to kick out a helpless lady whose husband was in prison.

🎯 Exam Tip: Answer both parts of the question clearly: first identify who Gyan Babu was, and then explain the reason for his resignation.

Question 18. What kind of a lady is Gyan Babu’s wife ? Has she impressed you ? Give examples in support of your answer.
Answer: Gyan Babu’s wife is an extraordinary lady. She is fearless and full of patriotism and dignity. She is a helping lady. Due to these reasons she has really impressed me. Her courage to face difficult consequences for a noble cause is truly inspiring.
In simple words: Gyan Babu's wife is a brave, patriotic, and helpful woman who inspires others by standing up for what is right.

🎯 Exam Tip: Use strong adjectives like 'fearless', 'patriotic', and 'dignified' to describe her character.

Question 19. “She was flint outside and gold inside.” Who says this and about whom ? And what does it suggest [2011]
Answer: The narrator of the story says this about the wife of Gyan Chand. It suggests that Mrs. Gyan Chand was hard in her appearance and words, but at heart she was very gentle and generous. This contrast highlights how her strict exterior hid a deeply compassionate soul.
In simple words: The storyteller says this about Gyan Chand's wife to show that even though she looked tough on the outside, she was very kind and caring on the inside.

🎯 Exam Tip: Explain both parts of the metaphor—'flint outside' and 'gold inside'—to get full marks.

Question 20. In what way did the narrator express her feelings at her husband’s going to jail ?
(कहा नी का वर्णन करने वा ली स्त्री ने अपने पति के जेल के अवसर पर कि स प्रका र अपनी भा वना ओं को प्रकट कि या ?)
Answer: At her husband’s going to jail, the narrator felt proud. She was not the least perturbed or discouraged. She expressed her feelings by distributing sweets among the freedom fighters. Her courage served as an inspiration to many other women in the community. She addressed a meeting also organised by Congress and pledged to follow satyagraha. (अपने पति के जेल जा ने पर उस स्त्री ने गर्व का अनुभनुव कि या । वह बि ल्कुल भी परेशा न या हतो त्सा हि त नहीं हुई। उसने अपनी भा वना ओं को स्वतन्त्रता सेनासे नानि यों में मि ठा ई बाँ टबाँ कर प्रकट कि या । उसने कां ग्रेकां ग्रेस द्वा रा संगसं ठि त एक सभा को भी सम्बो धि त कि या और सत्या ग्रह पर चलने का वा यदा कि या ।)
In simple words: The narrator felt proud instead of sad when her husband went to jail. She showed her happiness by sharing sweets with freedom fighters and promising to support the freedom movement.

🎯 Exam Tip: Highlight the narrator's positive attitude and her active participation in the freedom struggle to score full marks.

Question 21. Why did Gyan Babu’s wife tell him to put in his resignation ?
(ज्ञा न बा बू की पत्नी ने उनसे त्या ग-पत्र देनेदे नेको क्यों कहा ?)
Answer: The principal had asked Gyan Babu to turn the lady out of her house. But Gyan Babu’s wife did not like to turn her out of the house at any cost. She valued human relationships and moral duties far above financial security. So she told Gyan Babu to put in his resignation. (प्रधा ना चा र्य ने ज्ञा न बा बू से उसे स्त्री को घर से नि का लने को कहा था । कि न्तु ज्ञा न बा बू की पत्नी उसे घर से कि सी भी दशा में नहीं नि का लना चा हती थी । अत: उन्हों नेहों नेज्ञा न बा बू को कहा कि वे अपना त्या ग-पत्र दे दें।दें )
In simple words: The school principal wanted Gyan Babu to kick the narrator out of their house. Gyan Babu's wife refused to do this and preferred that her husband resign from his job instead of doing something so cruel.

🎯 Exam Tip: Clearly state the conflict between the principal's order and the wife's moral stance to write a complete answer.

Question 22. Who made greater sacrifice-Gyan Babu or the narrator’s husband ? (अधि क बलि दा न कि सने कि या —ज्ञा न बा बू ने या कहा नी का वर्णन करने वा ली स्त्री के पति ने ?)

Answer: In my opinion the sacrifice of Gyan Babu is greater. He was not a political man. Yet he was ready to sacrifice his service; i.e. means of livelihood of his family, for the sake of his friendship. Risking one's entire family's survival for a friend requires immense courage. (मेरेमेरेवि चा र से ज्ञा न बा बू का बलि दा न अधि क महा न् है। वे एक रा जनी ति क व्यक्ति नहीं थे।थे फि र भी वे अपनी नौ करी अर्था त् पूरेपूरेपरि वा र की आजी वि का के सा धन को मि त्रता के वा स्ते बलि दा न करने को तैया र थे।थे ) ।
In simple words: Gyan Babu made a bigger sacrifice because he was not involved in politics, yet he was willing to lose his job and only source of income just to help his friend's wife.

🎯 Exam Tip: Compare the motivations of both characters, emphasizing that Gyan Babu's sacrifice was purely personal and moral, not political.

Question 23. How does the narrator regard Gyan Babu’s wife? Do you think she is justified in her feelings?
(कहा नी का वर्णन करने वा ली स्त्री ज्ञा न बा बू की पत्नी का सम्मा न कैसे करती है ? आपके वि चा र से क्या उसकी भा वना एँ न्या यो चि त हैं ?) हैं
Answer: The narrator regarded Gyan Babu’s wife as a goddess. She is justified in her feelings. Mrs. Gyan Babu helped her while her own father and father-in-law refused to help her. Her selfless actions stood out as a beacon of hope during a very dark time. She was so broad-minded and self-sacrificing that she herself asked Gyan Babu to resign if his principal was adamant to get the narrator turned out of his house. (कहा नी का वर्णन करने वा ली स्त्री ज्ञा न बा बू की पत्नी को देवीदे वी मा नती है। वह अपनी भा वना ओं में न्या यो चि त है। श्री मती ज्ञा न बा बू ने उसकी उस समय सहा यता की जबकि उसके पि ता और ससुरसु ने भी उसकी सहा यता करने के लि ए मना कर दि या । वह इतनी वि शा ल हृदय वा ली और त्या ग करने वा ली स्त्री थी कि उसने स्वयं ज्ञा न बा बू से त्या ग-पत्र देनेदे नेको कहा यदि उनके प्रधा ना चा र्य इस बा त पर डटे रहें कि वे उस स्त्री को घर से नि का ल दें।दें )
In simple words: The narrator respects Gyan Babu's wife like a goddess. This is completely fair because Gyan Babu's wife supported her when even her own family refused to help, and she was ready to let her husband lose his job for her sake.

🎯 Exam Tip: Mention the contrast between the family's refusal to help and Mrs. Gyan Babu's selfless support to justify the narrator's high regard.

Question 24. Gyan Babu’s wife says, “There’s only one answer, isn’t there?” Write in your own words what this answer is ?
(ज्ञान बाबू की पत्नी कहती है, “इसका केवल एक ही उत्तर है, क्या नहीं है?” अपने शब्दों में लिखिए कि वह उत्तर क्या है ?)
Answer: The answer is that Gyan Babu should tell his principal that he is not going to let that lady go from his house and if he does not like that idea, he can have his resignation. This bold stance showed her immense courage and moral strength in standing up for what was right.
(उत्तर यह है कि ज्ञान बाबू को अपने प्रधानाचार्य से कह देना चाहिए कि वह उस स्त्री को अपने घर से निकालने नहीं जा रहे हैं और यदि उसे यह विचार पसन्द नहीं है, तो वह उसको त्याग-पत्र ले सकते हैं।)
In simple words: Gyan Babu's wife wanted him to stand firm and refuse to throw the helpless lady out of their house. If the school principal did not like this decision, Gyan Babu should simply resign from his job.

🎯 Exam Tip: Clearly explain the moral choice made by Gyan Babu's wife to show her character's strength. Mentioning the option of resignation is crucial for scoring full marks.

Question 25. “If there ever was a goddess, she is one.” Who said this & why in the story ‘A Special Experience’? [2009]
(“अगर कहीं देवी है, तो वह है।” 'A Special Experience' कहानी में यह किसने कहा और क्यों ?)
Answer: The lady whose husband was jailed said these words about Gyan Babu’s wife. She gave the lady such affection and such respect whereas she was spurned by her father and father-in-law. This unexpected kindness deeply touched her heart during her darkest times.
(उस स्त्री ने जिसका पति जेल में है, ने ज्ञान बाबू की पत्नी के बारे में यह शब्द कहे थे। उसने उस स्त्री को ऐसा प्यार तथा ऐसा सम्मान दिया था जिसे उसके पिता एवं ससुर द्वारा ठुकरा दिया गया था।)
In simple words: The jailed man's wife called Gyan Babu's wife a goddess because she showed her great love and respect at a time when her own family had rejected and abandoned her.

🎯 Exam Tip: Identify both the speaker and the person being referred to clearly. Highlight the contrast between the family's rejection and Gyan Babu's wife's warmth to secure maximum marks.